in your analysis? sure, your honor. i think it makes a number of differences. i mention two in particular. one is it really does mark out the unbelievably profound ramifications of this area which in many other areas assisted suicide, a whole host of important areas, important to freedom and matters of conscience, it marks it out as one of the unique areas where this court has taken that important issue to the people and it is something that imply indicates life and just marks off justice thomas, how problematic and unusual and how much of a break the court s abortion juris pru dense is from the other cases. if we don t overrule casey or roe do you have a standard you propose other than viability? bill: a no stanld ard other than the