Transcripts For MSNBCW Morning Joe 20161010

Attacked, amed and intimidated his victims. The things she has said and have been reported in various books and magazines and other places about the women that bill clinton raped, sexually abused and attacked. Not bill clintons role but her role as the attacker. These four very courageous women have asked to be here. Im here to support donald trump. Mr. Trump may have said some bad words but bill clinton raped me and Hillary Clinton threatened me. I dont think theres any comparison. This was locker room talk. Im not proud of it. I apologized to my family and to the American People. Certainly im not proud of it but this is locker room talk. I have Great Respect for him. Nobody has more respect for women than i do. He has said that the video doesnt represent who he is, but i think its clear to anyone that heard it that it represents exactly who he is. If you look at bill clinton far worse. Mine were words and his is it action. What hes done to women, theres never been anyone in the history of politics in this nation thats been so abusive to women. When hillary brings up words that i said 11 years ago, i think its disgraceful, and i think she should be ashamed of herself if you want to know the truth. What a weekend its been. Good morning. Wow. Its monday, october 10th. What a weekend. Welcome to morning joe. What this mornings the New York Times describes as an ugly moment in american politics, donald trump and Hillary Clinton squared off in what would be one of the most remarkable political showdowns in modern american history. Last nights debate devolved into a pitched battle over 90 minutes framed by a decade old access Hollywood Tape and past allegations of rape, sexual abuse and systemic coverup of bill clintons alleged assaults against the very women who the former president found himself sitting uncomfortably close to last night. Even before the town hall style debate, donald trump shocked the political world by calling a News Conference with clintons alleged victims and they each delivered statements. I am wendy. Im here to support donald trump. Mr. Trump may have said some bad words but bill clinton raped me and Hillary Clinton threatened me. I dont think theres any comparison. Im kathleen. I am here to support donald trump. I think they should all look at the fact that hes a good person. Hes not what other people have been saying hes been. Im here to support trump. At 12 years old, hillary put me through something that youve never put a 12 year old through. She said shes for women and children. She was asked last year on what happened and she said she is supposed to defend. Whether they did or not, shes laughing on tape. The debate began with the two candidates awkwardly refusing to shake hands. Donald trump spent the next hour and a half fighting his way out of a political corner and looking like a man with very little left to lose. So, joe, well start off with you. What did you think . Despite what you think of donald trump, what you think of Hillary Clinton, what you think of how this race has gone over the weekend and where you think its going to end up, whether you think last night made any difference at all to the final outcome in november. I think there are a couple of things that people in theress may not want to admit. It was plainly evident watching it on tv last night. Number one, it was Donald Trumps most effective debate performance to date. Theres not a close second. Just not a close second. Secondly, despite the fact she had an unprecedented cheering section in the media, the fact is for somebody watching and people will see this if they watch it again today or so parts of it a week from now or a month from now, Hillary Clinton was on the defensive most of the night. She seemed unsure of herself most of the night and he dominated the second debate in the same way she dominated the first debate. And third, and i think most importantly for this political season, donald trump, who has made the Republican Party members lives living and breathing hells for the past year and a half, last night turned it up to 11. All of those people that jumped ship about halfway through the debate were looking at their tv saying oh shoot. Because i know everybody in the press hates donald trump. Im giving you reality if you dont like it. Hes horrible. Horrible. I heard it last night. I saw it on twitter. I understand. You believe hes an evil man. Im just giving you the political reality and this is the political reality. For the Republican Base, donald trump delivered the attack against the clinton machine that the Republican Base and Middle America have been waiting for for years now. And so good luck being in pensacola, florida, sayi ining off of donald trump or saying in kansas im not for donald trump anymore especially when no republican in america should have been surprised by what they heard on friday. No republican in america could have done what he did last night. They just my god. It was epic. It was vintage trump. He produced a daylong show that rocked the political world. Take a look at some of the moments. With his back against the wall. If i win, i am going to instruct my attorney general to get a special prosecutor to look into your situation because there has never been so many lies, so much deception. There has never been anything like this where emails and you get a subpoena. You get a seen and after getting the subpoena you delete 33,000 emails. So were going to get a special prosecutor and were going to look into it. You know what . People have been their lives have been destroyed for doing onefifth of what youve done and its a disgrace and honestly, you ought to be ashamed of yourself. Everything he just said is absolutely false. Im not surprised. Its just awfully good that someone with the temperament of donald trump is not in charge of the law in our country. Because you would be in jail. Secretary clinton [ applause ] now she got caught in a total lie. Her papers went out to all her friends at the banks, Goldman Sachs and everybody else. She said things wikileaks that she just came out and she lied. Now shes blaming the lie on the late great Abraham Lincoln. Thats one that i havent heard. Okay. Honest abe never lied. Thats the good thing. Thats the big difference between Abraham Lincoln and you. Thats a big, big difference were talking about some difference. She complains that donald trump took advantage of the tax code. Why didnt she change it . Why didnt you change it when you were a senator . I heard hillary complaining about so many Different Things over the years. Shes been doing this stuff for 30 years. She never changed and she never will change. Even the moderators were not spared from trumps attacks. I would like to know, anderson, why arent you bringing up the emails . Why arent you . You brought the emails. It hasnt. It hasnt been finished at all. One on three. Were going to move onto syria. Both of you have mentioned she said a lot of things i think we should be allowed to maybe were going to go on. This is about the audience. Disaster as a senator. Mr. Trump, were going to move on. I was against the war in iraq. Its not been debunked. You voted for it, and you shouldnt have it. Lots of Fact Checking on that. I would like to move to an online question. She went 25 seconds over her time. Could i just respond to this, please . Very quickly, please. She went a minute over and you dont stop her. When i go one second over you had many answers. Its really interesting. Hillary clinton wants to allow why did it morph into that . Answer the question. Do you still believe why dont you interrupt her . Would you please explain whether or not the muslim ban still stands. Its called extreme vetting. With us we have former Communications Director for president george w. Bush, nicole wallace, who has been up all night. You be careful now, nicole. And chair of the africanamerican studies and managing editor of Bloomberg Politics cohost of with all due respect Mike Halperin joins willie, joe and me. What is your takeaway . Mindblowing. Unlike anything i have ever seen. Donald trump had nothing to lose. He stripped away any pretense of being a politician or civility and said im throwing everything at her. I texted this to nicole last night. I said this performance by trump tonight is a fantasy come true for people who havent liked Hillary Clinton for 25, 30 years. And bill clinton. He got to stand on a stage and say all of the things theyve been saying and emailing to each other that you know very well for a generation. Now, i dont think that wins him any new voters. I think it talks to the people who already loved him and were cheering him on. I saw it on twitter. I was getting texts. The campaign was thrilled with his performance. I dont think he won any votes. What is the net effect of that . It stops the bleeding. A lot of people that jumped ship this weekend are having to answer phone calls all day today from the Republican Base telling them that they are weasels and need to get back on board. Talk he wasnt going to show up and get out of the race as many people asked him to do. Hes now stabilized and where he was which is losing the race. This doesnt help him win and become president but hes not going anywhere. The man with nothing to lose is what i tweeted yesterday afternoon. Its what willie was talking about. And the woman without any sleep. We already learned that off camera this morning. Youre reaction to the debate . Most important, what does it mean moving forward . In disclosure we were talking throughout the whole thing. We saw it in realtime very differently. I think i was incapable of shaking i dont think i can process trump in an event setting. Its never just the event. He gives a speech. We go on and we analyze the speech. But then by 8 00 he said something more outrageous to undermine it or contradict it by 8 00 and by 3 00 in the morning hes done something else. In isolation, the 90 minutes did represent the net effect of Kellyanne Conway and Chris Christie and Rudy Giuliani impressing upon him the need to prep. I think what you saw was someone that had done real prep. Not at a podium per se but someone playing Hillary Clinton and someone playing a moderator and preparing to answer questions for 90 minutes. Kneel like they had to teach him out to pivot after the first debate, and i think that was largely successful. He went in there way behind, and i think hes still behind in this race. The kinds of people he needed to win over were the ones repulsed about grabbing the p word. I dont think people that are repulsed about him grabbing the p word were turned around back in his favor last night. I think again the net effect last night was it was triage. He was bleeding out. His campaign was coming to an end. Everybody was talking about billy bush, Mark Halperin. Everyone was talking about him getting out of the race. Aint nobody talking about billy bush this morning. Last night everybody was talking. What are they going to do subsection e of the republican rules allow donald trump thats not happening. So hes still in the race, and youre in indianapolis where mike pence has spent quite a bit of time and mike pence was a guy over the past couple days who disappeared. We got word that im just going to hang back for 48 hours. Theres a word for it. You take care of this. He put out a tweet early on attacking donald trump saying he was offended. They then leaked to the press they were shocked, flabbergasted, horrified. Again, im going to quote here. Who could have been shocked by what you saw on fridays . I was shocked. Im saying republicans that are saying i thought he was an upright moral preacher. Please, just stop. I think mike pence is the perfect weather vain in Middle America. He let the press know how deeply offended he was and the statement the debate was over, put up the tweet. Yea you win. Wonder how many republicans do that, too, mark . He accomplished three things given the state of the campaign not only after the tape on friday but leading up to that are significant. One is hes energized the Republican Base. Theres no doubt that he said a string of things last night to her face that will get a lot of people energized. As willie said thats not majority. He needs to get that base back. Two, he has his running mate apparently back on board. I came here from st. Louis to go to North Carolina today with mike pence. Having pence back on the trail was hanging in the balance. Key thing to have accomplished. Inside their campaign, confident, energized, excited. Thats not the case over the weekend. He had the best debate performance. He showed a lot he didnt have in the first debate. Heres what hes not accomplished. Hanging in the balances will people today come out against him the way they did over the weekend . I think thats still possible including some big names. Two, how does he find an Electoral College path. He didnt have it before friday and he doesnt right now. If he can consolidate republicans he can be plausible and hoping about revelations about Hillary Clinton or a third strong debate performance. Nobody suggests at this table that he somehow tightened the race. What hes done is hes saved his campaign to fight another day. What was your overall take away of everything . I think its possible he doesnt win. I will say that a couple things happen that im trying to get through here. The media overreached. Republicans completely overreached. I just dont understand why any of the people who were denouncing donald trump that were pulling their support, are shocked now . Those statements are horrible. There are many more available to you. What do you mean . He said hold on. This is a sane man who told howard stern he wanted to have sex with a dead princess because he liked her skin. Are you really shocked . Come on. Who could be shocked . My point last night was i dont like to talk about people in their absence. He was never trump and really for trump and pulled his support over the weekend. I asked him the same question you guys are posing. I think that people that were never for him arent shocked because this was the character of the man that they could never get behind. And then people that were always for him, either didnt know they knew. Thats pathetic. Dont yell at me. All of this information is out there. Its baked in the cake. Really. Do a little google. Do a little google. This guy says a lot of things like that. He gets people to laugh. Theyre disgusting. I never heard him Say Something like that. Were you asleep during his New Hampshire rally . I must have been asleep. If i could finish what im saying because you do need to actually google him and so do key republicans who endorsed him and then pulled endorsements last night like you were shocked and appalled. This is what put you over the edge . Youre pathetic. Youre weak and spineless. And now you have to come back potentially. To be shocked to think this is the first thing he said. Please. I hate to again media get off your high horse, republicans get off your high horse, Clinton Campaign, please, god, get off your high horse. Okay. If i were the Clinton Campaign, i would bite my tongue they cancel each other again. Any time the topic comes up. I was horrified at how penetrating his attacks were. He teed up the whole day to go there and he went there. It was savage. I hate once again to bring up paul krugman but he tweeted it out yesterday. Hes absolutely right. Republicans acted shocked on friday. And they acted shocked because he was behind. If he were ten points ahead, they would have said the same thing. You know, my wives and daughters are upset but they know donald trump is going to weve been through this for a year and a half. They pick friday when hes down in the polls to be shocked. Civilizations arent ended by wicked people, theyre actually ended by the spineless. Thats what we see happening here. I want to make two distinctions. One distinction is about the politics. Everything you said. Last night i was horrified because i saw the slow death of democracy by 1,000 cuts of the stupid and the vile. Theres one thing to talk about politics itself. When we talk about the state of our country and the state of american politics, donald trump represents the bottom. The