Transcripts For MSNBCW Up With David Gura 20190504

Lasted longer than an hour, what the two leaders talked about and more notably what they didnt discuss and a fear 2020 could be a repeat of 2016. He actually sort of smiled when he said something to the effect that it started off as a mountain and it ended up being a mouse. And the countdown continues in congress, democrats have given bill barr an ultimatum. Where it may be headed. It is see the attorney gener misrepresent the facts, indeed lie to the congress of the United States, impeachment is they ever ohave neveever never. And i sit down with John Hickenlooper has he makes his case to voters and to beer drinkers. Most americans want to vote for somebody that they want to sit down and have a beer with, right . Why not sit down with the guy who made the beer. It is saturday may 4th. With some 20 men and women running for the democratic nomination, can we assume the field is finally set . Well start off with reports that mayor de blasio apparently ready to announce a run for the white house. Apparently not. With me now, cohost of unredacted. And now korea chair for the center of international studieses. And also Senior Correspondent at business insider. And also National Security analyst, spokes than during the obama administration. Lets start with tensions rei go nighted by north korea just two months afters collap the collape summit in hanoi, news that north korea launched several projectiles. A stark rebuke to what President Trump said about relations with north korea just last week. I think were doing very well with north korea. A lot of progress is being made. When i came here, there were nuclear tests, missile tests, rocket tests. There has been no tests, no nothing. So at some point youre going to report the facts. I have a great relationship with kim jungun. This morning that relationship being tested. John bolton telling nbc news the president has been fully briefed. White House Press Secretary Sarah Huckabee sanders issuing this statement late last night, we are aware of north koreas actions tonight. We will continue to monitor as necessary. South korean and u. S. Authorities are working to analyze the details surrounding the launch. This is a week after kim jungun traveled to russia by train to meet with president putin. Help us with the distinction here. Initially it was reported this was a missile test. And then we saw the word projectile. Is there a distinction without a difference . I think it is a big difference here. The important thing, this is a short range missile test. So this is c it is not a Intercontinental Ballistic Missile test. They would have gone there, but they didnt because they still want to engage with trump. So north korea is what kim jungun is doing is he wants to pressure the Trump Administration, right, while projecting strength at home. But were at an impasse. No question about it. So President Trump is not, you know, direcorrect when he says e is no threats. And kim jungun wants to remind everybody what we could return to, which is 2017. President trump saying some day they will report the facts. So he is claiming there havent been tests and youre bringing up the nuance as well. So that still stands. He can still say that, that they havent exactly. And kim doesnt want to completely blow it up. Kim wants to still deal with trump, so he is trying to pressure the Trump Administration to return to the talks. United nations agencies just came out with a report that said 10 million North Koreans are dealing with food insecurity. So north koreas economy is not doing well. Kims trip to russia, meeting with putin, did not really yield anything substantive. He needs to get something out of trump. He still thinks there is a deal to be had and the best way to get there is to pressure the Trump Administration by doing this. And the controlled tension here that kim is putting on. Yeah, you pointed out the contrast between what trump has said and what north korea is doing. We shouldnt be surprised by that. Weve been reminded that donald trump has this perverse set of incentives. I dont think Donald Trumps top priority is denuclearization or a halt to the missile tests. Yes, all those things would be good. What donald trump wants above all else is a Foreign Policy win. He wants something to be able to present to his base to say look, i inhir ratherited a bad probl made it better. He wants to camouflage over all the messy stuff, the fact that the North Koreans after the hanoi summit began reconstruction on a missile site. He wants to present it as though this was a massive success. No small wonder that on the campaign trail before the midterms, he essentially led the crowds in chants ev s of nobel, nobel. And he encouraged reports the japanese Prime Minister to recommend him for the nobel prize. Very clear what he is doing here. I want to ask you about the path of diplomacy here. Cindy warmbier was he speaking in washington, d. C. Late last week and she talked about certain stances surrounding her sons death. Ill read a bit. There is a charade going on, it is called diplomacy, how can you have diplomacy with someone who never tells the truth. Im all for it, but very skeptical temperature skept. He l vent cal. He lies. And that is referring to kim jungun. And the problem is for someone who lies constantly and a easily as donald trump does, youd think that he could spot it in other people fast and he cant. That is heartbreaking. When otto came back, his parents did an interview that was one of the most jarring things ive ever seen about what this was like when they went up on the plane and his mother was so struck by his screaming that she couldnt go in. His father said his teeth were rearranged. This is kim jungun. This is someone who knew what we were doing and by the way wants 2 million to bill us for his lack of medical care. But he is being naive. And ned hit the nail on the head. Only difference is that it is not that he wants Foreign Policy, he wants a buddy, who just says i love donald trump, says i got another beautiful letter. And here we are. You joke about were going to hear a few more days of there were no tests, but that is what were going to hear. Well hear Congressional Republicans saying projectiles arent missiles. God forbid on twitter you can have anyone saying they were missiles. A water balloon is a projectile. I dont want a projectile like they are testing to hit my house. I mean that will kill you. We shouldnt pretentends otherw. In fairness, everyone can vouch for that, north korea is a wicked problem. Otherwise. In fairness, everyone can vouch for that, north korea is a wicked problem. So were being my eefr abonaive a tough week for john bolton and mike pompeo as well. Yeah, venezuela was a very strange case because it seemed like john bolton and the rest of the administration were really playing for an audience of one there. Their messages werent even in spanish. They werent helpful to the people on ground. It was like what are you even doing. It was very clear that trump was sending his guys out to say show that you are tough, show that Nicolas Maduro cant mess with us. Were the ones and there are very serious issues with venezuela, with it becoming a failed state and with the Vice President s ties to terrorist groups like hezbollah, that is a very real threat and were not engaging in any of this, were turning it into Nicolas Maduro is a bad embrey and well get him out and these are my american guys who will do it because were tough. This is like the simplicity of Donald Trumps mind. It is like stunningly simple and scary. I wish i had a joke for this, but i dont. I think that facial expression means were deemed. So where do we go from here as you see it . There is talk from kim jungun that he would do another summit here by the end of the year. How much of that is a distraction . We are at an impasse because unless were going to give sanctions relief, and this is exactly what north korea wants, we wont get there. So i think that we will be kind of stuck. And well see what the North Koreans could offer up something just to have the charade continue, just look like there is going to be a deal. But if we are looking for cooperati denuclearization, were not going to get there. Thank you very much. And when we come back, the president who would not talk to Robert Mueller about president putin, does not seem to have a problem talking with president putin. We continue to get more information from the russian government than we do from the Trump Administration. What the two leaders said, next. Hi. Maria ramirez mom maria Maria Ramirez. Mcdonalds is committing 150 Million Dollars in tuition assistance, education, and career advising programs. Prof Maria Ramirez mom and dad Maria Ramirez to help more employees achieve their dreams. Mom and dad Maria Ramirez what is that . Uh mine, why . Its just that its. Lavender. Yes it is, its for men but i like the smell of it laughs its been a long time since andrew dusted off his dancing shoes. Luckily denture breath will be the least of his worries. Because he uses polident 4 in 1 cleaning system to kill 99. 99 of odor causing bacteria. Polident. Clean. Fresh. And confident. Of odor causing bacteria. Driven each day to pursue bioplifechanging cures. Ers. In a country built on fostering innovation. Here, they find breakthroughs. Like a way to fight cancer by arming a patients own tcells. And a new therapy that gives the blind a working gene so they can see again. Because its not just about the next breakthrough. Its all the ones after that. A Business Owner always goes beyond what people expect. Thats why we built the nations largest gigspeed network along with complete reliability. Then went beyond. Beyond clumsy dialsins and pins. To onetouch conference calls. Beyond traditional tv. To tv on any device. Beyond lowres surveillance video. To Crystal Clear hd video monitoring from anywhere. Gigfueled apps that exceed expectations. Comcast business. Beyond fast. Welcome back to up. President trump says he discussed the, quote, russian hoax in a phone call with president putin on friday, but one topic that did not come up in their hour long discussion is russias meddling in the 2016 election and concern russia might try to do it again in 2020. Russia news agency released this photograph of president putin on the phone call which the president claims was initiated by prud. Here is what President Trump had to say about their conversation. He actually sort of smiled when he said something to the effect that it started off as a mountain and it ended up being a mouse. But he knew that because he knew there was no collusion. Did you tell him not to medal in the next election . Excuse me, im talking. Im answering this question. You are very rude. Did you tell him not to medal in the next election . We didnt discuss that. That was the First Exchange between the two leaders since Robert Mueller stated the russian government interfered in the 2016 election in sweeping and systemic fashion. Chris wray warned things could get worse in 2020. Our adversaries will keep upping their game, so we are very much viewing 2018 as just kind of a dress rehearsal for the big show in 2020. The panel back with me including a professi including a professor of law. Ned, we were introducing some lingo here. What is the message here . President trump making this phone call discussing what he did. I should say we used to get official readouts of the calls. We dont get those now, we