President ial nominee tim kaine in ohio today. Im betty nguyen, alongside louis bergdorf. Morning joe starts right now. How was your weekend . It was wonderful. How are you feeling . Its fall. Its almost fall. Are you feeling okay . Yes, i am. Everybody okay . Nobody going to faint on us here. Its monday, september 12th. Anybody . Woozy . Come on. Come on. Its not like were talking about a death in the family. You all dont have to be so theyre uptight. Im woozy 85 of the time. When you fall back like that, we all know what it has to do with. Dont have to wait for 12 hours from your people. Full transparency on that matter. Every day. Welcome to morning joe. With us on set we have managing editor of Bloomberg Politics and cohost that airs at 6 00 on msnbc, Mark Halperin and John Heilemann. Chair of the department of africanamerican studies at princeton university, author of the book democracy and black and columnist to Time Magazine and in washington, associate editor for the Washington Post. Lets just get right to it. I had a huge democratic supporter call me yesterday afternoon. Its over. Its over. What . Its over. She fainted. Trump is going to be calm down, cowboy. I went back and i looked at it. It doesnt look great. Doesnt look great. Its over . The campaign is over because she fainted. There are a lot of conspiracy
theorists and its going to feed into it. Video doesnt look good. I tell you what, i wake up at 4 00 a. M. Every day. Done it for a decade. There are times when im walking down stairs and, you know, very active guy, i have to stop for a second and grab a handrail. You do that every day. You do what shes been doing every day. Im not arguing her case for her. For people that sit back in their arm chairs all day watching cable news and say how could somebody do that . When you go back and you think about in january what was she doing . She was debating Bernie Sanders every night on cnn. They had those town hall meetings. Okay. One of those a week would kill most people. Shes been doing it nonstop. So to take this and say it proves that shes unfit to be president of the United States. Im sorry. Its stupid. Im sewure there are a lot of m republican bretheran that would agree. She needs to release her medical records. I will tell you, youve seen me. I do prohibition. I am up sweating and everything. Once a show. Ive been up since 4 00. Its 10 00 at night. Im on stage. I got to close my eyes and stop and say lean back on your heels so if you pass out you will fall into the drums. Whats the difference with donald trump . He doesnt do work behind the scenes. I want to see because when i follow all over backwards, i want a rim shot. Just like that. Lets go through what happened. Youre right though. Shes work, work, work. Donald trump sits in his office and makes phone calls. How are we doing . Having a good time. A little different. So lets go through what happened and then we can go around the table here because i do think you bring up a good point. Ive seen that happen. Having said that, we dont know. I think the campaigns reaction has been frustrating. Hillary clinton has canceled a trip that was set for today and tomorrow in california after falling ill during a 9 11 remembrance ceremony yesterday. Last night her campaign revealed she had been diagnosed with pneumonia days earlier but that was only explained after a morning rife with speculation. Clinton joined donald trump during a ceremony in Lower Manhattan on a warm day but after more than an hour there, she left abruptly appearing unsteady. All the while the press was left in the dark with the campaign mum on whether the democratic nominee was going or what happened but video entered her a van with help of the secret Service Showed she was unsteady and clearly require support. She appeared to lean on a post and at one point her legs seemed to buckle. At 11 00 a. M. Her campaign put out a statement saying she felt overheated so she departed to go to her daughters apartment and is feeling much better. The Campaign Says she even played with her grandkids there before appearing in front of the awaiting press posing for a photo with a young girl hopping back in her van. How are you feeling, secretary clinton . Are you feeling better . Yes. Thank you very much. Thanks, everybody. Clinton then headed home but left the press pool in the dust once more. Left the city 90 minutes behind her motorcade and last night her physician revealed in statement secretary clinton has been experiencing a cough related to allergies on friday. During followup evaluation her prolonged cough she was diagnosed with pneumonia. She was put on antibiotics and advised to rest and modify her
schedule. While at this mornings event she became overheated and dehydrated. I have just examined her and shes now rehydrated and recovering nicely. Mark halperin, tell us, whats your take on this . I think there are three buckets we can put this in. You like buckets. These are halperins buckets. Bucket number one. Legitimate concerns. Their health, their age, their lack of transparency. Lack of willingness to have a protected pool with them at one times. One is likely to be president in january. Those are public things we must press them both on. Two is the freak show aspects of this. And degree to which this is being made into the normal carnival and negativity. And then lastly theres the politics of it. I think until we hear how Hillary Clinton handles both the health issue and the buckets of
deplorables and how donald trump handles them, with he dont know where the story will go but theyll define the beginning of this week in a big way. John heilemann . I agree with all of that. Are you going to add a basket . Do you have your own bucket . I just think that it cant be stressed enough theres been a long history of debate and litigation in the small l sense of the word over what the standards of disclosure should be in president ial campaigns and over nominees and takes on greater weight when you talk about nominees who are older. There are no rules on taxes or health this year. There should be rules. There have never been rules. Formal conventions people comply to. As you suggested, both candidates Hillary Clinton has disclosed a little bit more about her health than donald trump has. Both of them by historic
standards have disclosed very little. I think its really the taxes is an issue ive been banging on with trump for months and months. Its now incumbent on both candidates. Donald trump is going dr. Oz this week and talking about his personal health regimen. We need to have credible we need at this point both sides just go completely open. Just show us the records. Show us the records on health care. At this point, i dont mean to veer off course but its relevant. Whats going on between trump and Vladimir Putin . Why does he show up on putins tv network . Why does he continue to shock republican supporters . Is there a Financial Link . Is he loaning him money . Whats the linkage. Its dumb. No idea what hes saying. We dont know that because he wont release his taxes. Do you think to have someone running for president if they have pneumonia have an obligation to disclose it . Absolutely. The issue is how much is the Campaign Going to stumble and lead people down the untrustworthy lane. We need transparency from this candidate. We need press conferences. We need everything to be as transparent as possible given the legacy, the clinton legacy. We have nbc News White House correspondent Kristen Welker who is covering the Clinton Campaign. Why didnt they announce the pneumonia diagnosis on friday . Reporter well, thats the big question. And heres what we know so far. According to senior official talking to you are a own andrea mitchell, there was a sense that secretary clinton felt as if she could power through. She wasnt coughing on saturday so she thought she would just take those antibiotics and
continue with her regular schedule. The campaign obviously realizes that was now a big mistake. So there are a lot of internal discussions going on around that. Also worth noting, there is a sense that the Broader Campaign wasnt made aware of the fact that she had been diagnosed with pneumonia. I can tell you prior to friday i had a number of conversations with a number of officials that batted down any speculation that her cough was anything other than seasonal allergies and there was a real defensive posture about that. I think some democrats are going to try to spin this and say, look, this shows how strong she is. Think about what she did on friday after she was diagnosed. She attended two fundraisers. She convened a twohour meeting with a National Security team. She held a press conference, which i attended. She also gave an interview to a Major Television network. So thats what she did after she was diagnosed but you could say it raises questions about judgment clearly the doctors
saying she needed to scale back her schedule. It will feed into republicans raising questions about her health and put pressure on her to release her full medical record. Worth noting shes released more information than donald trump but right now this is what folks are going to be focused on and want more information about it and could not come at a worst time for this campaign as the polls are getting a lot tighter. Kristen welker, thank you very much. Thank you. Good point of transparency. You were going to say . I want to agree with all of marks buckets. I want to focus on the second one about the spectacle. Part of what concerns me about this is this is the first woman to be a major nominee of a party. The nominee of a party. Theres a sense in which questions around her health play be tied to frailness. Did we get this level of coverage around dick cheneys heart . Here she has pneumonia in this moment. I think transparency and all of the points were making is important but i want us to be very careful the way in which we read hear health and now that reads as a proxy in the way in which we talk about gender. I remember jimmy carter collapsed during a race. We would all look horrific if we collapsed. He was running a 5k. The press put it all over the papers suggesting he wasnt Strong Enough to be president. He was collapsing, et cetera, et cetera. Just as a matter of debate, im for maximum disclosure all the time and in her case because of the trust issues she has, shes always politically in a better place when she discloses more. But there was an interesting debate that broke out about this on twitter among people that
work for barack obama who said, you know, every campaign ive worked on the candidates had pneumonia at some point. Its really common. Treatable with antibiotics. Whats the standard for when we should have our candidates have to disclose illnesses treatable with antibiotics . The case every time all candidate get ill they take antibiotics have to disclose that to the press . I dont know what i think about that. Generally im for more disclosure. In her political situation it makes sense. Its an interesting question. Lets ask the icon school of medicine at mt. Sinai. Based on what youve seen so far, does the prognosis and the diagnosis of walking pneumonia concern you . Its concerning. Shes 68 years old. We know so little about whats wrong with her. We dont know if she had a chest xray. We dont know if there was
troublesome blood work. To make a prognosis based on a dearth of information is almost impossible. On the other hand for someone who is Walking Around and going to these events, i can tell you that 9 11 here in the city is very stressful even if youre not standing down at ground zero. Its a tough day for people who live in new york. So she looks like she tried to power through frankly. But in terms of a prognosis, very difficult to say. Is it a serious diagnosis, walking pneumonia . Well, it can be based on whether or not a person is healthy in an underlying way. Do they have cardiovascular problems . Do they have high Blood Pressure . Are they in general poor health . Those people who have underlying medical conditions, it can be a serious condition. On the other hand, its a kind of a run of mill thing that general practitioners see all
the time. People get over it. They go back to work. No big deal. What about underlying conditions. Shes taking medication. Taking blood thinners. Does what little we know of her health at 68, would that concern you more as a physician . Not those this specifically. Her Blood Pressure was reported to be normal Blood Pressure. That makes me believe she doesnt have any cardiovascular problems or significant cardiovascular problems with her heart. She doesnt have diabetes. Those are the types of things i would be very concerned about. Shes 68 years old. Stuff happens over a lifetime and shes accumulated some dvts, blood clot in her brain, none of that would specifically worry me in terms of the pneumonia. Okay. There emily senay, thank you very much. Im sure you remember that
image of jimmy carter collapsing. Im not talking about the killer rabbit. I think a few weeks later when he was jogging jimmy carter collapsing and a lot of people reading way too much into that. Jimmy carter extraordinarily healthy even today. Add some Historical Perspective to this. Was all of the hyperventilating yesterday from people watching mrs. Clinton hyperventilate overboard . As with famous jimmy carter image youre talking about, the reason it was important is because it came at a time when there already was a discussion about whether jimmy carter was up to it as president and then suddenly had this image where he was an extraordinarily healthy man running a marathon or long race shouldnt have added concern but it did. In this case Hillary Clinton has
had a difficult couple of weeks. I think by anybodys judgment. And two things that i have seen in her since i first began covering her many years ago. First, she always pushes herself to the edge of stamina. When she was secretary of state, she had to go to that next country, that next rally, that next event. Its just part of the way she operates. And second, shes always been extraordinarily reserved about any personal information. They didnt let it out at the white house. They didnt let it out at the state department. Theyre not doing it now. I think that combination of people asking questions about her, pushing herself super hard and not saying much about her personal situation, those came together in this incident. What we can say or what i would say in conclusion is hear hear h health is now a legitimate campaign issue. Yesterday unfortunately one
of the things that this storyly memorials across the nation about september 11 incredibly moving. What are your thoughts . Whats happened with americas Foreign Policy in the intervening 15 years. It was a day of remembrance. I was out on the mall with my family seeing every flag at halfstaff. So many markers. I stand back and i look and i have to say the dream that Osama Bin Laden had 15 years ago of a global jihad has been realized. Thats the most painful thing to say. In so many ways al qaeda has been crushed, bin laden is dead but his idea that he had on the morning of september 11th in many ways has born fruit. Well talk more about that ahead. Still ahead on jmorning joe, well get to Hillary Clintons basket of deplorable statements and Kellyanne Conway is here on set and also congressman mike mccaul and david brooks calls the president ial election a race to the bottom at olympic speed. And as we go to break, as the nation yesterday commemorated the 15th anniversary of 9 11, here is a portion of the song joe wrote for the 10th anniversary of those terror attacks. Reason to believe. What would you guess about a stranger caress that reminds me of what we used to be at the end of the hour when im drained of all power i still find a reason to believe