bottom. Really . To me in a sense that hes the only one . No. Im saying he is the exaggerated indication of what the state of american politics actually is. You sound like republicans talking about bill clinton in 1992. I was confused actually who you were talking abt. Mark halperin. If theres no difference between what donald trump was revealed to say on friday in past statements, why did mielana put out a statement denouncing it . It was a massive reaction and a hot mike so it was new. If you look at any of his interviews with shock jock howard stern or anything that he said on the apprentice none of them involved bragging about violence. None of them do. Some involve bragging about his daughter. Some involve bragging about being i dont want to compete with you about how much i know about horrific, gross statements that donald trump has said, but i have to tell you for everyone to be so shocked and yet Hillary Clinton and bill clinton for some reason get a pass on these things, which, look, i want hillary to win. I dont want to have this conversation at all. People have to come down to earth. The fact is they have had a past from Polite Society. Theyve had a pass from Polite Society for decades. They have. And actions on record. Im not talking about women that showed up last night. Im talking about actions that are on record in the oval office. I guess the question is, for these republicans that scurried away and now may be forced to come back, if donald trump were up by ten points, would they have ran away on friday . I think thats the point were making. Theyre such hypocrites. They scurry away when hes behind. Donald trump said hes sorry. I had the same conversations and interviews on tv that nicole had with people that flipped. I said where were you last december when he called for a ban on all muslims entering the United States of america . That didnt offend you . Thats a question to these people of you didnt know all of this was coming. You didnt know this was there. What i think is different, the distinction is what hes talking about on that tape is physically grabbing a woman and using his star power to go at somebody, to kiss them if they dont want to be kissed or grab them. Talking about what donald trump said on the tape. Thats the distinction people make. Youre physically going at a woman and assaulting a woman. Thats different than being creepy and talking about if a girl is a ten or an eight or a four. Whatever she is. Go back to the muslim ban. Go back to what he said about mexicans. Denial of knowing who david duke was. I can say its all in transcript, i said two months before the first republican vote was cast that i couldnt vote for him because of the muslim ban. These guys have stayed with him and continued to stay with him and theyre fine with banning over 1 million muslims from coming into the United States. Theyre fine with all of these other things he says and then on friday they get an access Hollywood Tape and suddenly theyre moralistic about it. Their chance to be moralistic passed a long, long time ago. I remember speaking to paul ryan and other Republican Leaders going, guys, this isnt going to end well for you. Wheres your spine . To the point where you said stop. You need to stop saying this again and again and again. Where was it . Did they really think this was going to get better . Did they really think mika, you said it a thousand times. Do a google. You all read that. This guy has been there. You have republicans some republicans who are trying to claim the moral high ground. Which they cant do. And then irony of course is you have certain evangelical leaders saying he doesnt share values, were still supporting him. So you have this really interesting kind of confusion about what constitutes the kind of human being we require in the oval office. The problem is last night people were looking at two human beings that they didnt want in the oval office. Its unbelievable. So key reactions after the debate on twitter. Erick erickson, i may not care for trump but he beat hillary tonight. And brett hume, he lives to fight another day. Lewd tape begins to fade. Again, these are all people that are not fans of donald trump. John avlon, threatens and admits zero taxes. Hillary doesnt put him away. Franc luntz. And chuck todd, bottom line of the entire conversation for those at home trying to keep score with what exactly is going on here. Trump made life more miserable for swing state goppers who want to bolt on him. His base is going to love this performance tonight. Did he gain another vote he didnt have before the debate . I dont think so. Is he going to go up in polls . I dont know. Maybe, maybe not. But the thing we do know is hes made republicans lives more miserable across america, and he has absolutely no problem, mika, deare are war on the Republican Party. In fact, i think he likes it. I think hillary should play the woman card. I propped up men like you all my life. Lets move over. Lets get a woman in there. James baldwin said that. Later this morning, Kellyanne Conway joins us and so does joel bennison. More people were looking up lepo than aleppo. I did not know that gary johnson had well see how that makes richard haas feel. First bill karins after Hurricane Matthew laid waste to much of the southeast over the weekend. Unfortunately the damage isnt done yet. Were watching major rivers in eastern North Carolina going to hit record crests throughout this week. Millions of dollars of additional damage will be done. Theres some pictures from the outer banks as the back side of the storm really caused significant damage. Worse than was expected there in eastern North Carolina and outer banks. Its the river flooding that caused all of the heartache as we went through areas of eastern North Carolina. This is the fayetteville area. Town of princeton evacuated yesterday. They think a dam is going to collapse at any time. Overall we have 19 storm related fatalities. Have in eastern North Carolina related to rainfall and river flooding and death toll in haiti is nearing 900. Over 2 Million People without power. Estimated insurance losses up to 6 billion. Beautiful weather in the southeast for another full day of cleanup and that will continue tomorrow. Nicole is going to become a hurricane in the days ahead and that could threaten bermuda but will spare us on the east coast. New york city, chilly start. Beautiful finish. Well be right back. Only those who dare drive the world forward. The cadillac ct6. My lan Early Morning mode. De. And a partly sunny mode. Transitions® signature™ adaptive lenses. Are more responsive than ever. Experience life well lit®. Upgrade your lenses to transitions® signature™ this car is traveling over 200 miles per hour. To win, every millisecond matters. Both on the track and thousandof miles away. With the help of at t, Red Bull Racing can share critical information about every inch of the car from vtual anywhere. Akes are getting warm. Confirmed, daniel you need to cool your brakes. Understood, brake bias back 2 clicks. Giving them thagity to have speed precision. Because no one knows like at t. I want to emphasize that what is at stake here is the ambitions and the aggressiveness of russia. Russia has decided that its all in in syria, and theyve also decided who they want to see become president of the United States, too, and its not me. I dont know putin. I think it would be great if we get along with russia because we could fight isis together as an example. I dont know putin. I notice any time anything wrong happens, they like to say russians she doesnt know if its the russians doing the hacking. Maybe there is no hacking. He always blame russia. They think theyre trying to tu tarnish me about russia. I dont deal there. I have no business there es the. I dont have loans in russia. Russia is killing isis. Iran is killing isis. And those three have now lined up because of our weak Foreign Policy. I want to remind you what your running mate said. He said provocations by russia need to be met with american strength and that if russia continues to be involved in air strikes along with the Syrian Government forces of assad, the United States of america should be prepared to use military force to strike the military targets of the assad regime. Okay. He and i havent spoken. I disagree. I disagree. You disagree with your running mate . So memo to future Vice President ial candidates, if you decide to bail for a 48hour time period on your running mate, its just not going to end well for you. Lets bring in richard haas. When you were coming on you said it was remarkable that Hillary Clinton had a strategy. There was so many charges that she did not answer last night. So many things she did not respond to. Was that tactical . What was behind that . My take on it was she played it safe during the debate. They came in ahead in the polls. A team ahead in the fourth quarter. You dont want to lose it. Rather than going to win it, you play not to lose. Thats what i thought it was. A safe debate performance. Trump demeanominated the debate. They are probably still ahead in the election. Mark halperin, it makes good sense . Donald trump had to save his political life last night. He did it in a way that probably didnt expand his base whatsoever. Probably stopped the bleeding. Allowed him to fight to another day. People critical of Hillary Clintons performance. Why shouldnt she have just played it safe if shes five, six, seven points ahead in the polls. It makes sense, right . On some level if you have a lead, you dont want to do anything thats combustible. Part of why trump had a solid or good night is because shes not very good at explaining her positions. Shes a good debater technically and to be prepared but there are no Magic Moments for her last night. Most of the volatile moments played better for trump. Shes got a lead. They are very comfortable with where they are in battleground states. Why not stay comfortable with that knowing theyre not going for 500 electoral votes. Theyre going for 271. Let me ask you about those rumors swirling last night but over the last couple days that mike pence was reconsidering his place on the ticket . Any truth to that . Was he thinking about getting off the ticket . I think he was in a Holding Pattern. I think that he was like many republicans genuinely baffled, stunned and upset by the tape that came out. I think he felt donald trump needed to do just what he said in his public statement. He needed to explain himself in the debate. Trump last night laid down a daring marker and said hes never forced himself on a woman either tried to kiss her or assault her. Theres already some people on record saying thats not true. I think for now mike pence is out of the Holding Pattern headed to North Carolina today to campaign. But theres no doubt that over the weekend he was besieged by people. He wasnt responding to them t besiegeded by people saying either you should be the nominee or get off the ticket. I found it unbelievable when he had those women in the audience and just went after her. I do think Hillary Clinton did what she had to do. She played it safe. She tried to stick to the issues. She laughed at his lies or misperceptions of the truth and facts about Foreign Policy. She did everything that she needed to do. Its just the problem is baked in the cake. Is that a good way of putting it . The bigger problem is for the Republican Party right now. Donald trump, i believe, has survived for now. We dont know what happens tomorrow. We dont know what happens the next day. Maybe there are more tapes that are coming out. If clintons want to release tapes, i suggest they probably hold off on it because that doesnt end well for them whatsoever. She could be elected president with a 3 Approval Rating and bill at 1 Approval Rating. At least for the time being, it seems to me that they seem to be clintons seem to be in shape electorally and donald trump has salvaged his campaign for now. Thats bottom line after this whirlwind of a weekend. Everyone said it was over. Its not over. He lives to fight another day. A lot of people are going to have to recalibrate what they were thinking. Things are going terribly for him last night against the backdrop of the previous couple of days and then the pressure on him to leave might have been extraordinary. Now it recedes to some extent. We are where we are. Somewhat different but where we were before the weekend. Willie, think about how crazy this weekend was. Friday night was a political equivalent of the o. J. Simpson bronco chase. I think msnbc was on until 2 00 in the morning. They werent running any canned heat. They dont do that anymore. Those jail things. You dont watch locked up abroad . Its awesome. They go until 2 00 in the morning without showing any of that stuff. When theres news, we cover it. Going until 2 00 in the morning and everybody was watching. My phone was exploding. Its 11 30 at night. Ive been up since 4 00. Stop. And then you follow that through saturday and its just nonstop and then into the debate last night. Everyone saying this is it. Crazy weekend politically. It was crazy weekend. I was with my kids friday night not paying attention to my phone. I picked up my phone and it was like an earthquake shattered my phone on many levels. Assumption was this was an extinction event for donald trump. Thats what it felt like for a lot of people. How was he going to handle it . Go out with dignity. Its not over. He was cornered. Dont corner somebody. Give them a chance to get out. When i saw those tapes, i said here we go. Now its going to get really ugly. It did get really ugly. Can i say one thing from Foreign Policy perspective . Nobody answered the question about syria. That was put out there. Questions like north korea never came up. This is the 10th anniversary today of north koreas First Nuclear test. Never came out. One other point on Foreign Policy, remember the whole expression the whole world is watching . They are all watching. If there was stock called reputation of the United States, it suffered a serious correction if not a crash over the last couple days. Its donald trump against the establishment, the media and the establishment class and last night i will say he got a lot of followups deserved ones because he wouldnt answer legitimate Foreign Policy questions. He didnt have answers. It was very clear he would go off on weird random tantrums. Hillary clinton was asked about wall street speeches and she didnt answer and there was no followup saying please answer the question. She went off and blamed it on russia and blamed it on the hacking. Theres no followup. Instead of content. There was absolutely no followup. Which plays into Donald Trumps other line he has going here, which i think is extremely effective with his followers. Thats the medias unfair. Media is trying to bring him down. It was very clear once the tape hit on friday that this campaign was going to become more populist, more vicious, and more destructive. I said it on friday it played itself out this weekend. The question is where does it end up . Not only for the Republican Party but for this country. We have another month to go. I was saying to you before we came on the air, i think a year or so ago, almost in a joking way we said donald trump is the kind of guy this is last year, last summer, the kind of guy who might bring Juanita Broderick on stage. His staff didnt know that was going to happen. And i cant even the whole thing was she said donald trump used words. Bill clinton thank you. Thank you, richard. I have no idea what you just did. Programming note, governor mike pence is going to join stephanie at 9 00 and this hour chuck todd is going to join us. Yesterday he tweeted that today is going to be one of the most consequential days in the history of the gop. He may be onto something. Well talk about that when we return. I served in iraq in tikrit in 2009. Whi mean a fewe anceresults came up that were really shocking. 