Transcripts For MSNBCW Morning Joe 20180907

The last time you did the same thing. You with the grauardian. You just body slammed me and broke my glasses. I mean a fighter and a winner if youre talking about beating up reporters. Thats just not right. Assault charges. Didnt he get assault charges. Terrible. And that guy behind the president was removed because he wasnt clapping. You must clap good morning, everyone. President trump last night praising the montana congressman who pleaded guilty last year to physically assaulting a reporter on the eve of the election. Hes a fighter. Yeah. Not really. Welcome to morning joe. I noticed you guys arent clapping hard enough. Its friday. Exactly. September 7th. Oh, boy. Among joe, willie and me, National Affairs analyst for nbc news and Msnbc John Heilemann in a loud shirt and columnist and associate editor for the Washington Post David Ignatius. Elegant. Elegant. A lot to talk about. Its a whodunit in the white house. This person who was the anonymous author of the oped. Im not listening to you. This person is creating a big buildup. Nobody cares about donald trump right now. Come on. There he is. There he is. He was a big deal. Jupiter, florida, is amazing. When you saw the reaction of the women folk. The women folk, yes. To Burt Reynolds in playgirl magazine, did you not think you wanted to grow up to be Burt Reynolds . Oh, yeah. You know you did. You wanted to be the bandit. We were hearing you coming in here. Because youre so loud. And you i think you need to do it, whenever i called you. I told you, about Burt Reynolds. He broke the news to me yesterday about Burt Reynolds passing. Surprising. Yeah. Sort of like, where you were you when you heard about pearl harbor. Where are you, you sum bitch. Wow. Immediately went to Jackie Gleason in smokey and the bandit. First hour of the morning. Not until later in the morning. And 90 movies, 300 television start, how he got his start. On deliverance. I saw that. Smokey and the bandit. Im trying to figure this out. My parents, strict southern baptists, go to church four times a week. Wed go sunday morning, wed go sunday night to trading union, tuesday night bible study, wednesday friday night sometimes family night, but somewhere in the middle of all that when i was 9 years old my father took my brother and sister and i to the longest yard. Wow. At 9 years old . And when i went back to school in meridian, mississippi, and told them that i saw rrated the longest yard i was the coolest kid in school for about 15 minutes. You wonder what the the defining influences were on the man who will one day be your husband, mika . It warped me. It warped me bad. No. You know, but, you know what . The thing is he filled this really interesting place in american popular culture. Its hard for people now to remember. He was extraordinarily huge. Huge, yeah. And nowhere is about him. He was just a fun guy, but sort of sort of became, i dont know a parody, selfparody later, but then in 97, he did boogie nights and suddenly kind of like when travolta went back and did pulp fiction. Suddenly people looked at Burt Reynolds and said, man that guy can act. You know, i was reading an interview with him last night and he said after boogie nights he realized he should have taken his acting more seriously. Wait a minute. Im pretty good in this stuff. Dr deliverance. Then smokey and the bad it caper movies and came back after a down period and did biggy nights. He was great. In that period joe was talking about, the smokey and the bandit period, he was omnipresent on movie screens. Two or three movies in the multiplex at the same time. He was everywhere. Burt reynolds was the worlds highest grossing movie star back in the 80s and iconic roles. Really iconic roles. And an snl parody of Burt Reynolds. Joeys favorite. The gumsmacking detachment cool of Burt Reynolds, he turned down roles. He turned down james bond. What . He turned down hans solo. Michael corleone. Sounds kind of one flew over the cuckoos nest. Turned down every great role. Turned down die hard, and actually wanted him to be morning burt decided to turn it it down. Best decision he made. Incredible. A great quote i read in one of the obits of Burt Reynolds was, you know, i always said that id rather win a heisman than an oscar. Yeah. I was lying. Almost got there with boogie nights. Almost got there. But Robin Williams beat him out. So you know, i think youre the only person your age, mika. I know. That never saw smokey and the bandit. Just for you, this is Jackie Gleason looking for smokey and the bandit. Where are you, you sum bitch . Im right here at the bottom, 6 foot with a little pygmy right bead beside me. You cant miss me. 10 4. Im too good a man. I cant lie to you. Look over your left shoulder. Were on our way to boston to get some clam chowder. Byebye so you see whos sitting in the back seat . Jerry reid. Aim miss moses, man. Incredible basset hound in the movies named fred who had cheeseburgers and he did all the music. Pounded down huge hit country songs. Oh, my god. That was the number one movie in america for about four months, then. It was a gargantuan film. Preacher went a hunting on a sunday morning what does it mean when you only one i saw was deliverance. Lets move on. The life of Burt Reynolds. We have our own very special way of remembering things here on morning joe. Yes, we do. Lets get to more news now. The white house continues the hunt for the Anonymous Administration official behind that scathing New York Times oped. Whodunit . What did donald trump say last night . When he was looking for the anonymous oped writer . Oh, my god. The quote, if you will. Do we have it . This is so good. Listen to him. He doesnt have it. Jackie gleason i just wow. You sum bitch right down the middle of the plate. I whiffed on that one. Wow, alex. Sorry. The times reports that white house officials have been calling around asking cabinet secretaries if theyre responsible. Really . You guys have really maybe Better Things to do . Just asking. It helps build up the big reveal that is taking donald trump at his own game. So far one cabinet official issued a denial. Everyone with the exception of chief of staff john kelly, and attorney general Jeff Sessions, referred nbc news to the statement from Sarah Sanders that calls the anonymous official a coward. Sanders also denies reports that aides are printing out and delivering the denials to the president directly. My god. She posted the phone number to the New York Times opinion desk and urged people to call in and demand the paper to reveal the writer. Senator rand paul reportedly recommended members of the administration be subjected to lie detector tests and whats happened to rand paul . By the way, rand paul missed mr. Civil libertarian. And a principal. Haul them down and strap them in. Take the test. There was at least some discussion among the president s advisers, also reportedly discussed asking senior to sign sworn affidavits that could be used in court if necessary. One outside reporter says the white house has a list of about 12 suspects. Willie, lets talk about that. Talked about it yesterday. If youre the New York Times and the editor and somebody comes to you with Something Like this, thats this significant. It cant be an assistant to an assistant at the National Economic council. Its got to be the Vice President or its got to be nikki haley, or its got to be the sec def or theres only seven other eight officials that the New York Times should ever grant right . Can we expect if its not theyre not going down i know Linda Mcmahon denied it yesterday, but theyre not you would hope the times would say its either mattis or kelly or, you know keep it pretty tight. The term they used again was senior official in the Trump Administration. Not senior white house official. So that sort of broadens it out a little more than the people youre talking about who are that close to the president on a daily basis. But, yeah. I think, you know, if theyre going to try to go find this person, and they feel like they havent found them yet, when you look at that list of 27 people, it starts to look like, if you believe all of these denials, it may not be one of those headliners were talking about. You wonder, and the editors of the New York Times were asked on their own podcast the daily yesterday if they could nair rr it down. What does it mean to name a senior official and wouldnt do that because they felt would be too revealing. The answer we may not know for a very long time, john, who this person s. Iis. Im with joe. The piece of reporting thats new in this piece, assertion, early stage of the Administration Cabinet officials discussing invokes the 25th amendment. Any cabinet person would be in a position to know about that. The times because of the gravity probably not extend an nomt ano discussions of that kind. Youre talking about logically someone whos a principal. Whether a cabinet member, senior white house official, not casting suspicion on someone like head of the nec, the nsc. Logically, someone that senior and comport with the notion, have to be someone that senior to reliable assert those kinds of discussions had taken place in the administration nap wouldnt be a junior official at the Veterans Affairs department that would be in no position to know about those things. You certainly would hope not. You would hope it would you one of eight or nine top officials. David, heard quite a few people saying the real news isnt who wrote it but the fact 1,000 people in the administration could have wrote it. If you had been in washington, d. C. As you have and we have a good bit since donald trump was sworn into office, this sort of talk, very loosely in elite circles of policy leaders and officials and journalists from day one. I think thats really the one message. Its that although we have a list of denials, the very fact that its known that there are many, id say a half dozen or more, people who have doing what this oped describes, have been trying to steer policy in a way that it wouldnt be damaged by the whims and impulsive decisions of the president. That tells us that the phenomena in the piece, whatever the controversy about who wrote it, is real. And i think that in that sense it underlines something we sort of knew but it just drives it home. Trumps rage at this is in part of rage against the government he has understood i think for months that he doesnt fully control. Yeah. And the i think the question is how much damage this crazy period Bob Woodwards book quoted somebody as calling it crazytown, in living in crazytown after a while gets exhausting and thats what washington felt like this week. You go outside, to play tennis last night, somebody was screaming, who wrote the piece it was like, people are obsessed with this game, people are making bets with bookies, one online bookie said hed had more than, like, 5,000 wagered on the names of who my have written this oped. What a crazy situation. The question, how are we going to get out of that . Yeah. That book, by the way, reports that mike pence is the odds on favorite. Ah, mike pence who talked about the president s extraordinary leadership yesterday. Its kind of hard to watch. Go ahead, john. One last thing to willies point. The point you made conditional. If denials are to be believed we all know that denials of this kind in washington are utterly worthless. I mean, we have watched how much people that have said, have we seen in their career, i am not running for president , serve out my term and then theyre running for president two weeks later. In this white house in particular, this white house, more promiscuous with the truth than anyone weve covered, i dont take any of those seriously. Not a single one. The denials are incredibly important. The list of denials issued already whether compelled by the president or voluntarily put out. Look at this. Now, david writes in the Washington Post a piece about surviving crazytown. Frankly, look at that long list of denials, david, its probably very possible that the president is looking at that list, and is extremely disoriented himself, because those are all the people that felt they had to issue a denial. So those are all the people who it could have been. Which means his entire white house basically doesnt believe in him, thinks hes crazy, does not think that hes able to do his job and now the president himself knows it, because they had to issue denials. And the president is saying he can only trust his children now. Wow. Where are they on the list . You know what about melania. Really . You know, its just its an amazing situation. The president , im sure, is going to brood and stew, and the fact that all of those people basically the entire top rank of his administration felt compelled to issue a statement. It wasnt me. I didnt do it. Just shows you an administration in some disarray. Now that the way in which business has been managed, it kind of you know, wait until after the tweet. Wait for the actual order. You know . Dont rush into doing things, just because the president made a comment. Now that thats been outed. Yep. Whats going to happen . And i have a feeling that youll see just as people rushing to put their names on a list, people rushing to show any whim of the president , yes, sir, got it. Right on that. And that could change the character of the way the government works. Not for the better. I agree. And i think thats really going to be an interesting question going forward. You know, david, its interesting, though, that the first bit of Foreign Policy news we get after these revelations is that actually the president is going to do what everybody in the Foreign Policy community believes he needs to do, and hes going to commit to keeping our limited number of troops and our presence in syria as a bu bulwark against russia, against isis, against the assad regime. Youve been out there. Talk about what an important move that is. Joe, this really is important. Our military in syria has been, i dont want to say pleading. The military doesnt plead, but they have believed deeply that we would give up hardline strategic advantage by pulling these troops out. Every president ial statement, ah, what do we need this . Has distressed our special forces in particular who are in syria, and there is now a new policy and it does have claritys they chose one. Most respected diplomats in the last 15, 20 years, jim jeffrey to run it. Career straight department officer. They are sending very clear signals to the russians, the turks, the saudis, the iranians maybe most important, the United States is going to play its hand differently, and this period of kind of, lets get out of dodge. This isnt matter, that seems to be matter, at least for now. Theres an example of good policy being made, being made by a group contrary to the president s initial instincts. He didnt want to do it but was talked into doing it and officials are saying, jim jeffrey says specifically in the Washington Post im confident that this policy has the support of the president of the United States. Other stories making head lines. Defense secretary jim mattis is in afghanistan on an unannounced visit. Mattis along with general Joseph Dunford are meeting with army general scott mill here took over as commander of nato troops in afghanistan on sunday. President trump has yet to visit troops fighting in afghanistan, nor has he visited any soldiers in a combat zone ever. Also making news, this november, americans could elect more than 100 women to the house for the first time in history. A race by race Analysis Shows between 30 and 40 new women are poised to enter the house next january. That would shatter the previous record of 24 set in 1992s year of the