Live Breaking News & Updates on Agnes Monson

Stay updated with breaking news from Agnes monson. Get real-time updates on events, politics, business, and more. Visit us for reliable news and exclusive interviews.

The 'Not Proven' trial that served as inspiration for the Sherlock Holmes books


IN this short series about the uniquely Scottish not proven verdict, I have reached the stage of the controversial trial that led to the acquittal of Alfred John Monson on the charge of murdering Lieutenant Cecil Hambrough in 1893.
For me, even more than the case of alleged poisoner Madeleine Smith – probably the most famous or infamous trial ever to end in a not proven verdict – the Monson verdict proves how unsatisfactory is the “bastard verdict” as it was called by Sir Walter Scott. Next week I will give my conclusion as to whether Scotland should switch to guilty and not guilty verdicts or continue with not proven as a second form of acquittal. ....

Ardlamont House , Argyll And Bute , United Kingdom , City Of , North Yorkshire , Loch Fyne , Agnes Monson , Edward Sweeney , Dudley Hambrough , Joseph Bell , Ted Davis , Beresford Tottenham , Sherlock Holmes , Scott Sweeney , Sweeney Scott , Athole Macdonald , James Macnaughton , Risley Hall , John Macmillan , Henry Littlejohn , Comrie Thomson , Edinburgh High Court , St Catherine Church , Major Dudley Hambrough , Yorkshire Militia , Ardlamont Estate ,

How Not Proven verdict played its part in controversial trial


THE current controversy over the Not Proven verdict which is unique to the Scottish criminal justice system has rarely been placed in its historical context. That cannot be done in just one column, but I will attempt to do so over the next three weeks during which I will return to a particular case which continues to fascinate me – that of Madeleine Smith who I have now concluded got away with murder when the jury found the charge of poisoning her French lover not proven.
That case in 1857 is usually claimed as the biggest not proven controversy of them all, but today and next week I am going to write about the most infamous case of the latter years of the 19th century that featured a contentious not proven verdict, namely the Ardlamont Murder of 1893, which is more properly known as the Ardlamont Mystery because the jury decided that the accused, Alfred John Monson, was not proven to have murdered Lieutenant Cecil Hambrough in a shooting incident. It was the most sensat ....

United Kingdom , Ardlamont House , Argyll And Bute , City Of , Edward Sweeney , Agnes Monson , Cecil Hambrough , Thomas John Monson , Windsor Dudley Cecil Hambrough , Joseph Bell , Ted Davis , John Monson , Boris Johnson , Sherlock Holmes , Alfred Monson , Arthur Sebright , Caroline Isabella Monckton , Alexander Moncrieff , Arthur Conan Doyle , Risley Hall , John Macmillan , Pipewell Hall , Henry Littlejohn , Dudley Albert Hambrough , Royal Insurance Company , Eagle Insurance Company ,