Transcripts For MSNBCW MTP Daily 20160411

York heads to the polls, were watching one lelel of a fight break out on the republican side of things in new york. Its an allout war over delegates. Trump is slamming the Republican Partys nominating process as corrupt. His campaigns accusing cruz of employing catch this favorite word gestapo tactics to intimidate delegates. And cruz doesnt like it. In just a minute, well dive into that battle royal. But we begin tonight with the breaking news weve got. Weve got new numbers from our exclusive nbc news wall street journal marist poll out right now on the state of the race in new york state, where hundreds of delegates are at stake next tuesday. On the republican side, catch this, trump leads big. Its trump, 54 percent. Kasich, down at 21 . Cruz further down at 18. Remember, if trump wins more than 50 statewide, he will win all the states, 14 atlarge delegates, in addition to likely cleaning up across the state at the local level. 64 of new york republicans, by the way, say that the Republican Party should nominate trump as long as he has the most delegates. Even if he doesnt have the requisite 1,237 to get the nomination on the first ballot. And there isnt much love for the convention savior, either. Come look at this. 59 of new yorkers say that if the Republican Party nominates someone other than trump, it should nominate someone who has actually been running. Only 32 say its acceptable to nominate someone who hasnt been running, an outsider. And in the democratic race, Hillary Clinton holds a commanding lead as well. Its clinton, look at this, 55 . Bernie sanders, 41. A 14point gap. But does clinton have a party unity problem brewing in new york . Nearly a third of sanders supporters say they will not support clinton if she wins the nomination. For comparison, only 16 of clinton supporters say they wouldnt support sanders as the nominee. Figure that one out. Lets dive into those numbers. Im joined by lee maringoff, the director of the marist company for public opinion. Glad to have you on. Does the number that trump have right now, well above 50 fact, suggest that if nothing changes between now and next tuesday in new york, eight days from now, he will have swept the whole thing, the whole shebang . Yeah, thats the magic number. Over 50, and you know, right now, thats where he is. And the campaigns of kasich and cruz will have to figure out a way to pull him down. Trump doesnt close well, but right now, hes where he needs to be to erase some of the deficits that have happened in recent states where cruz has done well. We dont have the white evangelical population in new york. The number of very conservatives, the number of tea party supporters. New yorks a different ball game in terms of the republican electorate. And trump is benefiting from that. And hes doing very well here in new york. Is trump more in tune with the usual historic Republican Party . Im not saying jake javits, but rockefeller, a little bit to the right of rockefeller . Is he sort of in the sweet spot of new york republicans, rather cruz, whos sort of a country boy . Yeah, well, im not sure how overwhelmingly supportive trump is in terms of differing elements. Hes doing very well. He has doubledigit lead in most of these critical categories. Hes got the new yorker thing going. We can talk a little bit more about that, when we talk about the democrats, as well. But, look, cruz is not a very acceptable candidate here for new york, because thats not who we got. And kasich is the second choice. Might pick up a little bit, as voters who dont like trump start to think of, well, whos the stoptrump guy in new york. Right now, its neither of them, because kasich and cruz are splitting the remaining vote that trump doesnt get. Trumps positioned just where he needs to be here in new york. Im just thinking, lee, if trump had had a decent couple of weeks coming into this instead of a bad week, hes lost like ten contests in a row to cruz out there, and he had the whole thing about what he said with me and everybody else, and what he said with the comparison of the two wives looks and all that stuff, with lewandowski, all that stuff is bad news. Was he running like 75 before this poll was taken . I dont know about that. I just wonder, nothing seems hes bulletproof, it looks. But dont confuse the numbers hes getting for a republican primary with what is a very blue state. I see. Because Bernie Sanders and Hillary Clinton clean his clock and all the republicans, as far as the electoral votes in new york is concerned. This is a battle. Does trump get back on the pathway to getting the nomination uncontested . And this would be a step in that direction for him. But by no means finishes that argument. Well still have other states with lots of delegates to be selected. It just gets him back on course. Thats a sharp assessment. Last question. Hillary clinton, is bernie gaining on her or not . Can you tell . In new york. Well, its obviously closer than it was months ago, but she has a very comfortable lead, and its no accident that Hillary Clinton is talking about the time she was a senator. We did polls way back when she was a senator in 08, her Approval Rating in new york was at 62 . So shes going around the state reminding people. Remember me . You liked me then pip need you now. But the difference in new york is whether youre 45 years of age or older. Age trumps everything heres in terms of, if youre over 45, Hillary Clinton has a 23point lead. If youre under 45, sanders has a 25point lead. The benefit for clinton is that more people are over 45. And thats why shes running up the score right now in new york. And this gets her back on the path, you know, sanders argument is hes going to chip away the delegates and make it among the pledged delegates. Well, you dont do it in new york if you dont win the primary. As yogi berra would say, its getting later earlier here in new york. I would think, free tuition, thats a hell of a deal, if i were a kid. Thank you, lee. Donald trumps going to need a big lead in new york. When it came to delegate selection, theres no sugar coating his situation right