woman. Currently there are 61 female democrats and 23 female republicans serving in the house. Also another big story, officials in five states are investigating decades worth of sexual abuse claims in the catholic church. Attorneys general in illinois, missouri, nebraska, new mexico and new york asked local diocese for their records in an effort to unearth cases potentially covered up by the church. The move follows an explosive pennsylvania grand jury report that detailed more than 1,000 victims accusing priests of abuse. We will follow that. Still ahead on morning joe, Rudy Giuliani confuses the conversation about whether or not the president will answer bob muellers questions. Well get to that, plus cory booker looks for a moment during yesterdays Supreme Court confirmation hearings. What was that . Hmm. This is about the closest ill ever have in my life to i am spartacus moment. Yeah. Orrin hatch weighed in, you know, i knew spartacus. He was doing the whole spartacus thing, willie, saying, i dont care if i get kicked out of the senate, i am were going to get this information out. Its against all the rules. He got the information out, and then theyre like, yeah, you asked us to do it last night and we released it. The documents were cleared wednesday night. Cleared wednesday night. All right. Lets go to are you spartacus . Bill, are you spartacus . I am spartacus. Oh youre spartacus. Really . Hes spartacus. Bill karins with the forecast. Bill . Remember last year, guys, harvey, irma, marie, horrific hurricane season. This year not that named storm to remember forever. Theres a chance frorlorence co be that storm. Not set in stone but getting into the time people should get into preparations on east coast. The track of florence. Right now a Tropical Storm dont care about intensity. Six, seven days away from the east coast. The path south of bermuda major category 3 and a forecast path looks like its heading towards eastern north carolina. At that point it could head further north or could head towards the coast. Its not going to get set in stone at least another three to four days. Bottom line is now the european model has it towards the carolinas. The american model closer to the midatlantic and into new england. Everybody has to make sure you have your hurricane supplies for the middle of next week just in case you need it from southern new england all the way down to the coast and well narrow that cone as we go throughout the weekend and into next week. A major story obviously next week. Today were watching flash flooding. 27 million people. Be prepared. Illinois, indiana into the ohio valley, you are going to get drenched as much as five to seven inches. Everyone else in the way, d. C. And cooler finally in areas of new england. We dont know exactly where florence is going to hit, but it will look like to have an impact on the east coast. A time frame of wednesday to friday during next week. Keep that in mind for travel plans. Somebody have cruise plans changed because of that impending storm. Well be right back here with more on morning joe. A hotel can make or break a trip. And at expedia, we dont think you should be rushed into booking one. Thats why we created expedias addon advantage. Now after booking your flight, you unlock discounts on select hotels right until the day you leave. Addon advantage. Discounted hotel rates when you add on to your trip. Only when you book with expedia. electronic dance music takes more than just investment advice. From insurance to savings to retirement, it takes someone with experience and knowledge who can help me build a complete plan. Brian, my certified financial planner™ professional, is committed to working in my best interest. I call it my comfortable future plan, and its all possible with a cfp® professional. Find your certified financial planner™ professional at letsmakeaplan. Org. Are you one sneeze away from being voted out of the carpool . Find your certified financial planner™ professional try zyrtec®. Its starts working hard at hour one. And works twice as hard when you take it again the next day. Stick with zyrtec® and muddle no more®. We distributeus, im the owner environmentallyfriendly packaging for restaurants. And weve grown substantially. So i switched to the spark cash card from capital one. I earn unlimited 2 cash back on everything i buy. And last year, i earned 36,000 in cash back. Thats right, 36,000. Which i used to offer Health Insurance to my employees. My unlimited 2 cash back is more than just a perk, its our healthcare. Can i say it . Whats in your wallet . So we were just sitting around talking. Wow. First of all discovered a couple interesting thing. One, mika brzezinski, who is cultural illiterate. No. Actually shocked us all. Pop culture illiterate. She knows high culture. High culture, of course. Ballet, opera. But doesnt like shakespeare. Stop. I had to memorize it so many times. Doesnt Like Star Wars but is going to her moms show tonight. High culture. Sculptor. Loves that. In washington, d. C. We learned two things. Number one, mika is a huge wkrp wkrp in cincinnati. My favorite show. My office is closed. You may not please. Stay out of my office. Talking about Burt Reynolds. Doors closed. Led us to this and alex, if you can get clips when i tried to make my hair like thanksgiving, push the turkeys out of the helicopter promotional and didnt realize when i think of this group i think of you as the doctor johnny fever and you as the you as the fly trap of the show. Wasnt he on i loved wkrp cincinnati. And fernwood a great show oh, my jodonny is here. Scandalous even today. And the number two, the other thing we figured out around here that doesnt really matter, who figured out whos anonymous. Who wrote the oped. Do you want to reveal, john heilemann. I thought it was somebody else but you guys convinced me, i was wrong. Credit where credit is due. Charlie on esquire suggested his wife detected a feminine perspicacious. What is she . Perspicacious, detected a feminine tone in the oped and suggested, suggested it was Kellyanne Conway and i had not even contemplated that. More in the dan coats mode at the outset. The more you think about it, makes some sense. Very cagey. The kind of person who would find out that mike pence used the word load star and put it in to try to pit it on mike pence and if you think about the double act doing with her husband, trying to set herself up to the be carville and madeleine of the future, the kind of person who would want to come out after trump failed and say you know what . I was working on the inside the whole time. And evidence, ends of the campaign, she would, in the green room, around the set, talking about how she couldnt wait for the campaign to be over. Like her summer abroad. In daytona beach. Doing the show with you on the break. She said, what are you doing . Its a vacation at daytona beach. Like being on the beach with all the kids is how crazy this is. I agree. Who is cunning and clever enough to use the word, a pence word to throw people and who in the postTrump Administration has most to lose . All go back to political words. Alternative facts. If you are somebody who wants to be on television, in the Communications World whatnot, you really have to reinvent yourself. Mike pompeo does not have to reinvent himself. The way to do it and you need that mindset. Look at others that have left the white house. Yeah. Except for one or two. Uhhuh. They aint working in washington anymore. Theyve destroyed their reputations. They might as well go back home, because no administration will ever hire them again. And that twoyear thing earlier about junior staffers. That doesnt make that much sense is because it takes a lot of sophistication to go to the New York Times execute this, communications skill, can write, knows their way around the New York Times and media makes sense. Another piece of evidence, have somebody pull he denial yesterday which is which is not in the category of denials where shes trashing the person. Its a its a denial, but its a pretty soft denial. John heilemann . You can make the case for a lot of slashy big names. I maintained based on some conversations ive had that its a name that is not a household name. Somebody you wouldnt recognize if you heard but holds some power within the Trump Administration, but not a household name. That would be a problem. I think youre wrong about kellyanne. You say conversations, random people on the street . No, no. People who may be familiar. All speculation, unless youre one of the three, four editors at the New York Times, you dont know. You think our idle speculation is just that . Its not kellyanne. Respectfully, i do. And john, the door is closed now donny is going to speak. And i want to bring one thing up a lot of people complaining about an nom itnomity. Played right boo what trump does, pick up his gun. Of course, i mocked them in a meeting last week, blah, blah, blah. I dont have a problem with an n nom annomity, New York Times will have a lot of explaining to do. Im farcest from that at the New York Times, i would want in my pocket when fanned it comes out that its a name weve heard. And associate editor of the Washington Post and political analyst eugene robinson. Youve won the pulitzer, we bow to you. We defer to you. We defer to you. It better be one of the top seven, eight officials around donald trump or the New York Times has made a terrible mistake here. Well, you know, i agree with you on that. It really should be somebody really high ranking, if youre going to grant an nom knitanomi that. I wouldnt personally, if ive been an editor i wouldnt let a junior person make that sort of assertion. Yeah. I think that the kellyanne theory is interesting. Ive been more in the coates cacoates coats camp. I agree with donny, anonymity added than took away from the impact of the piece. Again it would have been about the person. It would have been about the writer. And also, nothing would have happened. I mean, if this valleyreally is person helping save us from Donald Trumps worst impulses every day, i think thats not a bad thing to continue. Just to add two other quick things. One, obviously i am the venus fly trap of the show. I just im just not standing for that. Okay . Well give you that. And the other thing is, i do want to grill willie a bit more, and i dont think we should let him off the hook, about his conversations with persons who might know something about who anonymous, that anonymous person is. Tell us more, willie . Gene, speculative so im not going to talk about them on tv and its not somebody i dont think with direct knowledge but somebody whos done some hunting and talked to a bunch of people that if i can nail it down i certainly will report it immediately. Gene, though, in terms of the New York Times decision, even if its not a toplevel person but its senior, but maybe not one of the, you know, household names, would it also be an argument to go ahead and print it, if that person provided evidence that there were toplevel people who were involved in this sort of group effort to contain this presidency . Absolutely. Its not the end of the world if the person isnt a household name as long as theyve really brought to the table the facts and they can be multiple sources . Well, thats true, but then you really have a burden to assure yourself, if youre an editor, that this isnt all true. Right . Absolutely. So that the two big assertions are, number one, that the 25th amendment discussions and number two, that there is this sort of organized group of officials who are working in concert to thwart, you know, to keep us from disaster. Right. And and so you would you would have to, to really assure yourself that this was somebody yep. Not only in a position to know that but who could provide you some sort of evidence, unless its somebody who obviously, who you know would have been in the room, and who was in a position to just assert this. You know, David Ignatius, your oped about crazytown, how to survive in crazytown and the fact that so many people in washington and around the country see washington, d. C. As crazytown really, doesnt that prove what a massive disconnect, and all of this nonsense, sort of what a massive disconnect there is between the Nations Capital and the rest of the nation . We have peace and prosperity. Seven years of economic growth. The economys doing much better now. Then you go back to 2008. My god. People would have absolutely been thrilled. Wouldnt have believed how well america would have recovered over the past decade. We have peace across the world. Isis has been defeated. Of course, that started under barack obama, but it has continued under donald trump, and james mattis leadership. What a disconnect from washington, d. C. And the United States of america. Ill give you a perfect example, joe, of that disconnect. This week in the middle of all this fevered speculation about the latest screwball thing that happened at the white house, i was talking with a person whos prominent in the Investment Business who said hed just been talking to a very big asian client, Sovereign Wealth Fund that wanted to substantially increase its exposure to u. S. Financial markets, because of a feeling that compared to the rest of the world, the u. S. Was at a pretty good trajectory and i kind of went, wow. Gee, thats important to remember, isnt it . In terms of those fundamentals, as crazy as washington, our political system is, theres still a lot going right in the country. Just to close out our conversation, maybe, about anonymous, the oped writer, i really hope the New York Times did make a wise decision. The language in that oped pieces specially the reference to hearing whispers about invocation of the 25th amendment scares me. If you are a part of that conversation, you werent hearing whispers. You were in a very serious debate, and so you wonder if this was somebody maybe who speaks for one of the principals . Somebody whos close to Vice President pence could go to the New York Times and say i speak on behalf of mr. And mrs. X and not the principal him or herself, and i think if that turns out to be the case, that thats going to, unfortunately, make the argument about the press and its ethics and not about how the white house works. Still ahead, yesterday we showed you senator Kamala Harris digging on whether or not Brett Kavanaugh had spoken to anyone as law firm of trump attorney marc kasowitz. What . Kasowitz . Im sorry. Yeah. Kavanaugh was unsure on wednesday but now he has an answer. Thats coming up on morning joe. Anonymous anonymous anonymous at booking. Com, we cant guarantee youll find gold on your wild west vacation. But we can guarantee the best price on that thar rental cabin or any hotel, home, boat, yurt, whatever. Just dont get carried away with the wild west thing. Hey guys. Get the best price on homes, hotels and so much more. Booking. Com, booking. Yeah if you have moderate to thsevere rheumatoid arthritis, month after month, the clock is ticking on irreversible joint damage. Ongoing pain and stiffness are signs of joint erosion. Humira can help stop the clock. Prescribed for 15 years, humira targets and blocks a source of inflammation that contributes to joint pain and irreversible damage. Humira can lower your ability to fight infections, including tuberculosis. Serious, sometimes fatal infections and cancers, including lymphoma, have happened; as have blood, liver, and nervous system problems, serious allergic reactions, and new or worsening heart failure. Before treatment, get tested for tb. Tell your doctor if youve been to areas where certain fungal infections are common, and if youve had tb, hepatitis b, are prone to infections, or have flulike symptoms or sores. Dont start