get the tweets. Kremlin put out an official readout and what was so interesting, in President Trumps tweets, he mentioned that they spoke of the quote unquote russian hoax. And you compare that with what the kremlin put out. Kremlin put out what sounded like a pretty professional document. It said they discussed the situation . Venezuela, regional issue, shared global threats. But President Trump made clear to say that they talked about mueller. It was almost like the american president was much more intent on putting out russian propaganda, the russian hoax, than the kremlin itself was. But i think the much more sober what we should be concerned about is the sobering message that President Trump by all accounts didnt bring until election meddling that chris wray the fbi director has warned of. The dni coats before Congress Warned of. Everyone seems to be concerned about this except for donald trump. And by not bringing it up, it is not just a sin of omission, donald trump is in many ways essentially sending the signal to Vladimir Putin that we wont care about this, you do what you have to do and you know he what, if it works to high benefimy be the better. The mixed metaphor, mountain and mouse. It is a mole hill. Im glad i got to say it. And a clear conversation a lot about mixed metaphor, i think a lot about his inability to use email and how in jail he might already be if he could use email. I think a lot about Donald Trumps limitations especially when it comes to the russia situation. It is a long phone call, an hour. We definitely dont know what happened on that phone call. And russia is definitely involved with venezuela for years. So i dont know what else to say. I mean we cant believe anything that comes out of the president s mouth. So what is your reaction to all of this, and all the while the storm continues on capitol hill, will bob mueller be brought up to testify, will we see contempt of congress with bill barr. And i think it will be a great episode of the americas for next season. That is the first thing. But it is concerning that this question of russian interference has been established by the Mueller Report. It is uncontroverted and yet they dont discuss it at all and the president says nothing about it. So again, i think it is an open invitation for russia or any other power to step in and interfere with the 2020 election and perhaps that is what the president wants. Pivotin ining to capitol hil. Nancy pelosi yesterday saying impeachment is not off the table, something that she has avoid tackling head on i think you could say. How does that change the conversation, how does that testimony that we heard from bill barr this week change the conversation about impeachment . I think in the last year, two years, there probably has been only one or two people that has done more damage than bill barr has done. You read the stories about donald trump watching the tv and cheering him on and i fine apple have a loyal a. G. This guy was screwing up left and right. He is all but daring bob mueller to come and tell it like it is. He was making fun of mueller, subm snitty letter, not really a career prosecutor. And now the issue of not showing up to the house is a serious one. Ill be a Debbie Downer for a minute. As someone who workeded hill for almost a decade, congress has very little power. It is almost like a london bob about i who doesnt carbobby wh carry a gun. Stop or ill yell stop again. Only three things they can do. Typically they can go to the department of justice to try to compel a witness. I assume that is not going to happen. Second is to go to court which would take exactly what trump wants, it will burn years. And then there is the third option that everyone is loving, this inherent contempt that the congress could physically go and get someone. And i think democrats are having this fantasy about him being arrested. It is not happening. What is going to happen now is barr basically is calling a bluff. And the democrats are going to democrats in Congress Know this already. There is a reason why nadler is saying ill send another letter, well negotiate, because he knows he has nothing after that. And inthat the democrats putting their faith in oversight and in congress, people will get a very hard civics lesson in the next couple weeks about how toothless congress can be. And how, you know, Speaker Pelosi is right to be cautious about impeachment. We might be on that path and we might need to step on the gas a little bit. And ill ask melissa, there is a familiarity talking about Robert Mueller as bob, there is this open question where is bob mueller, what happens and how many agency does he have at this point. I actually think bob mueller is the democrats best hope. If bill barr wont come before congress and testify, the next best thing would be to have bob mueller come before congress and talk about all of the things that bill barr wont. And again, bob mueller is a very careful sir consu circumspect person. And that is really their last best shot here because this is usually about negotiating with the department of justice and it is clear that bill barr sdudoes want to negotiate. And i think congress does have another tool that were overlooking and that is the tool of public messaging. They can go to oversight through the committees and hold consistent back to back to back to back hearings about donald trump. We have this 448 page report, some of us around the table may have read all 448 page, but i dont think that lot . Will pretend to. But i dont think very many people beyond those at this table have. And that report is cholk full of are information. The more donald trump stone walls subpoenas, the more he intimidates witnesses, the more he pressures them not to testify, the stronger that case is. The problem is both in there at the same time. Because it is not just with barr. The Trump White House has said no to every subpoena since january, whether it is about the clearance issue with jared, whether it is about anything. And it is not going to change. And the public messaging is a great point because, you know, it is very oneoff. Nadler should say by the way i think were lucky that jerry nadler and nancy pelosi are the tip of speer. But they should say were having barr next thursday whether he comes or not. Were having don mcgahn the thursday after that, bob mueller the thursday after that. Just keep it going, not these o oneoff could people could break the momentum. Coming up next, the 2020 candidate who says the race could come down to the economy. My sitdown with John Hickenlooper as a he tries to break out from a very crowd of candidates. Y crowd of candidates were finally back out in our yard, but so are they. Scotts turf builder triple action. It kills weeds, prevents crabgrass and feeds so grass can thrive, guaranteed. Our backyard is back. This is a scotts yard. Hey, who are you . Oh, hey jeff, im a car thief. What . im here to steal your car because, well, thats my job. What . What . . What . laughing what . . What . what . [crash] what . haha, it happens. And if youve got cutrate car insurance, paying for this could feel like getting robbed twice. So get allstate. And be better protected from mayhem. Like me. Or trips to mars. 4. 95. Delivery drones or the latest phones. 4. 95. No matter what you trade, at fidelity its just 4. 95 per online u. S. Equity trade. Toujeo provides significant a1c reduction, and stable blood sugar control, around the clock. Find your groove with toujeo. Lets groove tonight. Toujeo is used to control high blood sugar in adults with diabetes. It contains 3 times as much insulin in 1 milliliter as standard insulin. Dont use toujeo to treat diabetic ketoacidosis, during episodes of low blood sugar, or if youre allergic to insulin. Get medical help right away if you have a serious allergic reaction such as body rash, or trouble breathing. Dont reuse needles, or share insulin pens. The most common side effect is low blood sugar, which can be lifethreatening. It may cause shaking, sweating, fast heartbeat, and blurred vision. Check your blood sugar levels daily. Injection site reactions may occur. Dont change your dose without talking to your doctor. Tell your doctor about all medicines and medical conditions. Check insulin label each time you inject. Taking tzds with insulins may cause Heart Failure that can lead to death. Lets groove tonight. Ask your doctor about toujeo. Today american capitalism has gone wrong. In so many ways. But we can rescue it. Next up, that is the former colorado governor John Hickenlooper making his pitch to New Hampshire voters friday as he makes his way across battleground states. He is polling near the bottom of the nearly two dozen candidates. He is in New Hampshire this weekend meeting with voter, discussing his plan for the which i. I spent friday with the governor. And we talked for a good half hour at buttering jam. You are such an optimist when i listened to you deliver this speech, worry came across time and time again. Help me square the two things. Your optimism about this country and the worry that you feel, that you said you feel about the economy. Im still an optimist. I cant be a successful entrepreneur without being an ocht mis optimist. Persist insience and grit is whe entrepreneur needs. And i see you in the center and a left ward poll. A lot of your opponents are moving more toward the left. Why are you such an ardent believer that there is a space for a centrist right now . How hard is to resist that pull . You know, the bottom line, it is not hard to resist. I came out to colorado as a geologist. I thought id be a geologist my whole life. Commodity prices tanked. I got laid off. And there were no jobs. And government didding in t not retrain me. I had to reinvechts myself and i was lucky. Turned out i was an entrepreneur. I was 100 times better at running restaurants than i ever was as a geologist. So my good fortune. But a lot of people dont have that option, especially nowadays. You made the case that you are worried about the u. S. Economy. You saw the jobs report that came out friday morning, Unemployment Rate we havent seen since 1969. What do you say to an american who says why should i be worried about how things are today. First, after the Great Recession which was the result of george w. Bushs approach which are very similar to Donald Trumps in many ways to get rid of regulation, let capitalism run rampant, we saw what happened in 2007, 2008. Recovering from that Great Recession, it has been almost continuous increase in jobs, dropping in unemployment. I mean the economy has been going great and trump even with a gigantic borrowed tax cut which most of the Companies Used for stock repurchase bs didnt really help the workers, but most of that was to the largest corporations, rich ees richest the country, and even with that, improvement hasnt changed. What was happening is continuing to happen. Id say just because youve got stock market high doesnt mean that the country is any stronger. There is a big debate about whether this primary is about personality or about policy. I look at what you leased oyou friday. A detailed list of what you want do. Is this about policy, is it about personality at this point . Historically american politics has always been about both. There is policy and youve got to know what youre doing. Your policy has to make sense. But in the end, historically most american want to vote for somebody that they want to sit down and have a beer with, right . Why not sit down with the guy who made the beer, right . Seriously. I think there is a level of people vote based on likability as much as they do policy. Is posttrump washington something that can be changed were there to be a democratic president . I learned something, we had the worst flood in the history of the state in 2013 in colorado 13 people were lost. And governor from vermont had had a similar catastrophic flood a couple years before. And he called me while the flood was still happening. And we talked for a little while and i said have you got any advice. He said when you go through the worst that people can imagine, dont promise that you will get it back to where it was. Promise that you will get back to Something Better than what you had before. And i think that when you look at what donald trump has done to our International Relations and 1,000 jobs unfilled in the stapt department rig state department right now, and i was at the Munich Security Conference and people in nato didnt know who to call in the u. S. Government anymore, they have no contact point at all, these are senior diplomats, it is a train wreck. But we were struggling, we had real challenges before. This might be the perfect opportunity to come back and rethink how do we make it better. Just after a Natural Disaster, i think it is fair to say that President Trump is a form of a Natural Disaster in very real way, lets go back to a better place and take the opportunity to rebuild our structures and our framework and get more people together on it. I want to ask you about the timing of this. He is releasing this economic plan a day when trump is trumpeting how great the economy is. Here is a guy looking for his lane. Waiting for his breakout moment. This i guess could have been it. He has a Small Business background. Yet on the day he announces this plan, you get the report that unemployment is as low as it is and the economy at least in that way is doing well. But what you have to say is that unemployment is low, but what are the jobs doing for americans. Are these jobs allowing americans to feed their family, buy a home, build equity. And you also have to remember that the jobs report is a lagging indicator. So what is coming in the future. We know that the white house seems to be scared of what will happen in 2020 to the economy because they keep pressing to keep Interest Rates low. And all these economists are forecasting that the economy could slow down in 2020, 2021, so donald trump doesnt want that to ruin his election or potentially his second term. So this is why he is putting so much pressure on the fed. John hickenlooper is not spli splicing those hairs and he is also not getting into the weed of anticooperate corporatism. He doesnt want to go into that. And i dont think that you can stay in the middle. I think that americans you bring up the financial delay sis, you brought up with george w. Bush did, i come from the world of wall street, i will bring up what wall street did. That was fraud. And nobody went to jail for that and nobody was punished for that. So until you address the fact that we have Corporate America that is a bunch of rent seekers and that we need to change our laws and restructure the way that we think about antitrust and capitalism, you are not going to really speak to the American People. Because they have jobs. Their jobs just arent doing anything for them. He took a stand in the speech that he gave against democratic socialism, against socialist ideals. What do you make of that move . Instead, he is jabbing the left. And there is a compulsion here as you look at the democratic field to embrace some of those issues like medicare for all. Yeah, governor hickenlooper more than anyone has sort of epitomized the inability to get the socialism straight. It was on msnbc where he was asked if he was a capital list and he couldnt bring himself to say yes. He did declare yesterday that im a capitalist as it were. That should be a gimme. Like is he a capitalist. Is your name john. He did start a business and he is pro government and there is a way to say capitalism is part of america. Should we let it run amok, should we let taxes be inverted . Of course not. He is trying to find that lane. And frankly, when i see him running, everyone jokes about, oh, there are 20, 21, 100 different candidates. He is in Public Service for the right reason. Everyone is inputting discussion. If his discussion is wage growth and whether the obama economy is still humming along, then that is great. No harm no foul. But they do sort of ironic these guys are all running to challenge donald trump who says the dumbest things on an hour by hour basis and they are all worried about what they say. Just let it rip. And to your earlier point, Elizabeth Warren who is progressive has no problem saying that she is a capitalist. She knows what she is doing on this topic. And it seems like hickenlooper is still a little confused. Maybe it is because Elizabeth Warren keeps handing out policy papers to americans telling them she has the answers which is great because somebody needs to, but you youve got to be pretty firm on this. And the idea of the republican attack and Everybody Needs to get it right. Well play more of the interview in the next hour, his thoughts on the Mueller Report and the push to impeach president. And tonight Pete Buttigieg will sit down on saturday night politics. And up next, there could be a vote next week to hold him in contempt of congress. Many wondered what happened to bill barr. Several sendicentrist democrats backed his nomination now filled with regret. Stay with us. Hey alright, lets get going and you want to make sure to aim it. Im aiming it. Ohhhhhhh i ordered it for everyone. [laughing] dad vo we got the biggest subaru to help bring our family together. Im just resting my eyes. dad vo even though were generations apart. What a day. I just love those kids. avo presenting the allnew threerow subaru ascent. Wave to grandma, everybody. avo love is now bigger than ever. Going back to the doctor just for a shot. With neulasta onpro. Patients get their day back. To be with. Family. Or just to sleep in. Strong chemo can put you at risk of serious infection. In a key study. Neulasta reduced the risk of infection from 17 . To 1 . A 94 decrease. Neulasta onpro is designed to deliver. Neulasta the day after chemo. And is used by most patients today. Neulasta is for certain Cancer Patients receiving strong chemotherapy. Do not take neulasta if youre allergic to it or Neupogen Filgrastim . An incomplete dose could increase infection risk. Ruptured spleen, sometimes fatal as well as serious lung problems, allergic reactions, kidney injuries and capillary leak syndrome. Have occurred. Report abdominal or shoulder tip pain, trouble breathing. Or allergic reactions to your doctor right away in patients with sickle cell disorders, serious, sometimes. Fatal crises can occur. The most common side effect. Is bone and muscle ache. Ask your doctor. About neulasta onpro. Pay no more than 5 per dose with copay card. Hi, whats this Social Security alert . Its a free alert if we find your Social Security number on the dark web. Good, cuz im a little worried about my information getting out. Whys that . [bird speaking] my social is 8 7 5 dash okay, i see. [bird laughing] somebody thinks its hilarious. Free Social Security alerts from discover. The house, kids, theyre living the dream and here comes the wacky new maid maid . Uh, im not the. Is she an alien, is she a spy . Shes always here, someone tell us why why, oh, why shes not the maid we wanted because im not the maid but shes the maid we got again, im not the maid. I protect your home and auto. Hey, campbells. Whos your new maid . We have a document that shows over 200 connections between a president ial campaign and foreign adversary. Sharing information that would be legal if you did it with a super pac, we know that what information was shared . Polling data was shared, sir. It is in the report. I can cite you the page. Bill barr questioned about the contents of the mueller and that the Trump Campaign shared polling data with a man linked to russian intelligence. Barr saying he had not reviewed the underlying evidence that mueller relied on. In the huff post, barrs Mueller Report testimony has everyone wondered what happened to him. The man that many previously viewed him as an institutionalist is facing calls for resignation from democrats who see him as little more than Donald Trumps coverup man. Matt miller in that article telling the you author the evidence was sort of staring us in the face that he got picked to land the plane for the president and he did. Ryan rhyme riley for huff post joining us. A great piece. And as you note, it took just 76 days for this metamorphosis to happen. What is your sense of what happened . Yeah, i mean it is sort of like line up with what the washington legal establishment has gone through. There are certainly some republicans saying this is bad the way barr a has been handling this, but a lot of people have just been going along with this and been com police it complici is handling this. And this is something that weve seen with many people around donald trump. I think he said he eats your soul was the kicker of that piece. Your sense of what happened. You heard the calls from people who have known bill barr, who have made that argument that he had been attorney general, he had respected reverence for the institution and were fairly comfortable with him being in that position again. Garbage, garbage. It was crap when it was said and crap today. The only power that he answers to is the fact that there is power and they want to keep it. This man wrote a memo to audition for this job arguing that the president couldnt be indicted, that the president enjoyed unfettered executive power. What did we expect . All these people who thought he was an institutionalist, garbage, garbage, garbage. And ned, were you one among them, your thoughts on what he said about the fbi during that testimony. I think that there is a misimpression that bill barr leveled only one lie before congress. You look at his record over the past six weeks or so, and you see a series of lies that i think point to that very point. It was all garbage. He said that muellers decision was left up to him and that is why he took that on. He said that mueller hes decision had nothing to do with the underlying olc opinion. He claimed that the white house fully cooperated with the probe which we know donald trump refused to speak to investigators. And he repeated this term no collusion, no cluks, ollusion, cluks, wh collusion, when the report made clear that it didnt examine the issue of collusion. I think what is so striking in that exchange you showed with cory booker, bill barr made the point he didnt read the underlying evidence. It seems that he habit enread the report. He did not know a key point in the report that Paul Manafort shared this polling data with konstanin kilimnick. How can you be surprised by that when you were rendering the judgment on that very report. And what are you hearing about why bill barr took this job . He was in the private sector, was beckoned back into government to do this. And you heard mike lee praising the long time Public Servant here. He was in the private sector, he had left Public Service. Why did he decide to come back, why did he decide it take up this mantle in. I think that is a good question because