11 of me comes from the part where i had served. We all come from such different backgrounds that you never know. Its what the National Debt could do to our economy. If we dont solve our debt problem 19 trillion and growing money for programs like education will shrink. In just 8 years, interest on the debt will be our Third Largest federal program. Bad news for small businesses. The goododews . Theres still time for a solution. Ask the candidates for a plan to secure our future. Not to be focung to finaon my moderate. To severe chronic plaque psoriasis. So i made a desion to talk to my dermatologistbout humira. Humira works inside my body to target and help block a specific source of inflammation that contributes to my symptoms. In clinical trials, most adults taking humira were clear or almost clear and many saw 75 and even 90 clearance in just 4 months. Humira can lower your ability to fight infections, including tuberculosis. Serious, sometimes fatal infections and cancers, including lymphoma, have happened; as have blood, liver, and nervous system probls, serious allergic reactions, and new or worsening heart failure. Before treatment, get tested for tb. Tell your doctor if youve been to areas where certain fungal infections are common, and if youve had tb, hepatitis b, are prone to infections, or have flulike symptoms or sores. Dont start humira if you have an infection. Ask about humira, the 1 prescribed biologic by dermatologists. Clearer skin is possible. Up next, will republicans who criticized donald trump change their tune after last night . Ted cruz tweeted these comments are disturbing and inappropriate. Theres no excuse for them. Every wife, mother, daughter, every person deserves to be treated with dignity and respect. Just two days earlier cruz was phone banking for the Republican Party and by extension, donald trump. So confusing. Chuck todd joins us when morning joe comes right back. Have conquered highways, mountains, and racetracks. And now much of that same advanced technology is found in the audi a4. With one notable difference. The highly advanced audi a4, with available traffic jam assist. At bp, we empower anyone to stop a job if somhing doesnt seem right, so everyone comes home safely. Because safety is never being satisfied. And always working to be better. What powers the Digital World . Nevecommunication. Ied. Likeenturylinks Broadband Network that gives 35,000 fans a cutting edge game experience. Or the network that keeps a leading hotel chains guests connected at work, and at play. Or the it platform that powers millions of ecards every day for one of the largest greeting cd companies. Businesses count on communication, and communication counts on centurylink. Weve just been hearing youre a digital company, yet here you are building a jet engine. Well, ge is digital and industrial. Like Peanut Butter and jelly. Yeah. Ham and cheese. Cops and robbers. Ham ayeah. Eese. Nachos and karate. Ahh. Not that one so much. The rest were really good. Socks and shoes. Ok, ricky. When i was too busy with the kids to get a repair estimate. Liberty did what . Yeah, with Liberty Mutual all i needed to do to get estimate was snap a photo of the damage and voila voila sigh i wish my Insurance Company had that. Wait hold it. Hold it boys. Theres supposed to be three of you. Wheres your brother . Wheres your brother . Hey, wheres charlie . Charlie . you can leave worry behind when liberty snds with you. Liberty stands with you™ its 48 past the hour. Joining us now, moderator of meet the press, chuck todd, no sleep for you either all night long covering this. Last night you were saying that this was Donald Trumps best debate performance, but at the same time we shouldnt expect cheers from the Republican Party because actually you say hes just made the gops decision all that much harder. Its interesting last night. You get the feeling that paul ryan and Mitch Mcconnell and probably mike pence were all assuming or waiting for her to deliver a knockout. It was going to here it comes. They just assumed it was coming. I think the Clinton Campaign just assumed they were waiting for trump to just implode on stage. Well, neither happened. And now if youre paul ryan this morning, you are in this youve been in a vice for months. Youre in a worst vice. Boy, does the Trump Campaign feel good this morning. Does the trump base feel like its almost like theyve got a taste of that red meat. This is everything this is a dream. Dreaming about this moment since he got fired from the whitewater investigative committee. What about the Republican Base waiting for somebody for 20 years to deliver the argument against the clinton machine. So theres this excitement among this 35 to 40 . But then you still have the same issue that the Republican Party has been dealing with with trump for the whole time which is how do you win a suburban swing voter in this . What did he do to improve his standing somehow that is going to make those republicans or independent or right leaning independents or whoever these swing voters are at this point come over and so now the Republican Party, lets take pat toomey. He cant win without trumps base and he cant win out the suburban philadelphia voters. He probably cant win them without totally denouncing trump and walking away from him. If you do that this morning, i think the sort of the right wing base is going to be how dare you . And almost come with pitch forks for toomey. Angrier at him. Thats the vice mcconnell and ryan are in. For the long run, they have to dump him but right now its politically probably the worst idea. Its a total vice. Why didnt they know they had to dump him when they endorsed him . What is it that we learned about donald trump thats new today . Everything has been confirmed. Thats the thing. Everything that was predicted if trump is nominee, the fear of what he could do came true on friday. You have people like john mccain i think to talk about folks that peeled off over the weekend and give them the benefit of the doubt that this was a Tipping Point, for john mccain he was called a cruddy p. O. W. And he stuck in there. You have to look at marco rubio i understand everything youre saying, mika. The notion that there cant be a Tipping Point and there cant be so much evidence of a lack of character for some of these men and women, i think just a couple women, is false. I mean, i think for some of them it was just more than they could take. No doubt. The question is the ones that were waiting that i think were going to say use the debate to say i was waiting to see if he could show more contrition. Im waiting to see. And so then what do they think this morning . He didnt show any contrition on that video. Mark halperin, if youre a republican, that depends on your base, lets take senator burr. You dont bolt from donald trump this morning because he didnt show contrition unless you want to lose 50 of your Republican Base. Burr cant win without having donald Trump Supporters voting for burr. Or unless you think from your own sense of morality or your own sense of the longterm politics you want to play that you must. Look, i think theres four things to watch for between now and friday. Wait. I want to say, as far as morality, i say muslim ban. David duke. Kkk. Et cetera, et cetera. Im sorry. I dont want to hear from republican politicians, morality. Sexual assault is a Tipping Point for some people. I have never said any of it was cool. For some people, people like senator john mccain, senator like rob portman and kelly ayotte and defections to come, gro groping a woman and bragging about it on a bus was a Tipping Point. Are there more . Trump may have had a better debate performance as trump said but there may be defections that could drive the news this week. Second is what happens with the polls. Third, what does a trump pence message look like this week and more disclosures. Everyone is talking about more disclosures. Not just about trump but potentially Hillary Clinton. What happens if theres another disclosure for people as they make up their mind do they break from him or not. Im telling you, dont take your eye off paul ryan. Paul ryan is still the key. To your point, sexual assault, bragging about it, bad. Bragging about murder, bad. He could shoot someone on fifth avenue. Still ahead, well speak live with Kellyanne Conway and Clinton Campaign chief strategist joel benenson. Youre watching morning joe. [ front assist sounds ] [ music stops ] [ girl laughs ] on the road again like a band of gypsies we go down the highway beetle horn honks ] no matter whic passat you choose, beetleyou get more] standard features, for less than you expected. Hurrin and lease the 2017 passat s for just199 a month. Stop clicking around. Travel sites to fina bett price. The lowest prices on our hotels are always at hilton. Com. So pay less and get more only at hiltonom. Coming up at the top of the hour, trumps virginia chairman said of that tape from 2005, acted like a frat boy as a lot of guys do. Willie and i were talking about this. Weve been in locker rooms. I never heard that kind of talk from no. Maybe seventh graders that are just learning the word for the first time. Ive been in a lot of locker rooms. I never heard that. Played sports every day of my life until i was about 22 years old. A lot of locker rooms. Never heard that before. Well talk about that. Well play a lot of the debate last night. Wow. Are you doing okay . Are you going to be steady for the second hour . I couldnt sleep i was so stressed out. Ne credit card. Hold on. Yoonly got double miles on stuff you bought from that airline . Let me show you somethg better. The capital one venture card. With venture, you earn unlimited double miles on every purchase. Not just. dismissively airline purchases. Every purchase. Everywhere. Every day. No really double miles on all of them what in your wlet . See me. See me. Dont stare at me. See me. See me. See me to know at psoriasis is just something that i have. Im not contagious. See me to know that. I wont stop until i find what works. Discover cosentyx, a different kind of medicine for moderate to severe plaque psoriasis. Proven to help the majority of people find clear or almost clear skin. 8 out of 10 people saw 75 skin clearance at 3 months. While the majority saw 90 clearance. Do not use if you are allergic to cosentyx. Before starting, you should be tested for tuberculosis. An increased risk of infections and lowered ability to fight them may occur. Tell your doctor if you have an infection or symptoms. Such as fever, sweats, chills, muscle aches or cough. Or if you have received a vaccine or plan to. If you have inflammatory bowel disease, tell your doctor if symptoms develop or worsen. Serious allergic reactions inflammamay occur. Disease, see me. See me. See me. On my way. Find clear skin. And clearer path forward. Ask your dertologistnd about cosentyx. He wants to start. Go ahead. No. Im a gentleman. I hate to interrupt you, at some point we need to do Fact Checking here. We have a divided nation because of people like her. She has tremendous hate in her heart. And when she said deplorables, she meant it. Does mr. Trump have the discipline to be a good leader . No. Im shocked to hear that. He jumps right in. Someone says you have tremendous hatred in your heart, respond. There are a thousand Different Things that she just didnt respond to. Thats the sort of conundrum of debating donald trump. He throws so much out there and, boy, last night did he throw so much out there. Not even waiting until the debate to do that. So donald trump and Hillary Clinton squared off in what would be one of the most remarkable political showdowns in modern american history. Last nights debate devolved into a pitch battle over 90 minutes framed by a decade old access Hollywood Tape and past allegations of rape, sexual abuse and systemic coverup of bill clintons alleged assaults against the very women who the former president himself found himself sitting uncomfortably close to last night. He looks comfortable there. They were there even before the town hall style debate. Donald trump shocked the political world by calling a News Conference with clintons alleged victims and they each delivered statements. Hi. Im wendy broderick. Im here to support donald trump. Mr. Trump may have said some bad words, but bill clinton raped me, and Hillary Clinton threatened me. I dont think theres any comparison. Im kathleen. I am here to support donald trump. I think they should all look at the fact that hes a good person. Hes not what other people have been saying hes been like hillary. Think about that. I support trump. At 12 years old, hillary put me through something that youve never put a 12 year old through. She said shes for women and children. She was asked last year on what happened and she said she is supposed to defend whether they did or not. Now shes laughing on tape. The debate began with the two candidates awkwardly refusing to shake hands. Donald trump spent the next hour and a half fighting his way out of a political corner and looking like a man with very little left to lose. Joe . Mark halperin, we have over the first hour discussed how donald trump lived to fight another day. And he probably turned in his best debate performance of his political career. And most important ly froze mor republicans from defecting from his cause because of the case that he prosecuted against the clinton political machine last night. A case that republicans have been frustrated for years that their leaders havent been able to fight even though it was ugly and it was off kilter at times. I just find it really hard to believe that some congressman from oklahoma is going to dart from Donald Trumps team this morning. Theres no doubt there will be fewer defections than there would have been without that performance. Trump came in with an actual strategy, which he executed. It was a flawed performance. He executed something. As we said before, he certainly not just lives to fight another day but brings back people, elites and grassroots vote nears t voters into the fold. Mika, on friday and saturday, we saw billy bush and access hollywood bus nonstop. If the goal is to get that off of the front pages of the newspapers and stop those clips from running in a 24 hour a day cycle, Mission Accomplished for donald trump. You can check that box. Here are trumps heated attack lines. If i win, i am going to instruct my attorney general to get a special prosecutor to look into your situation. There has never been smany lies, so muc deception. There has never been anything like this where emails and you get a subpoena. You get a subpoena and after getting the subpoena you delete 33,000 emails. So were going to get a special prosecutor and were going to look into it because you know what . People have been their lives have been destroyed for one doing onefifth of what youve done. Its a disgrace. You ought to be ashamed of yourself. I want to follow up on that. Everything he just said is absolutely false, but im not surprised. Its awfully good that someone with the temperament of donald trump is not in charge of the law in our country. Because you would be in jail. Secretary clinton she got caught in a total lie. Her papers went out to all her friends at the banks, Goldman Sachs and everybody else. She said things, wikileaks, that just came out. She lied. Now shes blaming the lie on the late great Abraham Lincoln. Thats one that i havent heard. Okay. Honest abe. Honest abe never lied. Thats the big difference between Abraham Lincoln and you. Thats a big, big difference were talking about some difference. She complains that donald trump took advantage of the tax code. Why didnt she change it . Why didnt you change it when you were a senator . I heard hillary complaining about so many Different Things over the years. Shes been there for 30 years. Been doing this stuff. She never changed. She never will change. Mark halperin is still with us along with the chair of department of africanamerican studies at Princeton University eddie, and contributor to time magazi magazine and how did donald trump do last night . If his goal was just to douse himself in kerosene and let everyone watch the expespectacld watch his body burn over the next month and light hillary on fire along the way, is the bar now for running for president just to be willing to put yourself through utter humiliation over and over and over . That wasnt pretty for her. And for him either. Absolutely. I think it was we hit the bottom