humira if you have an infection. Help stop the clock on further irreversible joint damage. Talk to your rheumatologist. Right here. Right now. Humira. Joining us now, cofounder of axios, mike allen. Good morning. Happy friday all the household names around the table at morning joe. Okay. I see a couple of them. I see it, yeah. So can we look at donnys glasses for a second . No. I dont want to see it. Out of peoples mouths when they use vulgarities. Can we blurt out look at donnys cell phone cover right here. What does it say . Burt reynolds would have never worn king of everything. My daughter got it for me for my birthday. Master of his domain. This my beautiful daughter got that. Whats wrong with my glasses . Theyre not very guys are angry. The trend. Too much. Stop. Axios is looking at what President Trumps legal team is calling muellers moment of truth. What are they telling you guys over there . Right. So Rudy Giuliani last night told a. P. Questions about obstruction would be off the table. Written or in a voluntary interview. Later he backtracked with hallie jacks jackson, heres what going on. The trump team is trying to jam conflicting statements from rudy, trying to dare mule tore issue a subpoena for the president. They are gambling and were told behind the scenes this is more a p. R. Strategy than a legal strategy. They are gambling mule zeller it going for the high stakes multimonth court fight, that he will back off from that and as a result issue an incomplete report. A report that does not go deep into of obstruction as it could have if he had answers from the president. And the excerpts weve seen anyway from Bob Woodwards book, mueller was in touch with them saying i dont want to subpoena the president but i keep that option. Mueller is not one to back away from a fight and why people close to the team question this strategy. The idea of just trying to basically bully mueller to get him to back off. One thing this does do for the president s legal team is it gives them a little exit ramp or breathing room with the president , because were told from the inside there is no diminishment in the president s hunger to interview, to sit down with mueller, to go facetoface. An astonishing sdmeen ining sc woodwards book where the president s legal team tries to do a mock session to convince him it wouldnt go well, which it didnt. Hmm. Does anybody thank you, mike allen. Happy, happy friday. Does anybody think bob muellers going to back down on any point . Of course not. No. All Approval Ratings are going in his direction. Bob muellers not backing down. Gets delayed, that works to trumps detriment. The back and forth whether or not hell submit to ar interview or wants to is tedious. You want to talk to bob mueller, knock hadnt his door hed be happy to clear his schedule and sit down with you. Theyre playing a cat and mouse game. If you want to do the interview, go do it. Still ahead, is the United States already in a constitutional crisis . Gene says yes and also theys who can save us. Well read from his new piece coming up. Hungry eyes one look at you and i cant disguise ive got hungry eyes i feel the magic between you and i ive got hungry eyes now ive got you in my sights applebees new 3course meal starting at 11. 99. Now thats eatin good in the neighborhood. You always get the lowest price on our rooms, guaranteed . Lets say it in a really low voice. Carl . Lowest price, guaranteed. Just stick with badda book. Badda boom. Book now at choicehotels. Com with my bladder leakage, the products ive tried just didnt fit right. They were very saggy. Its getting in the way of our camping trips. But with new sizes, depend fitflex is made for me. Introducing more sizes for better comfort. New depend fitflex underwear is guaranteed to be your best fit. Man are unpredictable crohns symptoms following you everywhere . Its time to take back control with stelara®. For adults with moderately to severely active crohns disease, stelara® works differently. Studies showed relief and remission with dosing every 8 weeks. Woman stelara® may lower the ability of your immune system to fight infections and may increase your risk of infections and cancer. Some serious infections require hospitalization. Before treatment, get tested for tuberculosis. Before or during treatment, always tell your doctor if you think you have an infection or have flulike symptoms or sores, have had cancer, or develop any new skin growths, or if anyone in your house needs or recently had a vaccine. Alert your doctor of new or worsening problems, including headaches, seizures, confusion and vision problems. These may be signs of a rare, potentially fatal brain condition. Some serious allergic reactions can occur. Do not take stelara® if you are allergic to any of its ingredients. Man are you fed up with crohns symptoms following you . Talk to your doctor today, and learn how janssen can help you explore cost support options. Remission can start with stelara®. Gene, your piece for the Washington Post is not anonymous. Its by you. S oirkz they know the risk the nation is running, they have the power to alleviate that risk but they do nothing. Instead counting on mature adults to keep trump from plunging the nation off a cliff. The whistleblower in the New York Times oped said there were people inside the cabinet to push for the 25th amendment. After this week its clear were already in a constitutional crisis of frightening proportion. The cabinet will not act. Congress under gop control will not act. The internal resistance can only do so much. Would we be in a constitutional crisis if all the institutions that were set in place to check the president s power were not checking the president s power . Well, you know, the thing is, its all written down, right . We have congress is supposed to hand all situation like this. And so congress could be doing serious oversight and Serious Investigation and leading to the logical conclusion it could be commencing impeachment or the cabinet could have more serious discussions about the 25th amendment. Theres this weird dichotomy because on the one hand as David Ignatius pointed out a while ago, things in the country are pretty good right now. But on the other hand were like one step away from being at war in venezuela or from precipitating some sort of military meltdown in pakistan or a crisis in south korea. Wouldnt the constitutional crisis began when an erratic move was made by the president . Yeah. Im saying, im just arguing perhaps were not in a constitutional crisis right now but a step or two away whats erratic. A tweet is not a constitutional crisis. A tweet isnt a constitutional crisis. But the failure, i believe, of the institution that ought to be acting, the failure of congress to at least confront honestly the situation were in now in terms of the executive branch, i think is a crisis. And i think i think its dangerous. I think its dangerous for the country. Its damaging for the country. Yes. And the presidency. Voters need to fix that in november. Gene, thank you. Thank you so much. I do agree its damaging. I agree its dangerous. I agree were in a crisis. I would say were not in a constitutional crisis. Impeachment, every day people said impeachment. Constitutional crisis is when you dont go to the crisis. It ran its course, bill clinton was not impeached, served out his term. Left a 67 approval rating. In this case our founders foresee a need to elect house members ofry two years and rotate senate voting. Americans made a decision in 2016, they can see the decision they make. They can go back and make that judgment and within the parameters of the constitution of the United States they will vote in 60, 70 days. The constitution works. Okay but the bar has been lowered on what erratic behavior is. I would say that. Im not so sure its a constitutional crisis. Republicans struggle in states that President Trump won. Donnys blue glasses. Well have the new numbers for you. The president says hes been portrayed as a lunatic. But thats the socalled resistant who is angry and crazy. Well play his remarks from the rally last tonight. Well talk to two senators on the Brett Kavanaugh nomination. Is she spartacus. Senator blumenthal will be our guest as well. Morning joe is coming right back. You won best looking in your senior year of high school . Somebody had to win it. My Best High School moment was the day i walked across the stage. My dad. Couldnt read real good, so, it was a milestone for me. Ancestry now has over 300,000 yearbooks from all across the country. So go back to school with your family, and discover more of their stories. Start searching for free at ancestry. Com. When the guy in frontd down the highway slams on his brakes out of nowhere. You do, too, but not in time. Hey, no big deal. Youve got a good record and Liberty Mutual wont hold a grudge by raising your rates over one mistake. You hear that, karen . Liberty mutual doesnt hold grudges. How mature of them. For drivers with accident forgiveness Liberty Mutual wont raise their rates because of their first accident. Liberty mutual insurance. Liberty. Liberty. Liberty. Liberty is its circling the parking area. Looking for a place to land. No something came out of the helicopter. Its a dark object. Perhaps a sky diver. Welcome to the earth. No parachute yet. Cant be a sky diver. I cant tell what they are. Oh, my god they are turkeys. They are crashing to the earth right in front of our eyes. One is going through the windshield of a parked car. One is running around pushing each other. I love him. Hes so cute. Thats les nessman. They dropped turkeys a turkey drop. Important les. They dont fly very well. Welcome back to morning joe on this friday, september 7th, 2018. Loni anderson was married to Burt Reynolds. Farewell bandit. Donny, would you like to say anything appropriate about burt . Obviously, huge movie star. You guys talked about him. What was interesting about him is he was the kind of essence of idealized masculinity. Our view i dont know if he would have played as well today with a lot of gender issues going on in this country but that kind of flip, unabashed glib womanizer wait im doing some soul searching here. Interesting, very symbolic of the times. We can think about our leading men today they dont carry themselves that way and its interesting. It is hard to remember that for several years he was the most successful movie star in america. I mean he and Robert Redford for a time were the two giants on the stage. Bing cosby in the 40s. Nobody was a Top Box Office draw for five years. I didnt know that. Shifting topics quickly. Jonathan, you and i are the doubting thomas of red sox nation. Its predicted the red sox are going to be swept by the yankees. They swept instead. A week ago we were on the phone saying, you know, this red sox team is good but not that good. Season team not a playoff team. And they somehow cobbled together they are the mcguyver of baseball. When they started, a team that would have been embarrassing during training season and then win it in the ninth. It gives me hope well at least within that wild card game. I actually think we locked down six games away from locking down the second wild card. You got low expectations. My yankees are mcgruber, blowing themselves up. You have the division. Listen, we know better than anybody that the fall does not go well for trk. Hardly ever goes well for the red sox. Dont jinx that. The indians last year won 22, 23 in a row. Left it in the season. Nothing matters until october. Nothing matters. President trumps attorney Rudy Giuliani appears to be back tracking on comments he made about the president and the Mueller Probe. In an interview with the ap yesterday giuliani said President Trump will not answer federal investigators questions in writing or in person about whether he tried to block the probe into russian interference in the 2016 election. He said quote, thats a no go. Thats not going to happen. There will be no questions at all on obstruction. Lets stop right there. Jonathan, you reported that story. Talk about the circumstances surrounding it. What was giuliani what was how defiant was giuliani . We spoke early yesterday evening about a variety of topics cluing the New York Times oped and pivoted to the latest negotiations. He couldnt have been clear. One thing about giuliani hes consistently inconsistent. And he changed his story a few different times. After i spoke to him he cleaned up his remarks. When i spoke to him, it was clearly an attempt to lay down another marker in these ongoing interview negotiations in which he said the president would not talk, he would not field questions written or in person about obstruction. Moreover anything that happened after he took office, that he felt the Mueller Probe should be confined to the period before he was sworn in. He then went on to discuss how that they were fielding the offer from mueller about written questions about the russian collusion part of this. Even then the goal post shifted from giuliani we said well perhaps be open to that but we wont talk about the idea of followup questions. And if there are any were not sure we would permit them we should agree to them in advance and limited in scope. Giuliani said those questions are not ruled in or now. Giuliani told nbc quote we said we would agree to written questions on russia after we review questions but no further commitment on interviews after we finish. Well assess it with no agreement to any postpresident ial questions. Giuliani added that for now theres quote no commitment on obstruction but says the legal team will agree to talk after the collusion prepresident ial questions are over. These negotiations are still going on between the Trump Legal Team and muellers team and we know mueller wont say anything, not publicly. This is giuliani, hes a lawyer. Hes the pr person. This is what hes been doing for the president since he took this job is the idea of trying to sort of shape Public Opinion on this. Believing that eventually its going to be a report from mueller that through doj will go to congress and thats his audience. That members of congress and their constituents, the idea that they are the ones who will eventually weigh in and decide the president s fate. This is this dance back and forth. Seemingly another shot across muellers bow, suggesting we wont sit down for this. Amp up the pressure. Dare the special counsel to issue a subpoena. Any insight into giulianis strategy. If hes the president s pr man hes doing a terrible job. Robert muellers Approval Ratings are skyrocketing. Donald trump is in the mid30s on three of the latest National Polls that have come out. Any insight into what giuliani is trying to do and how its helping or hurting the president . Joe, we all feel watching giuliani which is like donald trump hes a counter puncher. He just wants to be out there in a feisty combative way, carrying the president s defense that his previous lawyers were cooperative, trump thought to a fault. One thing that intrigues me about this discussion of the interview or questioning the president , often in a criminal trial, this is obviously different because it involves the president , you have a moment where theres the issue of interviewing a principal witness. That person typically gets a target letter or a letter that informs the person of his or her status before this interview. Any lawyer would ask for that. I cant help to wonder if there hasnt been some communication from mueller to the white house, to giuliani and the other lawyers just putting them on notice that in regards this question of an interview they should understand the status of the potential witness who would be interviewed. So, susan, i dont know what the challenge, where