there are reports about him having discusseses with friends about how tough of a job this would have been to get back into. There were certainly issues in his previous tenure at attorney general, but i think overall his reputation, like we said, semi retired, in this position where he could have just gone out easily. And now this is going to completely rewrite history on barr. He will be seen sort of as this guy who was just there for donald trump. His rep pew takiu donald trump. His rep pew takitation i think major hits. And there are moderate democrats who backed him. Joe manchin. From the state of my birth. Is that right . Yeah. Fun fact about me. It is the mouse state. I mean there are a lot of democrats who were like this is a guy who has served before, he looks like a good guy, well just ignore as a woman and as a brown person and west virginiian. And west virginiian, it seemed like they were supporting someone who looked like them, sounded like them, they had seen before. And hhad not distinguished hf well in the prior outing. No, not at all. And there is an amazing faith in washington for other people in washington that they feel like they have known for years. But the game has changed. So you need to look for different players. And we were joking with who has actually read the Mueller Report in the last segment. But how about this 19 page memo. When you talked to senators, are they looking at that on a different light, this unsolicited memo that bill barr then private citizen wrote to the attorney general . Yeah, that was strange to write that memo basically laying this out and apply turning it over to Rod Rosenstein during some sort of lunch he had with him when he was sort of in private practice. It was very strange and i think that that is obviously sort of a glaring sign now that he really didnt believe in the obstruction of justice investigation. And i think it is clear from his testimony that he sort of was focused on the volume two, that obstruction part of the Mueller Probe rather than volume one which lays out this extensive campaign. Because he didnt really know the details. He was sort of fighting back and forth with the senators about some very basic details of volume one. And i think that is what reporters did initially when this report came out is sort of jump to volume two with the obstruction part and then come back to volume one. But that volume one, you have to read it, it is really important stuff that lays out this entire campaign and was really a major part of the mueller. Thank you very much for joining us. Lowest unemployment figure since 1969, but you might have missed it after the president trampled over what would have been a strong messaging day. Why the white house says they are, quote, killing it. E, quotet its the easiest because its the cheesiest. Kraft for the win win. Thanks to priceline working with top airlines to turn their unsold seats into amazing deals, Family Reunion attendance is up. Were all related yeah, i see it. And because priceline offers great deals by comparing thousands of prices in real time, sports fans are seeing more away games. Various yeahhh is that safe . Oh, y. Ahh not at all. No, maam. Nope. And more people than ever are enjoying romantic getaways. romantic music thats gross priceline. Every trip is a big deal. Rheumatoid arthritis or Psoriatic Arthritis. When considering another treatment, ask about xeljanz xr, a oncedaily pill for adults with moderate to severe Rheumatoid Arthritis or active Psoriatic Arthritis for whom methotrexate did not work well enough. It can reduce pain, swelling, and significantly improve physical function. Xeljanz xr can lower your ability to fight infections, including tuberculosis. Serious, sometimes fatal infections and cancers, including lymphoma, have happened. As have tears in the stomach or intestines, serious allergic reactions, low blood cell counts, higher liver tests and cholesterol levels. Dont start xeljanz xr if you have an infection. Your doctor should perform blood tests before and while taking xeljanz xr, and monitor certain liver tests. Tell your doctor if youve been somewhere fungal infections are common and if you have had tb, hepatitis b or c, or are prone to infections. Dont let another morning go by without asking your doctor about xeljanz xr. Jobs, high wages, big consumer confidence, major productivity, and no inflation. Its totally awesome. Were killing it on the economy. Bill shon may be gone but his legacy lives on at the white house. The white house tweeting that video of an exuberant larry kudlow, the president s top economic adviser hours after the release of the latest jobs report. These are the headlines, 263,000 jobs created in april, 80,000 more than economists expected. Unemployment at 3. 6 . Are those numbers the entire story. This caught me by surprise, releasing this press release, so proud of the numbers yet she gets them wrong and says 283,000 jobs were created. This is emblematic. This administrations press releases, im trying to keep my brain agile. So okay. That is a great jobs number, wonderful, the devil is in the details, a lot of people left the work force. That was the only sad thing, lower Labor Force Participation but again, why is the white house trying to keep Interest Rates low if they really believe the economy is doing this well, and the answer is the jobs number is just one indicator of whats happening in the economy. We have seen a softer housing market, we have seen other, you know, grumblings in the economy that are telling us things might not be okay and so the white house is looking at that, theyre looking at the rest of the world, trying to just kind of put a bandaid over its Bullet Wounds and kept running. Now we here in the United States are looking at the world, were looking at our own economy and saying, okay, a slow down could very well be coming and the white house is trying to talk out of two sides of its mouth saying everything is going great. Were amazing, we are taking all the credit for this. By the way, though, we should keep Interest Rates low because we want the party to continue. And, you know, everybody else in Financial Markets is like that could be a bad idea. Lets spend a few moments talking about expertise. We saw the whole debate over the fed nominees and there was an amaze piece in the hill herman cain writing the disgraceful attack of moore is proving what trump knew, the political liberal establishment will protect the Federal Reserve from the growth hawks, but as demonstrated, trump is not afraid to take on the washington swamp, the president will appoint someone else as his growth hawk at the Federal Reserve, perhaps someone like herman cain. I love this notion of steven moore, a guy who has inhabited the Heritage Foundation for two, three decades. What is the growth hawk . I would love to know. Rare breed. I think herman cain sells pizzas, i dont understand what hes saying in that. Theres so much that disqualifies steven moore, more than just his crank views. The beauty is nominating them both at the same time. Thats beyond i mean, i knew herman cain wasnt qualified. I knew herman cain no, i didnt know herman cain, i went on fox against her maman cain, was sitting there thinking, if youre on with me, you should not be on the board of the Federal Reserves. I have been on cnn with steven moore, and he is a partisan hack who knows very very little about the economy and has made it very clear that he is here to do the bidding of rich republicans who want their, you know, political thoughts and economic thoughts out there. He comes out fine from all of this. He has been able to be on tv, as an economist. I go on up with david, i dont know what theyre talking about. I think steven moore is just like donald trump. Steven moore wants air time. Steven moore wants his name out there. I have repeated it twice already, and thats giving him more than he deserves. When you talk about character assassination, steven moore is the person who wrote these things. No one else wrote them and put them in his nobody asked him not to pay child support. You could have said ten minutes after they were each nominated they werent going to make it, and that was like a month ago. Lets tie this all back together from what John Hickenlooper told me, he can go toe to toe on the economy, we heard linette talk about the cold water, is that where the election is going to be won or lost on the issue of the u. S. Economy . I think these are bread and butter issues, Kitchen Table issues that voters care a lot about. Thats going to be a big part of this. I also think this election is going to be about, i hope the trust the American People feel in their government, and if that is on the table, then i think its a much harder road for the Trump Administration. If its just about the economy, yes, its a great economy. History suggests its not going to be a great economy for much longer. This is almost the longest economic upside we have seen in a while. Are you saying it started before donald trump . Well, i mean, thank you, president obama. Thank you so much, president obama. I know were not supposed to think about what happened before donald trump. There was a time. If the economy is going to be the most important thing in the election, Donald Trumps Approval Rating should be higher than it is, but its not, and people are very scared about the direction the country is going. Its the ball game for them. Which is why theyre lying about numbers. Thank you all very much. Ned price, linette lopez, joining us tomorrow, a lot of great guests, kurt brabella, berit berger. Today the newly ignited controversy, the latest chapter in the saga that is transformation of senator Lindsey Graham, and John Hickenlooper on everything from impeachment to bill barr. Thats next. Rom impeachment to bill barr thats next. Es . Ive always had a knack for finding things. Colon cancer, to be exact. And i find it noninvasively. No need for time off or special prep. It all starts here. You collect your sample, and cologuard uses the dna in your stool to find 92 of colon cancers. You can always count on me to know where to look. Oh, i found them i can do this test now ask your doctor if cologuard is right for you. Covered by medicare and most major insurers. You get the freedom of what a 7day return policy. This isnt some dealership test drive around the block. Its better. This is seven days to put your carvana car to the test and see if it fits your life. Load it up with a weeks worth of groceries. Take the kiddos out for ice cream. Check that it has enough wiggle room in your garage. You get the time to make sure you love it. And on the 6th day, well reach out and make sure everythings amazing. If so. Excellent. If not, swap it out for another or return it for a refund. Its that simple. Because at carvana, your car happiness is what makes us happy. Im david gura we start the hour with controversy President Trump ignited with his hour long fool with Vladimir Putin. Now we get tweets from the president , quote, had a long and very good conversation with president putin. We discussed trade, venezuela, ukraine, north korea, Nuclear Arms Control and even the russian hoax, very productive talk. But there is one topic the two men did not discuss that is drawing scrutiny. Did you address the election meddling issues. We discussed it. He actually sort of smiled when he said something to the effect that it started off as a mountain and ended up being a mouse but he knew that