its not something you do now and then. Or when its convenient. Its using stateoftheart simulators to better prepare for any situation. Its giving offshore teams onshore support. And its empowering anyone to stop a job if something doesnt seem right. At bp, safety is never being satisfied. And always working to be better. At bp, safety is never being satisfied. Thats why a cutting edgeworld. University counts on centurylink
to keep their global campus connected. And why a Pro Football Team chose us to deliver fiberenabled broadband to more than 65,000 fans. And why a leading car brand counts on us to keep their Dealer Network streamlined and nimble. Businesses count on communication, and communication counts on centurylink. [ clock titime. ] you only have so much. Thats why we want to make sure you wont have to wait on hold. And you wont have to guess when well turn up. Because after all we should fit into your life. Not the other way around. You know, to just be grossly
generalistic, you could put half of Trump Supporters into what i call the basket of deplorables. Right . The racist, sexists, islamic phobic. You name it. Unfortunately there are people like that. He has lifted them up. He has given voice to their websites that used to only have 11,000 people. Now have 11 million. He tweets and retweets offensive, hateful, mean spirited rhetoric. Some of those folks are irredeemable but thankfully they are not america. That was Hillary Clinton at a new york city fundraiser friday night seemingly writing off half
of the support donald trump is garnering. Clinton went onto say the other half of Trump Supporters felt left behind in the current economy and by the government and are in search of change. An outcry led clinton to clarify her remarks by saturday afternoon saying last night i was as she said in the first place grossly generalistic. Donald trump hired a major advocate for the altright movement. I meant what i said about last night about empathy. Many Trump Supporters are hard working americans who just dont feel like the economy or our political system are working for them. Trump responded to clintons reaction with his own statement calling her unfit and incapable to serve adding isnt it
disgraceful that Hillary Clinton makes the worst mistake of the political season and instead of owning up to this grotesque attack on American Voters she tries to turn it around with a pathetic are rehash of words and insults used in her failing campaign. For the first time her true feelings came out. How can she be president when she has contempt and disdain for so many great americans. What do you think of both statements . Trumps statement is very difficult to wrap my mind around. Why is that . Because i think we need to separate politics from the truth. Ive been saying on this show for weeks now what does this election suggest about the american electorate. What we do know is 60 of Trump Supporters believe they have a
negative view of islam. 67 of his supporters believe that we should build a wall or ban muslims from the country. Nearly 50 of Trump Supporters have a negative view of africanamericans. Over 40 think were lazy, were criminal and there was a poll that was shown after these statements and Trump Supporters horrifying in every way. But as far as who is lazy and who is this and that. Dav david, the week of the South Carolina primary, 80 support the ban on muslims entering america. 31 ban homosexuals entering america. 62 support a National Data base. 40 support shutting down all mosques in america. 33 say the practice of islam should be illegal. There are scores of other polls like that. Again, its not 50 but any candidate running against donald trump by the way, a lot of republicans were saying similar things back in the fall. The numbers show that there is a strain among Trump Supporters. The reason people have responded to this as a mistake by Hillary Clinton is characterizing your opponent supporters, americans who are out there getting ready to vote in language like that with basket of deplorables is going to stick and be a sound bite for the rest of the campaign. People will come back with all kinds of numbers. I think clinton was wise herself not to argue the point. She didnt do what you just did. I was wrong to use that language. I think that was probably the smart call. Not to show numbers that might
say heres what i meant but to say i was wrong. You know, Mark Halperin, those numbers shown there, the reason i remembered it is because other republicans back wall while trump was moving up, were going to have to come face to face with this in our party when you have 60 of republicans believing x in these primaries. So do you think what Hillary Clinton did was calculated . She knew things would blow up but would draw attention to a certain percentage of supporters for donald trump . No. You think it was a big mistake . I think she might have been speaking what she really believes in a way thats not politically acceptable to attack voters that way. I think everybody who disagrees with the position like the ones in that poll have to ask themselves if they would use the word deplorable to characterize the people that have those views. Very uncomfortable thing for the country right now. Doesnt that play into what we conservatives have been saying about liberals forever that they are just arrogant and condescending and look down their noses at us . Do you think the people that think mosques should be banned are deplorable . I would not call them deplorable. I would say its a deplorable position and born out of ignorance and as a leader my responsibility would be to talk to that segment of the Republican Party and tell them we need to keep everybody involved in this. Would i call them deplorable . Not in a million years. I would say their positions were deplorable and i would try to educate them. I had the same attitude about mitt romneys 74 thing. I dont think politicians should be judged in one statement. She needs to explain what she meant. The Clinton Campaign would say donald trump has said hundreds
of things just as outrageous and hes not being held accountable. The 47 remark fit a narrative that was building. I dont think this fits a narrative. If it fits a narrative, it fits a narrative that Hillary Clinton is the only appropriate candidate and even if youre a republican voting in this election because donald trump has so many hatred fueled policies that are based on such a lack of knowledge that its deplorable. Let me be clear. I would call david duke deplorable. I would call people who hold the positions of the altright deplorable. Folks are experiencing difficult Economic Times and seen wages flat line. Cant imagine a future. That sense has joined with a host of positions that are deplorable. We have to say this. We just have to say this. There are also a large number of
americans, maybe 50 of the people who were voting for donald trump who are voting for donald trump because they believe Hillary Clinton is deplorable. They believe the fact that the fbi passed on indicting her when over 50 of americans believed she deserved to be indicted. The way she handled benghazi. The way shes handled her career. The way she handled herself as secretary of state. What the she did back in the 1990s. Were sitting here looking at that one side of the ledger. The truth is a lot of educated people who are not struggling financially who dont like donald trump say were voting for donald trump because basically we find Hillary Clinton deplorable. So it cuts both ways. Until we see how trump and clinton react to those two things, health and deplorable, we dont know exactly the impact. I can say this in the drudge fox news world that drives a lot of republican turnout, those two
things, her health and that one remark will unify a lot of conservatives and turn them out in a way that are dangerous to her chances to winning. I got in trouble yesterday when i talked about this. Donald trump has called Hillary Clinton a bigot over and over again. Ive said every time theres no evidence that shes a bigot. I dont think shes a bigot. No question about it. The point i made yesterday which got me in trouble is this statement came close to at least the definition of what people think of as bigotry. She offered a blanket statement for a bunch of people and threw them all into a basket and said they were deplorable. That may or may not meet the dictionary definition of deplorable but to make that kind of a blanket statement about what will likely be 30 Million People. We just spent ten minutes talking about it while donald trump throughout this campaign has a campaign thats been laced
with racism, insults to gold star families, to women and muslim ban. Everything is let go and then he claims that hes not pc and this statement is so horrifying at her lack of being politically correct for one brief nanosecond. Everyone get a grip. I dont think its a question of politically correct. When she gave the altright speech. It was a fantastic speech to give. Call out racists and call out xenophobes and hit donald trump hard when he says things that are racist. Its not a defensible position to write off 30 Million People. The reason its not defensible, because she apologized for it. I think its important that we make a distinction. Will are people idealogically who view Hillary Clinton in a bad light. She might think shes deplorable for ideological reasons. Theres a sense in which that statement was about the altright. Half of the voters are these folks and went on to lay on what she meant. What she meant or what she was referring to was those folks she talked about on the altright. This is what i think i do think this. Underneath this entire election has been the ugliness of race. The ugliness of racism. Unless we acknowledge this in a very honest and direct way i think 50 is high. I think she made a mistake generalizing. Which she said. Again, after 9 11, you know, over 35 of democrats thought
that george bush was inside on the attacks on 9 11. Probably the same number if they took polling thought fdr was inside on the attacks of pearl harbor. She said it was grossly generalistic. Is there one racist or insulting or inappropriate comment that donald trump has made that he apologized for along the way that we talked about for ten minutes . No. He offered that blanket apology with he said if theres anybody i ever offended i think at the end of the day this is much to do about nothing. The Trump Campaign thinks this is huge. People are going to be hyperventilating about it a lot. We wont be talking about it next week. Nobody will remember. Well be right back with much more morning joe including some razor tight state polls between trump and clinton. These things are close. Isaac hou has mastered gravity defying moves to amaze his audience. Great show. Here you go. Now hes added a new routine. Making depositing a check seem so effortless. Easy to use chase technology, for whatever you trying to master. Isaac,re you ready . Yeah. Chase. So you can. Americans are buying more and more of everything online. And so many businesses rely on the United States Postal Service
to get it there. Because when you ship with us, your business becomes our business. Thats why we make more ecommerce deliveries to homes than anyone else in the country. The United States Postal Service. Priority you
fmale teacher and then name thelargest planet . T . Male teacher someone we havent heard from. Female teacher anyone else . Through internet essentials, comcast is on track to connect 3 Million People in need to low cost, high Speed Internet at home, helping to make sure that every hand in the classroom goes up. Male teacher okay, veronica. Amphibian. Male teacher excellent. Welcome to a brighter future. Welcome to it all. Comcast. Up next, nicholas joins the conversation here on set. Were going to hes great. We like nick. Well get davids take on the syrian ceasefire with word that more than 90 people in the option were slain over the weekend. Well be right back with much more morning joe. Anyone with type 2 diabetes knows how it feels to see your numbers go up, despite your best efforts. But what if you could turn things around . What if you could. Love younumbers . Discover oncedaily invokana®. Its the 1 prescribed sglt2 inhibitor that works to lower a1c. A pill taken just once in the morning, invokana® is used along with diet and exercise to significantly lower blood sugar in adults with type 2 diabetes. In fact, its been proven
to be more effective at lowering a1c than januvia. Invokana® works around the clock by reducing the amount of sugar allowed back into the body, and sending some sugar out through the process of urination. And while its not for lowering systolic Blood Pressure or weight loss, it may help you with both. Invokana® can cause important side effects, including dehydration, which may cause you to feel dizzy, faint, lightheaded, or weak, upon standing. Other side effects may include kidney problems, genital yeast infections, changes in urination, high potassium, increases in cholesterol, risk of boneracture, or urinary tract infections, possibly serious. Serious side effects may include ketoacidosis, which can be life threatening. Stop taking and call your doctor right away if you experience symptoms. Or if you experience symptoms of allergic reaction such as rash, swelling, or difficulty breathing or swallowing. Do not take invokana® if you have severe liver or kidney problems or are on dialysis. Tell your doctor about any medical conditions and medications you take. Using invokana® with a sulfonylurea or insulin may cause low blood sugar. Its time to turn things around. Lower your blood sugar with invokana®. Imagine loving your numbers. Theres only one invokana®. Ask your doctor about it by name. [ala m beeping] the highly advanced audi a4. Heres my prediction. My prediction is its going to be i dont want to talk about. I feel really bad but people say people say shes frail. If youre kind of frail so more sadness than anger. He will come in sadness. Hope shes okay. Bob costas is reporting. Hes just all in the back room working. Hes a scribbler. Hes working. Bob reports that hes going to focus on deplorables. He would know a lot about it. Hes a very disciplined and focused he would know about
statements that are not politically correct. A lot about statements that have insulted people. Hes the expert on statements that insult people. Clinton up 51 to 43 . She has a lead in a matchup when you add mr. Aleppo. The latest nbc news wall street journal poll show them tight in four battleground states. In New Hampshire, clinton has a twopoint lead 39 to trumps 37 . I was in New Hampshire over the weekend. Some of the attack ads were really tough. Harsh. Wow. It seems like a tough race. Deplorable. In nevada, trump leads clinton by single digit 42 to 41 . Georgia trump at 44 and clinton
at 42 and johnson at 10 and look at deep red arizona. Trump leads by just two points. All within the major of error. Clinton is ahead in florida by two points. 44 to 42 . And in ohio, clinton leads trump by seven points. 46 to 39 . So there were a lot of polls there, republicans should be way away in georgia. In arizona. You would expect hillary to do better in nevada and New Hampshire. A lot better. Its a tie. Joining us now, Political Writer for the New York Times. Hello, nick. Good morning. Its a tie. Im excited that we have tightening polls to bring excitement back to this race. You sound very excited. Im not excited by it. Its been slow. Some people are scared. Its fascinating. I think it certainly goes back to the question of why is she struggling in her own way while he blows up bridges and ticks off people and insults all groups and perhaps its because she says things like basket of deplorables one day and insults people who might otherwise vote for her. I dont know. How do you explain a state that trump is way ahead, is tied and New Hampshire is tied. Hes not a conventional republican. Hes not trying to get the coalition that mitt romney is trying to get. Hes looking for different kinds of voters. I think he scrambles the normal calcul calculus. I think modern republicans and nonwhite voters are going to her in greater numbers than they have to past democrats. Hes getting crossover. I think these polls are all interesting and shows the race is close. Its a fourstraight race right now. Pennsylvania, ohio, North Carolina and florida. And those states are ones where pennsylvania, florida, ohio and North Carolina. Does trump have to win all four of those . His route to 270 without all four is really tough. I was going to say, david, all of these polls that weve been reading are from states he has to win. New hampshire, georgia, ohio. You go down the line. Florida. This is all trump territory. And yet even in arizona its tied. Hes in much more difficulty in the states that ought to be his. He already should have locked some of these states up. He has to spend money in states like florida and even in