you would begin with a challenge on representing President Trump on, for example, obstruction. While theres all this discussion about whether or not hell talk to mueller or answer questions on paper. Isnt the allegation of obstruction in plain sight, on nbc news, in his tweets, even his attacks on Jeff Sessions at this point one could read a lot in that this president is trying to push things away from him, potentially obstructing justice . Well, yes. I think at this point mueller probably has everything laid out that he needs so if the president responds in writing or not he has it. Whats really interesting its right after labor day that line in the sand that Rudy Giuliani was saying we can talk about the Mueller Investigation and should be suspended. Hes the one, not muellers team, who is talking about this investigation, who is talking about questioning the president. So i think as far as everyone goes we now have to look at it, its no longer an issue if you talk about it based on the president s team. Willie, remember tycobb said its all wrapped up by 2017. By christmas 2017. Giuliani has been saying deadline is labor day. Again, time and time again mueller has said nothing. Hes just kept his head down, working 24 hours a day. I dont think hes listening to him . Of course not. The Vice President told Andrea Mitchell a couple of months ago time to wrap it up. Time to wrap it up. You talk to giuliani more than the rest of us. The president s team are the ones that have some leverage over bob mueller. When the truth of the matter is they will do it if not voluntarily through subpoena they will do what bob mueller tells them to do. Its their attempt to shape Public Perception here and to put mueller on the defensive when theres no reason to think that would work that mueller is listening to these public pronouncements. There are behindthescenes negotiations. Mullers team sent a letter suggesting an openness to let trump offer written responses on russian collusion. So this feels like this wave of interviews that giuliani gave yesterday is an attempt to get ahead of that. Whether thats a Winning Strategy in the courtroom, if you will, remains to be seen and certainly theres nothing so far that would indicate that mueller has been intimidated by any of these warning shots coming from the white house. Bill shine went in and started running communication for the president. Ive known bill for a long time. Im curious, so separate yourself from this story. Separate yourself from the donald trump that you know, that youve known, that we know. I mean youve done youve done pr work forever. You got Rudy Giuliani running around hurting the president s cause. Making matters worse. Making Robert Muellers ratings go skyhigh. A lot of chaos inside the white house right now. Lets pretend for a second, lets suspend animation, and say that donald trump is going to listen to bill shine or Sarah Huckabee sanders or any of the communication peoples advice. What advice do you give him on september 7th, 2018, with an election a couple of months away and all the trend lines going in the wrong direction . I say, you know how you suspend the Russian Investigation you suspend it. Basically your talking points you laid out about 20 minutes ago. The economy has never been better. Unemployment is good. Were at peace we killed isis. I have more important things to do. The very thing they are doing is counter intuitive. The more they mix up the soup it keeps boiling up. If he was dismissive and i got more important things to do and im sure bob mueller well deal with that when it comes in. Thats not in his nature. Do you know what bill clinton was so brilliant at doing . Republicans were pounding on an issue, on an issue and bill clinton would go they are right. I agree. We need to balance that budget. We had no other choice. He got pounded on welfare reform. Did it twice. Signed at any time third time. Made it his. Look at the beginning of bill clintons biography, first two things he talks about is a balanced budget and welfare reform. What hes most proud of. Bill clinton would coop the best that the Republican Party had and then move forward with his agenda. Donald trump could go out the next couple of months talking about nothing but peace, prosperity, the destruction of isis, economic growth, the likes of which we havent seen in two quarters because the next quarter will be high as well. We havent seen in a couple of years. Yes, anything. Yes the economy is strong. Yes its stronger. Yes the fight against isis. We finished it. We won that war. And the biggest thing then, and nobody has been able to tell him the difference between collusion and russia interference. Hes so wrapped up and so enaune to separate those two terms. If he said yeah the russians interfered and better knock it off the sanctions will get tougher. Boom. Then he could talk about nothing but peace and prosperity. He tries to do that. They cant impeach me things are going too well. Its in there. So counter to who he is. If he today just looked at the camera and said look i dont want to talk about it any more. When it comes out well deal with it. Obviously they are doing what they are doing. Im running the country. Im making sure you have a job. Im making sure isis never attacks us. Im the president. Im acting like a president. Hes incapable of we know that. Two things he said that isis was on the run. We finished the job. That would give some credit to obama. If the economy is better that gives credit to president obama. To not talk about the russian interference question and the collusion question he believes that calls into question his very presidency. Any conversation about russia he thinks undermines his legitimacy and makes people think maybe he shouldnt be president. He cant allow that. He can stay away from it. He wont. He didnt last night at the rally. Talking about anything but. But he has to have a fight. He just cant talk about what success this administration has had. As far as hes concerned hes not donald trump unless hes fighting somebody. And thats why that strategy that, donny, i agree would make all the sense in the world, this president could never happen. Youre making the assumption, joe, he can recognize what good policy is. Right. Democrats made waves yesterday as you heard with senator cory booker suggesting hes willing to be kicked out of the senate over his move to release confidential estimates regarding Supreme Court nominee Brett Kavanaugh. Any senator, officer or employee of the senate who shall disclose the confidential business or proceedings of the senate including the business and proceedings of the committees subcommittees and office of the senate shall be liable if a senator to suffer expulsion from the body and if an officer or employee to dismissal from the service of the senate and to punishment for contempt. So i would bring up i would correct the senators statement theres no rule, theres clearly a rule that applies. Then bring the charges. Around the time that was going on senator hirono tweeted screen shots of documents saying they contain information republicans dont want americans to see. And the hawaii democrat joins us now. Senator good to see you again this morning. Senator spartacus. Was that your spartacus moment . I used the document that was relevant to the questions that i had regarding judge kavanaughs attitude towards native hawaiians. We learned later the documents that cory booker was explaining was confidential and he was going to put his hide on the line to be released, it was cleared the night before and he was free to distribute them at the hearing. Were your documents cleared before you posted them to twitter . No. I didnt ask for clearance on my document before, during or after i used it. Do you feel like you either broke a rule in the senate, a rule of that committee or are you in Good Standing to post those . I question the legitimacy of deis ination of confidentiality. After i used the document i said i defy anybody to conclude that this document should even be deemed confidential. By the way, the entire process of deeming thousands of thousands of documents confidential was named by this guy named bill burke. Who the hell he is. Hes a confidant of judge kavanaugh. So i think the whole process of not even legitimate and so i proceed use my document without asking for clearance. Dont you think, senator, though respectfully that as long as the rules are in place they ought to be followed and that theres a process. Same way cory booker got his documents cleared before he posted them. There was a process for designating these documents and that process was not followed at all. So we all acknowledge that. They are just trying to, as i say in hawaii cover their at this point. Do you think its a senator dangerous precedent to violate that rule on your own to go out i wont recognize the confidentiality. What happens if it happens to you or other democrats the next time. It was a dangerous precedent to allow thousands of documents to be hidden from the American Public using a process thats not legitimate. If we could have come together as was done in the past it would have been okay. Thats not what happened at all. If they want to expell me because i havent followed the socalled rule, then they should do that. But they are trying very hard now to, after the fact, say that my document had been cleared. You know what . Theres only one person who would have asked that very specific document relating to judge kavanaughs attitude about native hawaiians and that person would have been me and i certainly did not ask for clearance before, during or after. David ignatius is with us. Ask another question. David ignatius. Senator, i want to ask you whether you think judge kavanaughs basic credibility has been wounded by information thats come out in some of these documents . It seems that in past hearings he denied that he had been involved in confirmation of judge pryor, for example and documents that show he was involved. He denied he was involved in the case of somebody named Manuel Miranda and the documents shoefs. Is that hurting his credibility, do you think . As far as im concerned there are all these questions as to how forthcoming he was in his prior testimony in 2006. I wasnt here then. Im focused on his dissents which shows a pattern hes very much against womens reproductive rights and cases he definitely has a pattern, and i think it was a blinking red light. It doesnt matter to me that he never had a discussion now about the Mueller Investigation, but it was a blinking red light when he wrote that a sitting president should not be subject to either criminal or civil proceedings. Thats a huge red light to this president who is all about protecting himself. All right. One quick question. Senator, we have a split screen up here with cory booker and kirk douglas. Do you see still ahead on morning joe we showed you that moment from wednesdays hearing where Brett Kavanaugh struggled to answer whether he discussed bob mueller or the russian probe with somebody from a law firm linked to donald trump. Kavanaugh was asked about that again yesterday and it took a long time to get an answer. Thats next on morning joe. M Small Business, never owned a business. Are your hours small . What about your reputation . Is that small . Owning your own thing is huge. Your partnerships, even bigger. With dell Small Business technology advisors, you get the oneonone partnership to grow your business. Because the only one who decides how big your business can be, is you. The dell vostro 14 laptop with 8th gen intel core processors. Get up to 40 off on select pcs. Call 877buydell today. but one blows them all out of the water. Hydro boost from neutrogena®. With hyaluronic acid to plump skin cells so it bounces back. Neutrogena® how much more does Congress Need to see . Donald trump has now been implicated in two felony crimes, and hes all but confessed to them on fox news. No one is above the law, so we have to make sure this president doesnt use pardons to cover up crimes. If you agree that a president should not be allowed to pardon himself or his associates, join us at needtoimpeach. Com. The washington establishment doesnt have the courage to act, but the American People can. Takes more than just investment advice. From insurance to savings to retirement, it takes someone with experience and knowledge who can help me build a complete plan. Brian, my certified financial planner™ professional, is committed to working in my best interest. I call it my comfortable future plan, and its all possible with a cfp® professional. Find your certified financial planner™ professional at letsmakeaplan. Org. Find your certified financial planner™ professional have you discussed mueller or his investigation with anyone at the law firm founded by Mark Kasowitz, President Trumps personal lawyer . Be sure about your answer, sir. Um, well, im not remembering but if you have something you want to are you certain youve not had a conversation with anyone at that law firm . The law firm founded by Mark Kasowitz who is President Trumps personal lawyer. Have you had any conversation about Robert Mueller or his investigation with anyone at that firm . Yes or no . Well, is there a person youre talking about im asking you a very direct question. Yes or no. I need to know im not sure i know everyone at that person at that law firm. Who did you talk to . Im not remembering. But im happy to be refreshed or sir, are your saying that with all that you remember, you have an impeccable memory. Youve been speaking for eight hours about all sorts of things you remember. How can you not remember whether or not you had a conversation about Robert Mueller or his investigation with anyone at that law firm. The investigation has only been going on for so long, sir. Im trying to think do i know anyone who works at that firm. Thats not my question. My question is have you had a conversation with anyone at that firm about the investigation. Its a really specific question . I would like to know the person youre thinking of because what if i think youre thinking of somebody and you dont want to tell us. Wow that was part of a long exchange on wednesday between senator harris and President Trumps Supreme Court nominee Brett Kavanaugh. The two went at it again yesterday. Yes or no, have you ever been part of a conversation with lawyers at the firm of kasowitz, be benson, torres, where you ever part of a conversation. I didnt ask what did you say. Im asking were you a party to a conversation that occurred regarding special counsel muellers investigation and a simple yes or no is suffice. About his investigation, are you referring to a specific person . Im referring to a specific subject and the specific person im referring to is you. No, who was the conversation with . You said you had information. That is not the subject of the question, sir. Okay. The subject is you and whether you were part of a conversation regarding special counsel muellers investigation. The answer is no. Thank you. It would have been great if could you have said that last night. Kavanaugh finally acknowledged knowing kasowitz attorney from their time together in the Bush Administration but denied he had any contact with the firm regarding the Mueller Probe or prep for his confirmation hearing. That was really strange. How does he not know . Suspicious. Is it . Joining us now its obvious. Come on, this guy first of all, the Judiciary Committee democratic senator Richard Blumenthal is here on the set, msnbc chief Legal Correspondent is here. Senator, hold one second. I want to clear something up with ari. Ari, yesterday, hes asked about the kasowitz firm. He goes with kasowitz and then hes saying im trying to remember