Miracle. I didnt know if i would live. Was this some awful random crime . Or did someone want her dead . That was mystery number one. Someone was out there. Yeah, we were scared. Mystery number two, a secret 1600 miles away. There were several Text Messages. Its slowly snowballing. It was like a punch in the gut. Mystery number three. Im gonna hurt you. Who did they turnout to be . What did this lady do . Fate, temptation and the twist the size of texas. Lets be very clear. Justice needs to be served. I dont think it has been. Carol strollton, texas, nort dallas, where the upwardly mobile go to buy their dreams. Schools are good, golf courses got the landscape, and churches are more ubiquitous than starbucks. Theres not a lot of crime in that area. Its a great area to raise kids and a family. But travel east 100 miles or so, and you enter the piney woods of east texas. Jobs are not as plentiful here. Dreams are deferred. And some keep bail bonds men on speed dial. All the people that were dealing with here are poor. Theres a lot of drugs, lot of methamphetamine out there. Different cultures, worlds apart. And yet one summer those two worlds collided in a most unlikely way. This is the story of that summer when money seemed to fall like ticker tape on the piney woods. An affluent carrollton family experienced the kind of Violent Crime that always happened somewhere else. God, help me yes, maam. Help me, help me i need you to call me immediately. Your mom is in the hospital with a gunshot wound. Im sorry, what . Each day we look at each other, michael and i, and say, we cant make this up. Our story begins in august 2012. Can you believe it . 100 degrees again this afternoon. It was the kind of heat that melts asphalt and has everyone searching the sky for some sign of mercy. But in carrollton, 52yearold frank howard wasnt sweating it. Frank was an accountant. His life was good and Getting Better by the day. I took on a new client that would have been probably in 2009. Very wealthy client . Yes. What did that come along with, those perks . Well, the wealthy client, you know, he had his own airplanes and so i guess for the first time probably flying around in private planes. And going to cowboy games. As they say in texas, frank howard was standing in high cotton. I was still the same old guy, but it was definitely doing some fun things as well. Frank had come a long way since growing up as a preachers son in South Central texas. Very conservative up bringing, no drinking or cussing, never been to the school prom, never did any of that kind of stuff. At the same time, just wanting to be very down to earth, honest, and try to be the best person you could be. Solid values to last a lifetime. But it wasnt all smooth sailing. In College Frank had a brief marriage that ended in divorce. Eventually he fell in love with a girl from his church. Her name was nancy schor. A brunet with dazzling blue eyes. It was a great time. I still look back at that and think it was a good time. Franks father married the happy couple in 1983 and two years later they had their first child, a daughter they named ashley. That wasnt an easy birth. No. There were problems. Yeah, there were complications. She spent the first ten days of her life in the, uh, in the Neonatal Unit at the hospital. It was a close call, but one that seemed to deepen and enrich the couples faith. Soon the family grew to include a son jay and another daughter breyona. Growing up was great. I had a wonderful older sister and older brother who helped guide me through stuff, and obviously a wonderful mom and dad. Eldest daughter ashley says that whatever the Howard Family did, they did together. Both our parents did choir in church. Any time they needed a family. Oh, get the hours. Theyll come and bring all the kids. We were, you know, always together, always a family. We went to all of their events. They were busy. They were always doing something, whether it was, you know, soccer or, you know, anything in the fine arts musically. You guys almost do sound like leave it to beaver. We joke we were the cleavers. I was beavette. We would have game night. Legitimately the cleaver family. Absolutely, yeah. But by 2012 those days were gone. Frank and nancy were empty nesters. Ashley and jay were on their own. Breyona was in college in nashville. You were so close with your kids. Was it hard as one by one they started leaving the nest and going off to college . Sure, yeah it was. I mean, im proud of them, but it was difficult. I mean, change is difficult. Now nancy was often home alone. Franks work with his new client, a wealthy defense contractor, had him traveling to florida, california, even kuwait. There was a little bit more, you know, freedom or whatever, and like i said, a lot of it was work. And so, you know, i was out there trying to kind of build it and she was sitting at home. Still, nancy had her faith and Church Activities to fill the empty hours. In fact, thats where shed been the evening everything changed for the Howard Family. It was a saturday night, august 18th, 2012. Youre out of town. Yes. You get a call. Yes. That something horrific has happened to nancy. Theres been a robbery at