georgia. I think thats fascinating. Im really curious about turnout and i wonder what our experts think. Some of these pollsters see a softening in support among younger voters. Can you hold a second. Alex, can we get some experts. Working on them. Go ahead. So if all of you would speak to the question about turnout, about whether theres softening among the core, constituency supporting clinton in particular. This is why i think georgia and New Hampshire dont matter. If trump has a chance to win, he has to win those four states. If trump wins ohio, believe me, believe me, hell win georgia. Hes not going to somehow lose georgia if he wins ohio. Those red states are close. They show problems he has. If he has a chance to win, he has to win those four. Youre saying he has to win pennsylvania, florida, ohio, and
North Carolina to win. The next most likely path involves wearing six states where hes currently behind. If he didnt win pennsylvania, thats the most likely one for him not to win. He could put together a thing where he won New Hampshire and nevada and theres a way to do it. Its a complicated map for him. Unlikely if he doesnt win pennsylvania. Heres to davids question. This is an important thing. If you look at the abc news the Washington Post poll, its clear that trump voters are more enthusiastic right now than clinton voters. Part of the reason shes doing why with registered voter is because of that. Right now. That may change between now and election day. Theyre not as enthusiastic. If johnson and stein collapse, shes a much better position. You know who is in energetic and excited . Nick has brought it to the set today. Tell me, nick, why are these
races tied . Why are they so close . Why is georgia so close . Same question you asked me ten seconds ago. Partly we have these two thirdparty candidates who are pulling unexpected voters. Who is gary johnson pulling from . Conservatives that dont want to vote for trump. People that think hes too toxic. I think also if you looked at those polls more closely, i suspect you would find that trump polls from some working class whites who might vote on democratic in some place. Youll see collapsing support around suburban White College educated people. Jill stein will pull lefties. You see almost in the polls that youre reciting everyone is below 50 . Amazing. Scrambles in weird ways. As you were saying, you cant win ohio and lose georgia. Its not going to happen. Nick, thank you very much for bringing much needed excitement to the set. Is that better . I wanted to give you a second chance. Coming up on morning joe given the performances, plural this week, of donald trump, are you still convinced that hes the best choice for National Security issues . Thank you. Thanks. Thanks a lot. Look, ive supported the nominee of the party. Next question. Look, honestly. Im not here to talk about donald trump. And hes not going to. Why arent any Republican Leaders here to talk about
donald trump . We had this problem with corker. Paul ryan cant answer the question. You guys dont like your candidate. Just say it. You think hes terrible. Say it. They are saying that. Was that it . Mccains speak. That was it. Obvious. Thats why everyone is laughing. We get chairman of the Homeland Security committee Michael Mccaul. He may not want to talk about donald trump either but we may ask him about his partys nominee and talking about where we stand 15 years after 9 11. ,. You guys are working on some pretty big stuff over there, right . Like a new language for crazybig, worldchanging machines. Well, not me specifically. I work on the industrial side. So i build the worldchanging machines. I get it. You cant talk because its super highlevel. No, i actually do build the machines. Blink if what youre doi volves encrypted data transfer. Wait, what . Wowwww. Wow . What wow . There is no wow. What powers the Digital World . Communication. Like centurylinks Broadband Network that gives 35,000 fans a cutting edge game experience. Or t network that keeps a leading hotel chains guests connected at work, and at play. Or the it platform that powers millions of ecards every day for one of the largest greeting card companies. Businesses count on mmunication, and communication counts on centurylink. You made with your Airline Credit card. These purchases hold on. You only got double miles on stuff you bought from that airline . Let me show you something better. The capital one venture card. With venture, you earn unlimited double miles on every purchase. Not just. dismissively airline purchases. Every purchase. Everywhere. Every day. No really double miles on all of them whats in your wallet . When this busy family. Got a cracked windshield. Their dad went to the new safelitedotcom. And scheduled a replacement. In just a few clicks. With safelite you dont have to miss a thing. Yall did wonderful thank you. girls sing safelite repair, safelite replace. Coming up at the top of the hour, diagnosed with pneumonia just hours after Hillary Clinton left a 9 11 Memorial Service the campaign is finally explaining what was behind her departure but should they have disclosed it sooner . What i find out through this process is most candidates on these long brutal campaigns end up with walking pneumonia. It makes sense. You dont sleep. You dont eat well. You shake a zillion hands. People are coughing and sneezing on you. Its not really surprising, is it . We almost louis on one of those things. Donald Trumps Campaign manager Kellyanne Conway is in studio and mike mccaul says its a false narrative to think of Vladimir Putin as a friend. How hes breaking with his partys nominee on russia next on morning joe. How can good paying jobs disappear . Its what the National Debt could do to our economy. If we dont solve our debt problem 19 trillion and growing money for prrams like education will shrink. In just 8 years, interest on the debt will be our Third Largest federal program. Bad news for small businesses. The good news . Theres still time for a solution. Ask the candidates for a plan to secure our future. The full value of your totaled new car. The guy says, you picked the wrong insurance plan. No, i picked the wrong Insurance Company. With new car replacementâ„¢, well replace the full value of your car plus depreciation. Liberty mutual insurance. Using 60,000 points from my chase ink card i bought all the framework. Wire. And plants needed to give my shop. A face. No one will forget. See what the power of points can do for your business. Learn more at chase. Com ink seewhy does your tummy gonts grumbily, grumbily, grumbily . No more questions for you ooph, that milk in your cereal was messing with you, wasnt it . Try lactaid, its real milk, without that annoying lactose. Good, right . Mmm, yeah. Lactaid. The milk that doesnt mess with you. W. I was always searching for ways to manage my symptoms. I thought i had it covered. Then i realized managing was all i was doing. When i finally told my doctor, he said humira was for people like me who have tried other medications,. But still experience the symptoms of moderate to severe crohns disease. In clinical studies, the majority of patients on humira saw significant symptom relief. And many achieved remission. Humira can lower your ability to fight infections. Including tuberculosis. Serious, sometimes fatal infections and cancers,. Including lymphoma, have happened; as have blood, liver, and nervous system problems, serious allergic reactions,. And new or worsening heart failure. Before treatment, get tested for tb. Tell your doctor if youve been to areas where certain fungal infections are common, and if youve had tb,. Hepatitis b, are prone to infections,. Or have flulike symptoms or sores. Dont start humira if you have an infection. If youre still just managing your symptoms, ask your gastroenterologist about humira. With humira, remission is possible. My people are so smart. The polls say i have the most loyal people. I could stand in the middle of fifth avenue and shoot somebody and i wouldnt lose any voters, okay. Its incredible. Shes being so protected she could walk into this arena right now and shoot somebody with 20,000 people watching right smack in the middle of the heart and she wouldnt be prosecuted, okay. Thats whats happened. That is whats happened to our
country. I never thought i would see the day when this is happening to our country. You know why who talks this way without their mother getting very upset. That day, thank god, has not come to this country. Because im thinking if Hillary Clinton went into that arena and shot somebody in the middle of the heart, if she did that, i think you could probably go inside and just look at maybe some of the demographics if you go and track thats the republican nominee for president of the United States. We have with us and im very excited about this, we have dr. Lawrence odonnell who told us the first system of a heart attack is. The most common first symptom of Heart Disease for men is death. Thats the most common first symptom. Hes going to talk about this
more tonight. What are you talking about . When you wonder about someones health and you want a picture of your health, the true answer is we dont know. We can give you these documents but anyone sitting here could be dead by the end of today from natural causes. Thank you, lawrence. Donald trump set the bar so low that you can follow up with that statement and it actually sounds better. We have eddie here. Yes. Eddie is here. Chair of the department of africanamerican studies at princeton university. Heilemann is here. Columnist and associate editor for the Washington Post. David is with us. And joining the discuss, host of the last word he just had the last word, lawrence odonnell. Im not sure i want to you say for. We were talking about the health thing. I was explaining during the break why i actually dont care. I dont care about candidates
health. You dont care about Donald Trumps . No. Fdr in his last campaign for respect was dying during the campaign. Guess what . He died. And when he died so we probably should have known he was dying because this guy from missouri had to drop the bomb. Heres the thing. If you asked fdr voters what would they have done if any knew he was dying, they probably would have voted for him and not one of him when he died was out there saying i wish he told me that so i wouldnt have voted for him. Its why the choice of Vice President is important. Truth of the matter is that any of us could die at any moment. On that happy note, we have people talking about getting shot in the heart. Dying any moment. Why would he say that . What a horrible thing to say. Did the audience applaud . I mean i dont know why they were so quiet about that. What a horrific thing to say. Hillary clinton canceled a california trip after falling ill during the 9 11 Memorial Service. We just learned that shes going to appear at a fundraiser via teleconference. She was diagnosed with pneumonia days earlier but that was only explained after a morning rife with speculation. Clinton joined donald trump during a ceremony in Lower Manhattan on a warm day. After more than an hour there, she left abruptly appearing on unsteady. Press was left in the dark with the campaign mum on where the democratic nominee was going or what happened. Video of her entering the van showed her unsteady. She leaned on a post and at one point her legs seemed to buckle. At 11 00 a. M. Her campaign did put out a statement saying in part she felt overheated so she departed to go to her daughters apartment and is feeling much
better. The Campaign Says she even played with her grandkids there before appearing in front of the awaiting press. Let me ask John Heilemann this question. John, i know im going to get texts from friends and family members that are going to say to me we told you she was sick. We told you there was a problem. Youre part of a huge she coughed. She coughed. Fine. This, that, the other. But lets be serious about it. There are a lot of Trump Supporters out there that think the press is conspireing to cover up some Massive Health problem that Hillary Clinton has. What does the press do to prove that theyre going after aggressively as they would if it were somebody else . I think the press should be asking for both candidates, Hillary Clinton and donald trump, to meet Something Like the historical standard for Health Record disclosure that most president ial nominees have met in the past. Since when . Not since 1960. After that. How about that. Well do this. Not this century. You knew nothing about fdrs hol health. Were in the 21st century. I would be happy going back to kennedy. Kennedy didnt disclose. Say 20 years, 30 years, whatever it is. This century. Go. Lets have the press argue aggressively for trying to get the candidates to do more than they currently have done which is not disclose much. Hillary clinton has disclosed more about her health than donald trump has. Its incumbent on both of them to give us greater access to their Health Records and i think that the reality is that anybody at this table ever had walking pneumonia . I have. Ive had something happen to me while having walking pneumonia similar to what happened to her. You know, i passed out because i tried to power through. So i look at that and i totally recognizable phenomenon. However, she had a situation that occurred back in december of 2012. We dont know except for what we heard from the doctors letter we have seen, we dont know much about that. Bill clinton this weekend said it took her longer to recover from that concussion than expected. So to clean this up, to clear it up, and i say this is incumbent on donald trump as much as Hillary Clinton, if they want to have trust of the american people, they should be more transparent. David, by historical standards, the two candidates both when it comes to their health are far under the bar. Youre never going to get donald trump to release his tax records. Youre never going to get him to release his medical record. Hes just not. Youre never going to get him to admit the president was born in america. So what does that leave the
media with . Well, if the candidates dont give the Additional Information about their health, then we start digging. And youve already begun to see that. There was some good reporting in the paper this morning on donald trump looking at his finances and looking at the deals hes done and looking at the implied tax situation. You have seen some of that. Youll see a lot more. So i think the candidates may try to stiff the media in entirely legitimate requests on behalf of the voters of half of the public. These are things we do need to know. If the candidates say no, well keep reporting. So lets go. Well move now to basket of deplorables. Lets play the clip for lawrence odonnell. She said this at a fundraiser friday night. To be closely generalistic, you could put half of Trump Supporters into what i call the wbr id wbr41390 basket of deplorables. b