if i knew anybody all right. I never worked in the washington legal community. But i know it is a tight legal community. Everybody knows everybody. Kavanaugh has been inside, been swimming in that very small fish bowl for what, three decades. He clearly knows that his friend worked at kasowitz. He knows what the firm kasowitz. He knows about the firm. Yesterday he pretended like he said kaso what like he didnt know. I dont know, im trying to be if i know anybody in that firm. He worked with in the Bush Administration. Its a friend of his. Thats exactly right. One way to say is it is gentleman kavanaugh is too smart to play that dumb and shouldnt take 15 minutes and two days of rlg testimony. Hes finally said on the record a no. So thats useful. Thats why we have these hearings. The other point ill make that viewers can forget theres a thing in court called ex parte communications. Judges are highly restricted and regulated how they do that. If theres one thing they remember as something as big as the Mueller Probe potential one side or private communications with a lawyer where he said he didnt have. Especially if youre on the short list. The federalist short list to be a Supreme Court nominee. Senator, the judges that at least the judges i spent my 20s and 30s around, you ask them a question about a case like that, they would know. Did you ever talk about the Mueller Investigation, the most important investigation going on in america, judge, with a lawyer in a law firm that represents the president of the United States, every judge ive ever known would say, this is the answer no, of course i wouldnt. Even the question is an insult to the integrity of most judges. And yet Brett Kavanaugh and im not you know, im just stating what every lawyer knows, Brett Kavanaugh takes him two days to figure out whether he had an extraordinarily inappropriate conversation with somebody in the president s firm. Lawyers are very, very careful about their contacts with judges, and vice versa. Judges are extraordinarily circumspect and they are equally careful in talking to lawyers and in my questions to him yesterday he acknowledged knowing only one lawyer at that firm ed mcnally, but equally important he was ambiguous in stating whether he discussed the special counsel with anyone in the white house. And i asked him specifically about his potential conversations on the special counsel. He said i never had an inappropriate conversation, but he wouldnt be more specific about what he has discussed on the special counsel. Likewise, he evaded questions about whether he would pardon the president. He refused to say he would recuse himself even though hes been nominated bay president who is an unindicted coconspirator. I asked if he would not sit on issues involving the president s personal criminal or civil liability. He refused to say he would take himself off those case. He refused to say he would enforce a subpoena against the president which is more and more timely in light of the president s increasing resistance to this investigation. Senator, its willie geist. I know you have concerns about judge kavanaughs views on president ial powers but whether or not he spoke to an attorney at the Kasowitz Law Firm could loom large what happens with the Mueller Investigation, what the outcome is, whether it comes before the Supreme Court in some shape or form. Do you think this is a question worth pursuing further. Would you want to get documents from kasowitz and see if there was a phone call or emails . We need those documents. We need to make sure we find them. They are probably among documents that have been withheld from us, if they do exist. And we need to pursue them. Im doing so through a freedom of information act request that i filed. We may need to go to a court to enforce it next week. And certainly it taught be pursued. And youre absolutely right, the Mark Kasowitz firm is front and center in this investigation. Senator, i want to ask you about what Rudy Giuliani has been saying over the last day or so with regards to the Mueller Investigation, whether or not the president will submit to an interview, whether hell do it through written questions, whether hell allow a followup interview after the written questions. Do you believe that the president and bob mueller in some shape or form will sit down with one another, at least talk through the written word . Rudy giuliani had moved the goal post repeatedly saying what the conditions are, what the time and circumstances are in setting for any potential conversation. More and more im of the view that there needs be a subpoena that would have to be enforced and thats why this nominees views on president ial power and his doubling down on the idea that the president can refuse to enforce a law nullified in effect, deem it unconstitutional even after its upheld by the court and refuse to obey a subpoena are more and more alarming at a time when we face this impending constitutional crisis because of a president who is amoral. Do you think mueller will talk to the president at some point . He has to talk to the president to complete this investigation. Senator Richard Blumenthal as always thanks so much for being with us. Ari, a lot of concern right now among democrats in the senate that kavanaugh would vote against Robert Mueller being able to compel the president to testify. Got to say, i find it hard to believe, though, that john roberts, a man who believes his duty, his responsibility is to protect the institution of the Supreme Court would yield so much power to the executive branch and you wouldnt have john roberts and perhaps one other republican appointed judge compel the president to testify under oath when a subpoena is delivered to him. Well, joe, i dont want to scandalize your knowledge of washington, but i think the mueller part of these hearings and i was down there for a couple of days has more politics than the law. The roe v wade conversation has more law than politics in that what this hearing has unearthed is that you have someone who is giving private, very pro life advice to a pro Life Administration which underscores he might be a pro life judge. People can decide whether thats good or bad. On mueller part theres far less evidence he would be radical in that way, because theres just isnt much evidence at all. Theres a law article thats fascinating. Evidence of some partisanship, shocking that a little judge that was appointed by the Trump Administration has some partisanship. We dont know. We have to be fair about that. You look at the balance on the court. If you had a clintonlike situation that went with a grand jury subpoena to the court, it would be a big case but i think theres a lot of reasons why the court might want to rule backing up u. S. V nixon that no president is above the law. I find it hard they would not. Kavanaugh would act, we dont know. But the trump team, giuliani camp believes they are very confident in this. They have said repeatedly and again another effort to sort of perhaps taunt mueller they are looking for that subpoena. Thats a fight giuliani said they would welcome. They believe they would win on legal merits and predated the kavanaugh pick and certainly only grown more confident since. Despite the fact though, David Ignatius, that it was Rudy Giuliani himself who said during the clinton impeachment no man is above the law. If youre subpoenaed you have to answer that subpoena and testify. You know, the way in which giuliani has played this almost defying the mueller and the courts, i think it has to offend chief justice roberts. Everything we know about him, shows that he takes the courts role seriously. I must say in all the kavanaugh hearings the thing that bothers he in most was his refusal to criticize Donald Trumps remarks in particular about Justice Ruth Baden Ginsburg where he said in a tweet a couple of years ago her mind is shot. We remember that neil gorsuch during his confirmation hearings very specifically said he thought trumps comments about the judiciary were disheartening. Yes he did. Couldnt be more specific. Thats what kavanaugh has not done. That bugs me. Actually, its like watching paul ryan or some of the republicans on capitol hill where they are pretending that something isnt happening. When you get a question, susan, thats so obviously connected to todays events and can a president pardon himself, obviously, obviously kavanaugh knows what hes being asked about. Of course. Its frustrating to watch him dodge and i worry about a loyalty oath. I mean i cant imagine. But i wonder. I will say in the age of trump you cant actually put anything out of your mind. I certainly think theres merit to that but i also think when we look at this hearing it seemed like it was certain senators looking for their spartacus moment. It was politicized. Some senators wouldnt meet with kavanaugh. I can understand why they have problems. But at the same time this seems more like a political exercise. It was a political circus. I do want to follow up on something that david said where he said, couldnt believe that john roberts wouldnt be offended by what donald trump has said over the past year and half about socalled judges and questioning the authority of federal judges. You know, i talked to federal judges, ive talked to family members of federal judges who have said conservative federal judges, Federalist Society type federal judges have been deeply offended by Donald Trumps attacks on the independence of the judiciary. Ill say it again today. Rudy giuliani does not want to challenge the Supreme Court on this subpoena because hell lose and i dont think it will be close. Yeah. Thank you. Thank you. Great to see you. Still ahead the midterm races are all locked up in several states that President Trump won by double digits in the 2016 election. Well dig into the new numbers next on morning joe. Come with us to a new world deeper than the ocean as unfathomable as the universe a world that doesnt exist outside you, but within you where breakthrough science is replacing chemotherapy with immunotherapy where we can now attack the causes of disease not just the symptoms. Where medicines once produced for all, are now designed to fit you. Today, 140,000 biopharmaceutical researchers go boldly to discover treatments and cures unimaginable ten years ago and theyre on the verge of more tomorrow. But allstate actually helps you drive safely. With drivewise. It lets you know when you go too fast. And brake too hard. With feedback to help you drive safer. Giving you the power to actually lower your cost. Unfortunately, it cant do anything about that. Now that you know the truth. Are you in good hands . Lets do an ad of a man eating free waffles at comfort inn. They taste like victory because he always gets the lowest price on our rooms, guaranteed, when he books direct at choicehotels. Com. Or just say badda book, badda boom. Book now at choicehotels. Com. New polling shows close races in states where President Trump won. The nbc news marist poll in u. S. Tennessee senate shows the democrat, Phil Bredesen backed by 48 while mash shah blackburn gets 46 . Donald trump won the state by 26 points in 2016. Lets stop right there. Of course, the headline out of that poll still bredesens Approval Ratings, crazy. What were they like 6020. Avenues popular governor. Mayor of the city of nashville, state of tennessee likes him. The fact that donald trump won by 26 points obviously significant. Theres sympathy for trump. If you run the right candidate against Phil Bredesen, can you overcome the trump sympathy. Hes the ideal in a year where the democratic enthusiasm is as high as it is, tennessee is a red state but Phil Bredesen is a democrat that he can draw a lot of votes in that state. Hes maybe the only available democratic candidate who would be running this strong but the perfect candidate for this year in this race. The race for georgias governor is a dead heat. A new poll found republican secretary of skate brian kemp and exstate legislator stacy abrams had a 45 each. 8 of likely voters are undecided. 51 of likely georgia voters disapprove of the job the president is doing. 42 approve. Are you surprised by those numbers no. For two reasons. Stacy abrams, an incredible race with the florida race well have so much focus on florida and georgia because they are very similar in their historic potential for candidates and trumpy republican rivals but georgia, as you know, is not like tennessee. Georgia is a state thats becoming increasingly blue and thats a state because of the growth of suburbs around atlanta that strong africanamerican vote. Theres going to be an africanamerican georgia governor soon and it could be stacy abrams. Cal perry traveled to texas. You probably saw that video. Nfl video from beto discussing kneeling controversy something that may have had an effect foj which shows a dead heat in the state of texas. Many in the Democratic Party are hoping that the congressman becomes a face for the future. He recently competed a 34 day road 34day road trip and we caught up with him on his trip getting a look at the life of a democratic running in texas with the ever present sound track of texas political radio. He is hip, cool, ted cruz isnt hip and cool. His new trick is to go to those places, haul a rally, get people to show you and say the things they like to hear. I am concerned about the polls. I dont necessarily know where theyre polling people at. There are people coming out in el paso. There are people coming out in ft. Davis. I dont see one ted cruz. I see bato signs. Im concerned if ted cruz really wants to win this race, where are his people at . You go to some of the reddest places in texas, places like abilene, you and you can see it from outer space. There is something very special happening in texas right now. Now, it may be reflected in the polls. Ive talked to a lot of people and nobody i have ever even talked to, ive never met one person who has been polled. Who are they polling, the Illegal Immigrants . To everyone in this community who gave me a chance to succeed, i want to tell you, im going to make the absolute most of it right now. Three minutes after the hour, Robert Francis orourke, better known as beto, feels its very american to take a knee. I can think of nothing more american than to peacefully stand up or take a knee for your rights anytime anywhere any place. So thank you very much for asking the question. How about ted cruz attacking you on what you said about the nfl . No, my comments speak for themselves. It doesnt appear that Robert Francis beto hurt himself with the ramblings on and on and on about theres nothing more american than taking a knee. As a matter of fact, it looks like it might have helped him. Who are these people . Were american, you know . We should be able to if you want to kneel, be able to kneel. And if you dont want to kneel, you want to stand up, go ahead and stand up. Orourke, otherwise known as robert orourke, do you really think youre going to win with your hispanderring . Why beto and not ted cruz . Ted cruz has been out there for a long time and he hasnt really represented anybody, especially when it comes to hispanics, it hasnt stood up for what hispanics are for. So, you know, look, if i hear one more democratic operative either in the state or nationally say if were at least competitive in texas, thats like a win, im going to lose my mind. A win is a win. Watch the hearing and tell me if we get close its a win. Ive been saying for 15 years, pennsylvania is always fools gold for republicans and elections. Donald trump of all people, why pennsylvania . Maybe beto wins pennsylvania, but i mean, texas, but this sounds an awful lot like the talk we heard about wendy davis, profile on the front cover of the New York Times magazine. The darling the rock star. The east coast press. The rock star. The darling of hollywood. And she got absolutely hammered there because its a conservative republican state. Ted cruz will do anything to win this race. If hes got to embrace donald trump at a rally next month, hell do it. So the Democratic Party needs to get serious. He has a young, experienced staff. The democratic nominee for the state, democrat lupe valdez who also going by sheriff for a reason. Yes. I was the sheriff of Dallas County for 13 years. Usz this race is an uphill battle. Why . It is, but its not an impossible battle. Lets think about the woman who has to work two jobs to make ends meet. Think about the people in the rural desert. All these folks are interested in having changes made. Were continuously bringing the message out. You say its a red state. I say its a nonvoting state. Were 49th in the people coming out to vote. So what we have to do is bring out the vote. And we have a fighting chance. Which is what i want for all of texas. So change the turnout, change the color. Sheriff, inmate heilman has a question. Well, its been the case in texas theres been successive cycles where democrats have saying, you know what . Texas is on the brink of going blue. Clearly, texas will be california some number of years from now. It will be a blue state because of the changes in demographics. But are we there yet . And what do democrats have to do . What they failed to do with wendy davis was to get a lot of hispanic voters to vote. How is that going to be different in 2018 . Two things. You just saw in abilene, texas, you have this problem. We went at 2 00 in an afternoon on a monday and there was a crowd there. I thought i was going to be talking to the democrats in a phone booth, you know . 