now. His campaign has again had a terrible weekend. They were skunked. That means lost everything in colorados delegate conventions this weekend, thanks in part to pour Trump Campaign organization. And a slew of unforced errors. They were outmaneuvered in a bunch of other states, including iowa, indiana, south carolina, and virginia. And in many instances, trumps delegate slots were pilled by rival republican officials who say they hold no allegiance to trump, even though theyre elected in his name, apparently. Well, if trump doesnt win the nomination on the first ballot at this summers convention in cleveland, those folks will vote for someone else. Trump responded by slamming his partys delegate process as a fraud. Here he is. Weve got a corrupt system. Its not right. Were supposed to be a democr y democracy. Were supposed to be, you vote, and the vote means something. I want to tell you, its a corrupt deal going on in this country and its not good. Its not good. Trumps new head of delegate selection, thats Paul Manafort, is accusing the Cruz Campaign of foul play when it comes to this delegate strategy of theirs. This is tough language. Ready for this . Heres manafort with chuck todd yesterday on meet the press. What is fair game to win a delegate . Is threatening fair game . Its not my style, its not Donald Trumps style. But it is ted cruzs style. And thats going to win thin very fast. You think hes threatening delegates . Well, hes threatening you go to these county conventions and see the gestapo tactics thats a strong word . Well, well be filing several protests because the reality is theyre not playing by the rule. Anyway, cruz says his campaigns playing by the rules. He says their gains are thanks to a superior organization. Heres senator cruz late today going after trumps reaction to losing all those delegates out in colorado. Now, in response, donald has been yelling and screaming. A lot of whining. Heim sure some cursing. And some latenight fevered tweeting. All the characteristics i would note, we would want of a commander in chief. Well, despite Donald Trumps complaints about the rules of the Republican Party, the delegate system actually appears to benefit him instantly. According to an nbc analysis, trump has won 45 of the delegates, despite winning just 37 of the primary vote itself. So hes gained in delegate selection. Thats a much bigger bump than cruz has got, who has won 32 of the delegates, with just 28 of the actual vote. Im joined by nbcs hallie jackson, whos been covering cruz on the trail. Also msnbcs chief legal correspondent, ari melber. I have to go to ari first, to teach some things to me. Explain to me these delegates who get elected. They get selected somehow, and theyre not really loyal to the person they say they should be loyal to. Explain how this disloyalty works . You dont have to really be with the candidate . The disloyalty comes from the fact that this is all a mishmash of 50 states sets of rules and most of the rules do not require you to have an allegiance beyond the first ballot, nor you to be picked by the campaign. So in most cases, you basically have local party activists. They like who they like, and once theyre unbound, if there is a second vote, which there usually isnt, then they can do what they want. Two other points, chris, you show trump complaining. This is similar to sports. If youre complaining about the refugee, youre probably not playing that well on the field. And the other important part you played that dynamite, you know, big sound of Paul Manafort telling our own chuck todd these are gestapo tactics. The other important thing he said in this exchange is we are going to be filing protests. What hes previewing there, potentially, chris, is another route to dealing with this ongoing, increasingly hot exchange, where they might actually try to prevent these delegates from being seated if they dont think theyre protrump, or if they think there was chicanery in how they were selected. You can go back to the 52 election where taft came in with a lead, but the eisenhower folks did file successful contests kicking out delegates. And that ultimately led to eisenhower coming from behind and winning that nomination. Thats because they had a conventionwide vote on fairness and they were able to kick those out. They had the fair play amount. Let me go to howie on this and the culture of donald trump. I get the feeling were ready for a brooklyn dodgers we was robbed claim at the convention. It seems like everythings aiming towards, we was robbed. He walked out the door with a thousand delegates, brings the house down, doesnt run third party, because down in history is a guy who was robbed, but the Republican Party screwed him. Im not sure that isnt bad for donald trump after all the mitchigoss for this campaign. This is not the first time weve heard donald trump railing against the system and calling it corrupt. What is different now are these delegate wins and these delegate successes from the ted Cruz Campaign. Thats the backdrop against which all of this is playing out. So for trump, this fight against the system is picking up a new urgency, because of what the Cruz Campaign has been able to do. You talk about the Cruz Campaigns response, to sum it up for them, its sour grapes. They say trumps throwing a tantrum because hes not doing as well as ted cruz when it comes to delegate strategy. But even as donald trump rails against the system, he has hired a guy in Paul Manafort to help him play that system, to help him work within the delegate game and to try to pick up wins to be able to prepare for a contested convention. The other point i would note, just as aris talking about in sports, if youre whining about the ref, then youre not playing the game. For ted cruz, there is a risk that if hes talking about process so much and talking about delegates and strategy, that detracts from his ability to get the message out that he wants to get out, which right now is Economic Security and jobs, which you hear him talking about in california. Well, sometimes there are bad calls. I just want to go back to something help me out here, ari. Real simple