Your honor, in this area the court has said that assumptions like that cannot be the basis of the way district lines are drawn because time is running out, there is in your presentation youre saying we are attack the statewide plan. We are not picking one district or the other. And you have been attacked on that point. The attack is that claims have to be district by district they cant be statewide. So i would like your answer to that question. There hasnt been a claim as far as i know that was statewide. Your honor, our claim is that the exact same policy was applied in every black majority district which is we will use racial data to repopulate as close as we can possibly do it to the exact same black percentage. Thats a policy applied in all 36 districts. And how are your clients hurt by that . It seems to me you have to come up with a client in one of the other districts that would have been as you put it more competitive had this packing not occurred. Your honor i assume thats the
United-states
Alabama
Montgomery-county
Crenshaw-county
Pennsylvania
Georgia
Shelby-county
Brown-chapel
Americans
American
Trisha-newman
Francis-ying