last night. And whats so interesting about it to me is that in the midst of all of the kind of theater, we didnt hear anything substantive from donald trump and what was striking about it is that Hillary Clinton couldnt throw the knockout punch in the midst of all of this. Spectacle at its worst. We sort of changed our perspective and view of what president ial campaigns can be over the last year and a half. If you put this thing in a vacuum and didnt know anything about this event and you had a candidate up on stage basically referring to Hillary Clinton as the devil in one segment when he said he was surprised Bernie Sanders joined the devil. Had hate in her heart. Talked about putting here in jail through a special prosecutor when he became president and holding a press conference before that debate with people who accused her husband of rape. Bizarre spectacle but donald trump on the chopping block before the debate and people said maybe hell get out of this race, he pushes on. Thats the amaze thing. Im with joe. It was probably his best debate performance, which is sort of remarkable, right . He said she should be in jail and shes the devil and has hate in her heart but he wasnt that bad. He did some good things last night. The problem good things help him not at all and maybe hurt him in what hes trying to do. If this was six months ago, solidifying the Republican Base behind him, okay, right, there is an element of the Republican Base who wants that confrontation with the clintons and feels as though leaders have been insufficiently willing to force that conversation and last night was their high moment. The problem is that the election is in 30 days, right . He needs those people. He has some trouble there, right . Youre seeing rebellion in the ranks. He needs independents. He needs women. Theres just not much there last night that i think would convince you if you were not for him previously, particularly if youre a woman, he kept referring to Hillary Clinton as she, her, which was a concerted strategy. Im not sure why. So i think he did do enough to stay in the race and keep them from running but didnt do anything that would help him win. This was a campaign, mika, in the trauma unit and it was about to flat line and hes out of the trauma unit now. I dont know if hes in icu or Critical Care or whatever. Hes lived to fight another day. I suspect that to followup on what you said, i suspect he box mo becomes more dangerous for the clintons by the day. Instead of shooting from the hip about bill clinton and his past and hes going to say things that were said for years. Hes going to execute the case against bill clinton and Hillary Clinton and the corruption that surrounded the clintons and i think thats all hes going to do and in a sense, the Republican Party, all of these people that abandoned him this weekend allowed him to be back where he was in the primary. Thats where hes best by the way. Politically. When it all started, everybody said in chattering class, hell never win the nomination. Believe i was supposed to win a truck for that. Everybody laughed. Stormed off the set. Acted as if they needed a shower after the conversation. He won the nomination. Hes just a reality star. He doesnt know what hes doing. He says ridiculous things. He just gave us probably the highest rating reality show that weve seen so far over the course of this weekend. He took again a moment where everybody was saying it is over. Like this is the one. And he just doubled down on it. Escaped. I think youre right. They think they won and dominated last night. The lesson theyll take away is he took gloves off completely to the extent they were still on his hands, took them off and went personal and deep and lets try that for the next 30 days and see what happens. A more populist tone from now on. Sexual assault victims every day. Hell go to war against the clintons and the media and the establishment Republican Party. Vital parts of what the message is but two other things you talked about last night and theyre bullish on. One is the change message. The notion shes been there for 30 years. Hell keep talking about that and then policy on things like taxes, on things like Foreign Policy, on things like judges, i dont think theyre going to drop that from the arsenal because that allows them to build a center right coalition around big policy issues that a lot of voters do care about. Lets bring in Donald Trumps campaign manager, Kellyanne Conway. I have three boxes here. Hold on one second. Box number one, Kellyanne Conway is going to quit the campaign. True or false . False. Okay. Really bad reporting by nbc by the way. Heres another one. Mike pence is going to get off the ticket. Hes going to leave. Hes done. Its over, right . False. Hes on his way to North Carolina today and has a full slate of events. Go ahead and look them up. And donald trump is going to be pushed to the side. I heard this late into the evening last night that donald trump would be pushed aside and somehow the republicans are going to cobble together an alternative to donald trump. Hold on. How did that go. Whats happening there . 0 for 3. Thats an x. So if you score at home, three xs. What happened last night with all of this bad reporting and what is the next month going to look like . Whats donald trump going to do over the next month . We could back up into the weekend reporting, joe. This idea that im not on twitter or where am i . How about im in the tower all weekend long in debate prep and speaking with my client as were many people. Thats our job after all. I think people are looking for excitement and crazy stories. Tune into the campaign. Theres plenty there. Watch the debate last night. You have lots of fodder. And were just so pleased with mr. Trump and the debate last night. That was a masterful performance. He took the case right to Hillary Clinton from the very beginning. I hear her team really trying to spin the heck out of it last night and this morning as, hey, she came to talk about the issues. Shes the one who started this in the first debate with these diversionary tactics and extraneous mentions even though lester holt wasnt talking about it and even though it had nothing to do with the subject matter at hand. Last night donald trump talked about her 33,000 deleted emails, 15,000 or 17,000 she never turned over and doesnt know that c means confidential in a document. Someone thats been u. S. Senator, secretary of state, first lady. She doesnt know the c means that. Her entire failed record in libya, in benghazi when chris stevens, the ambassador and others, pleaded to get more security. They were ignored and theyre now dead. He took her on with russian reset and with the fact that isis was created and so he took the case directly to her, and i dont think it was her best night. She seemed off her game and rattled. Kellyanne, its willie. Good to see you this morning. Donald trump announced during the debate he would appoint a special prosecutor if he was elected president to look into Hillary Clinton and her emails and in an offhand moment he said she would be in jail if he were president. Does he stand by that this morning . That was a quip. Ill go with nbc on it. He had already finished his statement. She said something thats why youll never be president. He said you would be in jail. And so that was his answer. As for the special prosecutor, i think thats donald trump channeling the frustration he hears from thousands of voters on the stump every day. Theyre very frustrated that she has a different set of rules for her. Hes channeling the frustration he hears from people. How can she not have faced any type of penalty for doing something where people who do far less have faced a serious penalty, and this is the whole problem with Hillary Clinton. Her campaign loves to brag. Shes been in Public Service for 30 years. A, where is the product and deliverable and, b, if youve been there all that time, how do you not know these things and why is there a separate set of rules applied to exactly what this campaign is about. Shes a washington insider benefiting from the rigged system. Hes going disrupt it. Just to put a point, the jail line he was joking about her being in jail . She made a snide comment and he said this is why you cant be president and he said she would be in jail. Whether she goes to jail is not up to donald trump. Its up to whoever adjudicates whatever crime she has or has not committed. Kellyanne, reinmany have condemned trump and many others pulling support from donald trump. Any effort to get these republicans back . I hope so. We welcome them back. We would love their support. We have a lot of their voter support. Were competitive and winning in many of those states. Were taking the case directly to the voters. Hes a master communicator and natural connector with people and i think forums like last night, he can take the message to hem and cut through noise or silence. Of course we welcome them. If they dont come around and dont want to support their party nominee, that itself is incredible. How its only Donald Trumps burden is beyond me. Theyre going to have to be on the ballot with many of the people you just mentioned. I want to add my name to the list, of course, of people who among with Melania Trump who felt the comments were offensive and unacceptable and im pleased that donald trump apologized for them. He did it last night and that matters to people. And then of course, mika, he said theres a huge difference between words and actions. Lets make very clear that is specifically why he raised how Hillary Clinton has treated many of these women over the years. She has attacked them. Shes shamed them. Shes blamed them. And its always somehow the womans fault and hes making the distinction between words and actions. Kellyanne, to win this race donald trump has to get women. What did he do last night to pull women in . He seemed defensive. He didnt seem really like he was apologetic at all for what he had done. I dont see how youre actually going to win this race. Those are a couple different questions. Did you hear him say i apologize . I would think that meat him apologetic. He said he was embarrassed and didnt like it. He said that several times and many times since fridays revelation. Ill leave it to the American People to figure out that when someone says i apologize they are being apologetic. Secondly on women more broadly, he talked last night about how to make them safe and more prosperous. This election is simple. You either want more of the same, that would be Hillary Clinton and her 30year record with little deliverable. Why are millions and millions of women lacking in health insurance, in poverty, and yet shes been there all this time. Secondly, people dont feel safe as they did eight years ago. And if you dont feel as safe as you did eight years ago, if youre worried about safety and prosperity, he made a very compelling case last night. Hes also holding Hillary Clinton to account. We know from over the weekend its not getting much coverage yet but we know over the weekend its revealed in emails that she said you have to have a public position and private position. Thats exactly what people hate about politicians is that you tell donors one thing, like were all so deplorable and irredeemable or heres my private position and you go out in public and you pretend that youre something youre not. I have faith in women. I know theyre savvy consumers and can see the difference in these two people last night. I think last night you saw a Hillary Clinton not doing a very good job defending her record and yet seeming incredibly defensive. All right. Thank you so much. Appreciate you being with us. Lets go to st. Louis right now. Nbc news correspondent katy tur boring weekend for you. Boring night. What in the world happened . Well, donald trump some in the Republican Party say this campaign is imploding. I know Kellyanne Conway is going to dispute that notion. There were talks over the weekend about who in the campaign was going to remain standing after this weekend. There was rumors, i know kellyanne addressed this a moment ago, that she was going to step down. She didnt feel comfortable with this language and that she was a mother and christian. She again has pushed back on that as of last night even though she didnt push back on it when we asked her before our web story went to air. Over the weekend, 50 Different National lawmakers, congressmen and senators, have come out and said that theyre just not going to support donald trump. Many of them even saying that they dont believe that hes fit for office. A number of them also saying they believe he should step aside. This weekend was really a breaking point for the gop and last night was the test to see where the rnc would go. Would it stick by trump or find a way to separate itself, untangle itself from its nominee . I was talking to a pretty important state director last night about how they felt about the weekend and how they felt about the rnc and how they felt about the debate. I want to read you what they said. This debate is heartbreaking for me. The depth to which we have fallen in political discourse is worse than embarrassing. Its degrading to the American People. As for the rnc getting onboard with bringing these victims or these accusers, bill clintons accusers, socalled victims by the Trump Campaign, to the debate, the director reacted like this. Thats a total embarrassment. Every woman in america has now been told by the rnc that it is okay to build a president ial campaign on attacking women for their husbands bad behavior. Guys . Nbcs katy tur. Thank you so much. Yeah. There are a lot of people that looked at last night as a low point in american politics. All i can say is they obviously werent alive when robert bork was nominated. Thats as low as it got. Or back to when gary hart got outed. Or we could go back if you want to go back to the campaign of 1800 im tired of its like all of those little kids that get on the floor after obamacare passed. I hated obamacare. All those little kids tonight democracy died. Come on. How many times can democracy die . How many times can we have a low point in american political history . I would say what was brought up about Clarence Thomas in the middle of the Supreme Court nomination about coke cans and i wont even get into it, that was really scummy. What happened with robert bork before the man even respectable jurist was able to testify before the Judiciary Committee saying that robert borks america was america of back alley abortions and segregated lunch counters. You can talk about gary hart and the way they were absolutely shoved around and battered and abused by the media in New Hampshire. We can talk about this as a continuous decline to the bottom. Let me ask you this question. I was really struck. All of this talk about more of the same with regards to Hillary Clinton. What Political Economic position did donald trump put forward last night that wasnt more of the same in relation to the folks that support him. Thats been my complaint. My complaint about donald trump and tax code and Everything Else and donald trump not paying taxes for 15 years, i think the biggest scandal is not that donald trump hasnt paid taxes for 15 years, we have a tax code that allows it and you have two candidates, two candidates that are going to do nothing to change that. Donald trump wont do anything to change it. And Hillary Clinton wont do anything to change it. Because Hillary Clinton has been funded her entire political career by some of the richest people on wall street. Substance of him as a change candidate is really all the bluster. Its really the performance. The style. I dont think hell change the tax code. We can all talk about carried interest. What are you willing to fight for . Does anyone believe either of these candidates are going to fight Mitch Mcconnell and paul ryan to make billionaires pay more than 14 . Unfortunately the theater of what was happening last night overshadowed any issues even at times when he didnt make sense on them. On both sides, we really didnt talk about the issues. Donald trump got syria wrong. Hillary clinton said absolutely nothing about it. We didnt get to other policy issues