congressman adam schiff of california. do you agree with congressman rogers? well, i agree that there are risks, but i don t agree with them that we should keep guantanamo open indefinitely, and the problem i have with the critics of the president s actions is they don t offer any alternative. not only a military struggle with al qaeda and with isis, but also an idealogical war and guantanamo is a real setback for the united states in that idealogical fight, in that battle over ideas. ultimately we re not going to be able to kill our way out of this struggle. we have to defeat the underpinnings, the nar tiff, the ideology of al qaeda and isis, and so guantanamo really does need to be closed. i do have a concern here that uruguay isn t going to maintain any kind of monitoring these people, doesn t seem to have any intention of putting them through rehabilitation. that is something we have accomplished with other countries, and that does concern me, but at the end of the day we