right . [ applause ] the racist, sexists, homophobic, xenophobic. You name it. Unfortunately there are people like that. And he has lifted them up. He has given voice to their websites that used to only have 11,000 people. Now have 11 million. He tweets and retweets. Offensive, hateful, mean spirited rhetoric. Now some of those folks, they are irredeemable but thankfully they are not america. We can talk about what a terrible mistake this was. I have to say i think it was all calculated. I think i stand alone. I think this was a trump move, which is you Say Something that
the media and your opponent is going to think is outrageous. It stays in the press. Every day it stays in the press it has everyone going, okay, lets look at put up that poll. Lets see. Lets look back at the South Carolina poll. Are they really deplorable because i dont know where they are. Lets look at the data and see if theyre deplorable. If you go back to South Carolina, you see that 80 of trump voters supported banning muslims entering america. 62 demanded National Data base. 40 wanted to shutdown all mosques in america. A third said islam should be illegal. Look at the second one. 31 support a ban on homosexuals entering the United States. Hillary clinton knew by saying that she would get the blowback and then this sort of information would follow and
just like trump you create a controversy that allows the battle to be fought on your grounds for the next three or four days. Unlike trump, she does a form of retraction of the statement saying i wish i hadnt said half. So whenever i see a politician thats a doub ind they wish they hadnt said it that way. She used the same exact words in her apology. This is grossly generalistic. I apologize. I was being grossly generalistic. Youre right. Very first thing i went to when she said this was the polls. The majority believe, majority of Trump Supporters believe president obama is not a citizen. A majority of Trump Supporters believe president obama is muslim. Not that theres anything wrong with that. These are people that cant separate wbrid wbr43190 fact from fiction. She rattled off a bunch of deplorable ideas. Theres no argument that the ideas she was rattling off are deplorable. But in the first ten minutes of this hour, we have run two statements that caused controversy. One was just rude and kind of low brow ugly thing to say. Donald trump is not apologizing. The shot in the heart thing . Yes. And the second thing, we have picked apart for many minutes now over the course of two hours and shes already apologized for it. The donald trump Hillary Clinton can shoot people is nothing less than mental illness. No politician can ever suggest that theres an American Voter out there who is in any way indecent or maybe not quite smart enough to be trusted with a vote. Bill clinton cautioned that Donald Trumps vow to make America Great again might mean something more ominous for minority groups who face discrimination from an earlier
era. Speaking last week at a rally in orlando, clinton said he remembered the good old days and knew exactly what trumps message meant. Im actually old enough to remember the good old days and they werent all that good in many ways. That message i give you America Great again is if youre a white southerner, you know exactly what it means, dont you . What it means is i give you the economy you had 50 years ago and ill move you back up on the social totem pole and other people down. Hillary clinton was to take the totem pole down and let us all go forward together. Its so great. I love that bill clinton called out all politicians. Past and present. That used what he considers to be a racist term. I think you have to reexamine the historical record of every
single politician that ever used that term based on what bill clinton said this weekend, mika. Let me write that down here. Im going to write a column. What a racist thing to say. Bill clinton said himself back in 1991 at the announcement of his candidacy for president. I believe that together we can make America Great again and with your help, your heart, your devotion and your efforts, we can build a community of hope that will inspire the world. I know what hes talking about there. You know what the problem is . Hes a white guy from the south. Hes talking about making America Great. I was there. I was there, okay. It wasnt that great, okay. All right. Thats horrible. He meant the same thing donald trump meant. Joining us hold on a second. Seeing that clip of bill clinton in 1991, doesnt that show us just this journey continues. For sure. A Straight Line from 91 to 16. Bill clinton is coming out of dlc. Hes engaging in triangleation. Joining us from chappaqua, andrea mitchell. Tough weekend for the Clinton Campaign. Where do we stand . In 1991, bill and Hillary Clinton could not have afforded to live here in chappaqua. America is a lot greater than it
was back in 1991. All that stuff that happened after they left the white house. Look, this was so botched. This was so mishandled. The issue of transparency. This only reinforces all of the conspiracy theories. Weve all been trying to fact check and pointing out that theres nothing wrong with her. Im on the campaign with her. Aside from that cough. She has more energy than i do or half of the press corps which is a lot younger than her. The fact is they have only made things worse because theyve helped donald trump and Rudy Giuliani and all of the others who are making such an issue out of her health. Trump so far has not talked about it. Hes been smart enough to listen to advisers probably to stay quiet while your opponent is missing their own campaign up. The fact they didnt say anything on friday when they had
an affirmative obligation to the public through us after telling us that the cough in cleveland on labor day was just seasonal allergies, which is what she thought. After she had an exam on friday morning, they had an affirmative obligation to tell us about the diagnosis of pneumonia. And then the secrecy yesterday and for an hour half the press corps, protective press pool, the pool of reporters, which is supposed to be with her just for this kind of emergency, they are kept back at the ceremony. They dont know that shes theyre not told shes gone to chelseas apartment. Theyre brought there so we can see her coming out looking very spry and hugging the little girl and then eight hours after this first happened they finally tell us about the diagnosis of pneumonia that occurred on friday. Im sorry. There is an obligation not written, not in law, but theres an obligation and donald trump is even worse than she is in terms of telling us anything about his medical history. Weve got a lot of problems with both campaigns. No doubt about that. Thank you, andrea. David, i want to show you Financial Times headline. Warning to Syrian Rebels amid rare show of u. S. Russian unity talk about this ceasefire that is coming up. Do we have any reason to believe that its going to bring some bit of relief to the people of aleppo and the entire country . We have hope. I dont know if i would go further to reason. In a few hours when the muslim holiday begins, a ceasefire is supposed to begin in syria. If it lasts seven days, then the u. S. And russia will begin jointly targeting isis and al qaeda positions in syria. Working together on the target sets. Its hard to imagine the u. S. And russia doing it. And then after that happens in
theory, the Syrian Air Force will stop bombing, which would be a huge change in these contested areas. There are lots of reasons to think this wont hold over the weekend it was a mess. Almost always the case before ceasefires. You have to give secretary kerry credit for sticking with this and getting finally the deal hes been working on really since last february. All right. Well be following that as well. Lawrence odonnell, thank you for being on the show. Donald trump must be proud of john kerrys deal making. He has great things to say about kerry. David, thank you as well. Still ahead on morning joe, the chairman of the Homeland Security committee joins the table and Kellyanne Conway joins us here on set. Youre watching morning joe. Well be right back. Hero. Hes not a war hero, hes a war hero because he was captured. I like people that werent captured ok. Donald trump compared his sacrifices to the sacrifices of two parents who lost their son in war. How would you answer that father . What sacfice have you made for your country . I thinive made a lot of sacrifices, built great structures. Ive had tremendous success, i think. Those are sacrifices . Remember here at ally, nothing stops us from doing right by our customers. Whos with me . Im in. Im in. Im in. Im in. One, two, wait, wait. Wait wheres tina . Doing the hand thing . Yep we are all in for our customers. Ally. Do it right. Fmale teacher and then wname thelargest planet . T . Omers. Male teacher someone we havent heard from. Female teacher anyone else . Through internet essentials,
comcast is on track to connect 3 Million People in need to low cost, high Speed Internet at home, helping to make sure that every hand in the classroom goes up. Male teacher okay, veronica. Amphibian. Male teacher excellent. Welcome to a brighter future. Welcome to it all. Comcast. That irrational hostility toward president obama is unpatri unpatriotic. [ applause ] if you cant tell the difference between leadership and dictatorship, you wont face a fifth great civics exam. Tim, when donald trump and i said that the small and bullying president of russia was a strong leader on the world stage, that wasnt an endorsement of Vladimir Putin. That was an indictment of the weak effectless leadership of this president and your running mate. One thing you can certainly say putting these two next to each other, republicans now how to give their Vice President s better sound systems. Donald trump came under criticism this weekend. An open letter published saying
that trump cannot serve as commander in chief if he embraces putin. Joining us now, chairman of the house Homeland Security committee, Michael Mccaul of texas. Before we talk about anything, lets talk about the remembrance yesterday at ground zero. Talk about how moving that was. What you saw. Very moving as always. Very good turnout. Its the first time ive seen both president ial candidates show up to Something Like this. Every new york police chief was there. When they read the names and at that takes as you know about four hours to read 3,000 names, you get the gravity of that moment 15 years ago. Lets talk about syria. Right now obviously whats been going on in syria and aleppo has been a nightmare and we have not responded quickly enough through the years. What should we do . What else can we do as a nation to bring peace to that region . Well, i think weve been put in a bad position. I think four years of not making a decision is a decision in and of itself. Russians are in there now. So how do we deal with a very complex Foreign Policy civil war situation. The russian interests are different from ours in terms of propping up syria from their point of view and alliance from iran. One thing we share is going against isis. They havent demonstrated that capability. Theyve been doing assads bidding. Gone against rebel forces to help assad. If they would join us in targeting isis, that would be a very positive step. I dont really trust the russians and i think peace through strength that reagan talked about and trust but verify. Look, in theory it would be a
great step forward but were still a little bit cautious about it. Is Vladimir Putin one of the most dangerous men on the world stage when it comes to opposing American Interest . In terms of naked aggression. He sees weakness and that invites aggression. Mr. Putin has crimea. Hes aggressive in cyberattacks especially on our election system going into november. I think hes a very dangerous man. Once kbg always kbg. Who do you want to stare him down in a diplomatic negotiation . Do you think the republican nominee fully understands what you just said . I spoke with him yesterday. I urged caution when it comes to this man. He respects him in terms of his strength being a strong man. I think mr. Trump envisions
himself in that light as well. Urged caution to not think that we can embrace him. Mr. Putin is not our friend. Your father knows this very well. I mean with all due respect, does donald trump understand that . His advisers do. Thats important to note. Hes being advised by people like myself and others that this is not look, if you can work with him to take out isis you say he doesnt but advisers do so thats a circle of safety around somebody who doesnt get it . I think he has respect for the man. Respect that he thinks hes in a better position than Hillary Clinton to sit in the room with him and stare him down. Based on what you know, the talk of the russians trying to interfere with our election, what would they do . I cant im not at liberty to go into much of this. Its in the classified space. There are the allegations out there that they are attempting to undermine our democracy
hitting not just Democratic Party but the Republican Party. A threat they tried to change the result by faking more votes to one side . Its unclear at this point in time what their motive is. We have seen russia in the past demonstrate a capability to influence and mess with elections in europe and so were very concerned about these latest allegations. What do you think of the allegation that Vladimir Putin is somehow playing donald trump and manipulating him by flattering him . The response to that would be they hit both parties. Its not like they singled out the democrats. They singled out republicans as well. Were not sure what the motivation is other than potentially to undermine our way of life. Our democratic system in elections. All right. Chairman mike mccaul, thank you very much. I appreciate your candor. We appreciate you coming on. Thanks. Coming up, donald Trumps Campaign manager kellyanne
conway joins us live to talk about their strategy Going Forward and how they plan to respond to the basket of deplorable comments from Hillary Clinton. Thats just ahead. When you have something you love, you want to protect it. At legalzoom, our network of attorneys can help you every step of the way. With an estate plan including wills or a living trust that grows along with you and your family. Legalzoom. Legal help is here. Or keeping a Hotels Guests cuttinconnected. I to 35,000 fans. Businesses count on communication, and communication counts on centurylink. Safety doesnt come in a box. Its not a banner that goes on a wall. Its not something you do now and then. Or when its convenient. Its using stateoftheart simulators to better prepare for any situation. Its giving offshore teams onshore support. And its empowering anyone to stop a job if something doesnt seem right. At bp, safety is never being satisfied. And its empowering anyone to stop a job and always working to be better. At bp, safety is never being satisfied. And its empowering anyone to stop a job wiback like it could used to . Neutrogena hydro boost water gel. With hyaluronic acid it plumps skin cells with intense hydration and locks it in. For supple, hydrated skin. Hydro boost. From neutrogena