12 or so. There was 60, 70, at 2 00 in the afternoon on monday with two days notice that we were going come back. Theres changes happening in texas. Were willing to help the Tipping Point because poorest neighborhood in san antonio became the sheriff of Dallas County for 13 years. Thats an opportunity, a path. We need to do that for the rest of texas. We got more numbers yesterday about children separated from their families along the border. How prominently is that issue which is a National Issue playing in your race . Well, i bring it out quite a bit. Texans do have a heart. And this is what i am saying to all of us. The rest of the u. S. Is getting the wrong impression of texas because certain people are making the cry. You know, theres a lot of really decent, good people with a heart in texas. And i constantly bring it out. And the cheers are continually there for that. So i think changes is in play this year and were going to make the difference to cause that change. Sheriff lupe valdez, shes candidate for governor of texas. Thank you very, very much for being on this morning. Thank you. Kyle perry, thank you, as well. Coming up, the white house is on a tear to find the anonymous official who wrote that explosive op ed in the New York Times. Willie knows who it is. It could be so many people and there are denials of who it could have been and yet everyone is denying theyre the author. Well go live to california ahead of President Trumps first big rally before the midterms. Morning joe is coming right back. Im ken jacobus, im the owner of good start packaging. We distribute environmentallyfriendly packaging for restaurants. And weve grown substantially. So i switched to the spark cash card from capital one. I earn unlimited 2 cash back on everything i buy. And last year, i earned 36,000 in cash back. Thats right, 36,000. Which i used to offer Health Insurance to my employees. My unlimited 2 cash back is more than just a perk, its our healthcare. Can i say it . Whats in your wallet . Ill tell you what, this man has fought, in more ways than one, for your state pep has fought for your state. Greg gianforte, he is a fighter and a winner. Hes a winner. You know you were waiting to make your decision about health care until you saw the bill and it just came out. Well talk to you about that later. Yeah, theres no Time Partnership just im sick and tired of you guys. The last time i did this, you said the same thing. Get the hell out of here. Get the hell out of here. The last time you did the same thing. You are the guardian . Yes. And you just broke my glasses. The last guy did the same thing. A fighter and a winner if youre talking about beating up reporters. Thats not right. Assault charges. And then that guy behind the president got removed because he wasnt clapping. You must clap. Good morning, everyone. President trump last night praising the montana congressman who pleaded guilty last year to physically assaulting a reporter on the eve of the election. Hes a fighter. Yeah, not really. Welcome to morning joe. I noticed you guys arent clapping hard enough. Its friday, september 7th. Joe, natalie and me and David Ignatius. Elegant. A lot to talk about. Its a who done it in the white house and you think about it, its like playing trump at his own game. This person who was the anonymous author of im not listening to you. This person is creating this big reveal. You know what joe is focused on right now, nobody cares about donald trump right now. He was a big deal. When you were a young man and you saw the reaction of the women folk the women folk, yes. To Burt Reynolds in playgirl magazine, did you not think to yourself, i want to grow up to be Burt Reynolds . No. Yes, i know you did. You wanted to be the bandit. I dont know. So you we were hearing you as we were coming in here. Because youre so loud. And you i think you need to do it. Whenever i called you, i told you, you know, about Burt Reynolds he broke the news to me about Burt Reynolds passing. Its sort of like where were you when you heard about pearl harbor. Where are you you immediately went to smokey and the bandit. First hour of the morning. So burt starred in 90 movies, 300 television shows. Thats how he got his start. Amazing. I was on deliverance. I saw that. My parents, strict southern baptists, would go to church four times a week, would go sunday morning, we would go sunday night to trading union, tuesday night bible study, wednesday night friday night sometimes family night. But somewhere in the middle of all that, when i was 9 years old, my father took my brother and sister and i to the longest yard. Wow. At 9 years old. And when i went back to school in mississippi and told them that i saw rrated the longest yard, i was the coolest kid in school for about 15 minutes. You worn what tnder what the influences are on the man that will some day be your husband. It warped me. He filled this really interesting place in american popular culture. Its hard for people now to remember. He was extraordinarily huge. Huge, yeah. And he was just a fun guy, no worries about him. But it sort of became i dont know if a parody or a self parody was better. But then in 97 web did boogie nights. And suddenly its like when travolta went back and he did pulp fiction. People looked at Burt Reynolds and said, man, that guy can act. I was doing an interview with him and he said after he did boogie nights, he realized i should have taken his acting more seriously. He was great in deliverance. He went through a period of smokey and the bandit, cannon ball run. But then he came back years later after a down period in the 80s and 90s and did boogie nights and he was phenomenal in that movie. He was great. Also in that period, he was omnipresent on american movie screens. He would have three or four Burt Reynolds movies on at the same time. Everywhere, five years between 78 and 82, Burt Reynolds was the worlds highest grossing movie star and i mean, just some iconic roles. Really iconic roles. Theres a snl parity. When he got at the gum smauking detachment, cool of Burt Reynolds where he turned down roles, he turned down james bond what . He turned down han solo. Michael corleone. Sounds hard. One flew over the coocoos nest. Turned down die hard. And, actually, phil wanted him to be morning burt and he decided to turn this role down, as well. More news now. The white house continues to hunt for the Anonymous Administration official behind that scathing New York Times op ed. The times reports that white house officials have been calling around asking cabinet secretaries if they are responsible. So far, every cabinet official has issued a denial. Everyone with the exception of chief of staff john kelly and attorney general Jeff Sessions referred to referred nbc news to the statement from Sarah Sanders that calls the anonymous official a coward. Sanders also denies reports that aides are printing out and delivering the denials to the president directly. My god. She posted the phone number to the New York Times opinion desk and urged people to call in and demand the paper to reveal the writer. Senator rand paul reportedly recommended members of the administration be subjected to lie detector tests and by the way, rand paul, mr. Civil libertarian come on now. Haul them down and strap them. Wow, automatic. There was at least some discussion about that among the president s advisers, as well. They also reportedly discussed asking senior officials to sign sworn affidavits that could be used in court if necessary. All right. One outside adviser tells the paper the white house has a list of about 12 so lets talk about that. Willie, we talk about this yesterday. If youre the New York Times and youre the editor and somebody comes to you with Something Like this that is this significant, it cant be an assistant to an assistant at the national because they know that hes going to get its going to be the Vice President or its got to be nikki haley or the secretary i mean, is it only seven or eight officials at the New York Times you would ever grant right . Can we expect if its not theyre not going down. I know Linda Mcmahon denied it yesterday, but theyre not i mean, you would hope the times would say its mattis or kelly or, you know, keep it pretty tight. The term they used again was senior official in the Trump Administration. Not senior white house official. So that broadens it out even more than the people you are talking about who are that close to the president on a daily basis. But, yeah, i think, you know, if theyre going to try to go find this person and they feel like they vnts found them yet when you look at that list of 27 people, it starts to look like it may not be one of those headliners were talking about. So then the editors were asked on their own pod cast the daily yesterday if they could narrow it down. What does it mean to call someone a senior official and they wouldnt do that because they thought it would she too revealing. I guess the answer is we may not know for a very long time who this certain is. Im with joe on this. Theres a key element to this. Is the assertion that cabinet officials were discussing invoking the 25th amendment. So any cabinet secretary would be in a position to know about that. I think youre right, that the times, because of the gravity of this, would probably not extend anonymity to a junior official, knot nor would a junior official be in a position to reliably report a story like this, which is what that is, reporting that there had been discussions of that kind. So i think youre talking about, logically, someone who is a principal, whether thats a cabinet secretary or a senior white house official, someone who is im not casting suspicion on someone like ahead of the nec, ahead of the nsc, but you would have to be, for the times to extend, i would think logically there would have to be someone that senior and it would comport with the notion it would have to be someone that senior to reliably assert those discussions had taken place in the administration. That wouldnt away junior official at the Veterans Affairs department. It would be in no position to know about those things. You would hope not. David, weve heard quite a few people saying so far that the real news of this isnt who wrote it. Exactly. But the fact that a thousand people in the administration kwo could have wrote it. If you have been in washington, d. C. , this sort of talk loosely in ee lead circles in policy leaders from day one. I think that is the one although we have this list of denials, the fact that its known that there are many, id say, a half dozen or more people who have been doing what this op ed describes, have been trying to steer policy in a way that it wouldnt be damaged by the whims and impulsive decisions of the president. That tells us that the if a no one n phenomenon in the piece is real. It underlines something we sort of knew, but it drives it home. Trumps rage at this is part of a rage that he doesnt fully control and hasnt for months. I think the question is how much damage this crazy period Bob Woodwards book called it crazy town. Living in crazy town after a while gets exhausting and disorienting. That is what washington has felt like. People are obsessed with this game that people are making bets with bookies. I mean, what a crazy situation. Crazy. And the question is how are we going to get out of that. Stilt ahead, the pick for who may have authored that anonment op ed. This is a story about mail and packages. And its also a story about people. People who rely on us every day to deliver their dreams theyre handing us more than mail theyre handing us their business and while we make more ecommerce deliveries to homes than anyone else in the country, we never forget. That your business is our business the United States postal service. Priority you with my bladder leakage, the products ive tried just didnt fit right. They were very saggy. Its getting in the way of our camping trips. But with new sizes, depend fitflex is made for me. Introducing more sizes for better comfort. New depend fitflex underwear is guaranteed to be your best fit. Dinner date. Meeting his parents dinner date. Why did i want a crest 3d white smile . So i used crest. Crest 3d white removes. 