because he knew there was no collusion whatsoever. As President Trump celebrated one more no collusion victory lap this time in the company of president putin, its worth revisiting Robert Muellers report. The investigation did not establish members of the Trump Campaign conspired or coordinated with the russian government in its election interference activities, it reads but it did establish this key fact on page one of that report. The russian government interfered in the 2016 election in sweeping and systematic fashion, an assessment that even his staunch ally and supporter, senator Lindsey Graham emphasized in a rare rebuke of his pal the president , on wednesday. I would like to do more to harden our infrastructure because the russians did it, it wasnt some 400 pound guy sitting on a bed somewhere. It was the russians. And theyre still doing it. As putin smiled or chuckled or laughed, President Trump bristled as reporters continued to press him on the issue in the oval office. Mr. President did you tell him not to meddle in the next election. Excuse me, im talking, im answering this question. You are very rude. Did you tell him not to meddle in the next election . We didnt discuss that. The question came up the day before when President Trump sat down with fox news and asked if President Trump warned president putin to back off in interfering in 2020. I dont think i have spoken about the 2020 but i certainly have told him you cant do what youre doing, and i dont believe they will be. Have you been very firm with the russian president on that point. President trump has held firm on election interference. The russians did agree with President Trumps assessment of the phone call he initiated yesterday. The two heads of state expressed satisfaction with the business like and constructive nature of the conversation. Thats according to the kremlin. As david graham writes in the atlantic, it is helsinki all over again. Quote, he still refuses to acknowledge russian interference or do anything else about it, but dont expect this reprize to elicit the same reaction whereas trumps refusal to defend was once shocking, it has now become expected. Susan del percio, republican strategist. Tim obrien is executive editor and msnbc contributor. Glen kirchner a former prosecutor, now legal analyst. Let me start with you and him making this phone call, President Trump saying that he did this. His goal, the message, what he was trying to communicate by placing that phone call and have this hour long, its a long conversation. I think to begin with, he was spiking the football in the end zone. I think he was saying i have gotten through this event and im going to put it in everyones face, and im going to call Vladimir Putin and talk to him about whatever i want. He did the same thing after he fired joe fired james comey. And gloated. I think the larger issue is he clearly doesnt care about National Security and he doesnt care act protecting the 2020 elections from russian interference, and why is that . Either he doesnt care or he knows he would benefit in 2020 from russian interference. Either one of those isnt a good answer. I think secondly when you move beyond the elections themselves, what he is doing is opening a door to putin to flagrantly think about saber rattling in eastern europe, you know, remember russia moving into crimea was spurred along by the fact that he resented nato inviting ukraine into a membership there. And all of the states have been concerned. Sweden is worried about that. Thats why putin has been interfering in swedens elections. I think what he has done goes beyond what trump has done, beyond the u. S. Elections, hes allowing putin to have this sense of himself on the world stage that is going to be unfettered and unchecked by the u. S. Military, the u. S. National security apparatus, and good faith, and i think thats problematic. And putin loves that, by the way. Putin loves that because he is weak domestically and every time he can look like he is standing with the president of the United States and looking his equal, to add that he had met with kim jong un, and then was relaying messages, now all of a sudden you have two of the worst dictators out there basically getting recognized and being seen on even ground with the president of the United States. And i think to tims point, it goes to the president just doesnt care or respect what it means to be president of the United States of america. He doesnt care about its citizens, he only cares about himself. Alexa, i made a joke about the fact we used to get read outs and now we get tweets. It raises two serious issues, its another conversation that we have no sense or no record of what the two of them talked about, at least not one thats at all publicly digestible. The second is when you got a read out in the past, the past administration, it was an opportunity for the administration to say what they disagreed about and safe to say when it comes to venezuela, when it comes to ukraine as tim brought up, there are a lot of things the u. S. Could have pushed back on the readout that would have been useful internationally. And thats whats so interesting to tims point about sort of how President Trump may be validating president putin on a larger global scale. The u. S. And president putin are at odds on venezuela because they dont want the u. S. Interfering in that election, and on north korea because they want us to continue to lift sanctions on north korea and to my understanding, that is not what we are doing, and that is not what we want, and a readout from the white house like you were saying we previously got would have been a helpful thing for them to paint the narrative about how President Trump is pushing back on these things that we are very much involved in, and that we are very much following that president putin want that is we dont want. When President Trump was running for president , all had e talked about was easing the relationship between the u. S. And russia and we are seeing in the lack of readouts and in the hour long phone calls and in the way he talks about president putin or at the g20 summit, leaves out note takers, he wants to handle this on his own as the kremlin calls it in a business like manner bat at the end of the day, donald trump is a businessman who wheels and deals in personalities over politics and that speaks to the lack of readouts, because he wants to fix it alone, and hes doing that in these interpersonal ways rather than a political way. How dispirted are you, joining a chorus of people saying this is a problem, its going to be a problem as we approach the next election. This isnt a partisan issue. The Intelligence Community dwredwree agrees on, and agrees on, and the president continues not just to ignore it and full count it. Can i go hyperbolic this morning. This is another reason impeachment hearings should have opened weeks ago. We just saw the president of the United States tell the American People, i shared a laugh with Vladimir Putin over essentially what bob mueller found to be sweeping systematic interference in our elections. He smiled or he giggled or guffawed, whatever he did. Think about the implications. Hes telling Vladimir Putin, keep it up, 2020 is coming, ill be up for reelection, not only is he not trying to deter it, hes encouraging it so 2020, if he is still with us, he could be reelected with russias help. Lets look forward to 2024, though, what does it mean for 2024, if we are unfortunate enough to have trump for another four years, who might russia support in 2024 . Lindsey graham, i dont know, jim jordan, maybe steve king or should we cut right to david duke because this is the tone the president is setting. Hes welcoming and encouraging russian interference in our elections. The time is now. Tim, what does a john bolton say monday morning when he walks in the oval office after this phone call took place, after what we saw with north korea overnight, he, mike pompey yoer pompeo, how can they possibly react . I dont want to go as far as how do they continue doing their jobs, but maybe thats the question. And i think thats the trick for anybody working in the Trump Administration is if you are a principled person with a velocity on how the world works and you have a set of values and a skill set you bring to your job, do you walk into the oval office and speak your mind, and talk in a sensible way about what u. S. Policy looks like or do you think about the fact that trump puts people on the plank every day. If you speak your mind and have a difference with the president , hes likely to nuke you. I think if youre john bolton you probably try to leverage this through Jared Kushner or you probably try to find these end runs to get the president s ear. You know full well if you go right into the president s face, he will probably stop talking to you. The problem with donald trump as a manager is he doesnt authentically recruit topnotch people who he empowers to speak their mind because hes not intellectually sophisticated, so he breeds this environment of insecurity around him. I think that pompeo, and bolten have made their own beds. They chose to join this administration, but if they thought they were going to be able to enact or see their values in the world through donald trump theyre going to be sorely mistaken. I want to get everyone up to speed on a story that broke overnight. A 737 sliding off a runway into a river. This is a live look at the plane in the st. Johns river. All 143 people aboard Miami Air International flight survived. 21 were sent to local hospitals. None with critical injuries. That plane was flying from Guantanamo Bay in Stormy Weather last night. The ntsb is investigating. Well stay on that story over the course of the day. He called donald trump a bigot, crazy and unfit for office two years ago and now heaping praise on the president at every turn. The curious case of Lindsey Graham, next. Frgz the curious case of Lindsey Graham, next frgz next. Next heres one you guys will like. Show me making it. Oh i got one. The best of amy poehler. Amy, maybe we could use the voice remote to search for something that youre not in. Show me parks and rec. From netflix to prime video to live tv, xfinity lets you find your favorites with the Emmy Awardwinning x1 voice remote. Show me the best of amy poehler, again. This time around. Now thats simple, easy, awesome. Experience the entertainment you love on x1. Access netflix, prime video, youtube and more, all with the sound of your voice. Click, call or visit a store today. Republican senator Lindsey Graham has changed his mind, ended up inviting Robert Mueller to testify before the Senate Judiciary committee, asking whether he would like to comment on any of attorney generals bill barrs characterizations. Senator graham has been one of the president s most vigorous defenders. We saw that this week when bill barr testified. Graham made numerous false and misleading statements about the russia investigation including this claim on obstruction of justice. As to obstruction of justice, mr. Mueller left it to mr. Barr to decide. He said, mr. Barr, you decide. Thats false. Robert mueller said it should be handled by congress, not bill barr. He said there were zero instances of trump impeding mueller that is false. We know the president did try to have him removed. And the senator contradicting himself when it comes to subpoenaing the president. Listen to him speak about democrats versus his comments in the