A former american president and his fixer and a big time ally of his in the tabloid media. It was a plan crafted to cast then candidate donald trump in a positive light in the allimportant tabloids. Using stories that were favorable to him and silencing ones that werent and smearing everybody that got in the way. The witness on the stand today on the Hush Money Trial, details exactly how this scheme worked on a daytoday basis. David pecker, the former publisher of the National Enquirer described a relationship with donald trump that dated back to the late 1980s and noted that trump was one the first people to call him and congratulate him when he bought the National Enquirer back in 1999. So tlir friendship was already long standing by the time donald trump decided so to run for president. The questioning today was the details an the operational aspects of that explicit agreement between trump, his lawyer Michael Cohen, and david pecker. And what they did to boost trumps campaign. And pecker said he would look out for trump and act as his eyes and ears and described a practice where he could embellish stories that Michael Cohen sent over to him about trumps competition. The big moment showcasing how this arrangement functioned. In august of 2015, among these three men, Pecker Described Trump and the former fixer asking him what he and his magazines could do to help the Trump Campaign. Pecker said he told them if he heard anything negative, woe notify cohen right away. And then he would be able to have those stories killed. Like Everything Trump did, this part of the plan was not put into writing. Pecker referred to them as just an agreement among friends. But a huge moment came toward the end of peckers time on stand when the alleged affair between trump and Karen Mcdougal was discussed. It was a moment, according to the New York Times, when trumps Body Language changed. He started moving his head. Squinting and pursuing his lips and then crossed his arms over his chest. Here is a chunk of that exchange according to our sources in the courtroom. Pecker said, quote, prior to this, i was speaking to cohen once a week and once this issue came up, i was speaking to him every day, sometimes multiple times a day. That was in june of 2016. Did Michael Cohen ask you to communicate with him in a particular way. Yes said yes, we shouldnt speak over a land line, we should use signal. I didnt know what it was. It is encrypted so there is no paper trail and no one could listen to our conversation. I still to this day dont know if that is true or not. Pecker then added how trump became involved in all of this. Because before the mcdougal issue, pecker was just dealing with cohen. Pecker said, i was in new jersey at my largest investor American Media for a Business Presentation and theyre assistant came in and said donald trump is on the phone for you. So i left to pick up the phone and to speak to mr. Trump and he mentioned that he had spoken to michael and told me about he told me about karen and he said to me, what do you think . So i said, after dylan howard interviewed her, she claimed that she had an offer from abc, from Dancing With The Stars for her story and she had an offer from a Mexican Group for 8 million. I said to trump, no, i dont believe there is an offer for 8 million. I think the story should be purchased, he said to trump. And i believe we should buy it. Trump said to me, i dont buy any stories any time you do anything like this, it gets out any way. So i said, i still believe we should take this story off the market. Trump said to pecker, let me think about it and ill have Michael Cohen call you back in a few days. Peckers revelations werent the only extraordinary fireworks in court today. The day began a different way. With judge merchan Hearing Evidence and argument over trumps gag order. The prosecution said that trump has violated the gag order placed on him in this case at least ten times. In his defense of the expresident trumps attorney todd blanche had a Testy Exchange from the judge. Said you are losing all credible with the court which goes without saying not a good thing to be losing this early in a criminal trial. Were still waiting for the judges decision on the gag cord order. It could come out at any time today. Thats where we start with our favorite reporter as friends. Former top official, legal analyst Andrew Weissmann is back and legal analyst Charles Coleman is here and back again after being inside of the courthouse today, New York Times reporter susan craig. And my friend and colleague, nbc news correspondent Vaughn Hillyard who has been at the courthouse all day. I could see the stars from here. This is really important stuff. So just start telling me what happened. Well, i mean, it was a day. I just sort of feel like this is a play weve been waiting for and the curtain went up and it was in the detail that david pecker just calmly laid out. He was such a credible witness. Just to go through the story with the doorman and how they went back and forth with Michael Cohen on that issue. What i found was really just i just couldnt believe it, just the explanation of how if Michael Cohen wants a story on ben carson, he would phone over to the National Enquirer and say do a story on this on ben carson and then they would embellish details in her own words. In their own words. And then em billish and a story would appear or ted cruz. They would see somebody maybe ted cruz was gaining traction and Michael Cohen would phone over to david pecker and say, order up a story on his affairs, that hes not having. And they would embellish a story and it was striking to see at one point, it went on the projector and i was sitting in the Overflow Room and it was headline after headline. Here they are on the screen. It was headline on one person, and like five or six on ted cruz. Im a journalist and i was just shocked and i thought back to yesterday when you were talking to Locklan Cartwright and he said nobody believed me. And it was just so it was wild to hear this story and then to hear that Checkbook Journalism that was going on and the coordination and the key thing is that i think that im guessing that the defense is going to come in and saying this was Michael Cohen on his own and hes a rogue actor but to have it tied to donald trump with Karen Mcdougal was a longer relationship and in this case dylan howell was the editor who had gone out to see her and knew she was credible that she had a credible story to tell and just the panic that ensued after that and that went right up to donald trump and the way david pecker told the story was just i mean he was calm. Very it is interesting hes such a credible narrator for someone who made up so much stuff. He came off as credible. The thing for me. Because i know the piece of thetory that is so public because similar investigation and because he ends up going to jail is Michael Cohen. But Michael Cohen, he comes in and acts free. Pecker and trump are friends for decades. Trump calls pecker and because he is connected to the National Enquirer. It is a nothing burger compared to the National Enquirer. I started with that mcdoug alex change comes toward the end of the day because that is when pecker in his calm, and everyone described him as credible and calm and likeable. Kind of person a jury a juror would find as likeable and affable. Hes describing being on the phone with trump and trup doesnt say im not going to buy the story because i didnt do it. Im not going to buy it because when you do it, it gets out anyway. And just the intimacy with trump and the cash and kill. And hes embarrassed of catch and kill. Hes proud of Checkbook Journalism. That is stunning. And some things rang true going back to the apprentice years. They had a relationship and it really flourished during the apprenticeship, it was popular and he could put trump on the cover and they would leaktories about the contestants. And the ratings. And donald trump back then, you talk to anybody at nbc, that guy was obsessed with the ratings of the apprentice and he was leaking stories to the National Enquirer about the ratings. It rang so true because i knew all of that from other reporting that i had done. And this is just continued. And then they continued to be friends and then there was an email that was introduced where donald trump is now running for president and that june in 2015 and he get this is note from Michael Cohen and an email asking david pecker, editor and owner of the National Enquirer to sit in the front row and just this gushing email. We couldnt imagine anybody else we would want to have there in essence. It seems clear, vaughn, that strategy is to tell the whole story for people that havent broken with trump. Hope hicks comes in and plays prominently and part of the conspiracy to elevate trump by Killing Bad Stories and promoting good ones and smear the opponents. It appears that you could read the papers and well aware of what the attacks seems determined to preempt all of the questions about Michael Cohen. Right. And if we take a step back and leave the legal trial aspect of this for a moment, were talking about the presumptive nominee and now a friend of Donald Trumps dating back to the 1980s, they met at maralago and stayed in touch frequently over the 30 years. Now testifying today, publicly, telling the entire country that he sat in a boardroom in trump tower with donald trump on his first president ial run and concocted a plan which donald trump, who was pleased about in his own words, to cover up the Salacious Stories. That was a plan that a long time friend of his now tells the american public. And then the Karen Mcdougal story, to watch that testimony play out, again a long time friend articulating that donald trump was aware of this alleged affair and called up a friend to say how do we not let the american electorate know thistory. That is so key. And then to add on to that. Is the fact that this statement man, when talking about his finances or about donald trump, referred to him as a micromanager. He was aware of the checks that came in and he didnt just sign the checks as todd blanche alleged, but he wanted to know where every penny was going and he was cautious is another word that he used. Donald trump is the one that runs the Trump Organization and hes in charge and david pecker testified to that on not only the allegations of the extramarital affairs. And talk about hope hicks. We know that she was on the phone with Michael Cohen, there is so much more kind of like the david Pecker Testimony, we knew there was going to be more coming. But the hope hicks wouldnt be brought forward as a witness by the prosecution. If she didnt have more details to share and that is what awaits us. The other piece that is so interesting in terms of educating not just the jury but the public, is how much money they spent to kill these stories. I mean, a normal National Enquirer, and again, i had no idea what the going rate was. But 500, or a thousand bucks, they were dropping 30,000 in these Tabloid Catch and kill. Absolutely. And this is the first time that david pecker said that he bought Salacious Stories for the purpose of never publishing them and they threaten the dino the doorman with a Million Dollars penalty if he were to reveal his