that donald trump has been off on. And we didnt even get to Hillary Clintons open borders comment. Two things. One, this is lowest ever. Nothing drives me crazier than that. I would remind people that bill clinton was impeached by the house after having an affr with an intern. You can argue whether thats a good thing or a bad thing. I remember watching all of that 1998. Democracy is remarkably resilience which is a good thing. As much as we try try to do it, it tends to do well. Probably the first 20 minutes set the tone for the whole thing so within the first 20 minutes we had trump talking about bill clinton and his conduct and what he alleged hillary sort of covered up. We had the conversation about the hot mike tape. So after that, it sort of felt then he was to mikas point about theatrics, he made it hard not to focus on that. He was behind her. There was a lot of theatrics to look at. He put the moral debate right on center stage, and i think she should have addressed it. I think she should have addressed it and put it away and said, listen, first of all, the people you have here are unproven things. There are transgressions my husband had. No one was more upset than me. I stayed with it to keep my family together and for the country. It wasnt about me and my country. That would have put it away. Why doesnt she just say that . Its incredibly human and incredibly correct. She did it for her family and for the country. You can go talk to bill about that. Bill and donald, you have a lot in common. Go talk. Just stand up. Guinness book of World Records here, it seems weve broken a record for our 7 00 a block. It is 7 30. And you can check alex, is that a record . Thats a record. Were all going to be fired. Tell phil well have to blow through a couple breaks. We apologize. Coming up next, we have tom brokaw. He joins us. Come on. I just want to know. My kid has a school play. I got to get up to connecticut. Tom brokaw joins us with his take on this whirlwind weekend. Youre watching morning joe. I hope well be right back. Whether is connecting one of the worlds most innovative campes. Or bringing wifi to 65,000 fans. Businesses count oncommuni whether is connecting one of thcoun on centurylink. Ive campes. Lenan Early Morning mode. And a partly sode. Letrsitions® signature™e. Adaptiveenses. Are more responsive thanver. Experience life well lit®. Upgrade your lenses toransitions® signature™ amerans e buying more and more of everything online. And so many businesses rely on the United States postal svice g it ere. Because when you ip with us youruss becomes r business. Thats why we make more ecommerce deliveries to homes than anyone se in the country. R business. The United States postal service. Priority you sureor put themhave ston a rack. Tires. But the specialists atord like to show off thr rengs name brands. Albacked by our low prtire grantee. Ahwere strong when it cos to tires. Ght noduring the big tire event, get a 140 rebate by mail on four select tires. Whats succes iprofessowho never ops bea stent . Is it a caregiver determined to take care of her own . Or is it lifetimof work isthat blazes the path toned to tyo psions . F her own . Your personal success takes a Financial Partner values ias much as you do. Learn more at tiaa. Org sprint . Im hearing good things about the network. All the networks are great now. Were taing within a difference in reliability of ch other an sprint saveyou 50 on most Current National carrier rates. Save money oyour phoneill, invest it in your small business. Wouldnt you love re ctomers . I would definitely lov some new customers. Spntill he you add customers and cut your costs. Switch your business to sprint and sav50 eatment tions exe yr with speciists wtreat on. Ery ste. Every day. At cancer treatmentcenters. Len mo atcancercenters joining us now, tom brokaw and ben ginsburg. Gentlemen, ill read from the wall street journal opinion page. Americans didnt learn much new about donald trump in the video of his sexual boasting with billy bush. Anyone paying attention already knew that hes crude and lavish and judging women by their looks. Republican voters nominated him despite these risks. And now the release of an especially lewd 11yearold tape put candidacy in crisis and republicans dropped their support a month before election day. So now they say tom brokaw that their email inbox is filled with republicans saying this is a double standard. Because while mr. Trump may talk like it, bill clinton acts like one and Hillary Clinton enables him and democrats still revere jfk who was a sexual predator in the white house. Is there a point to be made here, tom brokaw . I think that obviously donald trump tried to invoke and include bill clinton last night. The country has been through that for one thing. And i think the country feels that everyone should have learned lessons from it. For him to dismiss what he had to say as locker room talk, ive been in a lot of locker rooms over the years and last time i heard that was in junior high uninformed people saying outrageous things. Last night what he did was just kind of stabilized where he was. I talked to a very prominent republican after the debate. One who wants him to get out of the race. He said the best that he could do was to get others from not abandoning him at that point. Deeper in the wall street journal article it says in that context mr. Trump could say he started the movement, mr. Pence is now able to lead it to success and saying in effect get out because youre going to lose both house and senate if you dont do something soon. What he had to do last night was to bring people back to him that not just a crowd thats been with him, but he had to bring people that were kind of on the fence line so to speak to his side. Im not sure that he accomplished that. And when he said that he would appoint a special prosecutor to go after her and later said you would be in jail, my guess is for people who are paying not a lot of attention to the details of everything, that statement gets their attention. So ben ginsburg, last night you were being asked what steps could be taken to remove donald trump from the ballot. I suspect youre not going to be asked that question again over the next 30 days. Donald trump apparently has decided hes going to fight this out to the very end. What does that mean to the Republican Party . Well, it means that if he loses, which i think is the assumption behind your question, we will have a circular firing squad for about a year afterwards. Well see whether the trump phenomenon is based on donald trump or whether there is more grassroots support for it. There will be a battle between moderates and conservatives for policy positions. And the driving forces behind that will really be the elected leadership in congres and the state houses. What is the challenge for the party at this point . And especially after watching the debate last night, ben ginsburg. The republicans who have shunned him, are they glad they did that . I suspect that the republicans who shunned him are glad because after all today is one day but there are still 30 days to go in the campaign and there has been a three day period let alone a 30day period where there hasnt been some new revelation or development in the course of this campaign. So the republicans who got out are out and they will run their campaigns accordingly in their states. The question really is what the party as a whole does and the interesting point you were talking about is what does the Republican National committee do . Reince priebus is flying around on the plane with him. Rnc is mortgaged everything they have to produce a ground game. Can that ground game produce . If donald trump had as good a debate as he believes he had, that should show up in numbers including early voting and absentee numbers. Theres going to be a test of at least the Institutional Party really soon here. So did donald trump have a good debate . You know, i think from a stabilizing point of view he had a pretty good debate. I dont think she had great debate because in part she has not yet sold the American People on why she should be president. Shes got a lot of grocery items lined up. The big vision we have yet to hear from her. I do think that what youre going to see and whats already in play in the house and senate theyve already kind of acknowledged that hes not going to be the president. We have to save the Republican Party in the house and in the senate. Thats where the concentration is shifting very fast at this point. That statement from rob portman yesterday, for example, who is a middle of the road very popular figure in ohio highly regarded on both sides of the aisle, he gave trump the back of his hand. Lets pull back quickly. You have seen a lot of these debates. Weve been talking about whether or not this represents a low moment in american politics and american democracy that we hit bottom what did you see in terms of all of the things that youve seen with regards to these sorts of debates. Where are we . Defining deviance down. Its a reflection of our culture. We live in a culture in which almost anything goes. The stuff you can read online and see on television, hear in lyrics across the board has bled over into politics. Thats exactly again what the times said. Its a bit much wall street journal. Its a bit much to see liberals that said mr. Clintons exploitations was about sex and the same moralist who celebrate pop music in a sex crazed culture outraged by a man who was marinated in that culture before he entered politics. Doesnt lie about it. The other thing is, what i think we do have to keep in mind, this thing changes at warp speed. A week ago at this time we were not talking about his comments on the bus for example. You know how much i have begun over the ufo theory. They are concerned about a terrorist attack. Economic meltdown for another. And they dont think they have put away questions about her health. All right. Tom brokaw, ben ginsburg, thank you both. Ahead on msnbc, mike pence sits down with stephanie in one of his first interviews since he didnt defend donald trump over the access Hollywood Tape. We have much more ahead. Stay with us. We iested in youfund to help us pay for a coe educion for our son. Weve enclosed a picre of ouron trusting y with their hardearned money. Idelity, dontust m, we manage peops money. Want lger lasting artburn relief . Try. Duo fn dufusion gs to work in secds lastup to 12 h. Tums oy lastup to 3. For ngerng relief. In e ctry duo fusion fromhe makers of zanta i spent many y as a nuclear missillaunch officer. If trr we h to launch theissis, i prayed that call wod [ radio chatter ] self ctrol may ese missilesrom firing. [ sirens blearin] i would bomb the [ beep] out of them. I want to be prictabl i lo w. The thought of dald trump with i want to be prictabl nuclear apons ares me toeath. It shod scare everyone. Hillary clinton and i approve this message or keeping a hotels guestscon cuttingmmunication,o 35,000 fans. And communication counts on centurylink. Whthwe met wwe were very yog. As 1 hwa18. Mysel or keeping a hotels guestscon cuttingmmunication,o 35,000 fans. Me the movie booklife. We startedoing animaon. With the surface book, you ca all ts stuff. You can actuly draw on the scen. Sorisp. I love it. Its almost like this supe porf cputeand a tablet had the perfect ba. Its a typewrir fo writing scripts. Ita canvas for painting. For sketches. You cando that a mac. Im not a custer, buim calling out th credit scord. to d g ve i s free for everyone. Oh ll thats nice and checking your ore wont hu your it. Oh to dog im so proud of you. Well thank you. Get your free credit scorecard at discover. Com. Even if youre not a custome anyou talking to your to seve, doctorbout your medicati. This is humira. This is is humiragelieve mys heing me go further. Humira works f many adults. It tartsndel to ock a ecificource ofnfmmatthat contributes a. Hura has been clinical studiefor over 1years. Humira can lower your abitto n ofnfmmatthat contributes a. Hura has been clinical studiefor over 1years. Including tuberculos. Serious, sometim fatainfections and hura has been clinical studiefor over 1years. Cancers, including homa, have happened,. As have blood, liver and nervous stem problems, hura has been clinical studiefor over 1years. Caw or worseniding ris alrheart iltions,. Beforeatment, gestedorb. Tell your doct if youveeeto areas and if youe had tb, infechepatitis b,mmon, are one tonfections, or have flulike symptomsres. Dont start humira if you haven infectio or have flulike rerey for a new chapter . Talk to rheumatologist. This is hura at wo. A chart that can describe whats going on here. No, no. Joining us now, Clinton Campaign chief strategist joel benenson. And steve rattner. What happened from the Clinton Campaigns perspective . I think on a macro level, donald trump had to have a Game Changing performance. He had a campaign that was failing on the way in. Republicans fraying him all weekend. He had to show them something he hadnt been able to show them before. I think he completely failed to do it, kind of from the moment he went out there, doubling down on his bogus apology, that really wasnt an apology. I dop think anyone who heard this tape think its locker room banter. I think he lost it on several issues where he was incoherent throughout the night. You think hes going to drop out of the race . No, no. He said hes not going to drop out. You want him to drop out . At this pount, its not practical. You had ben ginsberg on before me, he knows, but 29 days to go. I dont think thats an option. Steve, what did you think of the debate . Trump benefitted from the soft bigotry of low expectations. I knew you were a bush man. I was. And i think he saved himself from complete disaster. I dont think he advanced his cause. Do you think he mitt gaded disaster . From the tape . Mmhmm. I think he did, just by throwing up a bunch of stuff. He put on a reality show. You put on a reality show and people get confused as to what the reality is. I thnk me got out alive, and i think he will be in the race. I dont think youll see him move up in the polls where. Think what he misses to do, and this has been a weakness we see over and over again, is he really needed to go beyond just trying to solidify a base. He needs to talk to people in the middle, and he seems to be incapable of doing that. What about, steve rattner, her nonanswer to the cr transcripts, the Goldman Sachs. What part of the nonanswer . The whole part she didnt answer. Do you want me to go further . I can. She deflected. She started blaming russia and the hackers for releasing her information and revealing her to be potentially talking in two different ways and she did not answer that. Im sorry i had to say that, but you made me. Theres a lot in there. In terms of talking two different ways and joel may disagree with me, but i have never met a politician in my 30 or 40 years of hanging around them who didnt talk in somewhat different ways its private or public. I have been on the show 1,000 times where people said this and this, but im not going to say it on camera. I think shes been tough on wall street. I think shes tougher on wall street that donald trump who wants to repeal dodd frank. What she said on wall street has been clear. So i dont have a problem with it. Yeah. Joel, does the Hillary Clinton campaign have more tapes ready . Like the one we saw on friday . We have more tapes . Yeah, do you have Opposition Research like what we saw on friday. We have nothing to do with those tapes, willie. Im not saying you put that tape out specifically. Im saying do you have tapes like that youre prepared to release over the next month. We dont have tapes of donald trump. The world has tapes of donald trump. They had them for a long time. This to me one of the points about donald trump. He seems to be living in some alternate reality. Hes a tv performer. Whether youre talking about his tape recording where he was clearly for the war in iraq or this stuff, he doesnt seem to realize what he haas said and done is on videotape and audiotape. You cant deny it and say what are you going to believe, the ya odd wroe tape or me . Mark halperin. Do you expect more of this to come out . People have said there are