95 of surface stains in just 3 days. For a whiter smile. That will win them over. Crest. Healthy, beautiful smiles for life. Takes more than just investment advice. From insurance to savings to retirement, it takes someone with experience and knowledge who can help me build a complete plan. Brian, my certified financial planner™ professional, is committed to working in my best interest. I call it my comfortable future plan, and its all possible with a cfp® professional. Find your certified financial planner™ professional at letsmakeaplan. Org. You always get the lowest price on our rooms, guaranteed . Lets say it in a really low voice. Carl . Lowest price, guaranteed. Just stick with badda book. Badda boom. Book now at choicehotels. Com come fly with me, lets fly, lets fly away. To take care of yourself. But natures bounty has innovative ways to help you maintain balance and help keep you active and wellrested. Because hey, tomorrows coming up fast. Natures bounty. Because youre better off healthy. We have figured out who is the anonymous op ed writer. Shi wife detected a feminine tone in the op ed and she suggested charlie suggested it was Kellyanne Conway. And i had not even contemplated that. I was more in the dan coats mode on the outside of this. But the more you think about it, it makes some sense. Shes very cagey. Shes the kind of person that would find out that mike pence would use the word lodstar a lot. Plus, shes trying to set herself up to by the carva madeleine of the future. This is a good set up. We have evidence of this, donnie, because at the end of the campaign, she would in the green room and around the set talk about how she couldnt wait for the campaign to go over. She did have that side of her. She used the word daytona beach. I was doing the show with you on that day on the break and she said what are you doing . She said its like a vacation at daytona beach. Its like being on the beach with all the kids. And i agree. Who is cunning and clever enough to use the pence word and who in the Trump Administration has the most to lose . Theyll all go back to their political worlds, but if you or somebody who wants to be on television, in the Communications World, whatnot, you really have to reinvent yourself. Mike pompeo does not have to reinvent himself. Look at others that have left the white house. Except for one or two, they aint working in washington any more. Theyve destroyed their reputations. They might as well go back home. Because no administration will ever hire them again. Is and to your thing about junior staffers, it takes of sophistication to go to the New York Times, negotiate this kind of a thing, execute a really well written op ed. Some with communications skills, someone who can write, someone who knows their way around the New York Times and around the media world, it makes sense if its her. Have somebody pull her denial yesterday which is not in the category of denials where shes trashing the person. Its a denial, but its a pretty soft denial. You can make the case for a lot of these splashy big names, headliners. Ill maintain that its a name that is not a household name, somebody that you wouldnt recognize if you heard, but who does hold some power within the Trump Administration, but not a household name. When you say some conversations you had, you mean not just conversation with random people on the street. No, no, with people who may be familiar. But, again, its all speculation. But unless youre one of the editors at the New York Times, you dont know. So i think your idol speculation is not kellyanne. Respectfully, i do. Now donnie is going to speak. A lot of people are complaining about the anonymity. I think theyre smart. If the person had come forward, the discussion would have been all about lets say it was jim kelly. Well, hes a drunk or as opposed to the content, it would have been about the person and it would have played right into what trump does and he would pick up his gun and say of course this person said that. I mocked him in a meeting last week. I disagree with you in the sense that i think if it comes out and its not a top 20 names, i think the times will have a lot of explaining to do. And if if i am an editor and i am the farthest thing from an editor of the New York Times, i want to know when and if and it will come out and thats auto name weve heard. Morning joe is back in a moment. Us. Its what this country is made of. But right now, our bond is fraying. How do we get back to us . The y fills the gaps. And bridges our divides. Donate to your local y today. Because where theres a y, theres an us. Ayep, and my teeth are yellow. . Time for whitestrips. Crest glamorous White Whitestrips are the only adaaccepted whitening strips proven to be safe and effective. And they whiten 25x better than a leading whitening toothpaste. Crest. Healthy, beautiful smiles for life. vo ovewhelming air fresheners can send you running. So try febreze one. With no aerosols and no heavy perfumes. So you can spray and stay. Febreze one. Theres nothing small about your business. With dell Small Business technology advisors, you get the oneonone partnership to grow your business. The dell vostro 14 laptop. Get up to 40 off on select pcs. Call 877buydell today. call 877buydell today. This wifi is fast. I know i know i know i know when did brian move back in . Brians back . He doesnt get my room. Hes only going to be here for like a week. Like a month, tops. Oh boy. Wifi fast enough for the whole family is simple, easy, awesome. In many cultures, young men would stay with their families until their 40s. Lets go to eugene robinson. Youre article were in a constitutional rye sis only voters can save us now. Trumps voters pretend there is a normal president in the white house instead of, lets be honest, a maniac. They know the risk is nation is running. They have the power to alleviate that risk, but they do nothing. Instead, counting on mature adults in the administration to keep trump from plunging the nation off some cliff. The writesel blower wrote there were early whispers within the cabinet of invoked the 25th amendment. But it is clear we are in a situation of constitutional crisis. Voters are the last line of defense. You must say the day. Wouldnt we be in a constitutional crisis, gene, if all the institutions that were set in place to check the president s power were not checking the president s power . Well, you know, the thing is, its all written down, right . Congress is supposed to handle a situation like this. And so congress could be doing serious oversight and Serious Investigation. And if necessary, you know, leading to the logical conclusion this it could be commenting impeachment or the cabinet could have more serious discussions about the 25th amendment. But there is this weird dichotomy. As David Ignatius pointed out a while ago, things in the country are pretty good. Right now. But, on the other hand, we are one step way from being at war in venezuela or from precipitating some sort of military meltdown in pakistan or but wouldnt the constitutional crisis begin when an erratic move made by the president . Yeah. Im arguing that perhaps were not in a constitutional crisis right now, but we may be a step or two away. What is erratic . A sweet is not a constitutional crisis. No, but the failure, i believe, of the institution that ought to be acting, the failure of congress to at least confront honestly the situation were in now in terms of the executive branch, i think is a crisis. And i think and i think its dangerous. Its dangerous for the country, its damaging for the country and and for the presidency. I think vote erts ners need that. Coming up, president obama is hitting the campaign trail tomorrow. How can we say when you book direct at choicehotels. Com you always get the lowest price on our rooms, guaranteed . Lets say it in a really low voice. Carl . Lowest price, guaranteed. Just stick with badda book. Badda boom. Book now at choicehotels. Com i couldnt catch my breath. It was the last song of the night. It felt like my heart was skipping beats. They said i had afib. Whats afib . I knew that meant i was at a greater risk of stroke. I needed answers. My doctor and i chose xarelto® to help keep me protected from a stroke. Oncedaily xarelto®, a latestgeneration blood thinner significantly lowers the risk of stroke in people with afib not caused by a heart valve problem. Warfarin interferes with at least 6 of your bodys natural bloodclotting factors. Xarelto® is selective, targeting just one critical factor. For afib patients well managed on warfarin, there is limited information on how xarelto® compares in reducing the risk of stroke. Dont stop taking xarelto® without talking to your doctor, as this may increase your risk of stroke. While taking, you may bruise more easily, or take longer for bleeding to stop. Xarelto® can cause serious, and in rare cases, fatal bleeding. It may increase your risk of bleeding if you take certain medicines. Get help right away for unexpected bleeding or unusual bruising. Do not take xarelto® if you have an artificial heart valve or abnormal bleeding. Before starting, tell your doctor about all planned medical or dental procedures and any kidney or liver problems. Learn all you can to help protect yourself from a stroke. Talk to your doctor about xarelto®. To help protect yourself from a stroke. Whats going on . Oh hey thats it . Yeah. Thats it . Everybody two seconds dear sebastian, after careful consideration of your application, it is with great pleasure that we offer our congratulations on your acceptance. Through the Tuition Assistance program, every day mcdonalds helps more people go to college. Its part of our commitment to being americas best first job. So is this a Christmas Present or a birthday present . Whats further away . Christmas. Its been a long time. Its belated. John highlyman bought me a president for something. Thats nice. Ive never given joe a present ever before. So this was the cumulative present all wrapped up into one. And some people say they give me a gift and i get a tie. Just dont buy me presents, okay . Dont buy me presents. Just love one another. And but you found this is e the as mike pence would say, this is the loadstar here, my friend. This is an official 1973 original 6, i believe. No, 1973 is when band on the run came out. Please, all things mccartney, just defer to me. Paul mccartney, band on the run and by the way, ive got to say, the back, it was recorded in lagos, nigeria. And heilman and i, he recorded it. His band basically left him. He flew down with denny, linda. They go to lagos, record his greatest album. And basically, were going to write a book about this. Its one of the most extraordinary days in rock history and it comes on the day, heilman that Paul Mccartney is releasing his 17th solo album today called egypt station and hes going to have some Live Streaming event somewhere in new york. Yeah. I have to say, the funny thing about this, ive been trying to give this shirt to joe all summer. You may be aware, joe has not been in the studio that much in the last what . Hes been here. And the most important thing hes not been here all that often. So its not like i timed it like that. And if you smell it, you can tell he only fell asleep wait, important distinction, you say that is an original . It comes from 1973 . That is an original. Dont let go of my tshirt. God, man. The numbers are better than expected. The august payroll numbers coming out, a little better unanimous expected, 201,000 jobs added in the month of august. A little higher, although june and july revised down, unemployment at 3. 9 . Ill give you the good news which is maybely a loadstar for average earnings rose 10 cents, above 7 cents in july. We know is economy is strong. Theres more open jobs than unemployed people. Finally, wages are beginning slowly but surely to reflect that. Thats what we want to see is not just a tight labor market, but a tight labor market that turns into people getting paid more for the job. I know Joe Scarborough is wildly underpaid. So a better than expected call it a economy on the run. 201,000, guys. Quit that second job, willie. Thank you, brian. Oh, my gosh. Thank you, brian. Joining us now hugo gordon and the president and ceo of the mecino group, a former Deputy White House chief of staff and Campaign Manager for president Barack Obamas 2012 reelection campaign, jim macina back with us. Good to have you. So we want to go back row, but lets go microin a couple of races. Weve got some barn burners for historic reasons, possibly the first black governor in georgia, the firsts black governor in florida. At the same time going running against two dyed in the wool trumpists. Its about as big of a divide you can get. Both of those races look like barn burners. What should we expect . I think youre going to see incredible turnout. What youre seeing on these local elections is unexpected democratic turnout that is above any models that people are putting together. So the question is that versus a historic nature of these candidacies. But youre still talking about, especially in georgia, a red state, a state that is turning blue but may not be blue yet. I think both of those races and, you know, youre from florida. You know how much im obsessed with florida politics. No one, no one you know thought that an rue gillman was going win that primary. He was in fourth place in every poll. That goes back to my theory about why all polls suck. Now hes the democratic nominee and now no one knows how this general election will play out. It is the obama formula. Nobody can replicate it. But you have white progressives that usually white costal progressives who are culturally disconnected from rank and file black democratic voters. And then you have other candidates that are supposed to do better and bringing out the vote for minorities. But here, in georgia and florida, you really could put together the Obama Coalition of really high turnout, black voters as well as getting those progressives out. It looks like this year, at least, thats a big take away for democrats. Its very true. And its one of the gifts donald trump keeps giving us, right . Right now, hes the Unifying Force that brings all of us together. I think the problem for the party is going to be in 2020 in the president ial primaries about where those splits in the party are and thats what youre going to kind of see. But right now, joe, youre exactly right. What youre seeing is were all unified. Everything is together and youre having both historic turnout and real consolidation with independent voters. What youre seeing is trump scares them in the midterms. These two races also show just how divided our primary system makes general elections. Theyre going to be a hell of a lot of people in georgia and florida and some conservative to moderate democrats looking at the choices and going, who do i vote for . I suspect at the end theyll default to putting a check on donald trump. But still, man, there is a theres a hole in the middle of that offensive line that you can drive a mac truck through with a moderate or conservative. I think that is absolutely right, joe. The american politics is becoming more and more divided. The middle ground snod holding and people are moving towards those extremes. The left, the dim can party is getting its own sea Party Movement built on Bernie Sanders from the last election and i think Andrew Gillum reflects that. I think in florida the chances are that he will be defeated even though hes showing strong right now. I think President Trump is more popular in florida and has lost less of his support than he has in some of the other states that he won, the other swing states. I actually think theres a slightly better chance of the democrat winning in georgia. You know, ill admit i dont get my home state. By all measures, it is a more diverse state, it is a state that i always said donald trump wins florida, he wins the election because florida is such a diverse stais state. And we keep hearing Puerto Ricans are moving to central florida. Orlando is going to be this huge democratic hub. Is that just pollsters and pundits and democratic officials assuming because youre hispanic that is a vote in the Democratic Party . Yes, and theyre assuming wrong. Of all the battleground states in florida, trumps numbers have always been better thantory states. Why is that . I was going to ask you. I think its one of the most interesting questions in american politics right now. Part of it is hes fallen apart with latino voters in every other state except for florida. But he still st getting a bigger number, mika, with women voters than any other battleground state. You also have more people going to florida every year. You have people leaving new york, other states going into florida. So you have residents, more and more residents that tend to be older and whiter. So that kind of, i think, holds it a little bit more. But my question to you is when you talk about turnout, like republicans, we know in midterms, we know we have to have better turnout. But for democrats, it seems this year when you look at some of the local races that democrats have a better chance of prospecting for new voters. Yeah. And that theyre showing up. And where do you see that going . So this is the problem democrats always have with nonpresident ial elections which is we have a much lower turnout of our base voters, young