over the last few months donald trump has been critical of Hillary Clintons health and has questioned her fitness to be president. Shell stand at the teleprompter and spin around a couple times. Always a very short speech. Then she gets off the stage. She goes back home. She goes to sleep. To win trade in our country, you need tremendous physical and mental strength and stamina. Hillary clinton doesnt have that strength or stamina. Believe me. You know it. And they know it. And Everybody Knows it. She didnt go to louisiana. She didnt go to mexico. She was invited. She doesnt have the strength or the stamina to make America Great again. Believe me. So is he going to continue saying those sort of things in light of what happened this past weekend . He certainly hasnt yet today. But his Campaign Manager Kellyanne Conway joins us next. Were back in just a minute with more morning joe. At safelite, we know how busy life can be. These kids were headed to their first dance recital. When their windshield got cracked. But they couldnt miss the show. So dad went to the new safelitedotcom. And in just a few clicks, he scheduled a replacement. Before the girls even took the stage. Safelitedotcom is the fast, easy way to Schedule Service anywhere in america so you dont have to miss a thing. Yall did wonderful thats another safelite advantage. girls sing safelite repair, safelite replace. Using 60,0 points from my chase ink card i bought all the fruit. Veggies. I bought all the fruit. And herbs needed to create a popup pickyourown juice bar in the middle of the city, so now everyone knows. We have some of the freshest juice in town. See what the power of points can do for your business. Learn more at chase. Com ink see what the power of points can do for your business. Its scary when the lights go out. People get anxious and my office gets flooded with calls. So many things can go wrong. Its my worst nightmare. Every second that power is out, myitys at risk. Siemens digital grid manages and reroutes power, so service can be restored within seconds. Priority number one is keeping those lights on. It takes ingenuity to defeat the monsters that live in the dark. Is it a professor who never stops being a student . Is it a caregiver determined to take care of her own . Or is it a lifetime of work that blazes the path to your passions . Your personal success takes a Financial Partner who values it as much as you do. Learn more at tiaa. Org
i really just dont know. I hope she gets well soon. The coughing fit was a week ago. I assume that was pneumonia also. I would think it would have been. Something is going on. I hope she gets well and gets back on the trail and well be seeing her at the debate. So health is an issue now, right . I think its an issue. In fact, this last week i took a physical. Ill be releasing when the numbers come in. Hopefully theyll be good. I think theyre going to be good. I feel great. When the numbers come in, ill be releasing very, very specific numbers. That was donald trump earlier this morning. Joining us now, donald Trumps Campaign manager Kellyanne Conway. Very good to have you on the show. Thank you for having me. So donald had a physical last week . Yes, he did. End of last week. When are we going to hear about it . Were told well get the results from the doctor this week. As he just said on a different network, joe, hell release those. Its important. Do you know what specifically were going to learn about him . Blood pressure and i dont know that. Im not a doctor. None of them are my patients so i dont go there. I can tell you there being out on the campaign trail with him and you know having been a successful candidate, joe, its just so mentally and physically exhausting. I look at the schedule for this week. Well be in seven different swing states, five or six rallies, fundraisers, roundtables, its gruelling but people expect you to go where they are. If youre going to do fundraisers all the time or speech here and there it doesnt work for voters. In your hometown of pensacola, he had an unbelievable crowd. People up to the rafters. Whatever the capacity is, 12,000, 13,000 people, they were there and overcrowd people of 8,000 or 10,000 outside that couldnt get in. I think these crowds matter. People say it doesnt matter. It does matter. Since youve been around campaigns, you understand how gruelling this is and you can understand lets say what happened to Hillary Clinton the other day. Because it is so gruelling if someone gets woozy and starts to pass out and has to be righted, its not really shocking given the schedule day in and day out . I would echo mr. Trumps statement that i hope shes feeling better and gets back on the trail soon. What i learned this weekend were two things about Hillary Clinton. Shes had a very bad 48 hours. One, shes still not transparent. She wont open herself up to the press. The nonsense she respects what do you by having this phony press availability on the plane last week and moment you need to be with her, 90 minutes of radio silence. Took the entire day to get a diagnosis that she had received days earlier and i think its important because, joe, it ended up the number one story yesterday was Hillary Clinton
falling in front of that van and then ultimately her pneumonia diagnosis. The number one story should have been 9 11. So donald says something is going on. Do you think something is going on with her health . Thats a lay person saying as llions of americans will, what we know is her doctor diagnosed her with pneumonia and is on antibiotics. Being around him and being his Campaign Manager, i see the type of energy and stamina that you need longterm. Does she have that from what youve seen . I think anybody who runs for president does at that point. At some point, joe. I guess my question second thing i learned about her is she feels so comfortable to tell a bunch of money fat cats on wall street what she really thinks of people. One of the most candid moments for Hillary Clinton came friday night when she actually we got her true feelings about what she thinks about tens of millions of americans. Thats offensive to me. He and mike pence were at a fair in ohio last week where there were probably 85,000 people there. Ten deep just to see them. Are the military that support him by 20 points, are these the deplorables . People i saw at the fair deplorables . Sticking people into categories is what we shouldnt do. She meant people that support the muslim ban and sexist and racist and go against the basic tenants and morales that our country are based on. It came off wrong and using the word half was incorrect. Were still waiting to hear your candidate say that he thinks that president was born in this country and theres a long list of things that he has said that he has not apologized for that really are deplorable. How do you confront that and then find yourself able to call out Hillary Clinton on something that she actually has apologized for when your candidate is not
accountable for anything he says, not one thing. Quite frankly on september 11th weekend talked about Hillary Clinton shooting someone in the heart. Is that okay . He was using that as an example of what she gets by with by the media because she treats them as secondclass citizens. Whats not okay is everything he has said has been vetted and talked about on this show and elsewhere probably hundreds of thousands of times. Whats not okay is for Hillary Clinton to malign the character and the intention of millions of people and then pretend shes apologizing by repeating the same criticisms. She could said im sorry if i offended anyone or to coin a phrase in North Carolina last month, i regret causing personal pain. She said i shouldnt have said half. Shes quibbling with the numbers. Shes not apologizing to hard working americans for calling them these terrible insults. The problem for Hillary Clinton is when you see her in her own
words, when you see her yesterday and when you see her on friday night in front of the people that were laughing and shame on them as well by the way who were laughing. They think its so funny. When you see her where she cant go blame the right wing conspiracy, thats Hillary Clinton. Im working for a brilliant man. Shes reading scripted words and they call it a gaff. She said it before. We talk about energy and stamina to be president. What about the knowledge . It seems like a lot of what donald trump says is not based on knowledge. I just ask the chairman of the house Homeland Security Committee Republican congressman Michael Mccaul after he stated a list of things of terrible things about Vladimir Putin, if donald trump truly understood those things and his answer was his advisers do. And then he doubled down on it. Does your candidate have the knowledge to be president . Yes, he does. I was with him yesterday does he know anything about russia . Yes, he does. What exactly does he know . He knows a lot about russia. He knows enough that when hes president we wont get pushed around and to say that when hes president , if Vladimir Putin and other people want to join in stopping isis which killed 33,000 people, isis and its predecessors in the last 12 years, 80 of those deaths came in the last three years, the birth and growth of isis happened on president obama and secretary clintons watch. Theres no question. If we can get someone thats going to help stop that advance, Hillary Clinton referred to them as our determined enemies. What does that mean . Were playing them in a soccer match . What is a determined enemy . They are savage murderers. They kill people on our soil and abroad. I would not underestimate donald trump in these debates. You saw that in the commander in chief forum last week where all of the polls including your own nbc poll said he won that debate. People want to attack matt lauer. He didnt set up the private email server. He didnt lie about it. He certainly didnt vote for the war in iraq. She has a lot of explaining to do. The doctor who previously testified on mr. Trumps health, is he the one who conducted his physical last week . I wasnt present when he had his physical. Mr. Trump feels its very important for candidates for president to be very forthcoming with their health and feels great. What standard of disclosure are you looking for . As much as previous nominees have put out . You would have to ask the doctor that. Im not a doctor. Im not sure what the doctor will reveal. Do you believe in the previous standards of disclosure by john mccain, mitt romney, barack obama or something short of that . Maybe short of that. I would have to look at what they revealed. I have to tell you i have never studied their medical records and what they disclosed. As you saw this weekend and particularly yesterday, its incredibly important to be forthcoming if you have a diagnosis of pneumonia be honest when you say youre overheating. We wish her well. Were glad that hell be back on the campaign trail. Were sorry she had to cancel a couple fundraisers today. That probably wont hurt much. Given that youre making the case for transparency and donald trump will put forward some of his medical records on the basis of this physical, mike pence put out his tax returns. Why has donald trump not put out his tax returns. Dont say audit. Theres no reason he couldnt put them out. There are some. What would be the reason . The reason is he was told by his accountants and lawyers do not release taxes while under
you h audit. He said hell reveal his tax returns. Hell release his tax returns if we can get his hands on the 33,000 emails that are deleted and ill throw in 17,000 or so that never got to inspected general. After the audit is completed what about the deductions . That wouldnt be problem with the audit. Its under audit. The entire tax return. Are we going to change the subject from the fact that Hillary Clinton disrespects your profession so much and doesnt give you a straight answer how does putting out his annual income for a set number of years, charitable donations, how would that be a problem . Ill take that under advisement and discuss it with the boss. Its clear what do you know. Look around. He employes tens of thousands o people. Hes a job creator. Many women have been promoted through the Trump Organization through the years. Many countries of origin
represented in his employee base. Who is changing the topic now . People want to know in addition to being called deplorable, they want to know what your record is and his record is somebody to creates jobs. Youre asking what his income is and im telling you what people care about. They care about their incomes. Why is wage stagnation such a chronic problem in this country and how in the world can Hillary Clinton with a straight face really run on eight more years of the fact that for two presidencies now weve had wage stagnation. Thats what people care about. Youve been around for quite a few elections. We were trying to figure out earlier this morning just how tight the races are in states and its breaking both ways. Georgia, a lot closer than it should be for a republican. I would say nevada. A lot closer than it should be for a democratic. New hampshire. A lot closer. Hillary should be well ahead in New Hampshire. Arizona. Donald should be well ahead in arizona. Why do we see and state after state after state the map being
scrambled. Sometimes to donalds benefit. Sometimes to hillarys benefit. In my view you have two phenomenally spectacularly celebritylike candidates running. In other words people are really wondering whats going to come next . What will i learn in the debates . What will i see in ads . What will candidates themselves say, good, bad or ugly. Its a spillover from the primaries in this way. In the primaries you saw Bernie Sanders and you saw 17 republican candidates where this was the year where voters in both parties said i will not be told how to think, who can win and who cant win. You had sanders end up winning 22 states and millions of voters. You had the socalled electable ones, jeb bush or scott walker or marco rubio not win because voters said you play this game with me every four years and you tell me who can win two years before the election and then i have to stop and just stop and
support that person. Thats not free market. I think this year electricity has replaced electability. People do not feel like they have to make a solid decision yet. I have to say the number i look at all the time is Hillary Clintons number in most of these states and certainly nationwide is sort ofik 42, 44, 46, 43, 45. Why and how is that . 200 million in paid ads and other Campaign Activities by her and her super pacs. She doesnt have 65 of women. Thats a number we should look at. Shes not at 51 and staying there. Both of them are hovering up and down. We seem to be stuck in the low 40s. Its going to be a close race. Kellyanne conway. Thank you so much. We appreciate it. Still ahead on morning joe, we go to the man derby. Well be right back. Im Hillary Clinton and i approve this message. Hes a racebaiting, xenophobic, religious bigot. Donald trump is a phony, a fraud. Hes not a serious adult. I cant vote for donald trump given the things that he said. Trump should not be supported. I believe hes disqualified himself to be president. I just cannot support donald trump. Upgrade your phone system and learn how you could save at vonage. Com business dont just eat. Mangia bertolli. Americans are buying more and more of everything online. And so many businesses rely on the United States Postal Service to get it there. Thats why we make more ecommerce deliveries to homes than anyone else in the country. The United States Postal Service. Priority you [ rear alert sounds ] [ music stops ]n ] on the road again