more out there. I suspect somebody out there at some point is going to say heres this guy doing the same thing over again. Mark halperin. Joel, under questioning last night, mr. Trump said that despite what hes heard saying on the access Hollywood Tapes hes never forcibly kissed anyone or groped anyone against their will. Do you have reason to believe he wasnt telling the truth when he said that . I would have no reason to believe other than what we all heard on the tapes, mark. I think it was pretty clear to any american, and i think there are probably as Many Americans who watched the first debate, i dont know how many watched last night, but 80 million, for 48 hours, they heard that tape over and over again. Those kind of despicable, demeaning comments bragging and boasting. Oddly enough, i hate to bring it up, but nbc fired billy bush over what his role was in those tapes. Or suspended. Sorry, suspended. This man, you know, doubled down on it last night on the same comments. Well, when you say reason to believe, we dont know for sure, but he has been sued for sexual harassment, was settled out of court. There is stuff out there. By who . Trump . Yeah. See. Trump or clinton . Trump. Just a tratgist, why wouldnt you have her go there on these unfortunate turns that have been taken and these women who were paraded out and put in the front row, accusers of bill clinton. Why wouldnt you go there . Why wouldnt you go there . Why wouldnt you urge your candidate as the Campaign Strategist to go there and say, listen, these are all unconfirmed reports. This is totally inappropriate. And what we do know about my husband, the world knows, we have been through it. Lord knows i have been through it. Nobody was more hurt than me. But i did what i did for my family and for my country because itasnt about me at the time. Those were my choices. Hillary clinton has said that in the past. She has. She has talked akeeping her family together. And you know, i think the issue right now wouldnt that have been a powerful way to sort of turn the page last night . I think were in this moment. What she did last night was the right thing to say. This goes beyond this tape. This is a man, and he again last night refused to apologize to the khan family who he insulted almost again by not apologizing and saying captain khan would have been alive if he had been the captain in chief. The things he said about judge curiel in indiana. Totally agree. This is a pattern of disrespect for anybody who disagrees with this man, the way he treats people who disagree with him. Totally agree. The president of the United States has to listen and respect people. But to get it off her joel benenson, thank you. Im just concerned. A very concerned person. Mark halperin, we thank you for being with us. This capped off an incredible weekend in the president ial race. The past 72 hours boiled down into two minutes. T . Yeahdo. Yoguys working on some ptty stuf overre, right . Like a nanguage focrazybi rlanng machines. Well, t me sfically. I work on. So i bld the worli get it. Es. Cause s superhlevel. I actuly do build machines blink if wt you doing involv encrypted data transfer. Wait, what . Wwww. Wow . What wow . Ther no woho buzng somehings arsi poss. The e king ddlexus turbo a. The v that des togo beyont the e ththput of perfection. Whether its connectingne ofyont or bringg wifi to 65,000s. Bussesesount oncommunicatn cots on centurylin he h a srp wit, athletcholarship nohae tina the micrstay conneed. Ps e micinfinite scalabibity. The microsoft cld hes our custg ywre in e planet er there phone,you got bank, ao clformacacssle it hps us counbettation. Vanced analyticsoolso trk downybercriminals. Is clo hps trsforbusine. This is the microsoft cloud. Starurs withilsonire coar to oral 7000, reves signicy morelae. Th is the sod of Sonic Technology cleaningeep between teeth. Hear the difference . Gehealthier gums in just weeks vs ml toothb and experience a amazg fe of ean. Innovaon and you. Ilips sonica. Veown yoophilnire. I just start kissing them. Like a magnet. I dont even wait. When youre a star, they let you do it. You can do anything. Im out. I can no longer in good conscience endorse this person for president. I respectfully ask you with all due respect to step aside. Step down. Allow someone else to carry the banner of these principles. I believe our only option is to formally ask mr. Trump to step down. Anyone xoo knows me knows these words dont reflect who i am. I said it. I was wrong. And i apologize. Let me just start off by saying, there is a bit of an elephant in the room. And it is a troubling situation. Im serious. I have said some foolish things, but theres a big difference between the words and actions of other people. Bill clinton has actually abused women, and hillary has bullied attacked, shamed, and intimidated his victims. The things she has said and been reported in various books and magazines about the women that bill clinton raped, sexually abused, and attacked. Not bill clintons role, but her role as the attacker. Very courageous women have asked to be here. I am wendy, and im here to support donald trump. Mr. Trump may have said some bad words, but bill clinton raped me. And Hillary Clinton threatened me. I dont think theres any comparison. This was locker room talk. Im not proud of it. I apologize to my family. I apologize to the American People. Certainly, im not proud of it, but this is locker room talk. I have Great Respect for women. Nobody has more respect for women than i do. He has said that the video doesnt represent who he is. But i think its clear to anyone who heard it that it represents exactly who he is. If you look at bill clinton, far worse. Mine are words and his was action. He was what hes done to women. Theres never been anybody in the history of politics in this nation thats been so abusive to women. When hillary brings up words that i said 11 years ago, i think its disgraceful, and i think she should be ashamed of herself, if you want to know the truth. What a weekend its been. Good morning. Its monday, october 10th. What a weekend. Welcome to morning joe. What this mornings New York Times describes as a deeply ugly moment in american politics, donald trump and Hillary Clinton squared off in what would be one of the most remarkable political showdowns in modern american history. Last nights debate devolved into a pitched battle over 90 minutes framed pie a decadeold access Hollywood Tape and past allegations of rape, sexual abuse, and the systemic coverup of bill clintons alleged assaults against the very women who the former president found himself sitting uncomfortably close to last night. Even before the town hall style debate, donald trump shocked the political world by calling a News Conference with clintons alleged victims and they each delivered statements. Im wendy debrodrick, and im here to support donald trump. Mr. Trump may have said some bad words, but bill clinton raped me. And Hillary Clinton threatened me. I dont think theres any comparison. Im kathleen willey, and im here to support donald trump. I think they should all look at the fact that hes a good person. Hes not what other people have been saying hes been, like hillary. Think about that. We support trump. I, at 12 years old, hillary put me through something that you have never put a 12yearold through. And she said shes for women and children. When she was asked last year on what happened, she said shes supposed to defend me. Whether they did or not, shes laughing on tape. The debate began with the two candidates awkwardly refusing to shake hands. Donald trump spent the next hour and a half fighting his way out of a political corner and looking like a man with very little left to lose. So joe, well start off with you. What did you think . Despite what you think of donald trump, what you think of Hillary Clinton, what you think of how this race has gone over the weekend and where you think its going to end up, you think last night any difference at all to the final outcome in november, i think there are a couple of things, and people in the press may nay want to admit, but it was plainly evident watching it on tv last night. Number one, it was Donald Trumps most effective debate performance to date. Theres fought a close second. Just not a close second. Secondly, despite the fact she had an unprecedented cheering section in the media, the fact is for somebody watching, and people see this if they go back and watch it again today or if they see parts of it a week from now or a month from now, Hillary Clinton was on the defensive most of the night. She seemed unsure of herself most of the night. And he dominated the second debate in the same way she dominated the first debate. And third, and i think most importantly, for this political season, donald trump, who has made the Republican Party members lives living and breathing hells for the past year and a half, last night turned it up to 11. And all of those people that jumped ship about halfway through the debate were looking at their tv saying, oh, shoot. Because, and again, i know everybody in the press hates donald trump. Im just giving you the reality. What he said was horrible. Hes horrible, blah, blah, i heard it. I saw it on twitter. I understand. You believe hes an evil man. Im just sgiving you the political reality. This is the political reality. That for the Republican Base, donald trump delivered the attack against the clinton machine that the Republican Base and Middle America have been waiting for for years now. And so good luck being in pence acola, florida, saying, im off donald trump. Or saying in kansas, oh, im not going to be for donald trump anymore. Especially when no republican in america should have been surprised by what they heard on friday. And no republican in america could have done what he did last night. They just oh, my god. It was epic. It was vintage trump. He produced a daylong show that rocked the political world. Take a look at some of the key moments. With his back against the wall. Oh, yeah. If i win, i am going to instruct my attorney general to get a special prosecutor to look into your situation because there has never been so many lies, so much deception. There has never been anything like this where emails, and you get a subpoena, you get a subpoena, and after getting the subpoena, you delete 33,000 emails. So were going to get a special prosecutor, and were going to look into it because you know what. People have been their lives have been destroyed for doing one fifth of what you have done. Its a disgrace. And honestly, you ought to be ashamed of yourself. Secretary clinton, i want to follow everything he said is absolutely false, but im not vised. Its just awfully good that someone with the temperament of donald trump is not in charge of the law in our country. Because you would be in jail. Secretary clinton now, shes blaming she got caught in a total lie. Her papers went out to all her friends at the banks, Goldman Sachs and everybody else. And she said things, wikileaks, that just came out. And she lied. Now shes blaming the lie on the late great Abraham Lincoln. Thats one that i havent heard. Okay. Honest abe. Honest abe never lied. Thats the good thing, the big difference between Abraham Lincoln and you. Thats a big, big difference. Were talking about some difference. She complains that donald trump took advantage of the tax code. Well, why didnt she change it . Why didnt you change it when you were a senator . I heard hillary complaining about so many thingsover the years, but shes been there for 30 years. She never changed and she never will change. Even the moderators were not spared from trumps attacks. Id like to know, anderson, why arent you bringing up the emails . I would like to know. We brought up the emails. No, it hasnt, and it hasnt been finished. Ken has a question. Nice, one on three. Were going to move on to syria. She said a lot of things that are false. I think we should be allowed to dispute it because she has been a disaster as a senator. Were going to move on. I was against you can see it. I was against the war in iraq. It was not debunked, and you voted for it and you shouldnt have. I would like to move on to an online question. She just went about 25 seconds over her time. She did not. Can i respond. Quickly. She went over a minute over, and you dont stop her. When i go one second over, its like you had many answers. Really very interesting. Hillary clinton wants to allow why did it morph into that . Answer the question. Do you still believe why dont you interrupt her . You interrupt me all the time. Would you please explain whether or not the muslim ban still stands . Its called extreme vetting. Okay, with us, we have former Communications Director for president george w. Bush, Nicolle Wallace, who has been up all night. You be careful now, nicolle. Chair of africanamerican studies at Princeton University, eddy gloie glaude jr. , and Mark Halperin joins willie, joe, and me. What was your takeaway on a mind blowing night . Something were all still processing, that that was a p c president ial debate. I learned in my 20s not to get in a bar fight with a guy who has nothing to lose. Donald trump had nothing to lose. He stripped away any pretense of being a politician, any pretense of civility and said im throwing everything at her. I texted this to nikol last night. I said this performance by trump tonight is a fantasy come true for people who havent liked Hillary Clinton for 25, 30 years. And bill clinton. He got to stand on a stage and say all the things they have been saying and emailing to each other that you know very well for a generation. Now, i dont think that wins him any new voters. I think it talks to the people who already loved him and were cheering him on. I saw it on twitter. I was getting texts. The campaign was thrilled with his performance. What does that do . This is really the bottom line. What is the net effect of that init stops the leading, and a lot of those people that jumped ship this weekend are having to answer phone calls all day today from their Republican Base telling them that theyre weasels and they need to get back onboard. There was talk he wasnt even going to show up, that he was going to get out of the race, as many people asked for him to do. Hes now stabilized where hao was, but losing the race. I dont think it helps him win, but hes not going anywhere. Beware of the man with nothing to lose is what i tweeted yesterday afternoon. What willie was talking about as far as the bar fight goes. Beware of the woman without any sleep. We have already learned that off camera this morning. Your reaction to the debate . And most importantly, what does it mean moving forward . In disclosure, we were talking throughout the whole thing. We saw it in real time very differently. I think i was incapable of shaking i dont think i can process trump in an event setting because its never just the event. He gives a speech, and we go on and we analyze his speech, but then by 8 00, he says something more outrageous to undermine it or contradict it, and then by 3 00 in the morning, hes done something else. In isolation, the 90 minutes did represent the net effect of Kellyanne Conway and Chris Christie and Rudy Giuliani and others impressing upon him the need to prep. What you saw was someone who had done real prep, with someone playing Hillary Clinton, with someone playing a moderator, and preparing to answer questions for 90 minutes. They feel like they had to teach him how to pivot after the first debate. I think that operation was largely successful. Pivot he did. But he went in there way behind, and i think hes still behind in this race. And the kinds of people that he needed to win over were the ones that were repulsed by his talk of grabbing the pword. I dont think people repulsed by his talk of grabbing the pword were turning back in his favor last night. There might have been people who were emboldened. The net effect was it was triage, he was bleeding out. His campaign was coming to an end. Everybody was talking about billy bush, everybody was talking about him getting out of the race. Nobody is talking about billy bush this morning. Last night, everyone was talking ability, what are they going to do . Subsection e of the republican rules allows donald trump thats not happen. So hes still in the race, and youre in indianapolis, where mike pence has spent quite a bit of time, and mike pence was a guy over the past couple days who disappeared. We got the word, hey, you know what, im just going to hang back for 48 hours. Theres a word for it. You just you take care of this. He put out a tweet early on attacking donald trump, saying he was offended. They then leaked to the press that they were shocked, flabbergasted, horrified. Again, im going to actually quote paul krugman here. Who could have been shocked by what you saw on friday . Please, republicans. I was shocked. No, but im saying republicans who are saying oh, my god, i thought he was an upright, moral preacher, please, just stop. I think mike pence is the perfect weather vane in Middle America. He sort of darted away from him for the past couple days and let the press know how deeply offended he was. And the second the debate was over, theres a statement. Im shocked, stunned, deeply saddened. The second the debate is over, put up the tweet, yay. Im standing by you. Yay, you win. What are your reactions, Mark Halperin . Look, i think he accomplished three things, which given the state of the campaign, fought only after the tape on friday but leading up to that, are significant. One is hes energized the Republican Base. No doubt that he said a string of things last night to her face that will get a lot of people energized. As willie said, thats not a majority. Two, hes got his running mate apparently back on board. I came here from st. Louis to go to North Carolina today with mike pence. Having pence back on the trail, that was hanging in the blas. Thats a key thing to accomplish, and inside his campaign, theyre confident, energized, excited. Which was not the case over the weekend. They were worried. He had his best debate performance. He showed a lot that he didnt have in the first debate. Heres what he has not accomplished. Will people today come out against him the way they did over the weekend. Thats still possible, including some big names. Two is how does he find an Electoral College path . He didnt have it before friday. He still doesnt right now. If he can consolidate republicans. He can get back to being plausible, and then hoping for some revelations about Hillary Clinton or a strong third debate performance. I think, mika, nobody suggests this morning at this table that he somehow tightened the race. What hes done is hes saved his campaign to fight another day. What was your overall takeaway of everything . I still think its possible he doesnt win. I will say a couple things happened that im still trying to get through here. E media completely overreached. Republicans completely overreached. I just dont understand why any of the people who were denouncing donald trump vehemently and pulling their support are shocked now. What . What do you mean . His statements are horrible. Those statements were horrible. There are many more available to you. To be like that . What do you mean . He said he wanted hold on. This is the same man who told howard stern he wanted to have sex with a dead princess because he liked her skin. What . I missed that. Are you really shocked . I mean, come on, who could be shocked . My point last night was hugh hewitt was on. He was never trump, and then he was really for trump, and then he pulled his support over the weekend. I asked him the same question youre posing. I think people who were never for him arent shocked because this was the character of the man that they could never get behind. And then people that were always for him either didnt know no, they knew. Nicolle, thats pathetic. Dont yell at me. Information out there, baked in the cake. Really, yes. Okay. Do a little google. Just asking. Ill check the google. This guy says a lot of things like that. Okay. I never heard the pword. You didnt hear him say that in New Hampshire. Were you asleep in his rally . Must have been asleep. If i could just finish what i was saying because you do need to actually google him and so do keep republicans who endorsed him and then pulled their endorsements last night. This is what you put you over edge . Youre pathetic, weak, spineless, and now youre going to have to come back potentially. What i wanted to say is that i what did you want to say . I well, i mean, to be shocked, to think this and the first thing he said. I hate to get off your high horse, republicans, get off your high horse. Clinton campaign, please, god, get off your high horse. If i were the Clinton Campaign, i would be bite my tongue. They cancel each other out, again. Any time the topic comes out, but i was horrified how penetrating his attacks were. I was horrified. He teed up the whole day to go there, and he went there. It was savage. I hate once again to bring up paul krugman, but i think he tweeted it out yesterday. Hes absolutely right. Republicans acted shocked on friday. News anchors acted shocked. Because he was behind. If he were ten points ahead, they would have said the same thing, oh, well, you know, my wives and daughters are upset, but they know donald trump is going to we have been through this for like a year and a half. They pick friday when hes down in the polls. This is who they nominated. James baldwin said civilizations arent ended by wicked people. Theyre ended by the spineless. I agree. So im going to make two distinctions. One is youre right about the politics. Everything you said. Last night, i was horrified because i saw the slow death of democracy by 1,000 cuts of the stupid and the vile. Theres one thing to talk about the politics itself. When we talk about the state of our country and the state of american politics, donald trump represents the bottom. The bottom. Really . To me in the sense the only one . No,m just saying hes an exaggerated indication of what the state of american politics actually is. You sound like republicans talking about bill clinton in 1992. I was confused who you were talking about. Mark . If theres no difference between donald trump was revealed to say on friday and past statements, why did melania put out a statement denouncing what he said if theres no difference . Because there was some massive, massive reaction and it was a hot mike, so it was something new. But if you look at any of his interviews with shock jock howard stern or anything that he said on the apprentice none of them involved bragging about violence. Some of them involve bragging about his daughter. Some of them involve bragging about i dont want to, like, compete with you about how much i know about horrific, gross statements donald trump has said, but i have to tell you, for everyone to be so shocked and yet Hillary Clinton and bill clinton, for some reason, get a pass on these things, look, i want hillary to win. I really dont want to have this conversation at all, but people have to come down to earth. The fact is they have had a pass from Polite Society. A pass from Polite Society for decades. They just have. And for actions that are on record. Im not talking about the women who showed up last night. Anyway. Im talking about the actions that are on record in the oval office. So willie, i guess the question is, for these republicans that scurried away, and now may be forced to come back, if donald trump were up by ten points, would they have ran away on friday . I think thats the point were making. Theyre such hypocrites. They scurry away when hes behind. You watch, if he gets five points ahead, theyll come back. Donald said hes sorry. I had some of the same conversations and interviews on etv with people who flipped. I said where were you last december when he called on a ban for all muslims entering america. Thats not a defense of what he said. The tape friday, thats a question of you didnt know all this was coming . What i do think is different, the distinction, is what hes talking about on the tape is physically grabbing a woman and using his star power to go at somebody, to kiss them if they dont want to be kissed or grab them. Who are you talking about . Donald trump, what hes saying on the tape. Thats the distinction people make. Youre physically going at a woman, physically assaulting a woman. Thats different than being creepy and talking about if a girl is an 8 or a 10 or a 4. Sfil ahead on morning joe, inside a Trump Campaign divided. Hallie jackson doesnt sleep. She joins us live from st. Louis just ahead, along with the Washington Posts Eugene Robinson. But first, bill karins with a check on the impact of Hurricane Matthew and some people finally starting to be able to head back to their homes today. Bill. A lot of them arent going to like what they see when they get there, from florida to the outer banks, the stork left its mark. This is the outer banks. They were 100 miles from the center of the storm. No stopping that water in the lower levels. All those homes, all those ruined vehicles. Fayetteville, North Carolina, the biggest story in eastern nirk was the freshwater flooding from over a foot of rain. Two towns are still evacuated because theyre worried about dam failures. The tar river included, still has to crest later this week with numerous homes and businesses going under water, and hilton head, thats from the storm surge. Thats what six feet of storm surge does. A lot of the downed trees, pine trees, a cleanup thats going to take weeks. Lets get to the maps. This is the river flooding, all eastern North Carolina and a bunch of these still have to crest. The nuse river especially is one of them. Thats not going to crest until wednesday and thursday. That will be higher than floyd in 99. We just upped this number. No longer 19. 20 fatalities in the u. S. , and the death toll in haiti, we think will easily go over 900, close to 1,000. 2 Million People still without power and 4. 6 billion when its all said and done, in insurance losses at least. The power will gee going on shortly in a lot of those areas and nice weather for the power crews to get the cleanup going. Youre watching morning joe. jetngine heart beat watngrevving esn weroad lease thhilarating 201 onlyt yo lco dea lincz for 349 a mth kping hels guegin cuttged0 nnected. Fa. Busineesount o and commatn countsn ntylink. In60 pois my chase ink car i boht aherark wiwi. O will rget. Arn more at chase. Com ink e whatheowerpoin ca for yr buss o will rget. I thodithancestdna toalian. Find out i onl itian. So i wenr learned that on oancestors w. Americans e mey ancestor anmo of erytng oe. Any sies relone ununed stapoalr thths w wke moroecommerce s our business th anyonyouithe country. E itta post ser. Coming up on morning joe i have a strange feeling at the debate there will be another name that will come up from Hillary Clinton that we havent heard or thought about. I think between now and election day and the one thing trump cannot recover, he recovers from the sleaze, he doesnt recover from the hate stuff. There wul be more women stuff to come and he doesnt recover from that. I would be shocked if between now and november 8th, there arent three or four names of women we havent heard or thought about that articulate the problem trump has. What do they say about a Blind Squirrel, willie . What . Every once in a while. Even a Blind Squirrel finds a nut. Donny deutsch joins us. Well get his take on whether trumps damage control made up for the tape. Hotallreou . How do we ure greatnes erica . It msureby wt we do for ouchdr. Hotallreou . Its whys presidt ill investn ols. Colno. Lead rties. And economy w everyouamicind jb thatets them arfamily their own i mi nt our s to beas by theirs kids a families. Im artoan prove this message. Mobity ivery important toe. And it keepsy investment y mo. Up to six hundreredollar up eadt when start desnironx lethmusica i ce up. Lf borittmbe y mo. Wh this idea of fr towe there fire escapes. When start desnironx lethmusi. Essentially. Rittmbe y mo. Ill bui aite del inphothop a. Details in en. F fr towe there fire escapes. I could never do thawith a ma i fl my job is. O puout there juh tail to spurhe audnces. Magination to fiin allhe. Thisdo pc amang, having all of my too. Right at myinr tips is inedible right behind you, could you tell . I could tell, yes. That was Hillary Clinton on the plane home last night after the debate, talking about Donald Trumps looming presence on the stage, standing behind her, directly at many times. Over the course of the night. Joining us now from st. Louis, nbc News White House correspondent Kristen Welker who is covering the Clinton Campaign. How does the Clinton Campaign feel this morning after the debate . Well, willie, i can tell you that heading into the debate, a number of Clinton Campaign Officials Say they were bracing for an allout assault and attack from donald trump. And they think thats essentially what they got. They said they werent overwhelmingly surprised when trump actually brought up the four women who are accusers of bill clinton. They were surprised, of course, he actually brought them to the debate hall. They say secretary clinton handled it with steadiness, their words. Particularly the fact that when donald trump raised the issue of bill clintons accusers, secretary clinton quoted michelle obama, that line that we all know, when they go low, we go high. That was something she was planning for. She quickly pivoted. The question is will that strategy of pivoted work . The Clinton Campaign doesnt think trump will win over new voters. The one moment of difficulty was when trump raised the newly leaked wall street speeches. She said politicians sometimes need to be different in private than they are in public. Obviously, she was on defense about that a lilt bit last night. She will likely continue to get tough questions about that on the campaign trail. Today, she is back on the campaign trail in ohio, where shes going to be urging folks to turn out to register and vote, then she heads to droiths ahead of that states filing deadline. Kristen welker, thank you so much. We greatly appreciate it. Donny deutsch joins us now along with the New York Times reporter yamiche alcindor. We talked about we usually get through the debates, dreary sometimes. All of us said separately, we were staring at the ceiling at midnight like, what just happened . When the debate ended, i kept thinking i could have watched more of that. What you saw was two people going at each others throats and this idea you had donald trump really talking about jailing his opponent and then you have dt Hillary Clinton saying his campaign is imploding. This is stuff you have heard people say, but to have the candidates do that, it was incredible to watch. Its like youre describing a huge reality show. I want to talk about the reality of the debate last night. And donny, you said the same thing. Last night, you were jittery at midnight. He didnt take anything. Youre correct in that donald trump was the aggressor, was taking it to her, but he lost the debate. Let me tell you why. Very simple. This is no longer about politics. The isis a gender war. I have spent thousands of hours in women focus groups. And the friday thing how did you sneak in . Thats really pervy. How did you sneak in . The friday thing of we dont have to redo of grabbing a woman. Every woman in america, as he was lurking behind, as Nicolle Wallace said, i would have called 911. As he was telling her he was going to jail her, women in america are going to stand up and revolt. Its always been about the women, and there will be more to come. The words didnt mean anything. Every woman in america who has ever been held down, oppressed, harassed, there is something in them as a nerve that is hit that is so transcending Everything Else. If youre not seeing that, youre missing by the way, its not inpoint that men objectify wimb. Its what they heard and saw. To willies point earlier i wonder, were you saying this about bill clinton in 1998. Hillary clinton is running for office, not bill clinton. This is hillary, not bill. Seriously, are you everybody says donald trump im observing what is going on in this country. Just read what maureen dowd writes about Hillary Clinton. Dont scream. Im sorry. Let me make my point. A little hyped up. You are a little hyped up, but the thing