question. If you go to the voting booth as a primary voter in new york or anywhere else, and you vote for trump, you vote for his delegates, they can betray that . Are you telling me they can ignore that order, or just can ignore it after the first ballot . Im telling you, in the vast majority of states, the delegates that are allocated by the state are bound by the first ballot. So to your question, they cannot ignore it on the first ballot. There are exceptions, like colorado, which trump was complaining doesnt even hold one of those primary votes. But everyone knew that going in. Those rules were known. But, yes, chris, in most cases, what you have is basically state rules that for the most part bind on the first ballot and sometimes the second, but, again, delegates are people, and the whole reason we have this, as you know, as a student of political history is, we took a system that was parliamentary in nation, where the party elites picked the nominee. And after 68 and the mcgovern reforms, we have socalled democratized it. Let me go back to hallie to finish up here. I think people think its a democratic system. And i think trump has a case here. Because the people think that the guy or the woman who gets the most votes should win. Right. Is that its one vote, you know, one piece of support. But ari is making an excellent point. You probably saw us nodding here. You talk to republican operatives or strategists that are embedded in this, and they will point out, this is just like when you elect somebody to a member of congress. You are voting to have somebody represent your interests in washington. But the argument goes its the republican form of government. But let me tell you something, guys. The last time anybody tried arguing this case was back when men wear threepiece suits. Thought they had vests on. There were no women around. They smoked cigars in back rooms, they were all protestants. They ran the show the old way, pretty much. They were all white, obviously. The country is so far removed from that stuffy, world of elite that decides stuff in back rooms, literally in hotel rooms. You think the public you cant say that, because youre a straight reporter. But ari, you can do you think the American Public will buy the fact that all your votes dont mean nothing . I think youre but tkis. Nothing chris, i think youre putting your finger on the point. If this is seen as illegitimate and as overturning the clear will of the voters, thats a big problem. But we have a tradition of state runoffs. Ted cruz, who hallie goes around and covers, trailed and lost his runoff. He came in second running for the Senate Runoff in texas when no one had a majority. And in many states, then off runoff of the top two, and that means by definition the guy that started as number two can come in number one. But the whole purpose of that stuff in the south was to keep blacks from gett eting elected. That wasnt for a democratic purpose, but for trying to keep the blocks out of history. I know were out of time. The question is, does trump have a big enough vote to your argument to the legitimacy of the Republican Program here, that they want to steal it . If its close, though, if its close, cruise that the argument this this is like a runoff. I guess its who you like. Thank you, hallie jackson, as always. And ari melber. Coming up, Hillary Clinton takes on both Bernie Sanders and donald trump as she campaigns on her home turf, playing defense in new york. The latest oen the democratic primary fight up in the empire state. And paul ryan says hes not running, but what wait a minute, what do you think . His actions speak a lot louder than his words. Stay tuned. He has a sharp wit. A winning smile. And no chance of getting an athletic scholarship. And that is why you invest. The best returns arent just measured in dollars. Td ameritrade. Take on the unexpected. The new 2016 nissan altima. Built to stand out. Well, our brandnew poll shows Hillary Clintons leading Bernie Sanders by 14 big points up in new york state. And the reason may come down to location, location, location. Take a look at this list of the ten most populist counties in new york state and the ten most diverse counties. These numbers come from the u. S. Census, by the way. Heres what that looks like on todays map. Eight of those counties overlap, meaning the most populous counties in new york, the ones where you can expect the most voters are also the most diverse. And the sanders struggles for nonwhite voters, that goes on in the 21 states where weve seen exit polling in this election cycle, sanders has only one 50 , half, of nonwhite voters areas. So while there are many more rural, less wealthy voters, the places with more voters arent lacking good for him. Well be right back with more of mtp daily and the democratic fight, the big one up in new york. With flonase allergy relief, they wont. When we breathe in allergens, our bodies react by over producing six key inflammatory substances that cause our symptoms. Most allergy pills only control one substance. Flonase controls six. And six is greater than one. Flonase outperforms the 1 nondrowsy allergy pill. So you can seize those moments, wherever you find them. Flonase. Six is greater than one changes everything. Sure, we cor put them stacked on a rack. S. But the specialists at ford like to show off their strengths 13 name brands. All backed by our low price tire guarantee. Yeah, were strong when it comes to tires. Right now during the big tire event, get a 120 rebate by mail on four select tires. When your ford needs service, these are the specialists. At ford. Welcome back to mtp daily. Im Chris Matthews in for chuck todd. Ill be back for hardball at 7 00 eastern. Anyway, today Hillary Clinton put out a new ad aimed at donald trump. Catch this baby. He says we should punish women who have abortions. There has to be some form of punishment. That mexicans who come to america are rapists. Theyre rapists. And that we should ban muslims from coming here at all. Total and complete shutdown. With so much at stake, shes the one tough enough to stop trump. Wow. And speaking in queens new york today, one