Really appreciate you so much welcomed in the evening edit, and Elizabeth Mcdonald be up in just a few moments, is been Byron Donalds pt mcfarland want to get right of the action today, before Deputy Assistant attorney former Deputy Assistant attorney general john i think its both for joining us tom first year, tom former President Trump in todays Court Hearing of florida, we leave make tif today Trumps Team Asked to toss out special counsel, jack smith, classified documents case against trump. Tom sure these arguments we knew were coming and the president has legal they were asking the federal judge recommended for the case out entirely and based on her questions from the bench today, it is a semi shes inclined to do it a few points liz, were she made comments along the lines of flow, these may be very good arguments and powerful arguments were that you can make it the trial and you can make that is right im not sure that i see a basis for using them come into dismiss this case entire