late 1990s during the clinton impeachment. Our congressional subpoenas optional . No, no, you go into court and you fight it out. You just cant subpoena a person because youre a member of congress. You cant ask for a persons tax returns because you want them. You got to have a reason. Richard nixon as president failed to comply with subpoenas of congress. The day Richard Nixon failed to answer to that subpoena is the day that he was subject to impeachment because he took the power from congress. Lets take a moment to note how much of senator grahams feelings about the president have changed. Heres what he said during the 2016 president ial campaign. Hes an op portunist. Hes a race baiting, sooe knxen bigot. He doesnt represent my party. I think hes crazy. I think hes unfit for office. I want to turn to the panel in a second. First let me go to this great political cartoon of the Atlanta Journal institution here looking at President Trump doing some wall building as mike put it there, as he puts bill barr on the top of so many others. Susan, let me start with you, and lets talk about that transformation. We talked about bill barrs transformation that we witnessed in the hearing room this week. What do you make of the way senator grahams tact toward the president has changed. I used to think senator graham was a man of integrity, and had strong core republican values. It is clear that he never had it and basically fooled all of us. You cant go dfrom one position in 2016 to where he is today and a lot of politicians are on both sides of the aisle, he was concerned about a primary. He saw what happened to his former colleague mark sanford in south carolina, and knew if he got on the wrong side of the president he would be facing a primary. That shows besides having no core values, hes a coward. You watched the hearing im sure, and was supposed to be in headline about the Mueller Report and very quickly from the Opening Statement that the chairman of the committee Lindsey Graham gave, it became focussed on the former secretary of state, hillary clinton, about her emails again. I cant help but laugh. Dont you think it has never ended. Its just another example of how Lindsey Graham has become this trump acolyte, this person who will stand by his side no matter what and go out of his way to defend him. To me, its not that surprising if you read the profile that i believe mark did with the daily times in feb or listen to the podcast. Its incredible about what he claims Nothing Happened to him. What he reveals he is concerned with relevant and staying relevant, in which donald trump is the king maker of many things, and explained that politics to him is figuring out what works and what brings your desired outcomes ch one of senator grahams greatest outcomes or interests is getting reelected for a fourth term in south carolina, and he knows that President Trump is the king mak maker especially over republican primaries in any number of races as we saw in the 2018 midterm elections. If he makes it through the primaries and getting reelected during the general. That is something that is weighing heavily on him, and the idea of staying relevant at a time when everyone else could turn against the president or watching fellow republican colleagues coalesce, he has made the decision, susan characterizes, cowardly to do Everything Possible to stay relevant, and not anything else. I want to get your perspective on how this change is taking place. The transformation has taken place in the heart building, the kavanaugh hearings and saw his explosion after that lunch recess, and then at the beginning of this hearing you see him quoting liberally and out of context between the text exchanges between two fbi agents and dropping the f bomb in the course of doing that. There has been, he went back to the james comey piece that he wrote for the New York Times this week, hes taken on some of what the president offers when it comes to personality, hasnt he . He becomes a kind of a prism under what happens to people who exist closely to donald trump. Do they maintain a sense of themselves and their own values. We got into this earlier with the Pompeo Bolton discussion. I think alexi put her finger on something, Lindsey Graham is worried about not being relevant, and thats one of the broader longterm dangers of donald trump, he has polluted the national and civic dialogues are what are politics, do you talk in a fact free existence thats laced with just opposition, and partisan divisions and isnt about achieving results and hes clearly throwing his hat in with that. He has other options. Jim mattis showed us what some of the other options are. You can say i will be part of this agenda if i can enact my values in the world and if i cant, i will leave. I didnt agree with jim comeys perspective on barr that bill barr suddenly got bent. Bill barr has been doing what bill barr has been doing for decades. He did it for george h. W. Bush during the iran contra investigation. He has tried to neuter the congress when it comes to executive oversight. I was going to ask, you have covered the president so long, is it the people that they become these sycophants or are they weak individuals that he knows how to prey on to bring into the administration. Its both. If youre hitching your way into Donald Trumps star, what do you want out of that . If youre somebody whos a nobody, and theres a lot of them, or if youre a third tier talent and theres a lot of them in the white house, youre getting your resume stamped. If youre somebody who wants to get an agenda, Mitch Mcconnell has held his nose because he can get the courts packed. Lindsey graham is holding his nose for multiple reasons, he lacks a spine, he didnt stand up for john mccain, and i think he wants to stay relevant. St it also power, and i want to get your reaction to what happened at the end of the hearing, he leaves and tells reporters, its over. His intention was not to call bob mueller before the committee. You have seen the letter he wrote to the attorney general and bob mueller saying that he could come and testify. What do you make of that, the power hes harnessing for this. Its all about power. We have seen the amazing shrinking senator, Lindsey Graham, and you know, as a fed for 30 years, i labored under the hatch act so i was never political and it wasnt the person i was. I got to vote. Beyond that, maybe we can put a Bumper Sticker on our car as a federal Government Employee but were not allowed to participate in campaigning and really in the political process beyond voting, so maybe i was and remain naive because i talk to people, and im like, well, it doesnt seem to be about ideology because trump doesnt really have any principled ideology about anything. What in the world is driving these people . How could Lindsey Graham one day say trump is a cook, hes crazy, completely unfit to be president , and Lindsey Graham stands skpup and says thats my man. I dont think its power as much as fear. If it was power, you wouldnt have mcconnell and ryan abdicating their power to the president and more or less afraid of getting tweeted, you know, president tweeting at them or having their legs cut out from underneath them. I think its fear of losing power. So i think all goes back to power. Why would they abdicate that power . Because they want to keep it in the long run. They want to get reelected at any cost, ideology be dammed, principles be dammed. Thats the only thing they can say one thing on one tape, and another thing one day, and sleep with themselves because they want to retain that power. It reminds me of Michael Cohens testimony, being around trump is intoxicating. Thats a great way of this phenomenon, whether its inspired by wanting power or fear, theres a sense of intoxication that some people get, especially republicans in congress being around someone like donald trump, and thats what were seeing with Lindsey Graham. The foursome when the president goes out to golf. We head to New Hampshire to check up with 2020 contender John Hickenlooper as the former governor tries to set himself apart. Hes willing to give up a shot at another elected office to do it. Are you weighing at all running for senate if this doesnt work out . Senate would be meaningful, but i hate it. Meaningful, but i hate it. This is the story of john smith. Not this john smith. Or this john smith. Or any of the other hundreds of john smiths that are humana Medicare Advantage members. No, its this john smith. Who we paired with a humana team member to help address his own specific health needs. At humana, we take a personal approach to your health, to provide care thats just as unique as you are. No matter what your name is. With uncontrolled moderatetosevere eczema,n who got an awful skin condition. Or atopic dermatitis, you feel like youre itching all the time. And you never know how your skin will look. Because deep within your skin an overly sensitive immune system could be the cause. So help heal your skin from within, with dupixent. Dupixent is not a steroid, and it continuously treats your eczema even when you cant see it. At 16 weeks, nearly four times more patients taking dupixent saw clear or almost clear skin compared to those not taking it, and patients saw a significant reduction in itch. Do not use if you are allergic to dupixent. Serious allergic reactions can occur, including anaphylaxis, a severe reaction. Tell your doctor if you have new or worsening eye problems, including eye pain or changes in vision. If you are taking asthma medicines, do not change or stop your asthma medicine without talking to your doctor. Help heal your skin from within. Ask your eczema specialist about dupixent. Today, lifechanging technology from abbott is helping hunt them down at their source. Because the faster we can identify new viruses, the faster we can get to stopping them. The most personal technology, is technology with the power to change your life. Life. To the fullest. Welcome back to up, im david gura, John Hickenlooper, is in New Hampshire this week, and i spent some time following him around on friday. He released the campaigns economic plan and fielded questions from voters about a number of issues including the Mueller Report and impeachment. Topics i returned to sitting down with the candidate in a diner in nashua at the end of the day. A big discussion about what should happen to the attorney general and the testimony he gave on capitol hill. You mean what should happen after hes fired . My question is are you among those calling for his removal at this point . You know ir, i usually try t restrain those kinds of bleacher seat commentary, but you know, he is clearly not representing the American People. And that is his primary responsibility. I understand hes appointed by the president , i understand theres a relationship, but if you go back and look at what happened around watergate and there are any number of documentaries to watch these days on cable on all of the streaming media, i mean, clearly rule by law, where the attorney general has to be, i mean, Archibald Cox stood up and he was responsible to the American People, not to president nixon, and we should expect no less of our attorney general today. Nancy pelosi on friday said impeachment is not off the table, as you sit here looking ahead to the election, do you think it should be . Is there a point at which the window closes and your message would be lets focus on 2020, lets stop talking about impeachment or