your own house. Yes, i was just just beside myself. I didnt know, you know, what was happening. And so began one of the longest nights of Frank Howards life. Coming up, a harrowing cry for help. God, help me. Yes, maam. Terror was at the door. Im like, our mother . That just makes no sense. Almost like it wasnt real . Yeah, like it wasnt real. When dateline continues. Ot knives, watch your blue light lanterns, blast those eardrum bangers look at this one hes trying to pick up the mail hah silly. Oh. Silly humans. Who do you think you are . Pain will bring you to your senses. You cannot keep this up pain says you cant. Advil says you can. I am what i live. My way. The new fragrance giorgio armani. Are my smile cant compete. On for this . Anyone . Mmm. Nope for a smile thats always camera ready. Crest 3d white removes 95 of stains in just 3 days. Stnarrow it to all thes ikarate moms. In desperate need of brown sugar. Meaning, you. Youre the one we made mywalgreens for. With pickup in as little as 30 minutes. Hiya get 30minute pickup at walgreens. Com bundle auto and home, and save up to 25 with allstate. Bundling just feels good this time of year. Saving is easy when youre in good hands. Call a local agent, or 1800allstate for a quote today. After months of broiling temperatures, the afternoon of august 18th, 2012, brought the welcome sound of summer rain to carrollton, texas. But shortly before 8 00 that evening, the sound of a gunshot split the night. The 911 operator picked up the phone and heard a womans anguished cry. Lord, jesus, help me. Oh, my god, help me. Oh, jesus, help me. The woman said she had just been shot in the head by an intruder in her garage. Ive been shot. Whats the address, maam . The caller was franks wife, nancy howard. Shed somehow managed to drag herself into the house and in spite of taking a bullet in the head, she was able to give critical details to the 911 dispatcher. How many people was it . Its just one. He was yes, maam, im going to stay on the phone with you until they get there. A few minutes later Carrollton Police officers arrived at the home on bluebonnet way. As remarkable as it sounds, nancy managed to open the front door for them. Yes, maam. God help me. Help me. Soon, Carrollton Police detectives michael wall and brian turner were on the case. Its just incredible how she was able to give the information to the dispatcher about what had happened. And then be able to wait for the police at the front door. This was a really bloody crime scene. There was quite a bit of blood, yes. There was a small hole just above nancys left eye. She was struggling for breath and her vital signs were slipping. As paramedics rushed her to Parkland Hospital in dallas, detective wall turned his attention to the crime scene. You could see exactly where shed gone through the house. The garage and the hallway leading into the house were bloody. But the rest of the house appeared to have been untouched. The suspects had taken nancys purse. Did you have any reason to believe when you arrived that this was anything other than a burglary gone bad . We didnt have any other reason to suspect that it was anything other than an aggravated robbery given the information nancy had given us. What details did you get from that 911 call specifically . Nancy was able to give us suspect description of the person that shot her. It was a white male, he was wearing a black hat, the suspect was, in his 20s. Police officers could find no one in the neighborhood who had seen or heard anything. It had been raining significantly. Obviously when it rains people are inside. Theres no witnesses. We basically had nothing to go on. No witnesses and precious little in the way of leads. They wondered if the shooting was part of a pattern of crimes in the area. It seemed unlikely, but they couldnt rule it out. There had been some breakins in the area. There were some breakins we were looking at to see if they were related to this offense. At this point we were checking out everything to see if there was anything that maybe related to this. But there had not been any robberies of people being robbed at gunpoint for their property. The cops knew they had to notify nancys family. But as it turned out her husband was out of town. A Police Officer who belonged to the howards church got word to nancys eldest daughter ashley. Its a close friend of my moms calling to say your mom is in the hospital with a gunshot wound. Im like, im sorry, what . That must be the most bizarre phone call. It was the weirdest phone call. It was not even scary or worrisome. It was more like, so con we couldnt cross the hurdle of where she could have been to get shot. Almost like it wasnt real. Yeah, like it wasnt real. It was like, our mother . That just makes no sense. Shes not the type of lady thats going to get shot, you know . Ashley finally reached her father in california with the news. I was actually in South Lake Tahoe at the casino. I was taking a break and noticed that i had missed a call from my daughter. And so i stepped outside and called her back and then thats when i found out that something had happened. How does he react to the situation . He couldnt speak, he couldnt