story publicly elsewhere. What do you think . Well, just to vaughns point, which is i keep on saying this, this is ground zero of fake news. If you i know im here to give a legal analysis. But if you move away from the legal niceties, i could put this into a legal grid and why it is all relevant and how it is going to play into the summations. But lets focus on The Big Picture. The person who ran for and became president , there is one of his best friends on the stand credibly saying without donald trump by the way, truth socialing about how hes awful and cant be believed. There is no adverse comments about him which is fascinating to me, which is on the stand saying that we manufactured bad stories about our opponents, whether it is ted cruz, whether it is Hillary Clinton, we just came up with fake stories, fake news and then with respect to damaging stories, we killed them. So that was sort of to me The Big Picture. The other to susans point about credibility. One of the things that you look for in witnesses and you argue at the end of the case is were they guilding the lilly, saying everything that is bad about this and here with david pecker, saying, you know, donald trump was saying i dont know if you need to pay for this because it is coming out. This is not what youre going to say, he was all in from day one. How do we silence this. And that was a good thing. And the doorman, that story was faked and it was wrong and he could have if he was trying to Say Something that was going to damage donald trump, he would have said, oh, well, you know, we couldnt be sure. There was something there. And so you really so youre saying there is some tempermental moderation to him and the fact that trump isnt saying david pecker is half of the media mogul, but there is nothing to suggest that what he said and what is damaging to trump in terms of answering whether or not a crime was committed is the catch and kill and is the money and youre saying that he hangs on to every scrap of Tread Credibility with these nuances. Absolutely. I do find it fascinating that you have donald trump attacking the judge, that is allowed. Attacking the lead prosecutor, that is allowed. But also, doing things that are not allowed. Attacking jurors and witnesses. But it is fascinating to me that david pecker and hope hicks not yet the subject of his ire. So i do think we sort of im curious as to why, because unless david pecker is going to really change on cross, i think hes going to be in his sights. Because hes going to have to start attacking him. And because he i know a lot of people thought Michael Cohen will be the star witness but there is a reason that theyre starting with david pecker. He had as the full story. You listen to and i want to read some of it. Im no Rachel Maddow but i want to read some. I havent seen a transcript yet. The timeline is important and it was obvious that the peckertrump relationship, the catch and kill, and cohen comes in and it is like a chief of staff. But if the catch and kill scheme is the love child, they are pecker and trump. Before i get to be a lawyer, ill say that i find it very fascinating that donald trump the candidate whose locked in a courtroom for six weeks has to deal with this new revelation about how the sausage is made, to Andrews Point around the fake news. Now it is out there about how these manufactured and embellished stories sort of made you this super Human Candidate for your supporters and im curious how that impacted the electorate for donald trump the candidate. As far as donald trump the defendant, im sure well get to the gag order and that was just an entire mess. But when youre talking about what the prosecution has to do, we already know there have been a myriad of attacks on the credibility of other witnesses that are yet to come. And so for this to be the first witness that the prosecution puts in front of the jury, what they did was laid the groundwork to say, later on, you actually dont have to believe Michael Cohen. You may not think hes the most credible witness. You actually dont have to sort of hold Stormy Daniels in the highest of regard. You may feel like she has ulterior motives, but david pecker who knows donald trump the best have said these things and given us such a framework that is going to be corroborated and it helps them to a very big degree. And the other thing they if well today with peckers testimony, is that they took away the notion of donald trump being removed. Not only in terms of him being a Micro Manager as a Business Owner but placing him in conversations very specific about how these things would run. And to act as if you have no knowledge of this things is untenable. You cant maintain that from front of the jury so that was anective day by the prosecution and in terms of setting themselves up, with the witnesses they know are going to have some degree of challenges on the stand, they did a fantastic job. I was just thinking, because there was a discussion at the beginning of the trial about exactly how much of this relationship between david pecker and donald trump would be allowed in. And they just now see how crucial it was that the government was allowed to let in so much of it, to set the full table for exactly what was going on. Because there was some discussion it would be what david pecker knew about Karen Mcdougal and the doorman and i was thinking that today. Well and because if you have to prove that it is a crime in service of another crime, the scheme is the other thing that having worked on campaigns, that hes at trump tower in june of 2016. A normal president ial campaign in june, youre not catching and kill schemes with the National Enquirer. It was like nails on a chalkboard for me. And this was not entered into the record. But when were talking about what donald trump said in the public versus what donald trump and testimony that david pecker is providing, i went back to my notes from march 25th, 2016, the day that the multiple affairs that ted cruz this had a were unsubstantiated but just they were five. It was damning. It said five affairs. Scandal. Like we found out yesterday there were five. And it is insane. And it is what everybody was talking about and ted cruz, if i may, he quickly responded i was in Oshkosh Wisconsin on the trial and he said they are complete lies. Donald trump may be a rat but i have no desire to cop youll ate with him. But donald trump on the other hand, this is the beginning of the his entertainment. I have no idea about who whether the cover story is true or not but i have absolutely nothing to do with it. Did not know about it and have not as yet read it. I have nothing it came from his office. Likewise, i have nothing to do with the National Enquirer and i do not surround myself with hacks and henchmen and pretend. He said he did not want to read this ancient history. It is not that long ago. I just want to vote for him. That is the point now. That is the second part of The Big Picture of this. Is you have you have ground zero fake news, and you have people who are the victims of it who at least unlike mike pence, who said, you know what, you know where too far is, when youre trying to kill me. But that is a small universe. But it is a place that ted cruz. And he became a secretary in his cabinet. I will read from this and well top and it is going to be so fun. Dont go anywhere. Donald trump and his lawyers telling the jury this week that the candidates relationship with the News Organization was normal. Well look more closely than we already are at this Extraordinary Partnership with the National Enquirer. That was nothing normal about it. And still to come for us, while we wait for a decision from the judge on what kind of accountability, if any, trump will face for violating the gag order, that decision could come at any moment. Well detail the contentious back and forth that happened in court today. We have a little bit between judge merchan and the trump hours. Well hand the scripts around. Dont go anywhere today. Anywhe. So i didnt think i needed swiffer, until, i saw how easily it picked up my hair every time i dried it only takes a minute. Look at that the heavy duty cloths are extra thick, for amazing trap lock. Even for his hair. Wow. And for dust, i love my heavy duty duster. The Fluffy Fibers trap dust on contact, up high and all around without having to lift a thing. Im so hooked. Youll love swiffer. Or your money back [shaking] itchy pet . with chewy, save 20 on your first pharmacy order so you can put an end to the itch. Get flea and tick medication delivered right to your door. [panting] new projects means new project managers. You need to hire. I need indeed. Indeed you do. When you sponsor a job, you immediately get your shortlist of quality candidates, whose resumes on indeed match your job criteria. Visit indeed. Com hire and get started today. Youve got xfinity wifi at home. Whose resumes on indeed mat take it on the goia. With Xfinity Mobile. Customers now get exclusive access to wifi speed up to a gig in millions of locations. Plus, buy one unlimited line and get one free. Thats like getting two unlimited lines for Twenty Dollars a month each for a year. So, ditch the other guys and switch today. Buy one line of unlimited, get one free for a year with Xfinity Mobile plus, save even more and get an eligible 5g phone on us visit xfinitymobile. Com today. When others divide. We unite. With Real Solutions to help our kids. Like community schools. Neighborhood hubs that provide everything from Mental Health services to food pantries. Academic tutoring to prom dresses. Healthcare to after care. Community schools can wrap so much around public schools. And through meaningful partnerships with families, they become centers of their communities. Real solutions for kids and communities at aft. Org with so many choices on booking. Com there are so many tina feys i could be. So i hired body doubles. Indoorsy tina loves a deluxe suite. Ooh booking. Com booking. Yeah singlecare is easier to use than my insurance. There are no Membership Fees or premiums, and it works for everyone. So the next time you have a prescription to fill, check singlecare to make sure youre getting the best price. Visit singlecare. Com and start saving today. Why do you think they swapped the story . Back then or now . Now. Um, they didnt want to hurt him. You think it is because of a personal relationship with the guy who runs ami is friends with donald trump . Correct. I remember that evening when Anderson Cooper interviewed mcdougal. I was sitting at dinner with my exwife, with jared kushner, and ivanka trump and the phone rings. And ivanka goes into the kitchen and answers the phone. Oh, it is daddy. And what did daddy want to know . Whether they were watching Karen Mcdougal. So he was he was very, very concerned about it. That will forever be in my trump is daddy phase. This is, again, part of the story we didnt know, right. What we knew is what was public. Let me read from the transcripts of how the women and the mission of silences the women took shape. Brags team, you mentioned women in particular, did you raise that or someone else . Pecker, in a president ial campaign, i was a person that thought there would be a lot of woman who could come out to try to sell their stories baz trump