Reality. They provide thousands of paying strangers with public ordinances Public Performances over the tv. Thank you. The case is submitted. Following the oral argument, attorneys representing both abc ereo spur brief spoke briefly to reporters. Clement, paul clement. I just want to say we are very glad to get before the court filedon the case that we trying to seek review of the second circuits decision because we thought the second circuits decision was profoundly wrong and was a real threat to the nature of the broadcast industry. We are very happy to be in court today. We are very pleased with the way the Court Considered the arguments. They understood the technology. They understood the stakes. Obviously, they were focused on the interpretation of the statute and we convey to them are relatively straightforward position which is that a service can not provide live tv over the internet to thousands of paying strangers without engaging in a Public Performance. It is really as simpl