just cant wait to get on the road again [ front assist sounds ] [ music stops ] [ girl lghs ] on the road again like a band of gypsies we go down the highway [ beetle horn honks ] no matter which passat you choose, you get more standard features, for less than you expected. Hurry in and lease the 2017 passat s for just 199 a month. Soccer analyst and host, roger, the darby. Manchester. Start talking. Fantastic sporting spectacle. Manchester united, manchester city. Think red sox, yankees. But stuffed into one city with aaron burr managing one city and alexander hamilton, they really hated each other. Both teams perfect until this game. It would be man chaster city who would take the first blood. The gingerhaired wizard. They win that battle every time, royal right, joe. And he controlled the match. He was man of the match. A phenomenal, the best belgian in action. City would soon score again. It was kevin again. He mesmerized the defense. 19 years of old, pounlsed. Look at that finish. Instinctual. Hes like nigerian garoppo garoppolo. Thats what mika was telling me before. I dont understand a word. And then the manchester side found a way back in the game, the new goalkeeper. If he had a baby with chuck norris and he was swedish. Almost giving the game away. This is the worst since gary johnson on your show last week. Awful. A red card right there. Thats a red card. It wasnt given. It was a thunderous game. The thing is, inside, every bit as loud in tuscaloosa as manchester, but its outside, in the pubs, the life. Day in and day out. They live this 365 days out of the year. It really is religion. We were just lucky that you came back alive, mika. Joe spent the weekend with a basket of deplorables. A real one. Oh, my gosh. Incredible city. Im shocked by the turnaround. You expect it to be the manchester, the smiths in 1987, 1988. Its an incredible city. Like liverpool. Absolutely. The greatest northern city. Manchester possibly the greatest city. But the turnaround has been amazing. Playing leicester city, the winners last year. Liverpool dreaming of their own, the first in 26 years. Look at this guy. Cant keep his glasses on. He has his team playing. Look at this one. The chairman used to say hit the pingpong ball as if it was the head of your capitalist enemy. They have kind of turned it around. A remarkable human being. But for leicester city, like cinderella at 12 00. The title has turned into a pumpkin, but the fans dont care. Theyre playing with all right, roger, thank you. Well be watching men in blazers this afternoon at 5 30 eastern. And ill give you my tax returns if you want them. Thank you so much. I appreciate that. Im lying, i wont. Okay. Much more on the transparency question surrounding Hillary Clintons health scare, including whether we would have learned about her pneumonia had she not falling. Youre watching morning joe. Youll never walk alone. Here i am. Building a jet engine. Weve been hearing so much about how youre a digital company, so you can see our confusion. Ge is an Industrial Company that actually builds worldchanging machines. Machines that can also communicate digitally. Like robots. Did you build that robot . Thats not a robot, thats my coworker earl. He builds jet engines with his human hands. What about that robot . That is a vending machine, ricky. John, give him a dollar. Thats why a cutting edgeworld. University counts on centurylink to keep their global campus connected. And why a Pro Football Team chose us to deliver fiberenabled broadband to more than 65,000 fans. And why a leading car brand counts on us to keep their Dealer Network streamlined and nimble. Businesses count on communication, and communication counts on centurylink. Whats that . The number of units well make next month to maximize earnings. Thats a projection. No, its a fact. Based on hundreds of proprietary and open data sets folded into a realtime, actionable analytics model. Nine. Eight. Three. Five. Two. Youre not gonna round that up . You dont round up facts. Powerful analytics driving decisions for the worlds most valuable brands. Hewlett packard enterprise. How are you feeling . Its fall. Its almost fall. Feeling okay . Ious, i am. Everybody okay . Nobody going to fapt on us . Its monday, september 12th. Stop it. Anybody . Oh, come on. Come on. Come on. Its not like were talking about a death in the family. You all dont have to be so im woozy. Theyre journalists. Im woozy 85 of the time. When you fall back like that, we all know what it has to do
with. I dont have to wait for 12 hours from your people. Full transparency on that matter. Every day. Welcome to morning joe. We have manager editors of Bloomberg Politics and cohosts of with all due respect. Mark halperin and John Heilemann. The chair of the department of africanamerican studies at princeton university, and columnist for Time Magazine, and in washington, columnist and associate editor for the Washington Post, david ignatius. Lets just right to it, so people dont have to wait the whole three hours. Oh, okay. I had a huge democratic supporter call me yesterday afternoon. Said its over. Its over. Oh, come on. Its over. She fainted. Trumps going to be im like, calm down, cowboy. And i went back and looked at it. You know, it doesnt look great. Doesnt look great. But its over . The campaign is over because she fainted . I mean, i know there are a lot of conspiracy theorists and this is going to feed into it, but video doesnt look good, but i tell you what. I wake up at 4 00 in the morning every day. I have been doing it for a decade. A lot of times we work until 10 00, 11 00 at night. Theres some times where im walking downstairs and, you know, very active guy. You know, i have to stop for a second and grab a handrail. You do that every day, you do whathes been doing every day. Im not arguing her case for her. Its just, for people who sit back in their armchairs all day watching cable news, saying, oh, how could somebody do that . When you think about in january, what was she doing . Debating Bernie Sanders every night on cnn. They had those town hall meetings. Youre like, one of those a week would kill most people. Shes been doing it nonstop. So to take this moment and say, oh, it proves that shes unfit
to be president of the United States, its just im sorry. Its stupid. And im sure there are a lot of my republican brethren who would insist or who would agree with me, too. Its just, its just not all that. Maybe, i mean, she needs to release all of her medical records, right . Sure. We need to see if theres a bigger problem with the concussion. But just faint. I will tell you, you know, you have seen me. You know, i do prohibition, you know, and im up there playing and sweating, and once a show, because i have been up since 4 00. Its like 10 00 at night. I have to close my eyes, stop, and i say lean back on your heels so if you pass out, you will fall into the drums. Whats the difference with donald trump . He doesnt actually do work behind the scenes. I want to see, because what i want is when i fall over backwards, i want a rim shot. I want my head, just like that. Okay, so lets go through
what happened. Youre right, though. Shes work, wurx, work. Donald trump sits in his office, makes phone calls, how are we doing . Having a good time. A little different. Lets dougo through what happened and then go around the table. I think you bring up a good point and i have seen that happen. Having said that, we dont know. I think the campaigns reaction has been a little frustrating. Hillary clinton has canceled a trip that was set for today and tomorrow in california. After falling ill during a 9 11 remembrance ceremony yesterday. Last night, her campaign revealed she had been diagnosed with pneumonia days earlier, but that was only explained after a morning rife with speculation. Clinton yoined donald trump during a ceremony in Lower Manhattan on a warm day, but after more than an hour there, she left abruptly, appearing unsteady. All the while, the press was left in the dark, with the campaign mum on where the democratic nominee was going or what had happened. But video of her entering a van
with help of the secret Service Showed she was unsteady and clearly required support. She appeared to lean on a post and at one point, her legs seemed to buckle. At 11 00 a. M. , her campaign put out a statement saying in part, during the ceremony, she felt overheated so she departed to go to her daughters apartment and is feeling much better. The Campaign Says she even played with her grandkids there before appearing in front of the awaiting press, posing for a photo with a young girl, hopping back in her van. How are you feeling, secretary clinton . Are you feeling better . Yes. Thank you. Very much. Clinton then headed home to chappaqua but left the press pool in the dust once more. Left the city 90 minutes behind her motorcade, then last night, her personal physician revealed in a statement, quote, secretary clinton has been experienced a cough related to allergies on friday during followup evaluation, her prolonged cough,
she was diagnosed with pneumonia. She was put on antibialtices and advised to rest and modify her schedule. At this morning event, she became overheated and dehydrated. She is now rehydrated and recovering nicely. Mark halperin, tell us. Whats your take on this . I think there are three buckets we can put this in. We like buckets. These are his buckets. Can we get a graphic for this . Bucket number one. Legitimate public concerns with both candidates. They health, their age, their lack of transparency. And theyre both both transparent. Their lack to have a protective pool with them. One of these people will be elejted president in january. Two is the freak show aspect of this. And the degree to which this is made into the normal carnival and negativity. And then lastly, theres the
politics of it. I think until we hear how Hillary Clinton handles both the health issue and the buckets of deplorables and donald trump, how he handles them, we dont know where the stories are going. They will define the first part of the weekend in a big way. Those are a basket of deplorables. John heilemann . I agree with all that. Are you going to add a basket. Sorry . Are you going to add a basket, a bucket . I think that you cant be stressed enough. This has been a long history of debate and litigation in the small l sense of the word over what the standards of disclosure should be in president ial campaigns and over nominees. It takes on greater weight when youre talking about naunlnys in this case who are both, who are older. There are no rules this year, are there . Taxes or health. There should be rules. There are none. But there have never been ruled. There have been former conventions that people comply
to. Both candidates, Hillary Clinton has disclosed a little more about her health than donald trump has. Both of them, by historic standards, have disclosed very little. I think its really i mean, the taxes is an issue i have been banging on about with trump for months and months, but its now incumbent upon both candidates. Donald trump is going to go on dr. Oz this week and talk about his personal health regimen. We need to have them go at this point, both sides, just go completely open. Just show us the records. Show us the records on the health care, and really, seriously, at this point, i dont need to veer off course, but its relevant. Whats going on between trump and Vladimir Putin . Why does he show up on putins tv network . Why does he continue to just shock even republican supporters like he did in the matt lauer interview, talking about his relationship with putin . What is going on . Is there a Financial Link there . Is he loaning him money . What is the linkage there . I think its just dumb. I think he has no idea what hes
saying. Probably worse. We dont know that because he wont release his taxes. Right. Mika, can i ask you a question . Do you think as someone running for president , if they get pneumonia, they have an obligation to disclose . Absolutely. The issue, you know, how much is the Campaign Going to stumble and leave people down the untrustworthy, you know, lane. Because we just, we need transparency from this candidate. We need press conferences. We need everything to be as transparent as possible given the legacy, the clinton legacy. I think i wont agree with all of marks buckets. Im going to focus on the second one about the spectacle. And part of what concerns me about this is that, you know, this is the first woman to be a major nominee of a party. The nominee of a party. Theres a sense in which questions around her health may be tied to questions around fragility, frailness. Im sitting here thinking, you know, did we get this level of coverage around dick cheneys heart . And here she has pneumonia in this moment. I think transparency, all the points were making are important, but i want us to be very careful the way in which were reading her health and how th that can serve as a proxy for the way in which were talking about gender. We do, though, there were times. I remember jimmy carter collapsed during a race, and just a horrific visual. All of us would look horrific if we were like collapsing during a race where he was running a 5k, and the press put it all over the papers. Suggesting that he wasnt Strong Enough to be president. That he was collapsing, et cetera. Just to counter mikas point, just as a matter of debate, im for maximum disclosure all the time. In her case, because of the trust issues she has, shes always politically in a better place when she discloses more. But there was an interesting debate that broke about this on twitter among people for work for barack obama who said, you know, every campaign, dan pfeiffer was saying this, every campaign i worked on, the candidate had pneumonia at some point. Its treatable with antibiotics. Whats the standard for when we should have our candidates disclose illnesses that are treatable with antibiotics . Is it the case that every candidate every time they get ill enough that they take antibiotics have to disclose it to the press. Generally, im for more disclosure. In her political situation, i think it makes more sense, but its an interesting question. Lets ask dr. Emily. First of all, based on what you have seen so far, does the prognosis and the diagnosis of walking pneumonia concern you . Well, its concerning. Shes 68 years old. But we know so little about exactly whats wrong with her. We dont know if she had a chest xray. We dont know if there was any
suspicious bloodwork or troublesome blood work. To make a prognosis based on such dearth of information is almost impossible. On the other hand, for someone who is Walking Around, going to these events, i can tell you that 9 11 here in the city is very stressful. Even if youre not standing down at ground zero, its a tough day for people who live in new york. So she looks like shes she tried to power through, frankly. But in terms of a prognosis, very difficult to say. Is it a serious diagnosis . Walking pneumonia . It can be, based on whether or not a person is healthy in an underlying way. Do they have cardiovascular problems . Do they have high Blood Pressure . Are they in general poor health . Most people who have underlying medical conditions, it could be a very serious condition. On the other hand, its kind of a run of a mill thing that
general practitioners see all the time, people have, get over, go bato work. No big deal. Doctor, what about underlying conditions. Youre talking about underlying conditions. Shes taking medication. I think its coumadin and something for blood clots. And other things, blood thinners. Does what little we know of her health at 68, would that concern you more as a physician . Not those things specifically. Her Blood Pressure was reported to be normal Blood Pressure. So that makes me believe she doesnt have any cardiovascular problems or significant cardiovascular problems with her heart. She doesnt have diabetes. We have never heard about that. Those are the types of things i would be very concerned about. Shes 68 years old. Stuff happens over a lifetime. And shes accumulated some dvts. She had a blood clot in her brain. None of that specifically would worry me in terms of the pneumonia. All right, doctor, thank you