was wellknown as the most eligible bachelor. And this is why hell never attack him and the most beautiful women and it was clear based on my past experience that when someone is running for public office, it is very common for these women to call up magazine like the National Enquirer and try to sell there stoyeries. What about bill and Hillary Clinton coming up . I was running Hillary Clinton as an enabler with bill clinton and it was easy to say i keep running those stories. Did you believe it would help his campaign. Pecker, it was a of mutual benefit. How did mr. Trump react to that suggestion that you continues to do that and run those stories. Pecker, he was pleased. Michael cohen was pleased. You started to allude that to some extent this arrangement you came to at trump tower was mutually beneficial. You could explain what you meant by that. In writing positive stories about mr. Trump and writing negative stores about his opponents it would increase News Stand Sales for the National Enquirer so for me that was my benefit and then in publishing the stories it would benefit his campaign. Brag team, the portion of the agreement that involved notifying mr. Cohen about negativetories about women, what was the objective of that. David pecker, as i did in the past, when i notified Michael Cohen of a negative story, he would try to vet it himself to see if it is true or not and then go to the individual publication to make sure it wasnt getting published an getting killed. Brag team, prior to that meeting have you ever purchased atory to the to print it . Pecker, no. Brag team. And how did that part of it, not publishing the stories help you . Pecker, it didnt. Crazy. Fake fuse. It is fake news. This is your point. Nothing is new. It is all projection. What he was doing. Tu unbelievable. Now this is going to go to election fraud, which is the, as you said, this is the false Business Records, you have to prove that it was intended to aid some other to cover up or further another crime. So this is going to be the tate election crimes, at which the d. A. Today in court said is the main way theyre going to argue that this is a felony. And so all of this goes to election fraud. And i have to say, this is where, again, as a citizen, and thus as a lawyer arguing a case, i mean, you cant hear this and think this is great. This is this is at a basic level, this is fraud. Well, and the other thing is, what would you could maybe turn to is it was mutually beneficial and the part that was ruled out was the part that was krirm criminal wasnt. Weve been talking about the content and legally i wanted for a moment to zone in and discuss the context. This is a trial and theyre playing to a jury and this is the first witness that theyre hearing from, why am i saying this. Because in order to get to the actual illegal part, there is a lot that has to be laid out. You have to get to the documents and corroborate that. That is not particularly interesting and it is not gripping if youre the jury. So what you have to do as prosecution early on, is that you have to paint a picture that they could follow by the time you goodet to the point that youre introducing the documents it maybes sense to them. And they know where to place it. Beyond just the content being very interesting and salacious, what they did today and what theyre doing with all of this is grabbing the jury in and painting a very clear picture chronologically about, number one, how this relationship with david pecker and donald trump existed and number two how the other characters who they will hear from or hear about played a role down the line. As a prosecutor, youre selling a story to your jury and they did that by laying the foundation with david pecker today. How does pecker get limited immunity from Department Of Justice and cohen is like a middle manager in The Scheme Go To Jail . Yeah, some of that is when someone comes in, so if you are just starting out and in a case and so lets take i worked on enron, you have very little to go on and youre trying to find a toe hold. Ideally, you find youre trying to find the lowest level person and if youre going to give someone immunity, you want it to be the lowest level person and then you build up. But with david pecker and Michael Cohen, where you might say, theyre relatively the same, you might say maybe david pecker is a little more guilty, maybe Michael Cohen is a little less, but what do i have to prove a crime and first person to come in may get the better deal. But how does pecker evade criminal scrutiny for Election Interference, with the immunity deal. Yeah, with an immunity deal. And will he face prosecution . Well, this is like this is a great question. Because the president didnt. So, you know, if youre in a good faith doj that is operating under all norms, then you would say yes, you would you could have the proof, you could prosecute all three including the president. But im not going to look at it that way because this is bill barrs doj. And i want to go back to the transcript. I think he got immune because he ted trump was wellknown as the most eligible bachelor and dated the most beautiful women. That stinks. Yeah, except we need to know you need to know at the time that this is done, this is Southern District of new york, and they were building a case. And hes representing against who . Well against Michael Cohen. And you could tell they were trying to build a case i guess im asking, could a twist of fate have given Michael Cohen limited immunity and pecker jail time . Absolutely. But it is so interesting in hindsight. The relationship is deeper and longer with pecky and the killing of the stories that doesnt benefit pecker and cohen went to jail. And so this is where bromo witz represents david pecker and hes a good, wellknown defense lawyer. About as good as you could get on the defense side. And sometimes you have something going, you know what, this is your time to go in and get immunity. Im going to give a proffer to them as to what you are going to say, and if they think that it is truthful, then this is the moment. Because you know what, this is your window to come in. Because they might be thinking, Michael Cohen might come in. So, and youre deal youre getting the Michael Cohen deal, meaning youll be prosecuted. That happens a lot. The thing that is unusual here is you dont like to give immunity, what is called top down. And this is so you would think that pecker is above cohen in this scheme . At the very least, they both have a lot of culpability. What i say about Michael Cohen is he may have slootly less culpability in this scheme, but he also has a broad range of criminality that hes admitted. So you have to take that into account. But i think this is prosecutors dont get to know 100 what is out in the world, they are sort of beholden to who is coming in and what are their options at the time. It is fascinating, i have to sfeek sneak in a break and were going to broaden this out and talk to someone on the front lines of watching donald trump with the media and plus as a candidate and as president. Dont go anywhere today. Well all be right back. tony hawk skating for over 45 years has taken a toll on my body. I take qunol turmeric because it helps with healthy joints and inflammation support. Why qunol . It has superior absorption compared to regular turmeric. Qunol. The brand i trust. I used to leak urine when i coughed, laughed or exercised. I couldnt even enjoy playing with my kids. I leaked too. I just assumed it was normal. Then we learned about bulkamid an fdaapproved, nondrug solution for our condition. It really works, and it lasts for years. Its been the best thing weve done for our families. Visit findrealrelief. Com to find an Expert Physician near you. Ask if bulkamid is right for you and discuss potential risks. Results and experiences may vary. Move beyond the leaks. He knows the law and this is why hell be the star witness of this case. And why the prosecution are going to be relying on him. He could really set the table here. Going back to that meeting at Trump Tower In August of 2015, two months after donald trump goes down the escalator with where they had this meeting, it is Michael Cohen and High School Trump and it is david pecker and where pecker said hell be the eyes and ears of the campaign. Lacklan cartwright. The details that david peckers former editor told us about, that his boss could share with the jury as hes done today. It is a relationship that pecker described as mutually beneficial instead of the case of the stories that were killed an it is a relationship that grew over time into in person visits every month after trump announced his candidacy for president. Pecker details the secret plan to catch and kill any negative stories about trump and women. Something he would run by Michael Cohen as well as the quote embellished negative story thats ron has been talking about, about trumps political rivals. Pecker said, they pleased both trump and cohen and pecker admitted they benefited the campaign, explicitly. Joining our conversation, npr media conversation, David Holcomb is here. And david, youre thoughts about what were learning for the first time from david peckers testimony . It is pretty stark. To think about practices that were in affect at the National Enquirer. If you stopped someone on the street and said is the Gossip Tabloid going be an avatar or have secret agendas made for the stories they public or dont publish. And people thought gosh, there might be some give and take maybe there is some favoritism. But what weve learned about here is that this tabloid, that is consumed by millions of people, often on check out stands and often at home, often these days online, shared on social media, was picking and killing what stories to publish on the basis of what would help a friend ofity publisher david pecker, a friend by the name of donald trump and according to peckers own testimony, what might embarrass his president ial came in that 2016 cycle. Pecker was on board in 2016 walking through stories with Michael Cohen about what things they should pick to go after, Hillary Clinton and he had previous thought about what kind of stories earlier in the cycle might embarrass trumps republican riles, ted cruz and marco rubio and which stories could we keep from seeing light of day. This is not even a tabloid gossip impulse. This is a partisan or propaganda arm of the Trump Campaign. What is extraordinary, i take your point about a baseline understanding of the National Enquirer. But what is amazing about peckers testimony is all of things that the National Enquirer did for the first time to benefit the Trump Campaign. And among those, they paid sums that theyve never paid before. A typical source payment would be 250 and if it is a celebrity, up to 10,000 and i mad that decision because of that potential embarrassment it would bring to the campaign and trump. And the ome thing they had never done before is pay the sums for things that didnt benefit them for stories killed so history was made in this relationship with the National Enquirer and the Trump Campaign. It is an inversion of everything that you think motivated a tabloid publisher. Youre paying a doorman money because hes peddling a story that hes brought to you, i think on