of the boroughs, clinton continued to knock Bernie Sanders. I have noticed that under the bright spotlight and scrutiny here in new york, senator sanders has had trouble answering questions. Hes had trouble answering questions about his core issue, namely dealing with the banks. Hes had trouble answering Foreign Policy questions. And, so i look forward to a debate that is in new york with people asking the kind of questions that new yorkers ask. Well, meanwhile, sanders is hitting clintons record on fracking, which new York Governor Andrew Cuomo has banned statewide. He did it in 2014. And Nbcs Kristen Welker joins me right now from hall brook, new york. I thought bernie would come on strong against hillary, but these are doubledigit deficits. And all three polls as of tonight, the nbc journal maris poll, hes not doing well in new york. Youre right, chris. Ive been talking to his Campaign Officials who acknowledge the really steep odds theyre facing. Secretary clinton has a commanding lead here, that 14point lead you just reported on, chris, and we are seeing her keep her eye on the general election, as you pointed out, taking a number of swipes at donald trump, but also keeping her focus on Bernie Sanders, because if she can put him away here, chris, she can almost all but put this race away. Now, the reason why youre seeing this twopronged approach, as well, shes trying to argue to democratic primary voters that she would be the strongest candidate in a general election. Adding to senator sanders really steep odds, in addition to everything you just laid out, this is a closed primary. That means that dmindependents cant vote in this primary, and sanders typically does well in states where independents can vote. And for reference, chris, hes lost three of the states that have been closed primaries. Really steep odds for him there. Kristen, well be back to you later. Independents have played a large part in Bernie Sanders success so far. And so kristen has just said, new york will be the first in a series of upcoming primaries that are closed, meaning its just democrats. Only registered democrats will be able to participate. And that could cause some major problems for the sanders camp. Kasie hunt joins us right now. Is this going to hurt your guy, the guy youre covering . Reporter hey, chris. I think its entirely possible, yeah. And its about both the system here, but also about how this campaign in many ways grew beyond wherever they expected it to be in the first place. These original deadlines for some of the deadlines in new york were as early as last october, but Bernie Sanders really had contain off, you know, had performed the way he did in iowa and then won new hampshire. I asked around at the rally today about whether or not some of the people who showed up at Bernie Sanders event werent even going to be able to vote for him. Are you guys registered to vote in the democratic primary, do you know . Yeah. You are registered as a democratic . Yeah. Are you registered to vote in the democratic primary . I am. Are you registered to vote in the democratic primary . Knno, i wasnt allowed. Im an independent. New york, closed primary, by the time bernie announced, he wasnt allowed to announce as a democrat. Do you think the campaign should have done more to let you know that you needed to change your registration . It was too little i couldnt register. It was too little by the time bernie announced. There was nothing i could do about it. Reporter right. So i gave him money instead. But im not allowed to vote. Reporter a nice trade, i suppose. But, look, a lot of these people that i talked to said that even if they had changed their registration in time to make sure they could vote, it wasnt the campaign they heard from. It was a friend, someone else. Thats emblematic of Bernie Sanders campaign, generally. But overall that lack of organization could really come back to bite them. Thank you so much, kasie hunt, covering the bernie campaign. Lets bring in okeefe and alex seitzwald. Help us here. Who are these independents . If theyre on the left politically, why wouldnt they be democrats . What is the option for someone on the political left like sanders . Theres a lot of people who dont want to affiliate themselves with the party, but like to be seen as independents, though historically, they tend to vote one way. But you dont get to vote in the democratic primary, which is always a centerleft fight. A lot of people dont know this. That guy is 75 years old that was just there . We back on october 9th. New york has some of the most restricting voting and election laws in the country, and youve got other liberal parties in the state, working families party, liberal party, green party. He could be voting with them. That makes sense. I would think kate, i would think you would want to be where the action is. Pat moynihan, historically, there have been some great fights. Thats true, but independents right now are the i work for independent journal review, our readers, our staffs. Lower case i or lower case . Its upper case i. Theyre really struggling with this. If anything, there might be some reform. Oh, my goodness with, my hands are tied, i cant vote. The vastest group of voters in the country. You probably know this. These closed primary have said weighted to the back half of the calendar. So far, it hasnt really been a problem. Theres only been three closed primaries for the democrats. Arizona, florida, louisiana, Bernie Sanders. And nobody new york this is the biggest fight in new york since jerry brown lost to bill clinton in 92. Of the 17 upcoming contests, nine are closed primaries, including four out of the five biggest by delegate count. Down, its interesting to watch the ark of this campaign, the contour of it, you know . So bernie has a run and eight last night, including democrats abroad. This reminds me of early campaigns, like ted kennedy against jimmy carter. Or barack obama against hillary. You have this long period and you think one guys going down. Oh, all of a sudden, he starts winning. Its like a roller coaster ride. Absolutely. So were into a high coming for donald