breathe. Dad, who is with you . Because you are not in good shape. Okay, im going to drive to the airport. No, no, youre not driving to the airport. Get someone to take you. I was crying and just going crazy. And so then i was on the phone trying to find flights out and trying to figure out, you know wlarks to know, what to do and how to do it. It was 6 00 before frank could find a plane to board home. He could only imagine what awaited him once he landed in texas. Coming up. My dad is like collapsed on the ground. He was in terrible shape. As doctors race to save nancy, her family races to her side. Who could possibly be behind this . We were trying to figure out what happened and how it happened, and we didnt have any idea. Someone was out there. Yeah, yeah. We were scared. When dateline continues. Crafting our authentic fragrances begins with ingredients from the earth. To create fragrances infused with natural essential oils. Air wick scented oils. Connect to nature. Wthe Natural Light is amazing. Hardwood floors. There is a bit of a clogging problem. clog dancing at least geico makes it easy to bundle our renters and car insurance. Yeah, helping us save us even more. For bundling made easy, go to geico. Com unstopables inwash scent booster. Downy unstopables. Robinwithout the commission fees. So, you can start investing today wherever you are even hanging with your dog. So, what are you waiting for . Download now and get your first stock on us. Robinhood. Frank howard arrived home in dallas the morning after his wife was shot. His daughter ashley says he looked awful when she finally saw him. They drove to the hospital together and by the time they got there he could hardly walk. And i hear like this crash and i look back, my dad has collapsed on the ground. He was in terrible shape. And every time the little monitors would beep, he was jummy. Jumpy, just terrible shape. Was he in tears . Yeah. Tell me what happened the first time you saw nancy in the icu. It was a difficult time. She was real drugged up, but all the family and, and a lot of people from the church and stuff were there. Doctors told the family the bullet had entered nancys skull just above her left eye and traveled downward through her sinuses and throat before it collapsed one of her lungs. She had the first of many surgeries. She would lose one of her blue eyes, but luckily she escaped serious brain damage. Theres tubes and lines. You could say shes all right. It doesnt look like shes all right, you know. Theres swelling, theres inflammation all over. Things attached to her feet. So its kind of hard to feel like, okay, this is okay and this is right. It was very traumatic to see, to see that happen to her, very difficult, very, uh, very emotional time. Was she able to talk to you the first time you saw her . I dont believe so. She had tubes in her throat and she was conscious, so she had knowledge of kind of who we were, but she really couldnt talk or anything. While the family waited for some definitive word from the police on what had happened, they filled the void with theories of their own. Everybody in the family were sitting around talking about it. Thats, you know, we were trying to figure out what happened and how it happened, and we didnt have any idea. Someone was out there. Yeah, yeah, we were scared. There had been a series of breakins in the area. Did that cross your mind . That was one of the things that came up. I believe the detectives or whatever had told us there had been breakins. In fact, they had somebody that fit kind of the general description that he was someone that they knew of that had participated in some breakins in the area. Detectives wall and turner were eager to talk to nancy. Shes our only witness to this offense. We just had the minimal suspect description at this time, so we felt it was important to confirm those details with her as soon as possible. While they waited for nancy to get well enough to speak, they called in frank, hoping he could fill in some of the blanks. Can you update me on her condition, what the doctors have said . Yes. Actually very i mean, sounds bad when you say somebody it was very good. He confirmed she lost her left eye. No brain damage, you know, none of that. Shell lose her left eye, but from there it will be, um, cosmetic stuff. Detective wall asked if frank knew anyone who might want to hurt his wife. What would i know about her . Doesnt seem like she would have any problems with anybody. Absolutely not, absolutely not. In fact, everyone knew that nancy had a soft spot for anyone with a sob story. Nancy can be, um, real, um, um, giving and open. It was not unusual, he said, for her to pickup a hitch hiker or open the door to a stranger. A month before somebody did that. They needed money to get to a hotel, their car broke down. At your house . Yes, at the front door. Nancy told them she just said, uh, that, uh, she would try to help them find a hotel room. Maybe thats what happened. A good hearted woman befriended a dangerous stranger. The howard children thought that was a distinct possibility. That was my first thought was, oh, she probably was willing to help someone at some point and they