participate in commerce where do you stop? can t stop at healthcare. what about a car and juan s books as good as they are. can you compel somebody. chris: let me make the counter argument for the sake of argument which is for all due respect you can live without reading juan s books. people talk about broccoli. you don t have to eat broccoli. sooner or later everybody is going to use healthcare. how is that different from housing and transportation. most people in america need a car. i think i want you to buy a certain car because i live the chevy volt and the government likes the chevy volt just like i think you need to buy a certain healthcare product. we will mandate this product and you must buy that. just because somebody ultimately par table takes of h healthcare we can t compel you to buy that product. chris: mr. justice williams would you like to respond to your colleague on the bench?
participate in commerce where do you stop? can t stop at healthcare. what about a car and juan s books as good as they are. can you compel somebody. chris: let me make the counter argument for the sake of argument which is for all due respect you can live without reading juan s books. people talk about broccoli. you don t have to eat broccoli. sooner or later everybody is going to use healthcare. how is that different from housing and transportation. most people in america need a car. i think i want you to buy a certain car because i live the chevy volt and the government likes the chevy volt just like i think you need to buy a certain healthcare product. we will mandate this product and you must buy that. just because somebody ultimately par table takes of h healthcare we can t compel you to buy that product. chris: mr. justice williams would you like to respond to your colleague on the bench?
compel individuals to participate in commerce where do you stop? can t stop at healthcare. what about a car and juan s books as good as they are. can you compel somebody. chris: let me make the counter argument for the sake of argument which is for all due respect you can live without reading juan s books. people talk about broccoli. you don t have to eat broccoli. sooner or later everybody is going to use healthcare. how is that different from housing and transportation. most people in america need a car. i think i want you to buy a certain car because i live the chevy volt and the government likes the chevy volt just like i think you need to buy a certain healthcare product. we will mandate this product and you must buy that. just because somebody ultimately par table takes of h healthcare we can t compel you to buy that product. chris: mr. justice williams would you like to respond to your colleague on the bench?
participate in commerce, where do you stop? what about a car? what about books as good as they are. can you compel somebody? let me make the argument for the sake of argument. which is with all dupre respect you could don t it without reading a book. people talk about broccoli. you don t have to eat broccoli. sooner or later people have to use healthcare. how is that different from housing or transportation? most people in america need a car. i think i want you to buy a certain car because i like the chevy volt. the government likes the chevy volt. just like you need to buy a healthcare product. we are going to mandate the product for you. just because somebody ultimately par takes of healthcare like the housing and other markets we can t compel you to buy that product. mr. justice williams would you like to reply? certainly. i think just as you go needs to understand here that the
participate in commerce where do you stop? can t stop at healthcare. what about a car and juan s books as good as they are. can you compel somebody. chris: let me make the counter argument for the sake of argument which is for all due respect you can live without reading juan s books. people talk about broccoli. you don t have to eat broccoli. sooner or later everybody is going to use healthcare. how is that different from housing and transportation. most people in america need a car. i think i want you to buy a certain car because i live the chevy volt and the government likes the chevy volt just like i think you need to buy a certain healthcare product. we will mandate this product and you must buy that. just because somebody ultimately par table takes of h healthcare we can t compel you to buy that product. chris: mr. justice williams would you like to respond to your colleague on the bench?