very much. David ignatius, im sure you remember that image of jimmy carter collapsing. No, im not talking about the killer rabbit. I think a few weeks later when he was jogging, jimmy carter collapsing and a lot of people reading way too much into that. Jimmy carter, extraordinarily healthy, even today. Add some Historical Perspective to this. Was all the hyperventilating yesterday from people watching mrs. Clinton hyperventilate overboard . As with the famous jimmy carter image youre talking about, the reason it was important is it came at a time when there already was a discussion about mulace in america about whether jimmy carter was up to it as president , and then suddenly, this image, extraordinarily healthy man running a marathon, for goodnesss sake, or a long
race, shouldnt have added concern, but it did. In this case, Hillary Clinton has had a difficult couple weeks, i think, by anybodys judgment. And two things that i have seen in her since i first began covering her many years ago. First, she always pushes herself to the edge of stamina. When she was secretary of state, she had to go to that next country, that next rally, that next event. Its just part of the way she operates. And second, shes always been extraordinarily reserved about any personal information. Yoknow, they didnt let it out the white house, didnt let it out at the state department and theyre not doing it now. That combination, you know, of people asking questions about her, pushing herself super hard, and not saying much about her personal situation, those came together in this incident. What we can say, what i would say in conclusion is her health is now a legitimate campaign issue. No way to escape it. Still ahead on morning joe, New York Times columnist david brooks joins us to talk about what he calls our big me culture and why its paralyzing the country. Hell explain when he joins us on set. Plus, controversial and calculated, well, Hillary Clintons basket of deplorables line proved to be a mistake or a rallying cry . Youre watching morning joe. Well be right back. Remember here at ally, nothing stops us from doing right by our customers. Whos with me . Im in. Im in. Im in. Im in. One, two, wait, wait. Wait wheres tina . Doing the hand thing . Yep we are all in for our customers. Ally. Do it right. Of trumps supporters into what i call the basket of deplorables. Right . The racist, sexist, homophobic,
xenophobic, islamophobic, you name it. And unfortunately, there are people like that. And he has lifted them up. He has given voice to their websites that used to only have 11,000 people. Now have 11 million. He tweets and retweets, their offensive, hateful, mean spirited rhetoric. Now, some of those folks, they are irredeemable, but thankfully, they are not america. That was Hillary Clinton at a new york city fundraiser friday night, seemingly writing off half of the support donald trump is garnering. Clinton went on to say the other half of Trump Supporters feft left behind in the current economy and by the government and are in search of change. But an outcry led clinton to clarify her remarks by saturday afternoon, saying, quote, last
night, i was as she said in the first place, grossly gene l generali generalistic, and thats never a good idea. I regret saying half, that was wrong. But lets be clear. Whats really deplorable is that donald trump hired a major advocate for the socalled altright movement to run his campaign and david mook and other White Supremacists see him as a champion of their values. I wont stop calling out bigotry and racist views in the campaign. Many of the trump supportererize hardworking americans who just dont feel like the economy or our political system are working for them. Trump responded to clintons reaction with his own statement, calling her unfit and incapable to ever, adding, isnt it disgraceful that Hillary Clinton makes the worst mistake of the political season and instead of owning up to this grotesque attack on American Voters, she tries to turn it around with a pathetic rehash of words and insults used in her failing
campaign . For the first time in a long while, her true feelings came out. Showing bigotry and hatred for millions of americans. How can she be president of our country when she has such contempt and disdain for so many great americans. What do you think of that statement . What do you think of both statements . Um, trumps statement is very difficult to wrap my mind around. Why is that . Because i think we need to separate the politics from the truth. Right. And i have been saying on this show for weeks now, what does this election suggest about theelectorate. What we do know is this, 60 of trumps supporters believe that have a negative view of islam. 76 of his supporters actually believe we should build a wall or ban muslims from the country. Nearly 50 of trumps supporters have a negative view of africanamericans. Over 40 think were lazy, dependent, criminal. There was a pew poll that was shown after these statements, and Trump Supporters, was horrifying. In every way. But as far as who is lazy, who is this and who is that, david ignatius, a South Carolina poll of Trump Supporters back in february, the week of the South Carolina primary, 80 support the ban on muslims entering america. 31 ban homosexuals entering america. 62 support a National Database for muslims. 40 support shutting down all mosques in america. 33 say the practice of islam should be illegal. There are scores of other polls like that. Again, its not 50 . But any candidate running against donald trump, and by the way, a lot of republicans are saying similar things back in the fall. Well, the numbers show that
there are theres a nativist xenophobic stream among Trump Supporters. I think the reason people have responded to this as a mistake by Hillary Clinton is characterizing your opponents supporters, americans who are out there getting ready to vote in a language like that, a basket of deplorables. Thats just going to stick. Its going to be a sound bite for the rest of the campaign. People will come back with all kinds of numbers. But i think clint was wise herself not to argue the point. She didnt do what you just did. She said, i was wrong. I was wrong to use that language. And i think that was probably the smart call. Not to show numbers that might say, heres what i meant, but to say, i was wrong. Still to come on morning joe think this will be the last election. I dont know, i think this will be the last election that the republicans have a chance of winning because youre going to have people flowing across the borders. Youre going to have illegal
immigrants coming in, and theyre going to be legalized and able to vote. Once that all happens, you can forget it. Youre not going to have one republican vote, and its already a very hard number, already, the path is much more difficult for the republicans. You just have to look at the maps. Didnt someone tell him they were leaving . Someone needs to tell him theyre leading. The numbers are the opposite. Do you not remember lawyers in love by jackson broun . Good song. The russians escaped while we werent watching them. Like russians would. I leave the singing to you. The mexicans are leaving. The Illegal Immigrants are leaving. Hes not bright. What is going on . David is going to join us on whether trump is right to be so fatalestic. How can he blurt out such stupidity . Stop it. We have to go to break. Thats incredible. [ on the road again, by Willie Nelson ] on the road again
[ rear alert sounds ][ mus just cant wait to get on the road again [ front assist sounds ] [ music stops ] [ girl laughs ] on the road again like a band of gypsies we go down the highway [ beetle horn honks ] no matter which passat you choose, you get more standard features, for less than you expected. Hurry in and lease the 2017 passat s for just 199 a month. Im not a customer, but im calling about that credit scorecard. to dog give it. Sure its free for everyone. Oh well thats nice and checking your score wont hurt your credit. Oh to dog im so proud of you. Well thank you. Get your free credit scorecard at discover. Com. Even if youre not a customer. What powers the Digital World . Communication. Like centurylinks Broadband Network that gives 35,000 fans a cutting edge game experience. Or the network that keeps a leading hotel chains guests connected at work, and at play. Or the it platform that powers millions of ecards every day for one of the largest greeting card companies. Businesses count on communication, and communication counts on centurylink. I thought my bladder leakage meant my social life was over. Wearing depend underwear has allowed me to fully engage in my life and im meeting people. Unlike the bargain brand, new depend fitflex underwear is now more flexible to move with you. Reconnect with the life youve been missing. Get a free sample at depend. Com. You know what i did . Youll be very proud of me. I saw what was going on with her. And i said, you know, im going to go do something, and i actually took a physical last week and will probably, i guess this week, we announced the results of it. They come in. I did pretty much the whole
deal. And because i think we should. I think we should do that. Donald trump speaking with cnbc earlier this morning. Joining us now, New York Times columnist david brooks. His book the road to character is now out in paperback starting tomorrow. John heilemann, and Mark Halperin all back with us as well. David, it must be exciting. Your publishers must be thrilled that the road to character comes out in an election that will be long remembered as the character election, 2016. The central virtue in the book is humility. Thats had such a huge influence on the campaign. In so many ways, especially of the man we were just talking of. I love the latest piece talking about the transformation of the parties. People think parties are static and they stay as they are forever. Of course, it didnt happen. Reagan in 66 started something in california that really transformed politics with a lot of workingclass voters. You talk about more and more
republican republicans are town, and you have democrats who are gown. A big if, if republicans drop some of the racial tones, they have a great opportunity to grow. I just look at the divides dividing the society, and start with society before politics. If you ask if somebody has College Degree or not College Degree, you can tell a lot about them, whether theyre likely to smoke, to vote, to give blood, whether theyre trusting of the people around them. What their marriage is like. We just have a big sociological divide between the educated and less educated and our politics is basically catching up. Trump doing really well with the less educated. Clinton with the well educated. Thats going to break the divides we had before. That mump has been happening toward the Republican Party for some time. Why . Partly because, partly for racial issues. Partly because of the less, the more liberal you are, the less contrated you are. But you have had this weird marriage between the corporate Global People who love openness and the workingclass white people who hate openness. For a while, theres been stress, stress, stress between these two sides of the coalition. I happen to be with a bunch of ceos over the last couple weeks. And they talk like democrats now. You get the impression within ten class, the people who live in charlotte, new york, l. A. , theyre all going to be democrats. So the Republican Party faces a choice. Theyre either going to be a really small working class party or they have to get at the other groups. The transformation is going on as we speak. We showed polls, georgia closer than it should be. Arizona closer than it should be, nevada, New Hampshire. Its cutting both ways. States hillary should be way ahead in, its tight. Trump should be way ahead, its toit. All of these trends, first globalization, second, technology. Third, words. Do you feel comfortable talk sng were in a business, which is good in the modern economy, where we can talk a lot. A lot of people arent in that business. Makes me uncomfortable. Talking . I have noticed. If you feel the pressures of the modern world are at your back and theyre pushing you to success, you have one set of attitudes. If theyre in your face, you have an entirely different set of attitudes. Its interesting because you think back to when you had the transformation from an egrarrian economy to an industrial economy and you go through the same transformation were seeing now where the splits in the parties became more about future versus past, open versus closed than they were about left versus right. Out of that, you had huge partisan upheaval. Can you imagine that happening, not just kind of the smaller shifts, but a new party emerging . Democrats and republicans changing places. The whig party disappeared, which is my home natural party. So its that is correct. I have noticed in all of your
columns, you refuse to take a strong stance on slavery. They were antislavery, very prorailroad. But what you have traditionally, you have these periods of stability and then total disruption. Were in a period of i think disruption because the issue im sort of focusing on is trust. And its interesting were talking about clintons health because trust becomes so big for the candidates and then in the country itself. If you asked people 30, 40 people years ago, do you trust the people around you . A majority said yes. If you ask millennials, 19 say yes. People are very distrustful. Distrust of institutions, distrust of each other. Once that happens, all sorts of things can fade because they have lost fate in the normal things that bind them together. You talk about if republicans can give up racial wedge issues. I want to link that to trust. When we talk about race in this country alt the heart of it is a bad faith that were not honest about what were actually
committed to. And so even as we see these realignments, race seems to be at the center. And so how you say its a big ask in the article. How do we talk about race honestly given the erosion of trust, particularly around this subject . Because people just seem to be engaged in bad faith when they talk about it. We have had populist elements in this country before. We never had a populist movement that transcended the racial line. Exactly. Thats because economic anxiety is manipulated frankly be people like donald trump into ethnic anxiety. Its just easier to express. It feels deep. You have this fear so you want to turn it to an outsider group. It would take an act of imagination and creativity to overleap that faith. I would say the odds are against it. The republicans will become a party that has some latino elements, africanamerican elements and white elements. If they dont do that, they just become a 30 party. And ever shrinking. If the future of the republican part awas white working class
guys in northern florida, great. Mark halperin has a question. Just a bit about why the Republican Party is doing so well at the gubernatorial and congressional level. Well, two things. First its a straightup turnout issue, as we know, and second, you know, its funny, when you travel, i got the trump issue as wrong as it could be. I got the impression he would be giving the state of the Union Address and i would be writing columns, dont worry, hell never get the nomination. I got it really wrong. I spent the last five, six months traveling around. When you dpe to state and local politicsturic feels so different than national politics. States and localitiey ies seem function. It doesnt come with the trummian baggage. You see what trump won the nomination when you look at some of the candidates and what they need to do to appeal to their