figured out, okay, this woman is an easy target. Could your mom be naive when it came to these people and this helping nature she had . Definitely. I think that sometimes her, her willingness to see the good in everybody, it opened her up to more risk than, um, most other people would take. Frank didnt know much because he was out of town that night. Doesnt sound like frank is able to help you anything. Hes being cooperative. He is being cooperative. He confirmed he sent a few texts and emails back and forth to nancy. He knew she was going to Church Service. In order to confirm, i asked if i could see his cell phone. Would you have a problem if we ran an analysis on your cell phone . No. In addition to turning over his cell phone, frank told the cops to let them know if they needed anything else from him, anything at all. He even offered money to generate leads. I mean, if theres, you know, you put up a reward or anything like that, ill be able again, when we get to the point weve exhausted all of our investigative leads, thats another step we would take. I understand. Whatever we can do. Obviously money can prompt people to give information. At the hospital, doctors were optimistic about nancys condition. She was still in intensive care but making progress. There was every reason to believe that shed be able to tell her own story in a day or two. Coming up. I shoved my purse into his chest and i said, jesus, save me. Nancys dramatic story. Exactly what did she remember about that night . I did look him in the face and i did look him in the eyes. No pity. No emotion. He looked intent on doing what he came to do. When dateline continues. For people with certain inflammatory conditions. Because there are options. Like an unjection™. Xeljanz. The first and only pill of its kind that treats moderate to severe rheumatoid arthritis, psoriatic arthritis, or moderate to Severe Ulcerative Colitis when other medicines have not helped enough. Xeljanz can lower your ability to fight infections. Before and during treatment, your doctor should check for infections, like tb and do blood tests. Tell your doctor if youve had hepatitis b or c, have flulike symptoms, or are prone to infections. Serious, sometimes fatal infections, cancers including lymphoma, and blood clots have happened. Taking a higher than recommended dose of xeljanz for ra may increase risk of death. Tears in the stomach or intestines and serious allergic reactions have happened. Needles. Fine for some. But for you, theres a pill that may provide symptom relief. Ask your doctor about the pill first prescribed for ra more than seven years ago. Xeljanz. An unjection™. Narrator upgrade your protectin this holiday season. But come ye back when su mom, dad. Whys jamie here . Its sunday. Sunday sing along. And he helped us get a home and auto bundle. Hes been our insurance guy for five years now. He makes us feel like were worth protecting. [ gasps ] why didnt you tell us about these savings, flo . Ive literally told you a thousand times. Oh, danny boy, the pipes, the pipes are calling im just gonna. From glen to glen hello, im dara brown. Heres whats happening. Leaders in the house and santa anita reached an agreement on the 900 billion. It extends the deadline. Lawmakers did not vote on the deal itself. That should happen monday. The final package will provide 600 in direct payments to americans. Unemployment insurance, Small Business loans and funding for vaccine distribution. Now back to dateline. Nancy howard lay in Parkland Hospitals intensive care unit, sedated and surrounded by blinking, beeping machines. A breathing tube prevented her from speaking, but her daughters say she could still communicate. She used to do sign language, so she knows how to spell. Bri and i know how to spell a little bit. Shes doing stuff with the bottom of her hand. Shes spelling something. Crap, breyona, what is that letter again . Any time somebody would say something, shed beat her hand on the pillow. No, no, put our spelling caps on. Nancys recovery was remarkably speedy. Just days after she was shot in the head at close range, she was able to get out of bed, take a few steps, and best of all, the breathing tube was removed. The Howard Family rejoiced. Finally nancy could speak. Do you consider it a miracle . Oh, absolutely. Theres no explanation except my heavenly father was there. What did she say to you when she finally was able to speak . It was just, you know, i love you, glad youre here. I mean, that was the sense that we were both saying to each other. And then it was time for business. Detectives wall and turner wanted to know every last detail of that night. It began at nancys church. I had a plan that evening to go to church to see one of my little children that ive known since she was born, and she was being baptized that night at church. Surveillance cameras caught nancys car pulling into the Church Parking lot shortly before 6 00 that evening. In the service, i got my picture with their family. It was just a very, very special time. And then i walked on out and got in my car and started heading home. It was 7 26 when nancy pulled out of the Church Parking lot. On the way home, she picked up