is, i guess, ill just read from the wall street journal who says its a bit much to see the same liberals who said mr. Clintons actual exploitation of an intern was merely about sex, by the way, they destroyed her life. Or who called paula jones trailer trash, remember that line . You know, if you drag a dollar bill through a trailer park, no teller what youll pick up. Now wax indignant about mr. Trumps bragging. When people like you, and i know people like you through the 1990s were bragging about bill clinton and what he got away with. People like me are observing and understand how women are going to react to this. Im not passing my moral judgment on either of those. Where were you in the 1990s. Doing a lot of drugs. What i am telling you is that when did he stop . I thought he still did them. What happened friday was different than Everything Else. Was jfk a philanderer . Yes. Was bill clinton . Yes. Abusive. By the way, jfk in the white house, jfk in the white house had, i believe, like very, very young interns. A code name tweedle dee and tweedle dum, inexplicable. And american women love him. Which i dont get. Donny brings up a really good point. This election does seem that it is now going to be an election, its men on one side. You look at women, educated versus people with high school degrees. It seems you go down the polls, and there is more of a split than i think we have ever seen in our life. Part of the other thing i should bring up is this idea of why do we think this moment is different . I have a piece out today in the New York Times talking about to a lot of strategists and experts who say it feels different because its perceived hes talking about white women. An ide is at this point, we feel a though white womens lives have to be protected, saved. These people werent jumping ship when he was talking about mexicans or blacks or muslims. There are people saying that, but i think what Hillary Clinton did last night is point out what pollsters have been saying to me, that there are a lot of people who look at his attacks on those groups, suburban white women who look at his attacks on mexicans and muslims and blacks and flee and dont want to vote for him for that. This idea of the election being divided, its not just women versus men because the electorate is not that divided. When you talk about africanamericans or muslims, women were already fleeing donald trump because of that. You bridge up some great points about what he said in the past. I said two months before the first republican vote was cast, i could never vote for donald trump because of a muslim ban. Then i said it was disgirlfriending because of what he said about david duke. That should have stopped you right there, everybody. The moral preening i have seen from republicans in the past couple days has been sickening. You bring up a great point. Why werent they offended back in december . Go to the first day of the campaign when he said some mexican immigrants are rapists. Thats day one of the campaign. Going to him attacking a p. O. W. And saying hes not really a hero. Go to him going after the khan family. So many points along the road where you could have been indignant morally. What the experts tell me is republicans that are freeing, john mccain and jeb bush and people talking about their wives and daughters, they didnt see their wives and daughters when he was talking about immigrants, muslims. They thought maybe their neighbors, the people who work for them, but they didnt see their families. Now we have this idea hes going after women, groping white women. That could be my daughter. That empathy issue is problematic. Which makes me wonder where democrats were, and i wondered in the 1990s when a young woman who was 23, 23, was exploited by the president of the United States. And i will tell you, i heard men all around the capitol, i heard men on tv, i heard men who contributed money to bill clinton, wllaughing about how tt guy, he can get away with anything. I thought to myself, do these guys not have young daughters . Heres one difference. There is no difference. We read about the cigar. Heres the difference. He did it. And donald trump talked about it. If we heard him saying, video, oh, im going to take this cigar. There is a visceral difference. We have kids. Im just saying. Im not going to say that. You just did. If we visually saw or heard from his words youre saying if he had been with billy bush in a hot mike, it would history would have been different . Yes. Yes. Donny, we have to leave it there. We have kids. Okay. Kids are watching. Donny, thank you, i think. And i heard so many men, and it was sickening at the time, laughing about how he could get away with anything. Well be looking for your piece. In todays New York Times . Coming up in the 9 00 a. M. Hour, youll hear from mike pence. He joins msnbc. Much calmer than this just was. Trying to make sense of last nights debate and the whole weekend that was. I think donny is still doing what he did in the 90s. T its a manufacri job. Yeah, welle is doing a lot ofool things digitally to help machines communicate, mit wawao at lstntion that. M building does that at you . Es. No dont be silly. Im just, uh, going to go to chop se wood. With that . Yeah we dont have an ax or firlace. Uld yot thbread . Red. Sclking aunr travel sites to fd a bett price. Thlowest priceon ourotels always at hilton. Com. So pay less and t more only at hion. Com. For four years. You med it d then you. You two haen through everything together. Two boyfriends, three jobs. Youre like noing can ree. Theniberty mutl calls. And you brk into your happy dance well pafoa thats a model year ner with 15,00fewer mis an your olon berty stan with you™. Bertmutual ins. Doesn go on your wrist. Technology. Thghlyanceaudi a4, with claleadi horpower. Withmodete to severe crohase,. Was always. I tht i had itovered. En i realized managing was all i was doing. When i finly told my docto he said hu w for peoe ke me whve tried other dications,. Bustl experice thesymptoms of moderate to sere crohns disease. In cl, thmarity of patients on humira saw siificant sympto reli. A many acev remission. Humira c lerouabily to fight ctions. Serious,ometimes fat infectns and canrs,. Including lymphoma, have happened; asave blood, ler, and nesystem pros, serious allergic actions,. And new or worseninar before treatment, get sted fotb. Tell yououor if youve been to areas where certain fungal infections are common, teepatitis bare prone toeen and yinfeions,b,. Ohave fluike symptomsores dont starmira if you have an infection. Ifoue still just managingyour , dont starmira if you have ask your gastroeerologis abou. Thumira, rission possible. It a profr who ver sts being a student . Is it a cagiver determinedto . Is it a lifete of work that blazes path to yo pon your personasuccess takea financiapartner who values it as much as you do. All right, we have some kids here. You cover your ears because were talking politics. Over the weekend, many more endorsements for Hillary Clinton came out. Cover your ears, children. And this morning, Foreign Policy magazine writes in its first ever political endorsement, quote, the litany of reasons trump poses such a threat is so long that it is shocking that hes the major partys candidate for the presidency. Well talk about all these other things that i cant say right now. Next, well bring in the Washington Posts Eugene Robinson and Hallie Jackson live from the debate site. Dont miss it. Close your ears. And why a pro foball team chose tdelive fiand why a leading car bran thcounts on uso keep eir deal nwork streamlined and go ahead, spoil urur. Businesses count on communication,nd cnicati counts on nturylink. It ja the es and es id. This ithe pursuit of perfeion. Knows how iteels to see younuergo up,es despite your best efforts. Kbut what if you uld to seeturnhings around . Atf yocoul love youmbers . Scern escredsglt2 in kbut what if you uld to seeturnhings around . That workso wea1 invona is a anercise to significantly lower blood sur adults withype 2 diabetes. That workso wea1 invona is a anercise to significantly d in most inicalrials, the jority reached aa1goal of 7 pcent or lor. Invokana works ad the clock by u of your body thrgh thocess of urination. Its n for lowering syolic Blood Pressure oreit, but it melp th both. Invoka canause impornt sidefs inclg dehyation, mayuse yoto fe, faint, lightheaded, or weak,. Other side effts m include kiroblems, genil ast inctio, changes in urinaon, other side effts m include high potasum, creas in cholesterol, sk of bo fctur or urinary tract infections, possly sious. Skserious eec may inudtoacidosist infections, which can beife thatening. St takg d call your doctor rit away ifouiee symptoms or isuchra, ling,t allergicn oriffilty breathing or swa. Oridproble if or are on diys. Iv tell yr doctorbout any dicaconditions usinvona with a and sulfonylurea or sulin may cause w blood sur. Lower your blood sug with invokana®. Its time to tn things aroun imagine lovi your numbs. Theres onlyne invan®. Imask your dtor about it by name. Narrator it wasnt that long ago. Years of devastating cutbacks to our schools. 30,000 teachers laid off. Class sizes increased. Art and music programs cut. We cant ever go back. Ryan ruelas so vote yes on proposition 55. Reagan duncan prop 55 prevents 4 billion in new cuts to our schools. Letty munozgonzalez simply by maintaining the current tax rate on the wealthiest californians. Ryan ruelas no new education cuts, and no new taxes. Reagan duncan vote yes on 55. Sarah morgan to help our children thrive. Reagan duncan vote yes on 55. In your mutual fund. We invd in your fund to help us p forcolle educa. ve enclos a picture of our son sohayocan get a see eraral pplee at fidelit we don just nage money, we manage peoplesoney. Safety doesnt come ia bo its nobanner that goes on a wl. Its not something you do now and then. Safety doesnt come ia bo or when its convenient. Its using stateofthert simulators iging offore amonshore support. If something doesnem right. At b safy is ner being satiied. And al wking to be better. When a moment turns romantic, why pause to take a pill or stop to find a bathroom . Both erectile dysfunction cialis for daily use is approved to treat ke o frequently, day oright. Yor aboutll youredal conditismedicines, d asouheart is healthy oughor sex. Notrialcohoin e eess. Side efftsayncludead, upset, notrialcohoin e eess. Delad backache or muscle ache. To avoidongte iy,ludead, upset, get dicalp rigway for rection lag more than fourours if you have any sudden decase or loss ineariri or vision, or anyymptoms of an lergic reaction, ting cialis a get medical helpightway. Asyour dtor about cialis and a 200 sin card. Guy i ting cialis a get medical helpightway. Things authe network. Nt . Im hd all the networks are gat now. Wee lking within a 1 differee in reliability of each other. And,d,int saveyo50 ont rrent national crier rates. In reliability of each other. And,d,int saveyo50 save moneyyour pne bl, invest it in yr national crier rates. Small busiss. Wouldnt yove moreustomers . I would definitely lov someew custors. Switch your bunesso spri and se sprint will help you add customs and cut your cos. Most rrent rizon, at t and tobils. Nt t 1 difference cost you twice as much. Oo opleith hearinlovisisirirelay. But callinabt that credit srecard im customer to dog ve i but callinabt that credit srre rd im customer itsree for everyone. Oh ll tts ce and checking yr score wont rt your credit. Oh to dog m so pro of you. Well thank you. En if youre not a cusmer. Scorecard at dve joining us now, Pulitzer Prize winning columnist and associate of the Washington Post and msnbc political analyst Eugene Robinson. And from st. Louis, nbc news correspondent Hallie Jackson who is covering the Trump Campaign. Hallie, what are you hearing this morning from the trump people . Hey, guys. Listen, youre seeing, i think, that Kellyanne Conway did a masterful job on your show, other shows of summing up where the Trump Campaign is publicly, that is essentially trying to declare victory, to double down on the strategy we saw last night. The bannonesque strategy that you saw when you saw these women emerge in st. Louis. What am i hearing from other publicans . One top operarerative tells me think the agent of change has just lost his advantage with this move. What is interesting to me, continuing on to say it was a hail mary, essentially. What was also interesting to me, jeff sessions, senator sessions who i spoke with last night on the camp of washington university, i said when did you know that women like paula jones and juanita broadwalk were going to come here, and he laughed and said when i turned on the tv and saw it with Everything Else. This was a move that was planned with intentional surprise to try to rattle Hillary Clinton. I think there are some question marks that we will have answered over the next 24 to 48 hours as to how other republicans are going to be reacting to this. Particularly vulnerable down ballot senators. Its fascinating. Hallie jackson, thank you very much. Gene, first, just go. Whats your gut . My gut is that on friday, probably cooked the race. This deal is probably done. Donny deutsch said something earlier that i cant believe anyone would argue with, which is that theres a difference between reading soandso said this and somebody else saying somebody did that. And hearing and seeing the principal. Donald trump, it enters your head in a totally different way. And so, you know, i think the question now is how bad the damage is to the rest of the Republican Party. And last night, i dont think did a lot to make republicans feel better about their prospects. You know, it may cause some hesitation among republicans so were going to jump ship today. They might be more reluctant to do that now. Not because they dont think its the right thing to do. Just because they think he shored up the base last night. He didnt get a single incremental vote last night. He didnt get anybody new. Anybody new. Not one. I dont say anything unequivocal anymore. By the way, i covered banana republ republics, places where the new president tried immediately to put his predecessors and the brithe Previous Administration in jail. Thats not where the country wants to be. I was shocked when he said that. We heard the same thing we heard. A lot of people voting for donald trump are doing so because they so dislike Hillary Clinton. To me, watching last night was a pep rally for those people. A guy standing onstage, going after Hillary Clinton in a way they could only dream about as they have disliked her for so long. He has them excited. I wish she would have gotten them excited. Some of them might have come over, but here we are just down the street from ferguson, no mention of policing and race. No mention of climate change. No mention we couldnt talk about the issues, on and on. By the way, hard to be the change candidate when youre talking about stuff that happened 20 years ago. Involving the other candidate. Its a mess. Its a mess. Involving the other candidates husband. The damage being done to the Republican Party and to the Clinton Campaign i mean. Mind boggling. I open up this quote, but democracy is a word, the real gist of which still sleeps. Last night, we found ourselves ipa moment where walt whitman is turning over in his grave. That does it for us this morning. Mike pence joins Stephanie Ruhle straight ahead. Stephanie picks up the coverage right now. Thanks so much. Good morning. Im Stephanie Ruhle. This morning, down and dirty debate. Accusations and insults fly. Donald trumps attacks on Hillary Clinton over her husband. Never been knbld in the history of politics in this nation thats been so abusive to women. This after his Bizarre Press Conference with bill Clinton Accusers just before the debate began. Hillary clinton hitting back over that lewd tape of trump. But i think its clear to anyone who heard it that it represents exactly who he is. That was locker room talk. The revelations trump admits he may not have paid federal taxes for years. Did you use that 960 million loss to avoid paying personal federal tax snz. Of course, i did. His muslim ban has changed. The muslim ban is something that in some form has morphed into an extreme vetting