this child tax credit and earned tax credit, we should do it permanently. this would be something we can put into place setting us on a permanent trajectory. it doesn t end there. we are going to fight like hell to make sure we make it permanent. permanent. permanent. permanent. they are saying it so that s why republicans wanted this new cbo estimate of how much it would add to the deficit if these programs are as democrats made clear, become permanent. this should not a approximate partisan thing, right? all should want to know how much congress actually plans and intends to spend. so what does joe manchin think about this new multitrillion-dollar deficit analysis in well, he wouldn t say but senator lindsey graham did say he spoke to manchin today. i talked to him this morning. he was stunned. he was i think he felt vindicated in that his concerns