voters, single mothers, etcetera. In these special elections, thats gone. Youre seeing massive turnout of people who do exactly what joe talked about want to go put a break on trump. They are making sure they are going to put a break on trump. A friend of mine just ran and got exactly the vote he thought he was going to get by the number and finished in fourth place because the democratic vote was so much bigger than anyone thought it was going to be. Now, the real question here isnt about democrats or republicans because i think both sides are going to turn their voters out. You saw President Trump pushing this in my home state of montana. He needs to get these votes out. The question is where are independent voters going to go. And i think theyre going to go about putting a break on the president and thats why youre going to see the house go blue. We saw some of that earlier this week about independence breaking. Let me ask you about your former boss, President Trump, making a big speech in champagne, illinois, today which is going to push off his terms in the midterms. Going to ohio next week. Do you think hell be more confrontational with President Trump in his appearances than hes been previously . We saw whispers of it at the mccain funeral on saturday. No, not really. I think hes going to talk about the times were in. Hes been very honest when he disagrees with the president , especially on immigration and other issues. But i think hes going to work about turning the votes out you were just talking about and about having that discussion. I think its a very smart to start in california. Barack obama anticipates currs rating in california is 84 . Where is michelle going to go . Because shes sitting in the 80s and everyone lovers michelle obama. Good question. Wondering if you could answer the question that we cant answer at the table and that is why do floridans continue to stick with this president a little bit more than well, a lot more than voters in pennsylvania, voters in minnesota. You know, the upper midwest industrial states that went for trump but are now his reelect is around 30, 31 in many of those states. I think in the upper midwest, one of the reasons why President Trump was able to win and it was only by a few thousand votes by a number of different states was that he actually paid attention to them. And the democratic candidate, hillary clinton, simply ignored them and took them for granted. Wait a second, so youre saying you have to visit a state to get the votes . It helps, i am told. The thing about florida is, there is a constant influx to the state of those who like the fact that you dont pay income taxes there. Theyre older, theyre fleeing states like new york. So you dont go from new york to escape the taxes there or from new jersey to escape the taxes there and then vote for a guy who says hes going to raise hundreds of billions of worth of taxes. Thats a good point. Welly, tell willie, tell us before you leave, heilman was going to get me the ty tshirt of your guest this weekend on sunday today, but at the last second opted with i think you both would be happy with that tshirt. My guest this sunday is lenny kravitz, the man who plays all the instruments and does the music. And look at him. Hes just cool. Up next, well go live to california ahead of president obamas big rally there tomorrow. Plus, the government can hold immigrant children for no more than 20 days, but the Trump Administration wants to be able to hold them indefinitely. That new reporting is next on morning joe. Ood start packagi we distribute environmentallyfriendly packaging for restaurants. And weve grown substantially. So i switched to the spark cash card from capital one. I earn unlimited 2 cash back on everything i buy. And last year, i earned 36,000 in cash back. Thats right, 36,000. Which i used to offer Health Insurance to my employees. My unlimited 2 cash back is more than just a perk, its our healthcare. Can i say it . Whats in your wallet . You always get the lowest price on our rooms, guaranteed . Lets say it in a really low voice. Carl . Lowest price, guaranteed. Just stick with badda book. Badda boom. Book now at choicehotels. Com it was always our singular focus. To do whatever it takes, use every possible resource. To fight cancer. And never lose sight of the patients were fighting for. Our Cancer Treatment specialists share the same vision. Experts from all over the world, working closely together to deliver truly personalized cancer care. And these are the specialists were proud to call our own. Expert medicine works here. Learn more at cancercenter. Com Appointments Available now. At t provides edgetoedge intelligence, covering virtually every part of your healthcare business. So that if she has a heart problem the staff needs to know, they will theyll drop everything can you take a look at her vitals . Share the data with other specialists yeah, im looking at them now. Theyll drop everything hey. Take care of this baby yeah, that procedure seems right. That one too. At t provides edge to edge intelligence. It can do so much for your business, the list goes on and on. Thats the power of. When your patients tests come back. Takes more than just investment advice. From insurance to savings to retirement, it takes someone with experience and knowledge who can help me build a complete plan. Brian, my certified financial planner™ professional, is committed to working in my best interest. I call it my comfortable future plan, and its all possible with a cfp® professional. Find your certified financial planner™ professional at letsmakeaplan. Org. Ayep, and my teeth are yellow. . Find your certified financial planner™ professional time for whitestrips. Crest glamorous White Whitestrips are the only adaaccepted whitening strips proven to be safe and effective. And they whiten 25x better than a leading whitening toothpaste. Crest. Healthy, beautiful smiles for life. This is the largest audience to ever witness an inauguration, period. Well, newly released documents obtained by the guardian through a freedom of information act showing official photos were edited. This man is not well. He made them add more people. The president intervened. Well, i think it was more the cropping of the photograph than adding people. Come on. Trump complained to the head of the National Parks service that the initial images showed, quote, a lot showing that his crowd size was smaller than that of president obamas first inauguration. Then White House Press Secretary Sean Spicer then spent much of the day repeatedly calling the National Park service, quote in pursuit of more flattering photographs. This is what they were doing with their tile. Eventually the government photographer edited the pictures to crop out areas that were not filled with enough audience members. Thats amazing. Jim, how many days when you were in the white house did you spend calling the National Park service to get barack obama crowd sizes altered in photographs . Zero. Zero. First day i did, id be fired. Of course you would. Let me ask you quickly, we had a good jobs report. John heilman was just saying whats the likelihood you have an economy thats good and a president with a prove approva in the mid30s . Historically, you just dont see this. The problem is, jobs reports dont matter. In the midwest, their lives havent gotten better. They havent had an actual raise in 20 years. So these jobs reports and every time President Trump goes out there and sings praises, he loses those voters he needs the most because theyre like, wait, what world are you living in . One more question on this point. Because whenever i get my polls back, i wouldnt look at the numbers, id go straight to the see whats on peoples mind. Could you explain, if you had 100 verbates in the polls, how many would be talking about russia or Robert Mueller instead of the economy . Zero. Zero. Both bases are obsessed zero voters. The average single mother has 2. 6 jobs. He wants to know whos going to make his life better. And all this stuff with trump is scary. As we mentioned, former president obama is on the campaign trail. He will preview his message in an address in illinois. Aides say he aims to frame the upcoming election as a choice between an inclusive vision of america or fearful one. Tomorrow, he will hold a rally in Southern California which is where we find cnbc editor at large john harwood, hes in anaheim. What are you looking forward to there . Well, this is a perfect backdrop. Because here in orange county, ancestral home of Ronald Reagans conservativism, it is now nearly 50 nonwhite. Hillary clinton became the first democrat in 80 years to carry it last year. And theres a whole bunch of congressional races. Hes going to be campaigning in this center. There are ten democrat possibilities, as they seem 23 seats. Jim messina was talking about the former president , 74 in california. President trump is the remainder. Hes in the 20s. Although in orange county, hes around 40 , and its a fascinating test. The economys booming here. Its a high income county. Big contrast on the issue of providing a check on trump. Mimi walters, the republican incumbent, when i asked her about that, she said, well, look, if theres corruption, there are processes in place. My job is to focus on the policyings. Katie porch, shes a former executive for investment firms. Katie porter is an Elizabeth Warren coauthor and protegee and she says im going to go there and by the way lets have medicare for all. You talk about pocketbook issues. She said if you elect democrats, nancy pelosi becomes speaker, well have socialism and universal health care and universal health care is not popular in the district. Katie porter says bring that fight to me. People do want health care. John, thank you very much. Now to msnbcs correspondent jacob soberoff. Youre focused on the separation issue. We have to be. Ive been listening to you talking about how these hotbutton issues that the National Democrats might think are going to swing these districts are not going to be the ones to swing the districts if the districts do indeed swing. I heard willie asking the sheriff earlier about it. Florida, you know, the idea that hispanics in florida are all going to go with democrats because the separation is just a foolish thing to think about. I saw it, i was talking to a guy from florida earlier in the week. Take a look at this. This is the temporary shelter the Trump Administration set up to house unaccompanied minors who came into the United States illegally, including many children who were separated from their families. Today, there are still dozens of them inside. A few miles north of the detention facility, the areas congressman took me to a window serving locals their morning cubanstyle coffee. There, i didnt hear the outrage that separations of a vote elsewhere across the country. Can we bug you guys . What do you care about the most . Im a believer we should allow immigrants to come in but do it the right way. Legally. Like i had to do it. Just because its a district full of immigrants doesnt mean youre going to hate that policy . No, exactly, you know, its not that i like it, because it shouldnt, you know, youre separating families and its got to hurt if youre a family man like me but as a parent, i would have never put my kids in that position. You hear a lot of people with that opinion . Yes. A balanced view, right, we have a big heart for immigrants in this community, but we want our immigration system to be coherent and legal and for people to respect our laws. So he just said it. Hes in a tough position. Family separations now indefinite intention, this new settlement regulation that the Trump Administration put in yesterday are not the things that are going to flip the district. They dont turn off those voters there. We even have new numbers. I think i can put the new numbers up on the screen. 416 kids separated as of yesterday. From the Trump Administration. Despite that is largely hispanic district, this is not going to be the issue to flip the district. You heard the sheriff here saying she thinks the separation issue is going to be a huge driving motivator. And thats why this is the year when texas finally is going to start to look blue. Do you agree with that . This is not the year texas is finally going to look blue. That day is coming. Its going to be california in 10 or 20 years. Not now. Were just not there. I do think theres one i agree with what youre saying. We were talking about this turnout. The turnout that really matters are the firsttime voters or those who dont traditionally vote in nonpresident ial elections. You look at the Nevada Senate race. Thats an issue in the Nevada Senate race because its all about whether she can turn her voters out. I was going to go to hugo. Im curious what you think. Because theres a lot of issues that the medias outraged by, that a lot of well just call eastern elites. Not that they ever sit around this table of course. Are outraged by. But this child separation issue reminds me an awful lot of katrina. A lot of people from my church driving over that were huge bush fans. For about four weeks in katrina. Theyd go over and saw what was happening over there and, you know, they pulled the bumper stick, the bush bumper stickers off their cars. They werent going to vote for a candidate supporting nancy pelosi. I got a feeling in 2006 a lot of them stayed home. Is that could that be where this issue is . It could be, joe, but i dont think that the separation issue is going to be particularly powerful. I think you heard in the interview just done that, you know, there was this guy saying look, we want legal immigration, you know, he wants it done but he wants it done right. I think theres a lot of people all over the country who know that parents and children are separated not just on immigration issues but when parents are arrested for crimes, they dont have their children with them. I think a lot of people will think actually its horrible when children are taken away from their parent, but there isnt any particular reason why Illegal Immigrants would be treated better than people arrested for other crimes all over the country so i dont think thats going to be a highly motivating factor, no. Which is exactly what that voter, the hispanic voter, told the coppingressman. When you look at where the administration is now, we still have to keep a focus on these children. You cant see them. Yes, you cant see them. Where do you think if anything theyll be any changes in the next 60 days that could affect the election . You say the next 60 days. This flores Settlement Agreement that kept children out of indefinite children with their parents is the new focus of the administration. Nothings going to change within the next 60 day because of the Public Comment period. But they want to be able to keep children this is what we should all remember. Theres 416 kids still in custody. On the other, all the future families that come into this country, they want to keep them in indefinite, so it should be about that. Even though theyre coming illegally, in detention indefinitely. Jacob, thank you. Great jacob, the great jacob. Its an honor sitting next to you, sir. That does it for us this morning. How do you like this . I dont want to hear it. Thank you very much. Come on, ratner Stephanie Ruhle picks up the coverage right now, please. Thank you so much, mika, thank you, joe. Good morning, everyone. Im Stephanie Ruhle with a lot to cover today. Starting with it wasnt me. Top officials pledge their allegiance to the president as the white house faces even more fallout from that anonymous New York Times oped. Meanwhile, the president is trying to sell it as a good thing. I think its backfired