the tip line as Locklan Cartwright has remembered it, but nonetheless, hes brought to you saying that trump had impregnated a maid at trump tower and they dont use this to see how could this sell zillions of copies and he said he was subject number one for readership and he would dwarf anything else in terms of the interest of their audience and were going to take this out of circulation until after the election because that is going to serve the interests of the Trump Campaign and trump the politician. Not about hey i was thinking about what it would mean for his marriage. Not about gosh, his son barron is still young. None of that comes up here. This is all about working with somebody who is working hand and glove on came matters, Michael Cohen is putting out kind of eruptions that have beset politics sense just after the American Revolution but are playing out in social media and in front of our eyes on cable news and everywhere else. And even eight years ago, when year talking about National Enquirer and what Michael Cohen and donald trump saw in terms of the ability and the reach, you could take us back to that moment there and what Michael Cohen, i dont think marco rubio or ted cruz would have thought that is what they were pitching at the time david pecker aside, what did they offer donald trump and Michael Cohen . Well it seems to me if i understand your question correctly, that the idea is what role that the National Enquirer could place and you think it is a dinosaur but in reality, even though it is being in some ways even though it is being superceded by things online, what the National Enquirer is able to do is serve as a me mention, a define of the news cycle and ginning things up about Hillary Clinton enabled bill clintons continual sexual dalliances and his bad behavior, to keep hillary in the headlines, to raise questions about her health and her competence and bill clintons character and deflecting from questions about donald trump himself. This is what you would now see online social media warriors doing for campaigns and often in their employee and in the top levels of the inner world of trumps world and ensuring that Main Street Press outlets are following its lead about what the story theyre pursuing and what stories they might not know about as a result of National Enquirer not pursuing them. What is interesting and you mentioned this in the break. David peckers testimony doesnt speak to anything that we thought might have been hidden. Grave humiliation about Embarrassing Melania or ivanka or the other daughter, tiffany or barron. Like the people that knew him the best do not give voice to anything that we dont see from the outside. There is zero shame, zero embarrassment and zero regret. And i thought it was interesting, what david pecker said, he called him an eligible bachelor. He was married. Hes been married three different times. There was no mention about barron. There was about donald trump an the campaign. If you think about it, think back to just yesterday, the Opening Statements where at least for a moment his attorney tried to humanize him noting that he was a husband and a father and then the narrative that contrasts with the testimony from someone who knows him very, very well who never makes mention of his kids or how embarrassed he would have been respect to his wife should this infidelity become public the way that it did. It undercuts that even small attempt to humanize donald trump, which wasnt the right strategy, let me be clear. But nonetheless, it takes it away. David, thank you for joining us. Well continue to call on you. Ill give everyone a last comment. I have to sneak in a quick break before we do that. Dont go anywhere. Reak before we do that. Dont go anywhere. Ok yall we got ten orders coming in. Big orders starting a business is never easy, but starting it eight months pregnant. Thats a different story. I couldnt slow down. We were starting a business from the ground up. People were showing up left and right. And so did our business needs. The chase ink card made it easy. When you go for Something Big like this, your kids see that. And they believe they can do the same. Earn unlimited 1. 5 cash back on every purchase with the chase Ink Business Unlimited Card from chase for business. Make more of whats yours. What is cirkul . Cirkul is the fuel you need to take flight. Cirkul is the energy that gets you to the next level. Cirkul is what you hope for when life tosses lemons your way. Cirkul, available at walmart and drinkcirkul. Com. One in five Children Worldwide are faced with the reality of living without food, no family dinners, no special treats, not enough energy to play. All around the world, hunger is affecting childrens physical and Mental Health. Toddlers are suffering from acute malnutrition, which stunts their growth. Kids are forced to drop out of school so they can help support their families. Conflict, inflation and climate have ignited the worst famine in our lifetime, and we are fed up fed up that hunger devours dreams. Fed up, that hunger destroys joy. Fed up with the fact that hunger eats childhood. Help us feed the futures of children All Over The World by visiting getfedupnow. Org. For as little as 10 a month, you can join Save The Children as we support children and families in desperate need of our help. Now is the time to get fed up and give back. When you join the cause, your 10 monthly donation can help communities in need of lifesaving treatments and nutrients, prevent children from dropping out of school. Support our work with communities and governments to help children go from short term surviving to long term thriving. And now, thanks to special Government Grants, every dollar you give can multiply up to ten times the impact. That means more food, water, medicine and help for kids around the world. Youll also receive a free tote bag to share your support for children in need. Having your childhood eaten away by hunger is unimaginable. Get fed up. Call us now or visit getfedupnow. Org, today. You could see us during the break. All the good stuff. I want to read one more piece from the transpayment. In 2015, when trump announced his candidacy, did your increase increase contact increase or decrease with cohen . Decker, increase. An then he gets to his testimony, its multiple times a day. Thhe campaign. That is in the record. Were going the see a lot more detail on that tomorrow, because the examination continues, and well be talking about Karen Mcdougal. It was a longer, incredible relationship and well be hearing a lot more tomorrow im sorry, thursday. Were dark tomorrow. So thursday when court picks up. Tomorrow, do we expect any rulings on the gag order that would happen today . No. Its possible that the judge is waiting because there was often alleged violation an alleged violation yesterday, so the judge might be waiting for that piece to come before him. It doesnt need to, but he might, since there was sort of, you know, its like you cant catch up. What do you make of who might be adjusting their strategy with the dark day tomorrow . Ahead of i dont mean dark like sad, i mean david pecker doesnt take the stand again until thursday. I mean, not the state. Its hard to imagine that the state is its hard to think i mean, this is just the beginning. You know, i just think this is a hard witness to attack. You know, we were just talking about what do you do on cross . Like an easy cross of this is, well, you dont know about the false Business Records themselves, you didnt sign them, youre not in the Trump Organization. You just killed the story because nicolle, this is where a smart jury is good for the state, but you just say, but you werent a witness to that. So you just point the jury to like the limits oh of what he has to say. Sometimes thats all you can do on the defense side. What do you make of thats happening now that we cant see Behind The Scenes . Im going back to this morning and the Gag Order Hearing. That was the most explosive that is. For as accomplished an attorney Tom Blanchard is, i dont understand the argument he made. To have a judge tell you that you are losing credibility this early in a trial is really, really dangerous ground to operate on. If anything, i would have expected him to walk in there with a plan presented and ready that was going to somehow allow the judge to make a decision that perhaps didnt ding his client on everything. But also allows his client to move forward while preserving the integrity of these proceedings, and he didnt. And thats something that i dont necessarily know is going to be easy to overlook going forward, because donald trump is not changing who he is. So you can expect well have this issue again, and its going to get very costly for donald trump or difficult for todd blanch, if not both. Everything that trump touches turns to kaka. On the political end of that, part of this that i try to remind myself that im still covering the presumptive nominee for 2024, part of this is that donald trump, outside of this criminal trial, hasnt faced political repercussions for those efforts, these alleged efforts to silence these stories from coming out in 2016. When we were talking to david about what the National Enquirer offered him in 2016, it was for another outlet to put out, essentially a generator of Salacious Stories about his opponents. Fast forward to eight years, when i talk about no political repercussions, donald trump just reposted on his social media account now, random accounts with no name behind him. When he was running behind ron desantis, some person tweeted out ron desantis in high school with texts suggesting that he was grooming high school girls. And the campaign had to deal with it. And there was no repercussions for donald trump, so hes not even relying on the National Enquirer and his friend, david pecker. Hes just doing this himself. Again, no political repercussions. Fascinating. Andrew, charles, sue zan, thank you so much for being here the whole hour. Up next for us, more on this gag order that we have been talking about and the judge blasting trumps defense team as charles is describing. That story and more after a quick break. Dont go anywhere. Ter a quick break. Dont go anywhere. Cant filter out the real you. So go ahead, live unfiltered with the one and only sotyktu, a oncedaily pill for moderate to severe Plaque Psoriasis, and the chance at clear or almost clear skin. Its like the feeling of finding youre so ready for your closeup. Or finding you dont have to hide your skin just your background. Oncedaily sotyktu was proven better, getting more people clearer skin than the leading pill. Dont take if youre allergic to sotyktu; serious reactions can occur. Sotyktu can lower your ability to fight infections, including tb. Serious infections, cancers including lymphoma, muscle problems, and changes in certain labs have occurred. Tell your doctor if you have an infection, liver or kidney problems, high triglycerides, or had a vaccine or plan to. Sotyktu is a tyk2 inhibitor. Tyk2 is part of the jak family. Its not known if sotyktu has the same risks as jak inhibitors. Find what Plaque Psoriasis has been hiding. Theres only one sotyktu, so ask for it by name. So clearly you. Sotyktu. She gets her news from the New York Times, google, and