constituents. You see the opiate addiction in towns in west virginia. You see the isolation. A lot of people falling through the cracks. I would say this trip for me, these six months has been a hopeful trip. Because ill go to some place and there are Community Healers wherever you go. I was in a neighborhood in houston, its between three highways, latino neighborhood. Got nothing for the kids after school. Some young woman from a college in new england has come down and shes got 1500 kids going to her afterschool program. You run into these people everywhere. I ran into drug treatment counselors who have like 17 in the bank account, but theyre doing drug treatment for 50yearold guys. There are people out there creating little communities. If somehow that could get fused into a thing, it would just be the country would look a lot different. Well, the book out in paperbook tomorrow the road to character, is well worth the read. David brooks, thank you so much for being on the show. Well be right back with much more morning joe. Right. In. Your. Stomach watch this . Yikes, that ice cream was messing with you, wasnt it . Try lactaid, its real ice cream, without that annoying lactose. Lactaid. Its the milk that doesnt mess with you. Lets go meet them soon. In person, we could read the room. On the phone, youre just a voice. Yeah, im good. For fast rewards, lets book on choice. This trip could really help us grow. Should i stay or should i go . When its time to go for business, book on choicehotels. Com and get a free night when you stay with us two times. Book direct at choicehotels. Com
its what the National Debt could do to our economy. If we dont solve our debt problem 19 trillion and growing money for programs like education will shrink. In just 8 years, interest on the debt will be our Third Largest federal program. Bad news for small businesses. The good news . Theres still time for a solution. Ask the candidates for a plan to secure our future. You live life your way. We can help you retire your way, too. Financial guidance while youre mastering life. From chase. So you can. So, tomorrow is huge. We say that about every show, and usually we arent telling the truth, but tomorrow is going to be a really big show. Yeah . Really big show. Yeah. We have former head of the cia and nsa, retired general michael hayden. That big. Youre thinking that big. Hes going to talk about the delicately brokered ceasefire in syria that goes into effect. Also, larry kudlow with his new book on what todays candidates can learn. Kudlow, wow. Man. No, but wait. Kudlow has a great hell have a pinstriped suit. But wait, theres more. Oh, theres more. Oe conason, a new book on bill clinton. Thats more than one man can take. Tats it. Im done. Thats beer and thats egg in the beer. Right . But wait. Wait, if you dvr morning joe right now, in the next 15 minutes, youll get to see tomorrow, the New York Times maureen dowd with her new book titled the year of voting dangerously, the derangeable of politics and vicente fox. Is this a sixhour version of morning joe or the normal threehour version . Were going to compress it. Were going to compress six hours of sugar into a threehour pack. But the former president , who is no fan of donald trump, will be here. And thats just a dash of what youre going to have tomorrow morning. But still ahead this morning is he going to be on the show, too . I hope so. If you put barnicle in there. They go to central park and you dont know what happens. Seriously, dont know whats going to happen. Ask him about aleppo and god knows what will happen. What is aleppo . So coming up from the south side of chicago to the holes of
college campuses. While hes onboard with this idea of going away to college and finishing college and coming back and hopefully hoping to change his community in some positive ways, we cant escape the fact that when he leaves school every day, hes running up against some forces and some people that would much rather see him make poor decisions than make the right decisions. Our friend wes moore will be a here with a new documentary on two teens beating the odds. But there will still be pain. It comes when your Insurance Company says theyll only pay threequarters of what it takes to replace it. What are you supposed to do . Drive threequarters of a car . Now if you had Liberty Mutual new car replacementâ„¢, youd get your whole car back. I guess they dont want you driving around on three wheels. Smart. With Liberty Mutual new car replacementâ„¢, well replace the full value of your car. Liberty stands with youâ„¢. Liberty mutual insurance. They engine revs things about rain. Like how hard its gonna fall. engine revs the things it does to your parade. Weve got a saying about rain, too when it rains. It roars. The allwheeldrive charger. Domestic. Not domesticated. Every day starts better with a healthy smile. Start yours with Philips Sonicare, the no. 1 choice of dentists. Compared to oralb 7000, Philips Sonicare flexcare platinum removes significantly more plaque. This is the sound of Sonic Technology cleaning deep between teeth. Hear the difference . Get healthier gums in just 2 weeks vs a manual toothbrush and experience an amazing feel of clean. Innovation and you. Philips sonicare. Save now when you buy Philips Sonicare. Remember here at ally, nothing stops us from doing right by our customers. Whos with me . Im in. Im in. Im in. Im in. One, two, wait, wait. Wait wheres tina . Doing the hand thing . Yep we are all in for our customers. Ally. Do it right. My family, my fathers side of the family is real gang affiliated. I know that i have to be the one to make it through college. My mother really played the big role in my life, being the mother and father. When i lost my daughter, i was really sick for a long time. But i had to go on for the kids. I finally had a chance to see my mother again, i would say look how far i made it. I made you proud. It really only takes one generation to kind of right the course for any family. That was a look at the new pbs documentary, all the difference, that follows two africanamerican teenagers from the south side of chicago as they embark on a journey to achieve their dream of graduating from college. Joining us now, the executive producer of the film, bestselling author and combat veteran of the u. S. Army, wes moore. Good to have you back on the show. Its been forever. Great to be back. This looks so good. That grandmother, im already in love with her. She seems amazing. Her grandson, when robert, one of the stars in the show, that we followed for five years, when he was 17 months old, his father killed his mother. And he was about to go into the foster care system with all of his siblings and his grandmother said ill take them in. She took in seven kids. And this is a woman who was a share cropper in mississippi. Who lost her daughter. Who lost her daughter because her soninlaw killed her and is now taking in and raising all these kids on the south side of chicago. So all the difference, the basic concept is. The basic concept is we want to understand theres a larger conversation about how wonderful it is that we can get kids through k12, and that is important, but the truth is we also have to understand whats happening to so many students, particularly africanamerican students of color, first in the
family, as they enter into Higher Education. Currently, 17 of africanamerican men between the ages of 25 and 28, 17 have a bachelors degree in this country. And when you look at whats happening, when they first Enter College, theyre flagging out quickly, 50 of all africanamericans who Enter College every year will not make it past their freshman year of college. And we wanted to understand why. What is taking place in Higher Education and how do we change the narrative both in the ideas and minds of the young people, the people going through it, and then also how do we understand the structural challenges that exist in Higher Education keeping people from making it through. I want to ask this educator from your point of view, do you see that kind of phenomenal at princeton with africanamerican students . Absolutely. Part of what we do, and you know this from your work, you can have students coming from, in effect, the same economic background, having the same school preparation, but when they get to, when they get to college, a place like princeton,
theyre not doing as well as students. With the same background, and we have to figure out why. A colleague of mine, doug massey, has written about this and talked about social chaos, the baggage we bring to the campus. So i remember being at morehouse, and you know, i get a call from my mom in the middle of having to take an exam, or i have to figure out how this is going to how im going to pay for this or what happened to my cousin who just got locked up. So the teens face plenty of challenges on campus from Financial Aid to the issues of race, as we were just discussing. Heres another clip. You can tell by the look in their eyes, they look at me, what the heck are you doing here . Why would the class put you in . You can feel that vibe. Im not naive. But i never let the people who criticize me determine my destiny and my purpose i have at this college. I just Pay Attention to my schoolwork. Any classroom i go into, i sit in the front, i dont sit in the back, because im here for the professor. John heilemann. Theres obviously a bunch of questions that go to what the issues are that precede this and create this situation. At the institutional level, whats the right Institutional Response from both of you guys like how to deal with it, those facts as theyre current lly beg faced . Maybe they deal with it before. It has to be both before and after. 85 of colleges and universities in this country right now are either deemed open access or noncompetitive. By definition, they accept 50 or more of the people that apply. You understand we have a broad diversity of people who are college students. Its not the traditional idea of people think who is going to college, but i think colleges when theyre thinking about the onramping, when theyre thinking about the Financial Aid support, over 8 billion every year thats left on the table in Financial Aid because students arent filling out paperwork correctly, there are structural things that continue to sit in the way as we think about developmental course work and
remedial course wurx. These are courses students pay for but theyre worth nothing. Institutions can be more progressive and more thoughtful about ways they can give not just matriculation but momentum to students. Thats what were looking for. Brilliant ideas. I think its important we not paint the freshman class or paint the student body with one broad brush. Of course, sure. And to understand that particular populations have particular issues that need to be addressed specifically. I think what wes is talking about is precisely that. If institutions understand not only their unique histories but the unique demands these populations bring to the school, then theyre on the road to actually addressing the issue. All the difference airs tonight at 10 00 on pbs. Its part of the largest pbs spotlight Education Initiative happening all week. Wes moore, fantastic work. Great to see you. Thank you for being here. Always killing it. Never puts a foot wrong. I dont understand it. Flawless. Well be right back with much more morning joe. Rence
between life and death. For partners in health, time is life. We have 18,000 people around the world. The microsoft cloud helps our entire staff stay connected and Work Together in real time to help those that need it. The ability to collaborate changes how we work. What we do together changes how we live. Hey, need fast try cool mint zantac. It releases a cooling sensation in your mouth and throat. Zantac works in as little as 30 minutes. Nexium can take 24 hours. Try cool mint zantac. No pill relieves heartburn faster. Thiswell we thought gech programmed machines to talk. Ge is an Industrial Company that actually builds worldchanging machines. Machines that can talk to each other digitally. Hello . They dont talk to each other like that, ricky. Shhhh, youll anger it. He looks a little ticked off now. Americans are buying more and more of everything online. And so many businesses rely on the United States Postal Service to get it there. Thats why we make more ecommerce deliveries to homes than anyone else in the country. The United States Postal Service. Priority you wiback like it could used to . Neutrogena hydro boost water gel. With hyaluronic acid it plumps skin cells with intense hydration and locks it in. For supple, hydrated skin. Hydro boost. From neutrogena everyone thought i was crazy to open a hotel here. Everyone said its so hard to be a musician, but i cant imagine doing anything else. Now that the train makes it easier to get here, the neighborhood is really changing. Im always hopping on the train, running all over portland. I have to go wherever the work is. Trains with innovative Siemens Technology help keep cities moving, so neighborhoods and businesses can prosper. I can book 3 or 4 gigs on a good weekend. Im booked solid for weeks. It takes ingenuity to make it in the big city. Whether its connecting one of or bringing wifi to 65,000 fans. Im bocampuses. D for weeks. Businesses count on communication, and communication counts on centurylink. Shes being so protective. She can walk into this arena right now and shoot somebody with 20,000 people watching right smack in the middle of the heart, and she wouldnt be prosecuted, okay . Thats whats happened. That is whats happened to our country. I never thought i would see the day when this is happening to our country. So who says that . Who says that . Right in the heart. Time now to talk about what we learned today. What did you learn . I learned that donald trump has an interesting idea for the debates. Whats that . So i think we should have a debate with no moderator, just hillary and i just sitting there talking. Oh. Im totally for that, too. That would be fun. Wow. Thats what i learned. What did you learn . Same thing. Totally for that, no offense to the moderators, but let them go at it. I love that. What did you learn, eddie . If you name race in the election, you risk upsetting with everything. Why would you say that . Are people calling you names on twitter again . Always. I dont believe that. Impossible. You know what i learned . Whats that . I learned that the Trump Campaign has no good answer on the question of taxes and why he wont release them. Hes just not going to do it. Kellyanne is very good, though, at what she does. But she doesnt have a good answer on that question. Who does . Pbs, give us the info. Pbs, 10 00 p. M. Tonight, part of the pov grad nation siris and the thing i learned is that the College Persistence challenge in this country is real regardless of the institution. And tomorrow, seriously, seriously, this is like live aid. With all the stars. No kidding. Oh, my gosh. General michael hayden. Is vicente fox going to be there . Yes, and larry kudlow, joe conason, maureen dowd, former president vicente fox. A morning of 1,000 stars. We are the world. We are the children. All right. That does it for us. Were going to wrap it up. Thank you, all. Wrap it up. Chris jansing picks up the coverage. I hated to interrupt that song fest. Thank you so much, mika. Good morning, everyone. Im Chris Jansing in for stephanie. This morning, overheated. Hillary clintons health scare wobbling and apparently nearly collapsing after attending a 9 11 memorial. Are you feeling better . Yes, thank you. Very much. The campaign now revealing she has pneumonia. Cancelling her trip today to california. Donald trump weighing in this morning. Just hope she gets well and gets back on the trail. We have to see whats wrong. We have to see whats wrong. But whatever it is, it is. This as clinton comes under fire for this comment. You know, to just be grossly generalistic, you could put half of trumps supporters into what i call the basket of deplorables. Trump pouncing this morning. I think its the single biggest mistake of the political season. Plus, the protests. Nfl players taking a knee during the National Anthem on the
comparemela.com © 2020. All Rights Reserved.