trump and hillary. They seem to be running parallel, by the way. They are. And in the case of clinton, she knows these rules. I think her team knew this was probably going to happen with sanders. That a lot of his supporters would not have signed up. She thinks intricately. This is a state you have to turn in ballots certain colors. They have to be a certain length. They still use the old levers and curtains to vote. I hear that new york when thing of new york, i think a lot of State University institutions. The sunni institutions, huge school, campuses all across the state. I would think it would have a High Percentage of studentage voters. Apparently nothing like massachusetts and some other states. Its a big state. And that will be hugely helpful. And upstate, hes going to do really well. You have more white voters, fewer diverse voters. And if you go further upstate, plattsburg area, thats the same media matter as burlington. These people have been seeing Bernie Sanders on their air for 30 years. But for her, that graphic with the most populist counties, its gou going to be all about the five boroughs. Whats the power of blitzes and hot dogs and nathans hot dogs and juniors cheesecake and all this awful food you have to eat in new york. In new york, still like that guy or woman biting into some ridiculous hot dog, matza ball or something. The fork. Thats a big mistake. Who did that . Trump did it a few years ago. A pizza moment on that. Its like john kerry made the mistake of going to philly in south philly and ordering his cheesesteak with swiss. Bernie had some luck with the pope wasnt necessarily the pope, but going to the vatican. He sort of the pope, being in the same headline with him and the vatican, the pope has a very high Approval Rating among hispanics. So all of a sudden to be in that headline with him, does pretty well for bernie. Sort of helps him bernie took a burp just kidding, just kidding still ahead, john boehner, the former speaker, is speaking out why he would like to see the current speaker, paul ryan, at the top of the republican ticket. Stay tuned. One crest 3d white smile. Is all it takes. To turn the tables. Crest 3d white toothpaste. Removes 5 times more stains. Than the red box. For a smile like that, crest 3d white. Is the way to whiten. Wyou could just forget frthe beach wedding. And the beach booty. You could just book a different resort. Like in alaska. Theyve got igloos. People are taking charge of their type 2 diabetes with noninsulin victoza®. For a while, i took a pill to lower my blood sugar. But it didnt get me to my goal. So i asked my doctor about victoza®. He said victoza® works differently than pills. And comes in a pen. Victoza® is proven to lower blood sugar and a1c. Its taken once a day, any time. Victoza® is not for weight loss, but it may help you lose some weight. Victoza® works with your body to lower blood sugar in 3 ways in the stomach, the liver, and the pancreas. Vo victoza® is an injectable prescription medicine that may improve blood sugar in adults with type 2 diabetes when used with diet and exercise. It is not recommended as the first medication to treat diabetes and should not be used in people with type 1 diabetes or diabetic ketoacidosis. Victoza® has not been studied with mealtime insulin. Victoza® is not insulin. Do not take victoza® if you have a personal or Family History of medullary thyroid cancer, multiple endocrine neoplasia syndrome type 2, or if you are allergic to victoza® or any of its ingredients. Symptoms of a serious allergic reaction may include itching, rash, or difficulty breathing. Tell your doctor if you get a lump or swelling in your neck. Serious side effects may happen in people who take victoza®, including inflammation of the pancreas pancreatitis . Stop taking victoza® and call your doctor right away if you have signs of pancreatitis such as severe pain that will not go away in your abdomen or from your abdomen to your back, with or without vomiting. Tell your doctor about all the medicines you take and if you have any medical conditions. Taking victoza® with a sulfonylurea or insulin may cause low blood sugar. The most common side effects are headache, nausea, diarrhea, and vomiting. Side effects can lead to dehydration, which may cause kidney problems. If your pill isnt giving you the control you need ask your doctor about noninsulin victoza®. Its covered by most health plans. Well, still ahead on mtp dail daily, could a contested convention put speaker ryan as center stage for the nominati . First, Hampton Pearson has the cnbc market wrap. Thanks, chris. We had stocks slipping today. The dow losing 20 points. The s p down by 5. The nasdaq closing down by 17 points. Crude Oil Prices Hit a fourmonth high today, ahead of a meeting of Oil Producers in doha next sunday. 15 oilproducing companies have officially signed on to that meeting, aimed at freezing current output levels. And tesla motors will recall 2,700 modelx suvs in the u. S. Over a faulty seatlocking mechanism, which could cause thirdrow seats to collapse forward in an accident. This comes as the company enjoys 335,000 advance orders on its model 3 sedan, slated to begin production late next year. Thats it from cnbc, first in business worldwide. Ttle lamb. One of millions of orders on this companys servers. Accessible by thousands of suppliers and employees globally. But with Cyber Threats on the rise, marys data could be under attack. With the help of the at t network, a network that senses and mitigates Cyber Threats, their Critical Data is safer than ever. Giving them the agility to be open secure. Because no one knows like at t. When a moment turns romantic why pause to take a pill . Or stop to find a bathroom . Cialis for daily use is approved to treat both erectile dysfunction and the urinary symptoms of bph, like needing to go frequently, day or night. Tell your doctor about all your medical conditions and medicines, and ask if your heart is healthy enough for sex. Do not take cialis if you take nitrates for chest pain, or adempas for pulmonary hypertension, as it may cause an unsafe drop in blood pressure. Do not drink alcohol in