do you think its something that should stay on the table . Certainly so far were still getting information. The letter that came out this week that Robert Mueller wrote saying you have mischaracterized my entire report, thats an interesting new piece of information. Lets see the unredacted report, why is that at least congress should get to see it. Why cant the American People see it . Why cant we get mr. Mueller to testify before congress . Can we get the attorney general to testify again before congress . You talk a lot about your experience as an executive, as a mayor, as a governor, one of your proposals is to make a new federal minimum wage, make it 15 an hour, but scale to cost of living around the country as well. You have worked with other mayors in the past, as governor worked with mayors, what gives you optimism that were you to be elected president , you would be able to do whats so difficult this day and age, thats to work with the legislative branch, in other words, it seems so intractable, how do you propose to change that . Every thinks, we are not running for president , we are in a crisis of tradition. We are more divided than we have been since the civil war, and you know, its keeping us from addressing things like Climate Change or automation, artificial intelligence, what thats going to do to the workplace, and i feel ive got that track record that everyone said was impossible, that that track record of bringing people together. When i ran for mayor, and i was at 4 for the first seven weeks. No one thought i had never run for Student Council or anything, and suddenly here i was, i broke out, i was ahead and people said just because you got elected you preach youre going to work with the suburban mayors, most are republicans, denver hates them, i went out and talked to the suburban mayors, we got all 34 mayors, 2 3 of them republicans or conservative independents, we got all 34 mayors to unanimously support fast tracks, 122 miles of new track. Thats the only place in the country where we had, you know, a regional effort like that for something that mattered. You mentioned your early polling when you were running for mayor, i imagine youre aware of your polling now. Its almost identical. I started out at 3 for the first couple of weeks and then i got up to 4 . Thats where i stayed until i broke out. You know, i feel im different than any of the other candidates running. Ive run a business. I was out of work for two years, i know what that means. I have put together some really successful teams both as a Small Business person and as a mayor and a governor and we have been able to achieve things that people thought were impossible. Are you weighing it all running for senate if this doesnt work out . Its awful hard to imagine that i could be successful in a Senate Campaign or as a senator. What i love and what im willing to sacrifice, you know, i have been a Public Servant for 16 years, thats 70 hours a week, i cant imagine a week when i didnt work at least 65 hours, and i love it. You know, im not complaining u but im putting teams together. Im attracting the most talented people, and i dont care whether theyre republicans or democrats, tall or short, where they came from, business people, academics, nonprofits we put teams together and we decide to chae achieve the unachievable and i hold them accountable. I love that. Find that spiritually transforming. A senator doesnt get to do that. A senator has to go to washington, and its vitally important what they do, to debate, and try to improve the laws that govern this country is some of the most important work you can do, but it wouldnt bring me any kind of satisfaction or delight, and lifes too short. Im willing to sacrifice a huge amount of my private life because i lowe what im doing, and i feel its really meaningful. Being a senator would be meaningful, but id hate it. Thats a no, you wouldnt consider it. Its hard to imagine. I want to start with you, lets go back to the top of the clip we played there. There was a moment, we went to the stony field farms yogurt factory, and a woman stood up, it was more of a statement than a question. I want you to take the gloves off. When it docomes to Donald Trumpi want you to take the gloves off. You heard the first answer about impeachment, bill barr, hes not attacking donald trump head on. We are seeing that with a lot of candidates, how emblematic of what we saw from John Hickenlooper. You talked to him about carving out a centrist lane for himself, and i think avoiding attacking donald trump is a way that hes going to continue billing himself as this bipartisan human who can address this crisis of division as he referred to the state of the country. So im not surprised that hes not willing to sort of take the gloves off as that woman asked to fight against donald trump. He doesnt see that as his path forward. When i saw him in iowa, he was in one of the most republican counties in the state, look, theres a lot of things President Trump has done that i dont necessarily disagree with, talking about Different Things with trade and tariffs, but he was like, you know, the way hes handled it, i dont agree with that. And i think thats how hes going to try to carve out a space for himself. I talk to voters all the time who are like democrats are too soft. Theyre going to get bullied on the debate stage. I want someone whos going to fight back. For the democrats that leaves a question of do we stoop to his level or find a way to fight back thats both smart and clearly showing to voters a way toward for the country thats not necessarily just against donald trump. Something struck me as surprising, i have heard a lot of people say, when you get out of washington and new york, people arent talking about the russia investigation, a keen interest in the Mueller Report. I was surprised by how many people did want to talk about the process of impeachment or donald trump. Talk about how they are distinct. I took as youre not interested in the granular part of the mueller investigation, now theres this thing you can get your arms around, Donald Trumps presence in the oval office. And we saw in 2018, people have had it with a donald trump, and they dont like the way, even if they like some of his policies, they dont like the way he conducts himself as president of the United States, so they are against him, and if there is something and they do believe theres certain things he has done wrong. Theres no doubt, so if theres a way of punishing him, thats ha they want. They want to see that, and understanding why you would have the articles of impeachment is a little dicey. There is something to be said with the democrats message out of washington. Lets not forget, for the last six weeks, weve heard from Speaker Pelosi, lets wait, lets see, i dont think hes worth it. There hasnt been a Strong Enough message, but people are angry, and frustrated and as much as were in a good economy right now, theyre not feeling it. And while they want someone to just fight for them, they want someone to also represent them, so if its not hickenloopers way to fight, you cant make him a fighter, nor should you. But let him go forward with his ideas on how he can improve your quality of life and show that he cares about your values. Last question to you, i want to ask you about policy incubation, he gives a speech on the economy is a press gaggle to the side. He admits that all the candidates are looking at proposals and borrowing a bit from them. You look at his economic proposal. Theres a big antitrust component, something senator klobuchar and warren have talked about. Minimum wage is something other candidates have talked about. He drew a line when it came to medicare for all. How does that play out over the next six, nine months, the way they borrow from each other. How difficult is it to distinguish yourself and look at what others are doing. I wouldnt discount how shrewd voters can be when they want answers to their problems, and theres a lot of americans who are worried about health care. Theres a lot of americans who are worried about their jobs and their futures and i think they will start to separate these candidates out around how much they can actually articulate a policy driven response to their problems. I think the sort of fading of beto and the emergence of buttigieg, i think one of the things that distinguishes those two people is that buttigieg tends to have very thoughtful policy driven answers, and beto didnt. And i think that voters will be turned on by the new for a little while. If the rubber doesnt meet the road, i think theyll turn away from you. Since theres no shortage of candidates, mayor Pete Buttigieg sits down with Donny Deutsch with saturday night politics, debuting at 8 00 p. M. Eastern time on msnbc, and coming up here on up, President Trump compares the border to disneyland, new details in the exclusive reporting after the growing list of reasons why a Statement Like that is so far from true. T like that is so far from true. Hmm. Exactly. Liberty mutual customizes your car insurance, so you only pay for what you need. Nice. But, uh. Whats up with your. Partner . Not again. Limu thats your reflection. Only pay for what you need. Liberty, liberty, liberty, liberty welcome back, a new nbc news exclusive report reveals the Trump Administration has no clear prose for reuniting children separated from their parents at the u. S. Mexico border. My colleagues show emails privately admitting the government had information to reconnect 60 parents with their kids. Almost 3,000 were separated under the zero tolerance policy. The same day nbc news published that exclusive, the Trump Administration requested 4. 5 billion in emergency funding for managing the influx of refugees and family units at the southern border. The acting director of the omb wrote a letter to the president of the senate, thats Vice President mike pence, with a break down of the funding request. The administration specifically asking for 3. 3 billion for humanitarian assistance. Another 1. 