and some of these people here tell us that they have seen in person all eight of the people who were on stage wednesday night. poppy, victor. back to the panel now. jessica, let me start with you. vivek ramaswamy. seven of those say he had a bad night, but voters think differently. i m not shocked. he took up air time. some people didn t know him and they kept hearing from himoff and over again. i think whenever everyone attacks you, you appear like the frontrunner. and he almost acted as a trump surrogate not only defending the president time and time again, but repeating his lines. so i m not surprised that people liked that especially in the absence of the former president on the stage. he is amplifying a lot of conservative media talking points and that creates its own feedback loop. but nikki haley did well with hand raises well and she s had tough time getting traction. and that was notable as well.