cnn. She said two things that really stuck out, one, i dont really have an opinion of trump, and no one is above the law. Im not so sure about juror number two. Welcome to earth two where that guy, his names jesse, thinks neither of those things are possible from any human living on earth. Its now 5 00 in new york. Hi, everybody. It turns out that was a critical legal turning point, part of a Chain Reaction of the cruelty and venom and recklessness that brought us to today. Crash course in actions and consequences for a man who so doggedly has avoided them his entire life. Todays first order of business in court in the criminal Election Interference and Hush Money Trial was time to set aside to consider whether trump violated his gag order when it was imposed before he shared a Quote On Social Media from that guy, from fox news, insisting certain jurors from undercover liberal activists. During that hearing today, our nbc news colleagues, theyre in the courtroom, reported that the judge went as far as to raise his voice in frustration during his questioning of lawyers for donald trump, unless or unable to defend his position that the trump post in question were political in nature and outside the scope of the gag order all together. Attorney todd blanch got an ear al from the judge to the effect of prosecutors meanwhile, while making the case that theres no straightfaced argument that the post relates to anything other than the trial, they brought up the comment by that guy, jesse waters, pointing out that juror number two asked to be excused the day after that rant, not 12 hours after. It was in their words precisely what the gag order was intended to prevent. Braggs team suggested that they are not yet seeking incarceration as a penalty for trump, although they added this, the defendant seems to be angling for that. Indeed, after the Gag Order Hearing was through, like right when it ended, the judge said he was reserve a decision on the matter. Trump was right back on his social media platform, attacking the judge, likening the proceedings to a kangaroo court. Braggs team noted trump knows what hes doing. Before court adjourned today, the focus was on david pecker, former ceo of American Media, which owns the National Enquirer. As we mentioned earlier in the broad cast, hes an alleged coconspirator. The other edge of that mutually beneficial relationship with donald trump, a lucrative one, to not publish or publish. Pecker was right there at the beginning of trumps plan to keep his relationship with Stormy Daniels a secret, hidden from the American People ahead of the election. Of course, the coverup failed on the long road that led us to this day, with the disgraced expresident forced to sit and listen to pecker testify about it in front of a jury thats correct potentially decide hes guilty. As we said, action, consequences. Its where we start the hour. Back this hour with another great table, msnbc Legal Correspondent lisa ruben, she was in the courthouse for us today. And the host of the podcast Tony Deutsche is here. Nbcs von hilliard was not permitted to leave. Lisa, take me inside the day. Nicolle, i think one of the things that was most stunning about the Gag Order Argument is the way that trump not only quoted jesse waters, but then fed jesse waters. So one of the posts is that quote you just played, trump wrote, theyre catching undercover liberal activists just to get on the jury. The just to get on the jury comment, that wasnt anything that Jesse Wattors said until 8 00 that evening, the tweet was at 5 00 p. M. That afternoon. It fully illustrates the Feedback Mechanism between trump and conservative media. Watters says something, and trump attributes it back to jesse, and what does he do three hours later . He repeats the whole thing verbatim. So i thought what was really interesting about it was that they were showing how these actions have consequences, by how they get amplified and perverted. He takes an idea, he turns it into his own, it goes right back out into that same ecosystem to endanger the people who are participating in this process. Its important to point out too, this was the juror, juror number two that the judge said would have been a good juror. There is a known consequence to the actions of Jesse Watters and donald trump. There is, and the d. A. Mentioned that a number of these posts were talking about are not about the jury, theyre about Michael Cohen or Stormy Daniels. But in fact, the entire process, to the extent that they chill participation in the administration of justice, they threaten the integrity of these proceedings, that impacts all of us. And maybe most especially the jurors who are already afraid of what this means for them, because you have seen one excuse herself. Other potential jurors break down and say, i cant do this. Another juror yesterday asking for a side bar because of the pressure that person was increasingly feeling. Trump has often covered like a amoeba that cant control himself. There was a suggestion from the prosecutor that hes doing it on purpose. Theres an element of that. Its a both and. He cant control himself . I would say he is a person who is inherently impulsive, yet theres some element of strategy there. When i think how hes comported himself in the courtroom when ive seen him, when he walks down the aisle, that is absolutely selfdirected, very clear to pause, look down the aisle of everybody assembled. Yet this is also a person who is closing their eyes. Whether theyre doing that to prevent themselves av a temper tantrum, whether he genuinely is tired is not entirely clear. So its a both and situation. Donnie, well deal with the pecker of it all. Can i just say yuck . Which part . All of it. You get caught up in the details. What a sleazy, greasy, lowlife universe this is. Whether you start with trump and you go to pecker and to Jesse Watters, its just yuck. I dont think people tuning in are going to take away every one of these nuances. But there is such a yuck factor that if you forgot about donald trump is the net, net, net of this. I think theres an exhaustion, plus yuck that people just go, oh, do i want more of this . And i think a lot of people minimize this trial because it is not Election Interference, it is not insurrection, its not classified documents. It is a reminder of yuck. To your point, there also may be people that theres no camera in the courtroom, theres no audio. But no one is with him. Hes got three two living hes got a wife, exwife, kids, none of them are there. I dont know if i agree you give him too much credit that hes walking down the aisle. I think hes just one of these guys that is just in the moment, this is his own universe, theres nobody that exists beyond him, and hes just sleeping, talking, hes this, passing gas, whatever hes doing. I dont think that theres this great master internal puppeteer going on. I think hes lost that. We want to amplify this, hes like lying at the rate of the rest of us are breathing. Right. Lets stop. Im sure its frustrating for a criminal defendant to get caught . To have to [ laughter ] this person is contending that they are innocent, they should have never been charged in the first place. This case is a hoax, thats the donald trump position here. And yet at the same time, just in the last ten minutes, he put out a new social media post, which were having the conversation about a trial whether donald trump has lied or not. Can i just read the first line . Yeah. Thousands of people were turned away from the courthouse by police, literally blocks from the tiny side door from where i enter and leave. Its an armed camp to read people away. I read that because i was down there, lisa was down there. That is the furthest thing from the truth. Thats a lie. Its not real life. Theres less than ten people there to support donald trump today. And anybody across the country, you can fly to laguardia, jfk, or newark, take the train in, 100 center street, and you can walk on the sidewalk where the front door of that courthouse is. There are not thousands of protrump demonstrators that are there. But his 6. 6 million followers on Trump True Social will be saying that. So donald trump wants to argue via his lawyer inside that hes not a liar, but hes putting up posts that are not even comprehensible. I guess its laughable. Theres nothing laughable about the criminal justice system, but as a criminal defendant, he has a presumption of innocence, but whats laughable is that the sliming and the smearing of the process, where usually theres a moment where everything gets real. Hes immune to all of that. Theres no respect for the judge, no respect for the jurors. I wonder if anything has the standing with him to say this isnt going to help you. I dont think that is the Campaign Operation around him. Donald trump largely speaks for himself now. There were efforts in his 2016 campaign and while in the white house to try to moderate him or try to reason with him. And yet, what you saw was in 2016, efforts to try to Reach Main Stream News Organizations, nbc news, New York Times, despite him being frustrated by them, he kept on with fake tres and worked to a great extent. Americans trust in the main stream News Organization that is corroded. There was people he told them not to believe in the elections. Folks were there in the white house. That didnt work. Donald trump, though, as a result, has effective liquor loaded trust in our elections. Now with the justice system, its Effect Chully working now. Donald trump has largely not seen for himself the repercussions, and for him, his best effort is to erode trust in the justice system. And that means saying i should not be inside this courthouse. But i guess to your point, its another sign of him high on his own supply. Because in the real world, he and his party have lost every election except 16, and hes now facing 88 Felony Counts. Yeah. I want to stop on one word you said and thats lose. Donald trumps brand has always been winning. Were not getting to the end of the trial. I think the result of this trial has huge implications. Huge implications. I think if he wins, it just kind of shows his larger than life, i am a winner, ive always been a winner. Regardless of what this trial is, he comes out a loser, against the losing streak of the republicans and every way you put an l against their name, i dont think he recovers from this. I think the win loss here is a really big thing. Hes not going to go to jail, its just the badge that he comes out with a l on his lapel. He also makes Everybody Else think about a loser. I kept thinking about ted cruz, because in david peckers testimony, he confessed that not only did he embellish headlines, but he made up a photo of cruzs father with Lee Harvey Oswald by Mashing Up Two Photos together. When we look back, thanks to von, at what ted cruz had to say at the time, he was excoriating about the National Enquirer and the lies they were telling ant him. Trump, similarly, divorced himself from it and said that has nothing to do with me, thats the National Enquirer. Yesterday today, confronted with this testimony, what did ted cruz have to say . Thats ancient history. I have no interest in revisiting it. It is an interesting divorce from reality. I mean, this was testimony lets deal with david