all we know to himself, but that minor incursion, along with the idea that republicans are purposely trying to make it harder for minorities to vote, those are the takeaways and they are going to leave a, that, a long time. bret: right. was it a minor incursion when russia went into crimea in 2014? does that qualify? i see here where you are going. ari, what else struck you from this news conference? well, i think if he were a liberal democrat, the president may have been successful in a holding pattern where you your support no longer erodes there were feisty moments by joe biden that base of the party will enjoy. the problem joe biden has he is cratering among independence and he certainly has lost republicans. it s that damage among independents. i get it s caucus of the white house in off lehr election cycle they have got to run toward the base. which shows that peter doocy s question about why are you governing from the left was a very valid question. joe biden rejected it.