excess. Side effects may include headache, upset stomach, delayed backache or muscle ache. To avoid longterm injury, get medical help right away for an erection lasting more than four hours. If you have any sudden decrease or loss in hearing or vision, or any symptoms of an allergic reaction, stop taking cialis and get medical help right away. Ask your doctor about cialis and a 200 savings card. No, youre not yogonna watch it tch it we cant let you download on the goooooo youll just have to miss it yeah, youll just have to miss it we cant let you download. Uh, no thanks. I have x1 from xfinity so. Dont fall for directv. Xfinity lets you download your shows from anywhere. I used to like that song. The new craftsman pro series riding mowers. Now available with power steering. So you can turn with ease. Available with the tightest turning radius in the industry. And powerful v twin engines with up to 26 horsepower. Because the beer you drink after you mow your lawn tastes better than the beer you drink after someone else mows your lawn. Craftsman. When it matters. Welcome back to mtp daily. Paul ryan just has wrapped up his first overseas trip as speaker and back home, hes arriving to news of a delegate sweep for ted cruz out in colorado. And his party is inching closer to, you might say, a contested convention. But ryan is still saying no to running for president hills. And while aides and ryan himself have said hes staying out of the race, his actions lately are telling a different story. This video released from his office had the unmistakable look and sound of a general Election Campaign ad. And the New York Times today describes ryans intention to, quote, shape an agenda that he plans to roll out right before the convention a supplement, of sorts, to the official party platform. That means plans and talking points that may serve as an alternative focus to the policy of the republican nominee himself. Also today, the new york observer, a great newspaper, reports that paul ryan will attend an exclusive meeting of republican financial bundlers. Those are the guys who rate a lot of money, organized by todd rickets. A conservative donor. You might remember, donald trump told his family to, quote, be careful when he heard they had donated money to an antitrump super pac. Meantime, ryans predecessor, john boehner, is onboard. He says if no candidate came up with the majority of 1,237 in the first ballot, his vote is for ryan. Luke russert joins us on capitol hill, and were also joined by michael steele, who worked for a projeb bush pac. Thank you. Hey, luke, youve got a good nose for up there. What do you smell . I want this on record, what do you smell about the movements behavior, whatever, about the speaker you cover . Is he hoping to get drafted . Well, the establishment certainly would love for him to emerge from a contested convention and grab that mantle, chris, but everyone within his operation here on capitol hill, his pac and outside group, theyre all very tightlipped and said no, no means no, he cannot grab this nomination, because he has not run for president. He has not gone after the money, he has not gone state from state, he cant do it. When people bring up the analogy to the speakers race, i think its worth a discussion as to why its different. When the speakers race occurred, ryan said no. Mccarthy went forward. Mccarthy pulled out unexpectedly. Ryan was forced into it. Boehner gave him catholic guilt. They had Cardinal Dolan call him up and say, you have to do it. The difference with the president ial, cruz and trump have been going around. And if ryan were to somehow grab this mantlepiece and be forced into it, he would get a lot of backlash from the right, something he does not want to incur. And something ill say about ryan, if you go forward to this next year, assume cruz or trump is the nominee and the polls are legit and hillary cleans their clock. Mcconnell goes back to being the minority leader. Its speaker ryan in charge of the house republicans. He instantly ks be tun disputed leader of the Republican Party and can move forward and put his mark on the party how he wants. I think from viewing him, hes moreomfortable there than emerging as this sort of white knight in cleveland. But also, michael, it would give him the advantage of running against hillary in her second term, if she wins, and shell be much older. And by the way, if you look at history, its very, very hard for a party to get 12 years in the white house. Its impossible to get 16, unless your name is franklin roosevelt. So its very and it would be a what luke just says in the shortterm looks just as good in the long run. I think theres something to that. But he also wouldnt mind getting it in and out. Speaker ryan has been as shermanesque as you can be on this. He aint running, hes not interested in, hes not running for president. But he hasnt given us a sherman statement. I think some of his statements have been pretty shermanesque if nominated, he will not run. Have you heard that, luke, if nominated, i will not serve, if elected, i will not run, i will not serve. Do you want to know why hes not running for president . Because hes not running for president this year. He was the Vice President ial president last time around. If he would have gotten in, he would have been the frontrunner. If he wanted to run, he would have run. You dont have to like the guy, but you have to understand how conniving he is and how smart he is. He says its either trump on the first ballot in cleveland or ryan on the fourth. Because it will come to that. No matter what we say or ryan says, it will come to that. Because you cant run cruz, who comes in 200, 300 ballots short of trump. Theres no justification for that. Whether you like him or not, ted cruz has run for president this year. If he comes in short of trump, why isnt trump the nominee . To the point that luke was making, how can you run someone who never ran for president how can you run a guy who comes in second . He has more delegates than anyone else in the race other than donald trump. If youre looking for the second choice, ted cruz looks like it. Let me ask