pecker now. I mean, what david pecker and the idea that like trump trump has no appreciation for irony. Because you describe what Jesse Watters has been charged with these characters i missed his rise, but i guess hes been around there for a long time. He was the one that did the lovely thing, mimicking Chinese People downtown where he was imitating them. This was his rise to fox, he was interviewing kind of making fun of people who couldnt speak english very well and mocking them. This was his big rise. Like we enjoy the right to say what we want to say, we have a relationship with our viewers. I assume he enjoys the rights he has to say what he wants. But the problem, i think, that trump has is that it is his practices with the media that aligns himself with trump. The whole Pecker Testimony is about a campaign role, not a friendship with donald trump. Its about an explicit decision to take a role in the Trump Campaign, and what pecker put on the record today was this at some point, braggs team asked him, in 2015 when trump announced his candidacy, did your frequency with mr. Cohen increase or decrease . Pecker, increase. How often were you in touch with Michael Cohen after trump announced his candidacy . Pecker, maybe daily. One of the most interesting things that happens today with pecker is whats been public facing trump, cohen, stormy, macdougal. What happened today was trump, pecker, and Everybody Else. I mean, the chart of the hush money Election Interference, corporate Criminal Enterprise totally changed. And you really see the impact of pecker and the National Enquirer and how it plays into kind of the center hub of media, politics, consumerism, and the fact that hes obviously, theres legal decisions, but its a shame. Because there was a real, real he was he was more of a fiction than Michael Cohen in certain ways. And more influential. What dawned on me, i wondered from the outside, pomeranzs book, you wonder what bragg did with the time between the first team that looks at the facts and the charging of trump. Clearly what they did, with 22 meetings with Michael Cohen, they corroborated everything he knew. Because they were so focused. They were laser focused this their pecker questioning. Im going to get back to that. One of the things they did at the beginning of david peckers testimony was asked him about his phone numbers. Do you remember the phone number of your Office Number in manhattan, in florida . Theyre going to show david pecker, i imagine a whole bunch of phone logs to corroborate his own testimony about the calls he had with Michael Cohen and donald trump. Again, the day ended with him recalling a call he had not with cohen but with trump after they did the investigation of Karen Mcdougals story after dylan howard flue to california to interview macdougal. It was david pecker who told donald trump, i think we should buy this. Thats where we stopped. And donald trump says what does he say . He says, i think sometimes those stories come out anyway. You have this collision with donald trump he wants to silence that information about himself, and donald trump, the tightwad. Right. I would be your eyes and ears, thats david pecker telling donald trump that. And about the arrangement, he said that pecker responded or trump responded that he was pleased. You know, this is a clearly Campaign Motive here that was laid out by david pecker, talking about the purchasing of stories for the purposes of potentially releasing them after the election. If you are open to releasing these stories after the election, then your concern is not about your wife or your children one day finding it out. It is about making it through november of 2016, and a potential to win the presidency. As far as his defense about i was protecting my family, it was known. In new york, donald trump was never discrete about anything. It was always out and about. Thats what makes it an inside joke that understand trump and the social scene. Donald trump was never operating very low key, if you will. It was a joke to david pecker, too. One of the things that made me laugh out loud today is when he described donald trump as one of the worlds eligible bachelor without any sense of irony that he was married. And he corrects himself. He says, he was the most eligible bachelor. And he liked the most beautiful women. Von hilliard, who did double duty, thank you so much for being here. Lisa, youve been extraordinary. When we come back, how the trump trial is refreshing peoples memories of one of the most disastrous moments in american political life. Certainly of the 2016 Trump Campaign. The release of the access Hollywood Tape that is reviving a conversation about the expresident s disdain for women and their parts. Plus, while trump is in the courtroom, joe biden is out on the campaign trail, talking about the fight for women and their reproductive rights in a Battleground State with one of the strictest Abortion Bans on the books in the country. The White House Press secretary will join the table. We continue after a quick break. Dont go anywhere today. A quick. Dont go anywhere today. When you own a Small Business every second counts. 120 seconds to add the finishing touches. 900 seconds to arrange the displays. If youre short on time for marketing constant contacts powerful tools can help. You can automate email and sms messages so customers get the right message at the right time. Save Time Marketing with constant contact. Because all it takes is 30 seconds to make someones day. Get started today at constantcontact. Com. Helping the small stand tall. But st. Jude has gotten us through it. St. Jude is hope for every child diagnosed with cancer because the research is being shared All Over The World. When others divide. We unite. With Real Solutions to help our kids. Like community schools. Neighborhood hubs that provide everything from Mental Health services to food pantries. Academic tutoring to prom dresses. Healthcare to after care. Community schools can wrap so much around public schools. And through meaningful partnerships with families, they become centers of their communities. Real solutions for kids and communities at aft. Org youre probably not easily persuaded to switch they become centers of their communities. Mobile providers for your business. But what if we told you its possible that comcast Business Mobile can save you up to 75 a year on your wireless bill versus the big three carriers . You can get two unlimited lines for just 30 each a month. All on the most reliable 5g Mobile Network nationwide. Wireless that works for you. For a limited time, ask how to save up to 830 off an eligible 5g phone when you switch to comcast Business Mobile. Dont wait call, click or visit an xfinity store today. Good evening. As we come on the air tonight, a firestorm is raging in the Republican Party and beyond over comments about Women Donald Trump was heard saying in that 11yearold tape that just came to light. We have got to start with the breaking political news that took place overnight. A very rare apology from donald trump. The candidate forced to say hes sorry after a tape from 2005 where he said vulgar comments about women. Anyone who knows me knows these words dont reflect who i am. Hours away from the blockbuster debate rematch, and donald trump not backing down. After this explosive video. Republicans calling on trump to quit the race. Will the gop abandon its own nominee . So at the time, it really was a political bombshell. The rnc, for a while, suspended their support of the republican nominee, donald trump. And he was all but written off as a certain loser. We know what happened next, he won. And Donald Trumps first criminal trial is bringing it all back, and trying to bring a jury now back to that moment in time, and the real political jam trump was in because of the release of the access Hollywood Tape. The content of that tape and trumps reaction to it are central to proving the expresident s motives to orchestrate hush money payments that interfered in the election to Stormy Daniels. The tape and the fallout might be key to proving trumps criminal conduct in this trial, a police in the atlantic points out what its use in this case means for the american voter. Joining us conversation, msnbc political analyst Cornell Belcher is here. And also joining us, voters against trump, sarah is back. Donny is here, as well. Sarah, were going to show you some of your amazing ads. But first, this question on what the muck of the trial brings back into the news cycles and public view for donald trump politically. Yeah. So ive been doing focus groups recently on the issue of abortion with women, and one of the things thats been interesting is that a lot of times when new issues really come to prominence or salience, its because of a combination of things. I think the combination of the Abortion Repeal in arizona, they implemented this 18 sort of 64 law that completely bans abortion, even in the cases of rape and incest, along with the Stormy Daniels trial, which reminds people of just how gross trump is to women. The women in these groups were incredibly vocal about just sort of i hadnt heard it in a long time. A lot of this stuff is baked in with so many voters. Trumps sort of the misogyny, the gross way he talks about women. But its increased in salience because of these issues coming together right now. So the women in these groups, especially the groups that were in arizona were talking a lot about this case and how they cant believe that hes even allowed to run again. These were swing voters. And just how despicable his behavior is to women. It was one of the things really keeping them from any interest in going back to voting for him, even though they tended to be sort of center right independents and soft gop voters. Sarah, thats the 64 million question. Whether now he also was known to sexualize his own daughter. He made comments about how she was so hot, he would date her if she wasnt his own daughter. They were chalked up. But now that there is a massive policy revolution in this country for the first time in 50 years, there isnt a right to make decisions about your own body, youre saying that these comments are viewed differently. Yeah. Look, donald trump has always benefited enormously from his celebrity, right . People just dont hold the same sort of moral standards to him, in part because he was never a moral guy. And look, theres no doubt that for some voters, and i hear this all the time from men, but also from women, where theres also a part of the irreverence of donald trump and baked into that is the way he treats women and something that often times republicans like about him. Theres a big part of his constituency that is this maga, bro, Bar Stool Sports Combination in a way that the Republican Party that you and i know 10, 15 years ago, you know, this kind of thing wouldnt fly. But i do think that its the fact that there is now a policy issue that has an impact on womens lives, that has changed the way that women view how donald trump thinks about them, because this is just this wasnt the case in 2016, right . And now, these voters dont trust him on womens issues. They dont trust him to take women seriously. That was coming through loud and clear from the women in these focus groups. One