dinner at a a place called taco bueno. Her receipt shows it was 7 32 when she paid for the meal. Drove on in my driveway. Lifted the garage door as i usually do. Drove in. Got out of my car. Got up to the door, didnt hear a thing. But suddenly there was a man with his arm around my neck and a gun to my head demanding my purse. And whats that feeling like . It didnt really register what was going on. So much so that i guess i didnt have quite enough fear. I dont know. Because i wrestled away from him and turned and faced him. And realized this is for real. This guys got a gun. Robbing me. And, um, he demanded, again, my purse. And i had my purse on this shoulder and my taco bueno bag and so i gave him my taco bueno bag. I bet that guy was thinking, what is this woman doing giving me her supper . She doesnt get it. And so finally the third time he demanded with expletives my purse. And i finally caught on and i reached off, and i was standing close enough to him to have an arms length to shove my purse into his chest and i shoved my purse into his chest and i said, jesus, save me. And the bullet shot me right in the head and i went down. Nancy doesnt know how long she lay unconscious on the garage floor. When she came to, the shooter was gone. But she said she was not alone. I began to kind of come to and i thought, i think youve been shot. Youre gonna die. And then there was another voice and it was the voice the voic heavenly father who is more powerful than a speeding bullet. And he said, get up, get up. How much pain are you in . Im in excruciating pain. But its more the pain of not to be able to get a breath and knowing i was simply gurgling and spitting blood the whole time and barely able to breathe, trying to have the strength. And so i ended up belly crawling. Nancy knew she needed help fast, but her cell phone was gone. It had been in her purse, and that had been stolen. So she crawled into her car in hopes of activating her cars Emergency Response system, but she couldnt get it to work. Amazingly she got to her feet and walked into the house. And i was able to turn off my house alarm, the presence of mind to come up with those numbers, thats only a god thing. Because i had been shot in the head. She went to the nearest bathroom. When she turned on the light, she saw an absolute horror looking back at her in the mirror. That was when she called 911. Tell me exactly what happened. Did you still think you could die at that point . I did i didnt know if i would live. Ive been shot. Please. Whats the address, maam . I told her, please dont leave me. She said, no, miss howard, i will stay here with you until they come, because anyone who is fighting for their life and has called 911 knows that they could die. They dont want to die alone, and i wanted to live. Now, three days later, nancy was able to give police a more detailed description of the man who shot her. He had strong chin with facial hair. He was wearing darkrimmed glasses and a dark baseball cap. Could you see his eyes . I did look him in the face and i did look him in the eyes, but i dont know how to describe what that felt like. Did he just look blank . Did he look evil . He looked intent on doing what he came to do. I would say he certainly had no pity, no emotion of doing to some homemaker what he was doing. The detectives now had something to work with, but then their investigation developed a new and surprising twist. They discovered the cell phone frank had handed over contained some jawdropping information. Turns out frank had been keeping a secret. Coming up. That was the big red flag when looking at everything. Soon that secret would come tumbling out to everyone he loved. My dad actually called me at work and said, you know, ive got to tell you something. Thats a hard thing to hear. It is. A punch in the gut. This is not whats supposed to happen. When dateline continues. Ats coughing hi susan honey . Yeah . I respect that. But that cough looks pretty bad. Try this new robitussin honey severe. The real honey you love. Plus, the powerful cough relief you need. Mind if i root through your trash . New robitussin honey severe. Strong relief for your severe symptoms. The investigation into nancy howards shooting was still in its early stages when detectives made a surprising discovery. Remember, frank had given them his cell phone. Would you have a problem if we ran an analysis on your cell phone . No. When they examined that phone, they realized frank wasnt the devoted husband he appeared to be. Nancys husband had been having an affair. We noticed on his cell phone that there were several Text Messages to a contact in his phone which was identified as s. Tahoe cell. Those Text Messages, it was clear from the content of those messages, that frank was involved in an extra marital affair. There was more. Photos that showed frank with the other woman. There was photos on his phone of frank and this female that we believe to be the person that was sending those Text Messages back and forth with frank. The detectives asked the fbi to find out more about franks mistress. They learned she was a 40something mother of two teenage daughters. Her name, suzanne liantiff. We were