you, luke, about the guy you covered for a long time, boehner. Whys he so hot for this guy, for ryan . Well, he loves ryan. Because he views ryan as the intellectual future of the party. There is a working class, midwestern catholic connection that they both have. Theyre both sportsmen. Boehner, golf. Ryan, more hunting. Although he does do some golf on the side. So theres a natural closeness there. But boehner from his position, hes retired. Hes now finally free to say what he wants. As mike can tell you, the boehner rule was that he had to bite his tongue for the five years he was speaker here. You didnt get to say everything he wanted to say. He would love for his gop president ial nominee to be ryan. Not someone like cruz, who he despises, and someone like trump, who hes told me personally, is not necessarily someone he understands the rise. This was back last year. Im interested to see what he says now. Did you catch boehner at the American Ireland Fund this year . He was rather open mouthed about his views and you know what paul ryan said to him . He said, knock it off. And paul ryan used language that was a lot more irish dive bar 3 00 a. M. Type of talk, chris. Not knock it off, expletive, expletive, expletive, expletive. Well, i enjoyed the open mike from him there that night. Indeed. What do you think . Whats with your guy boehner . Paul ryans First Political experience was putting up yard signs for john boehner if his first congressional race. These guys go back a long way. Speaker boehner has an enormous amount of respect for speaker ryan. He thinks hes a great, smart, future of the party guy. Did ryan ever steal the lawn signs of the other guy . Of course not. I hope not. Because thats illegal. It is illegal. We learn these things. Luke russert, thank you. And thank you michael steele. The other michael steele. Well be right back. Sights to benefit from different points of view. And by consistently breaking apart risk to focus on longterm value. We activy manage with expertise and conviction. Mfs. Thats the power of active management. So you can invest with more certainty. I missed a payment. Aw, shoot. Shoot his is bad. No were good this is your first time missing a payment. And youve got the it card, so we wont hike up your apr for paying late. Thats great it is great thank you. simultaneously at discover, we treat you like youd treat you. Get the it card with late payment forgiveness. Well, now to an nbc news exclusive. Cia director john brennan tells Nbcs Richard Engel that the cia would not engage in harsh enhanced interrogation practices, including waterboarding, even if a future president orders it. This organization will do what it can to protect the American Public from the attacks from terrorist groups. I will not agree to carry out some of these tactics and techniques that ive heard bandied about, because this Institution Needs to endure and, as i said, weve learned lessoned from the past. We have a lot of capabilities and competencies and skills is. And so i dont believe that we need to resort to certain types of tactics. Like waterboarding . Absolutely, i would not, i would not agree to having any cia officer carrying out waterboarding again. Well, the cia directors came after both donald trump and ted cruz, suggesting they would end the ban on waterboarding as president. In a phone interview with fox news this morning, donald trump responded to brennan. Heres what he said. I think his comments are ridiculous. I mean, they chop off heads and they drown people in cages with 15 in a cage, and big, steel, heavy cages. Drop them right into the water, drown people. And e and we cant waterboard and we cant do anything. We have a huge problem with isis, which we cant beat. And the reason we cant beat them is we wont use strong tactics. Whether its this or other things. You can see more of Richard Engels exclusive interview with cnn director john brennan tonight on nnbc nightly news. Its your home. Its everything youve always wanted. And you work hard to keep it that way. Sometimes, maybe too hard. Get claimrateguard® from allstate. It helps keep your homeowners rate from going up just because of a claim. Call an allstate agent first. 8884295722. Accident forgiveness from allstate will keep his rates from going up. But not his blood pressure. Michael james middle name. Not good. Get accident forgiveness from allstate and keep your rates from going up just because of an accident. And it starts the day you sign up. So whether its your car or home, let allstate help protect your rates. Talk to a local allstate agent and discover how much more their personal service can do for you. Call 8884295722 now. Only those who dare drive the world forward. Introducing the firstever cadillac ct6. From bank of america to buy a new gym bag. Before earning 1 cash back everywhere, every time and 2 back at the grocery store. Even before he got 3 back on gas. Kenny used his bankamericard cash rewards credit card to join the wednesday night league. Because he loves to play hoops. Not jump through them. Thats the excitement of rewarding connections. Apply online or at a bank of america near you. Time now for the ws. The who. They got a letter Backing Supreme Court nominee Merrick Garland and pushing for republicans to break their blockade. And what . Its democracy spring. The activist groups outside the capital protesting Voting Rights issues. Thousands of demonstrators arrived in washington, d. C. Today, after a tenday liberty bell. Its the when. The year 2020, dubai is planning to build the worlds tallest skyscraper in time for the world expo there in four years. The city already has the tallest building in the world. And that one got its big screen debut in a Mission Impossible movie shortly after the building opened in 2010. I love those scenes. Dont you . The where. Wisconsin Governor Scott walker offering up old campaign tshirts in exchange for donations to help him pay off his 1 million president ial campaign debt. In the email to donors, he calls himself thrifty, though he did not mention the 90,000 that he spent during his 70day run. Now, the why. New york city mayor de blazio, the mayors