of whom was a trump voting focus group. They were all leaning, interestingly not so much towards biden but to kennedy because of trumps stance on abortion and the way he viewed women. Fascinating. Cornell, let me play some of the voters that sarah is talking about. These are testimonials from female republicans. Hes arrogant and egotistical, and shows utter disdain towards women and those of other races. He intimidates, cheats, he lies and steals. The plans that donald trump has laid out shows me that we would be at risk if he was in the white house. Women are at risk. He does not show the love of jesus in his treatment of people when he talks down to them, when he mistreats them. With the number of cases that women have fought against. As an individual and a woman with integrity, i do not like the way hes spoken about women, especially women of power. Cornell, sometimes its i feel exasperated how long it takes for the trump story to sort of penetrate the consciousness, but it seems among republican women, maybe it finally has. Well, well see, right . Nicolle, i want to be hopeful, but ive seen over the past week a lot of people who have come out and said terrible things about donald trump, one being his former a. G. , bill barr, but yet hes going the support him. Look, lets look at what the polling tells us. Lets look at what real elections tell us. Look, biden won women by 15 points in 2020. The gender gap is really important for democrats, really important for anyone who is trying to get to a majority in this country, because for better or worse, women are the majority of voters in this country. And the conversation goes, you know, can donald trump cut into that gender gap . What those focus groups tell me and what im seeing in my data is it gets really tough for donald trump to garner even more votes among women that it was even in 2020. If you look at nbcs polling, what youre going to talk about at some point, where is donald trump now . Hes at 46 . Nicolle, where was donald trump in the fall of 23 in nbc polling . 46 . Hes not growing his support and he needs to grow his support. I think a lot of these issues, especially with the way he treats women and the way he disrespects women, gets in the way of him growing beyond that 46 . Donny . Ive said this before on this show, women will win this election. Theres an ad running i forget which state, but its so powerful. It shows a young woman, sarah may have done this ad, i dont know, but a young woman who is driving and is a policeman following her. Can we look for this . What is it . I forgot which pac did it. A cop pulls this woman over, shes trying to leave the state to get an abortion and says, can i see your Pregnancy Test . It is like, stunning to see that. Weve got to find this ad. This is what i guess this is the piece i want to understand. I feel like even though of us covering the election should be held to a standard of covering the issues that are going to decide it. What i keep hearing, women are going to decide it. And if you look at what women who are likely voters who are still undecided, its not necessarily trumps travails, its this thing that sarah is talking about, where theyre bolstered by policies. He didnt just appoint the justices that overturned roe. He picked them because they would overturn roe. And he keeps taking credit for it. He said, i did this. Correct. As someone who tries to be thoughtful about where we shine a light, i wonder if were doing a disservice in terms of understand bring the voters are by not focusing on that. Well be right back. Cusing on tht well be right back. To a child, this is what conflict looks like. Children in ukraine are caught in the crossfire of war, forced to flee their homes. A steady stream of refugees has been coming across all day. Its basically cold. Lacking clean water and sanitation. Exposed to injury, hunger. Exhausted and shell shocked from what theyve been through. Every dollar you give can help bring a meal, a blanket, or simply hope to a child living in conflict. Please call or go online to givenowtosave. Org today with your gift of 10 a month, thats just 0. 33 a day. We cannot forget the children in places like syria, born in refugee camps, playing in refugee camps, thinking of the camps as home. Please call or go online to givenowtosave. Org today with your gift of 10 a month. Your gift can help children like ara in afghanistan, where nearly 20 years of conflict have forced the people into extreme poverty. Weakened and unable to hold herself up, ara was brought to a Save The Childrens center, where she was diagnosed and treated for severe malnutrition. Every dollar helps. Please call or go online to givenowtosave. Org today with your gift of 10 a month. Just 0. 33 a day. And thanks to special Government Grants that are available now, every dollar you give can multiply up to ten times the impact. And when you use your credit card, youll receive this special Save The Children tote bag to show you wont forget the children who are living their lives in conflict. Every war is a war against children. Please give now. A test or approve a medication. We didnt have to worry about any of those things thanks to the donations. And our family is forever grateful because its completely changed our lives. Were back with donny, cornell and sarah. Sarah, you did that ad. Its these simple, if this then that, right . If you couldnt get hired at the mall, he probably shouldnt be president. Tell me about that ad. Look, one of the things that we see in the focus groups, listening to voters all the time is just donald trump has now been with us for a long time. People are getting numb to some of this stuff. And, you know, the tort cases, just like with so in, its like that bannon line, were going to flood the zone with garbage, it creates a kind of, you know, were all that proverbial frog in the Boiling Water getting used to this, the new normal. Sometimes you just need to reframe things and hammer home some of the basics and wake people up to say, any if you just as a regular person, you know, had been found in civil court of sexual assault, you cant get hired. You know, being accused of 88 you got 88 different charges against you, a Jewelry Store is not going to hire you. A lot of stores at your local mall arent going to hire you. So the idea that this person who has mishandled Nuclear Documents were going to give him the Nuclear Codes again, has to shake people to remember this is actual insanity. Taking this person who has all of this baggage and trying to potentially put him back in charge of the country. And so look, thats the goal with an ad like this. I mean, cornell to your point, thats where voters are so disoriented by the likes of bill barr saying hes my guy, and Mitch Mcconnell. He could not adopt a dog from a shelter, right . You get a Background Check to take home a dog, and a criminal check, and he and the republicans, people like bill barr and Mitch Mcconnell are like yeah, yeah, im good with that. Its where the disorienting sort of fog of trump comes in and confuses voters and makes these campaigns all the more important. Well, you know, the campaigns are important, thats a fantastic ad. And what for us Political Campaign hacks understand about that ad, the power of that ad is it does remind voters, and it drives home a really strong case against donald trump. And to a certain extent, it nails tight the ceiling, i think, that donald trump has. I think donald trump, and we have seen it in several elections, donald trump has a ceiling of close to 46 , 47 . What that ad does is get in the way of him being able to grow that. I think it does effectively stop him from cutting into sort of garnering more women votes. But at the same time, you know, the Biden Campaign has a story to tell. And while we saw that biden had a large gender gap advantage in 2020, right now in the polling, where hes off is with the key constituencies like women voters who broke hard for him in the last election, and hes got to bring them home, both those women, particularly those women voter and Younger Voters overall. I do think he has a good story to tell about freedoms and reproductive rights, as well as college loan forgiveness. I think he has a good story to tell to bring these voters home. That is a really good ad at capping or kneeing donald trump off at 46 and hopefully hell stay there. And nicolle, its hard for him to garner a majority if, in fact, we have a turnout thats better than 54 . The other problem about the nbc polling is also that enthusiasm is really down at this upcoming election. Yeah, i mean, i heard it on our air today that its sort of the point in the calendar where maybe you look at likely voters, not registered voters. But to cornells point, it is time to start doing and not talking. How do you do . I think part of it, and one of the reasons sarahs ads have been so good and super pac ads have been so good is they have a story to tell. You have done this for a long time, and you know how sometimes youve got to you know, its like you have to do it cleverly and do it with bite, and i have to congratulate all the people that have been doing the biden communications, because that old republican bite to it. Democrats had that before. Underneath that, they have the facts. They have the issues on their side. Abortion, 70 to 90 , guns, student loan forgiveness, all these things. Its on their side. So i think so far, if this is a precursor of what is to come, if youre trump, you have inflation and bidens age. The border, you cant even go in full steam, because you have an argument against that as far as the republicans have shot it down. Tom swazy Ran On Immigration In on the Third District in new york and won. So we have a lot more bullets Metaphor Bullets In The Gun to work with. To be continued. Thank you all so much for spending time with us today. After the break, the candidate who doesnt have to be in court, Standing Trial on any Felony Counts is on the road campaigning, making his case on all these issues, perhaps the defining issue in 2024. Joe bidens message on Abortion Rights in Florida Is Our Next story. Stay with us. N Florida Is Our N story. Stay with us on medicare . Have diabetes . When enjoying lifes special moments are you left guessing which foods are right for you . With the freestyle libre 3 system youll know your glucose and where its headed No Fingersticks needed. Freestyle libre 3 manage your diabetes with more confidence and lower your a1c. So you can focus on those special moments. Covered by medicare for more people managing diabetes with insulin. Talk to your provider or visit freestylelibre. Us medicare a lot of new dry eye patients in my office tell me about their frequent dry eyes, which may point to dry eye disease. Millions of americans were estimated to have it. Theyve tried artificial tears again and again, but the relief is temporary. Xiidra can provide lasting relief. Xiidra treats the signs and symptoms of dry eye disease. Dont use if youre allergic to xiidra. Common side effects include eye irritation, discomfort or blurred vision when applied to the eye, and unusual taste sensation. Doctor why wait . Ask your eye doctor about a 90day prescription for xiidra today. Hi, im chris and i lost 57 pounds on golo. Golo isnt complicated. Ask your eye doctor