Carry ongoing up, please. So, that e mail which is on the 15th Of October is forwarded by ruth barker to Paula Venables on the 5th of november. Paula vennells. The next day we see Paula Vennells replies to ruth barker and your copy then. It says, the attachment needs to be in the e mailformat then. It says, the attachment needs to be in the e mail format please. Alan and i are out of the office so need to view it on blackberries. We also need the original e mails. Do you recall what conversation you had with Paula Vennells about this e mail . 1 with Paula Vennells about this email . , . , with Paula Vennells about this email . Del with Paula Vennells about this i email . Do you email . I dont no. Sorry. Do you remember email . I dont no. Sorry. Do you remember discussing email . I dont no. Sorry. Do you remember discussing anything i email . I dont no. Sorry. Do you remember discussing anything to i email . I dont no. Sorry. Do you i remember discussing anything to do with an investiga