Nonprofit Fundraising division. Heres why de blasio says hes not worried. Everything weve done is carefully done with many, many laurts. I assure you. But i havent heard anything about any investigation. Tonight mayor de blasio joins me on hardball. Im terrible at golf. He is. People say im getting better. No ones ever said that. But id like to keep being terrible at golf for as long as i can. Hes just happier when hes playing. But hes terrible. For the strength and energy to keep doing what you love, try new ensure enlive. Only patented ensure enlive has hmb, plus 20 grams of protein to help rebuild muscle. And its clinically proven formula helps you stay you. Oh. Nice shot. New ensure enlive. Always be you. For your retirement, you want to celebrate the little things, because theyre big to you. And that is why you invest. The best returns arent just measured in dollars. Td ameritrade®. Do you have the courage to stay up all night . Because this is our time the greatest tv week of our lives ladies and gentlemen, in the business of bingewatching, sleep is for the week so i want you ready to order takeout, every single night now are you with me . To awesomeness to watchathon big is back. Xfinity watchathon week starts april 18. The greatest collection of shows free with xfinity on demand. Weinto a new american century. Born with a hunger to fly and a passion to build something better. And what an amazing time its been, decade after decade of innovation, inspiration and wonder. So, we say thank you america for a century of trust, for the privilege of flying higher and higher, together. Obviously i dont want to force people to violate their deeply held religious convictions, but wed have to see what thats all about. I wouldnt have signed that law, from everything i know. I havent studied it, but nathan deal, the governor of georgia, vetoed another one. And look, youve just got to see what the laws are and what the proposals are and why you need to write a law. Cant we figure out just how to get along a little bit better and respect one another . I mean, thats where i think we ought to be. Everybody chill out, get over it, if you have a disagreement with somebody. This is why people like john kasich. Talking about the controversial North Carolina transgender law, the socalled bathroom bill. Anyway, its time for the panel tonight. What it is is a law passed in North Carolina by a very conservative party down there, Republican Party today, where it basically said if you have to go to the bathroom of your birth, whatever you were born physically, you have to whatever your identity or choices in life, or identity as you see yourself, who you are psychologically, cannot factor into this. Its almost biblical. Go back to where you were born and go to that bathroom. He said, why do we pass laws like this . That might work in new york. I would think it would work in new york. 5421, all kasich needs to do is drag trump below 50. That argument that he just made there, that might work on long island. This get along, go along, people take pride in new york. In how diverse their neighborhood is. And the travel ban, no North Carolina if they dont have to, because of what they did. It will be quick. I think its another emblem of the disintegration of the historical republican coalition. Big corporations have now come firmly down on the side of the Lgbt Community. For what reason . Business reasons. Because they think this is the smartest mullah. They lit up their triangle, in a Pink Triangle to show support for the Lgbt Community here. Youve got trump alex, what percentage of the Republican Party of new york state is the old Republican Party . Well, maybe the Republican Party in new york. Is it still rockefeller moderate . I dont know, 30, 40 . I have a little more than that in new york. Its amazing it survives all this. Kasich is making the run. Hes going to probably lap cruz in new york. Which shouldnt be too hard. Hell lap him. Is he going to lap up against trump . Trump hasnt said anything about these issues. Lgbt issues in general havent really been in this campaign. He hasnt been successful in talking about issues well, theres that. Insulting people. He hasnt weighed in on this one. Granted, he insults. Whats the nationalist issue. The democratic fight up there, bernie, hes got college kids. Hes got left, the hard left. Doesnt seem to be enough, kate. No, thats true. Hes got the independents and they maybe sort of missed the boat. What bernie keeps doing well is appealing to the human side of people. Even talking about the fracking issue and stuff. The safety issue. My kids drink this water. He keeps appealing to the human side. Hillary has trouble doing that. Hes running the playbook, the woman that ran against cuomo in 14. Im drawing across the bernie inside the beltway, alex. Here we are inside the beltway. Thats the touchy feely thing. Hes also got an act hes been doing for 50 years, according to howard dean. The socialist thing works. It hasnt worked until Student Loans started going through the roof. Social security benefits arent big enough. And health care is a hotbutton issue. And the thing bernie has been selling for 50 years seems in tune to the times. The time has finally caught up with him. Its a signal to his people hes willing to take this strong stand and hes not going to bend, hes going to stick with it. Is he going to go away into the night if he loses . It doesnt seem like hell quit and back hillary. I think youre seeing people close to him torn about which way to go. Are they the new party of the you know what, i think some of them, yeah. Thank you all. Great to have you on this other show. Ed and alex and kate. Chuck will be back tomorrow where he belongs. Tune in tonight at 7 00 for hardball. New york mayor bill de blasio, some call him the big bird, but for us hes our special guest. With all due respect starts right now. Im campbell brown. Im mark halperihalperin. Weve got your best friend on the show. Not you, little fella. Were talking about james. Hello, hello. Lets get started by talking about another unpredictable creature who tweets, donald j. Trump. Later on the show, well have