about a 90day prescription i dont have to follow a restrictive diet, and i dont have to spend a lot of time making meals. Using golo was truly transformative. It was easy, and inexpensive. Sometimes, the lows of bipolar depression feel darkest before dawn. With caplyta, theres a chance to let in the lyte™. Caplyta is proven to deliver significant relief across bipolar depression. Unlike some medicines that only treat bipolar i, caplyta treats both bipolar i and ii depression. And in clinical trials, Movement Disorders and weight gain were not common. Call your doctor about sudden mood changes, behaviors, or suicidal thoughts. Antidepressants may increase these risks in young adults. Elderly dementia patients have increased risk of death or stroke. Report fever, confusion, stiff or uncontrollable muscle movements which may be life threatening or permanent. These arent all the serious side effects. Caplyta can help you let in the lyte™. Ask your doctor about caplyta. Find savings and support at caplyta. Com lets be real clear, theres one person responsible for this nightmare, and hes acknowledging and he brags about it, donald trump. Trump says this will stay law, as theyre working in his words, brilliantly, brilliantly. Its a sixweek ban in florida. Each before a woman knows theyre pregnant, is that brilliant . It shouldnt matter where in america you live, this isnt about states rights, its about womens rights. That was joe biden a short time ago, slamming floridas sixweek near total ban on abortion, which goes into effect in a few days. Its a ban that was made possible by Donald Trumps hand picked Supreme Court justices, overturning roe v. Wade. Its one of the many contrasts between joe biden and donald trump. While biden is spending the week campaigning, the expresident is, of course, in court, Standing Trial as a criminal defendant in that Election Interference hush money case. The case deals with payments made to a porn star. It goes in front of the nations highest court to claim that hes immune from prosecution over his efforts to steal the 2020 election. Suffice to say, hes busy. This that case, hell be represented by an attorney who built his career fighting to end womens access to Abortion Health care. Join us is the White House Press secretary karine jeanpierre. I know there are limits, but lets talk about the president s focus on abortion. Tell me about today and tell me what the plan is for the coming months. Just think about it. You have joe biden, who went to florida to take it directly to the American People to talk about how reproductive rights, Womens Health care is under attack. You think about the 21 states that have active Abortion Bans. That affects 30 million women who are of reproductive age, 30 million women. You have women who cannot get health care. Theyre being turned away for the care that they need. You have doctors who are potentially could get arrested because they are providing care. This is where we are. We have pure chaos, because of what the former president did and bragged about and said im going to put justices on the Supreme Court, so that they could overturn a right, a constitutional right that we have for almost 50 years. We were just talking about our kids. Can you imagine, nicolle . We have more rights than our children have today. Its a kick in the stomach realization, especially for our daughters. I wonder how you break through and make sure that every voter knows that . So i would say, and i have to be careful about talking about the upcoming election, so ill take a step back. We had ohio, michigan, vermont, california, kansas, kentucky. When the Ballot Initiative was on that initiative for abortion, protect abortion or wherever you stood to protect a womans rights was on that ballot, they voted overwhelmingly to protect Womens Health care. Were talking about kentucky, kansas, were talking about some ohio. North carolina. North carolina. Were talking about some red states. So a majority of americans support the right of our freedoms, the right to make decisions about our bodies. That politicians should not be involved in what women decide to do, really difficult decisions. I started off by saying its been chaos, right . Its not just abortion, were talking about contraception, everything is under attack right now. And women cannot theyre saying no, we cant make decisions for ourselves when it comes to health care. Thats insane. We are in 2024. So thats what you saw the president do. Thats what you have seen the Vice President do, going across the country talking about it. She went to arizona. 1864. Thats insane. 1864. A law from 1864. And by the way, the republicans there wont allow it to be repealed. Right. Even after attacking it. Let me ask you this, you have supermajorities of americans. The republican ban, talking about 22 states that triggered their abortion ban, the bans are even more unpopular than roe ever was. You have 63 to 76 of americans that believe abortion should be legal. You have 93 of americans that oppose the bans except for rape and incest. The actual practical effect of some of the bans is that women lose their lives, lose their fertility. I think we have some sound of this ad cut for the Biden Campaign. We were told that with 100 certainty, we were going to lose our baby. What i needed at that point was an abortion. We were told i just had to wait until i got so sick that my life was considered in danger. It took three days, and a neardeath crash and septic shock before my doctor could provide the health care i needed. What i went through was nothing short of barbaric and didnt need to happen but it did because of donald trump. Over and over again, donald trump brags about killing roe v. Wade. And it is unthinkable that anyone could cheer on the proAbortion Bans that nearly killed me. Amandas story and the loss of her daughter, willow, complicates republicans arguments that this is about anything other than Womens Health care. Its difficult, because thats one story. There are hundreds of other stories. Probably thousands. Thousands of stories where you hear that women have to go what they have to go through when they are denied the care. And it is devastating. It is wrong. It is wrong. And amanda and so many other women should have the right, the freedom to make that decision. And thats what were talking about. Thats what the Bidenharris Administration has been talking about since almost two years ago when roe v. Wade was overturned because of the dobbs decision. Weve got to fight for womens rights, health care, their Reproductive Health care and talk about it. The only way you hear the president talk about this is to make roe the law of the land again. And this is where we are. Our freedoms are under attack, our democracy is under attack, and we have to protect that. We have to protect that. And we have to continue to hear stories like amandas, because thats the only way we are going to break through. But as you were just laying out, the percentage of women and where they stand of americans, the majority of americans dont want to see this. Right. Certainly republicans. Right. Including republicans. So you have to think about these extreme republican officials. What side of history do you want to be on here . Youre not standing with the majority of americans, even your own constituents are not standing with you. Let me ask you about something in the news, thats what is going on, on college campuses. What is that like, what is the White House Position and how do you balance the celebrated right to protest with a genuine fear of jewish students and their families they may not be safe . It is a genuine fear, to your point. The president , for passover, put out a statement and this that statement, he condoned he condemned, pardon me, he condemned what weve been seeing, the rise of antisemitism since october 7th. It is scary for the jewish students, Jewish Americans across the country. We have to condemn that. Remember why he ran back when we saw what happens in virginia, the vile, the hatred. Any type of vile rhetoric, we have to condemn that. Obviously, as youre asking your question, freedom of speech is important. Peaceful protesting is important. But when you see hate rear its ugly head, we have to condemn it. So he put that statement out on sunday. He repeated it again on monday. And we have been pretty consistent throughout this administration. Is there more you can do, though . I think the problem is that on the campuses themselves, jewish students dont see a uniform reaction. They see members of the faculty marching, they see the horrific messages. And people dont feel safe. Is there is the white house considering more things to make people safe . We have put forward an antisemitism strategy to make sure students feel safe, obviously jewish students feel safe, and so well continue to do that work. But in the meantime, we have to be very clear, we have to condemn. We have to condemn violent rhetoric. We have to condemn any form of hate and thats what the president has been consistent on throughout this administration. Youre right. The ad that launches its first run is we talked about it. We talked about it. So much, but we dont have enough time. Will you come back . It would be my pleasure, my friend. So nice to see you. Karine jeanpierre on the podium. A quick break for us. Well be right back. Um a quick break for us well be right back. vo want to upgrade but still paying off your locked phone . Break free from 3year device contracts. Switch to tmobile, and well pay off your phone. And upgrade you to one of the latest 5g phones, free. Your shipping manager left to find themself. leaving you lost. You need to hire. I need indeed. Indeed you do. Indeed instant match instantly delivers quality candidates matching your job description. Visit indeed. Com hire harry david makes mothers day easy. Share a gift, made with love, with the mom in your life. Choose from hundreds of stunning baskets and towers. Its the perfect way to say thank you for everything. Harry david. Life is a gift. Share more. Lakesha Childhood Cancer is its hard. But st. Jude has gotten us through it. St. Jude is hope for every child diagnosed with cancer because the research is being shared All Over The World. Business. Its not a ninetofive proposition. Its all day and into the night. Its all the things that keep this world turning. The gotos that keep us going. The places we cheer. And check in. They all choose the advanced Network Solutions and round the clock partnership from comcast business. See why comcast business powers more Small Businesses than anyone else. Get started for 49. 99 a month plus ask how to get up to an 800 prepaid card. Dont wait call today. When others divide. We unite. With Real Solutions to help our kids. Like community schools. Neighborhood hubs that provide everything from Mental Health services to food pantries. Academic tutoring to prom dresses. Healthcare to after care. Community schools can wrap so much around public schools. And through meaningful partnerships with families, they become centers of their communities. Real solutions for kids and communities at aft. Org thank you so much for letting us into your home during these extraordinary times. Were so grateful. The beat with katie fang starts right now. Thanks so much