This is from april. Its an hour. Case 15577. Trinity lutheran church. The state of new york excluded the Learning Center from a safer playground from children because it was operated by a Church Rather than a not for profit. Number one that the policy in this case is not neutral. Churches are not eligible for the benefit here. Assuming theres no serious risk of an establishment violation, thats off the table, are there ever instances in which status, religious status can be used to deny religion or religious believers, benefits from the state . Or are you saying that religious status can never be the basis for it. The question is why would it matter. The next question then i guess wasnt long ago now back in 1947 this court said in no uncertain terms, with tax money imposed to pay for building or maintaining churches or Church Property and doesnt that fit this case . And if so. I dont think it does. We have to be careful in not establishing a church not to deprive religious people or or
This is from april. Its an hour. Case 15577. Trinity lutheran church. The state of new york excluded the Learning Center from a safer playground from children because it was operated by a Church Rather than a not for profit. Number one that the policy in this case is not neutral. Churches are not eligible for the benefit here. Assuming theres no serious risk of an establishment violation, thats off the table, are there ever instances in which status, religious status can be used to deny religion or religious believers, benefits from the state . Or are you saying that religious status can never be the basis for it. The question is why would it matter. The next question then i guess wasnt long ago now back in 1947 this court said in no uncertain terms, with tax money imposed to pay for building or maintaining churches or Church Property and doesnt that fit this case . And if so. I dont think it does. We have to be careful in not establishing a church not to deprive religious people or or
Solely because of the preschool is operated by a Church Rather than a secular, not profit. The state has made several important concessions in this case. Number one that the policy in this case is not neutral and that number two based on the religious character churches are not eligible for the benefit here. This admitted discoloration against religion violates this court free exercise principles. First, as stated in mcdaniel and smith, free exercise clause prevents the government from imposing special disabilities on the basis of religion and used a religious status. And forcing a choice between the exercise of religion and receiving either a government benefit, right or privilege. Assuming that there is no serious risk of an establishment violation, thats off the table are there any instances in which status, religious status, can be used to deny religions or religious believers benefits from the state or are you saying that its absent in the establishment clause problem . The status
Shortly is supervisor jane kim you are clerk is alicia thank you id like to thank the mrs. Jim smith and leo from sfgovtv for broadcasting this meanwhile madam clerk read the anonymous completed speaker cards and documents to be included should be submitted to the clerk. Items acted upon today will appear on the september 17th board of supervisors agenda unless otherwise stated thank you very much can you please call to me the and she is the author. On oversee phenomenon is planning code for all demolition and mergers and with the kitchen stove or bathroom is being removed. Supervisor wiener. Madam chair p in legislation is a simple but important step forward in trying to insure the during this housing crisis people are able to remain stable in their housing specifically this legislation will close a loophole that allows the owners of illegal units to seek and obtain a demolition permit without having notified the attendants that lived in those units which could lead to a situation the
Completed speaker cards and documents to be included should be submitted to the clerk. Items acted upon today will appear on the september 17th board of supervisors agenda unless otherwise stated thank you very much can you please call to me the and she is the author. On oversee phenomenon is planning code for all demolition and mergers and with the kitchen stove or bathroom is being removed. Supervisor wiener. Madam chair p in legislation is a simple but important step forward in trying to insure the during this housing crisis people are able to remain stable in their housing specifically this legislation will close a loophole that allows the owners of illegal units to seek and obtain a demolition permit without having notified the attendants that lived in those units which could lead to a situation the tenant has no ability to challenge the demolition permit we have tens of thousands of illegal units and rental unit and San Francisco residents living in those units they live in those