It was time. It was time to bring something new. We did a lot of testing and this is just what the public wanted, said Sisk.
The Toast-Yay! cookie is becoming popular along with other cookie favorites: Thin Mints, Shortbreads, and Lemonades. But of course, with anything new, the Toast-Yay is drawing mixed reviews. My brother and my mom, they love them, but they re not really my cookie, said Isabella Garcia Dos Santos. Thin Mints continue to be her favorite cookie, but the Girl Scout from Troop 42504 in Asheville, is confident, if you like cinnamon, then you ll love this new cookie.