1 billion for Border Operations like detention beds and finally, 178 million for missions support. The letter then goes on to state that the unaccompanied alien Minor Program could run out of resources by june. Meanwhile, cbs news reporting former white house chaff john kelly has joined the board of caliber international, that company is the largest operator of shelters for unaccompanied migrant children. Let me start with you and get to this john kelly news in a moment. This request, what does it signal . This was not money for wall as the administration says. What is what shift does that signal to you . It shifts that they are potential think thinking about ways to address the so called humanitarian crisis that i think donald trump and his administration has created by not addressing these problems sooner and i think thats fair to say because the whole time the Immigration Reform that President Trump and his administration has been proposing is a border wall, simply a border wall, and that is to keep people out. That is not to address the crisis and the climate and the situation that people find themselves in when they cross the border or they are being separated from their parents and so i think that it signals a shift that, look, a border wall is not going to make things better. Its not going to solve this crisis. Does he want a border wall . Certainly. Does he know hes not going to get money for a border wall with House Democrats in control, yes. Democrats are going to be understandably nervous about giving him any sort of money when like i said, he created the problem himself. Under the egress of crisis, there are crises, the humanitarian one and a judicial one, theres an understaffed judiciary incapable of dealing with all they have to deal with on the border. And with kelly profiting off the detention of migrant children, you just shake your head. Im not sure which circle of held he belongs in for that he wil hell he broelongs in for that. Whether its the department of justice, homeland security, theyre in a tough spot. Most of them, like i said, 115,000 employees at the department of justice, 98 of them, good, hard working, doing the work of the American People, trying to keep us safe. Thats what they do. Homeland security is the same. Judiciary is the same. They have such an impossible decision to make. Do i stay there and remain part of the machinery carrying out trumps plans or do i stand up and be a jim mattis or quite frankly, a Chuck Rosenberg when he stepped down as director of the dea when he could not buy into the president s policies. My heart breaks for them, and i think theyre all making their own calls. Look, they have to put food on the table, thats important. I understand. But at what point when people are ordered, okay, lets start to put up the concentration wire, the razor wire around the areas where were going to now detain migrant children. At what point do they say im done. Susan, as we look backward and forward, you look back, they didnt have what they said they had, they lied about that, that they had the ability to pair these children with their families, looking forward, what plan exists at this point . Here we are how many months after this National Emergency was declared, and where do things stand . There isnt a plan, and the president doesnt care about people. He doesnt care about the people who are crossing the border in any shape or form. What he does care about is a visual. Thats why he wanted to see, you know, you saw fox news in 2018, showing the caravan. What hes concerned about and the humanitarian crisis that he sees is all of these people and the press showing whats going on at the border. That scarce him and scares him and leaves the democrats to authorize funds and the funds they see will make the biggest difference. And the president doesnt care. Hell take anything because he sees this as more of a political problem and a visual problem than anything else. Were going to come back in just a moment. Up next, what is next for stacey abrams, thats coming up. , thatb from any one else. Why accept it from your allergy pills . Flonase sensimist relieves all your worst symptoms, including nasal congestion, which most pills dont. And all from a gentle mist you can barely feel. Flonase sensimist. I like to plan my activities before i take trip, so by the time i get there i can just enjoy the ride. With tripadvisor, its easy to discover over 100,000 bookable things to do, from walking tours in rome to Wine Tastings in tuscany, and if you like what you see, you can book it with ease. Just another way tripadvisor helps you make your trip a masterpiece. Hoo read reviews, check hotel prices, book things to do. Tripadvisor. The Doctors Office might mejust for a shot. O but why go back there when you can stay home with neulasta® onpro . Strong chemo can put you at risk of serious infection. In a key study neulasta® reduced the risk of infection from 17 to 1 a 94 decrease. Neulasta® onpro is designed to deliver neulasta® the day after chemo and is used by most patients today. Neulasta® is for certain Cancer Patients receiving strong chemotherapy. Do not take neulasta® if youre allergic to it or Neupogen Filgrastim . An incomplete dose could increase infection risk. Ruptured spleen, sometimes fatal as well as serious lung problems allergic reactions, kidney injuries and capillary leak syndrome have occurred. Report abdominal or shoulder tip pain, trouble breathing or allergic reactions to your doctor right away. In patients with sickle cell disorders, serious, sometimes fatal crises can occur. The most common side effect is bone and muscle ache. If youd rather be home ask your doctor about neulasta® onpro. Pay no more than 5 per dose with copay card. If you have a garden you know, weeds are lowdown little scoundrels. Draw the line with roundup. The sure shot wand extends with a protective shield to target weeds precisely and kill them right down to the root. Roundup brand. Trusted for over 40 years. Still fresh. Unstopables inwash scent booster downy unstopables welcome back. Stacey abrams may not have won the georgias governors race but her influence is breathless. Stacey abrams announcing tuesday she will not run for georgias u. S. Senate seat delivering a blow to democrats looking to court her to run for congress. I am announcing today i will not be a candidate for the United States senate. But lets be clear. I will do everything in my power to ensure georgia elects a democrat to the United States senate in 2020. For now focusing on Voting Rights Nonprofit Group fair fight action. Down in texas she was giving a speech on the heels of this and said what she said time and time again which is, we won. Using that as the focus of all that shes talking about here as she moves forward. What power does that give her Going Forward . How resonant is that message within the Democratic Party . Depends on how long the legs are. Clearly she has a lot of Political Capital and goodwill behind her now, a Strong Social media presence, people care what she says. She has a chance now to and shes not wrong when she says that. I think republicans should be worried about texas in georgia becoming blue states. She obviously embodies i think potential for georgia to become more blue, or majority blue. So that should scare republicans. I think the issue is, what does she do with this tactically Going Forward . Voter suppression, a key issue for her. Something we as americans should care about and shes a great ambassador for that issue but has it move beyond that issue and needs a menu of responses. Whats wrong with the deliberative body . We could spend the whole hour of the show talking about that. Whats distasteful about this . Why is abrams and hickenlooper not interested in running for the senate . Theres the old paradigm of governors and executives hate going into the senate. Theyre used to being the ones making the call and go in and are one of two from their state and it rolls out. Influence is diminished. The other thing is, right now good people dont want to serve. Thats a tough problem. Just going a little back to stacey abrams. I think her biggest role could be kingmaker. If she endorses in the democratic primary that can be huge. I think its a way of taking her message and keeping her relevant and moving forward for the next 18 months, because that could be part of her challenge. I think potential kingmaker or queenmaker. Were seeing that happen. Meeting with candidates, embodying, playing that role . Certainly. To her filling a public ochs just because its open is not as bolsters Fair Elections and making georgia more competitive against republicans in the future. She said something recently in an interview, running for senate or the white house is a job, end of the day. She wants to make sure she is the most qualified person to hold that job p. I think shes thinking about it in a critical and smart way and others are returning, i believe, its a why not . President ial election cycle. Why not when running against somebody like donald trump. She wants to make sure the infrastructure is in place for people are color to have their voices heard and counted via voting in a place like georgia, could be crucial for senate and congressional races in the future and recognizes thats a bigger issue for democrats and the future of the party than her necessarily representing the party being a senator or a democratic candidate for president. Something she talked about a lot in the New York Times magazine interview. Favorite part. Written eight novels under a pseudonym. Really . No. Feels a sense of mission and refreshing. Thank you all for joining me. What happens when the countrys top Law Enforcement officer refuses to comply with your subpoena . My colleague joy reid will sit down with a member of the House Judiciary Committee to find out. Up next. Ind out. Up next. Directly to petmeds. Com. Because its the easiest way to save 30 on all the medications we carry. So skip the search and go directly to petmeds. Com now. Ive always been amazed and still going for my best, even though i live with a higher risk of stroke due to afib not caused by a heart valve problem. So if theres a better treatment than warfarin. I want that too. Eliquis. Eliquis is proven to reduce stroke risk better than warfarin. Plus has significantly less major bleeding than warfarin. Eliquis is fdaapproved and has both. Whats next . Reeling in a nice one. Dont stop taking eliquis unless your doctor tells you to, as stopping increases your risk of having a stroke. Eliquis can cause serious and in rare cases fatal bleeding. Dont take eliquis if you have an artificial heart valve or abnormal bleeding. While taking eliquis, you may bruise more easily and it may take longer than usual for any bleeding to stop. Seek immediate medical care for sudden sign of bleeding, like unusual bruising. Eliquis may increase your bleeding risk if you take certain medicines. Tell your doctor about all planned medical or dental procedures. Eliquis, the number one cardiologistprescribed blood thinner. Ask your doctor if eliquis is whats next for you. Heresshow me making it. Like. Oh i got one. The best of amy poehler. Amy, maybe we could use the voice remote to search for something that youre not in. Show me parks and rec. From netflix to prime video to live tv, xfinity lets you find your favorites with the Emmy Awardwinning x1 voice remote. Show me the best of amy poehler, again. This time around. Now thats simple, easy, awesome. Experience the entertainment you love on x1. Access netflix, prime video, youtube and more, all with the sound of your voice. Click, call or visit a store today. That does it for me today. Thank you for watching. A. M. Joy with joy reid starts right now. If, in fact, a proceeding was not wellfounded if it was a groundless proceeding, if it was based on false allegations, the president does not have to sit there constitutionally and allow it to run its course. The president could terminate that proceeding and it would not be a corrupt intent, because he was being falsely accused. Good morning and welcome to a. M. Joy. We have a lot to get to this morning, including Donald Trumps brazen phone call with russian president Vladimir Putin where not surprisingly he did not confront putin on russias interference in the 2016 election but did get a smile. Thats nice. Start with what you just heard from attorney general william barr this week. That is everything you need to know about his view on obstruction of justice. Namely, that essentially a president , at least a republican one, cannot commit it. Barr is among several legal minds on the right to hold a particular view about president ial power based on the theory called the unitary executive theory. According to politico supporters of this executive argue the constitution grants president s broad control of the executive branch to take a salient trump era example, the power to fire