able to speak with suzanne and confirm frank was with her on the night nancy was shot. He originally told us he was in california on business. That was a big red flag when looking at everything. We had to take a harder look at frank and whats going on with frank because he didnt mention anything about this mistress. The detectives wanted to know if frank had any more secrets they should know about, so they decided to interview his children. We had no idea that they were looking at my dad so seriously until, you know, we got in that room and they just kept hounding and hounding and hounding on my dad. You know, this line of questioning is concerning. They started telling me, somethings not right, and we think that before you talk to them any more, dad, you need to talk to a lawyer. Why would they say that . Because theyve seen shows like dateline nbc and thats what they always tell you to do. They always suspect the husband, so get a lawyer. Though frank says that at the time he didnt think innocent people needed lawyers, he hired one anyway. Then he had a heart to heart with each of his kids. My dad actually called me at work and said, you know, ive got to tell you something. And he said, the reason theyre looking at me so closely is that ive been having an affair. And i was like, crap, like, dad, come on. Dont have affairs, you know. Thats a hard thing to hear. Yeah, it is. A punch in the gut. This is not whats supposed to happen, you know . You guys were the cleavers. Yeah, we were the cleavers. It was like, this is not a good situation. There is never a good time to get caught cheating. But getting caught by police while your wife is recovering from a gunshot wound to the head is the worst. Frank had to tell his family embarrassing details about his other life, one hed been living in california with his mistress suzanne. How did you meet her . We basically found each other playing at a gambling table one night, and thats kind of what started it. There was just an attraction you couldnt fight . Yeah, thats why i fell in love with her. I absolutely did. I loved her. For his part frank said he wasnt trying to hide anything from police. I knew there was evidence of the affair and i felt like its going to be difficult, but i felt like that nancy and i could somehow work through that. Did you think at all, well, the police are going to find this information. Should i tell them . No, i dont think it was relevant to what happened with nancy. I didnt think that way. I dont, you know, it never dawned on me to make that connection. Frank knew he had to tell nancy about the affair before the police did. But because he was now considered a suspect, the cops had asked the hospital to keep him away from nancy. Now one of the most delicate conversations of frank and nancys married life had to happen on the phone. He was just broken apart, just broken apart, weeping to the point that i just almost couldnt understand him. A lot of crying, a lot of apologizing, you know, telling her that im sorry about the affair and that and that im gonna make it right and im gonna do whatever i can do and im going to do that. Was that a bombshell for you . I was dumb founded really. I was dumfounded. Im like, really . And i was i think there was a side of me that didnt really believe it. Nancy never thought of frank as the philandering type. She felt the relationship changed in 2009, the year frank went to work for that rich client, a defense contractor named richard rayly. Rayly had made millions during the iraq war, trucking supplies to the troops. He made frank his chief financial officer. And soon nancy began noticing changes at home. It increased our lifestyle a bit. We were able to do more things. But it did begin to interfere. With your marriage . With our marriage, umhmm. How did it change your marriage . How did it make it more difficult . There was a lot of travel, and we became empty nesters that year. I really missed my kids. I think he really missed his kids, but i think he had his work to help fill that void. Nancy says once frank even ditched her on new years eve so he could be with his new business associates. And i just blew a gasket. You were on the back burner at this point. I said, okay, im going to counseling because if we dont get into counseling, were going to lose our marriage. Did he agree to go . And, uh, he went for a little while and determined that he didnt feel that it was doing any good. Now as she recovered in the hospital, it was obvious to nancy why frank hadnt been interested in saving their marriage. Her husband was in love with somebody else. I said, where did you meet her . And he told me. I said, and how long has it been . He told me. Three years, frank told her, three years of lying. Three years of living a double life. One in texas. One in california. Frank wasnt proud of it. Youre a preachers son. You know better than that. Sure. It was very wrong, and, you know, and i know it now and i knew it then. I mean, i knew it going through it. It was just trying to figure out, you know, how to deal with it. While most men try to keep their indiscretions private, Frank Howards dirty laundry was now part of a criminal investigation. But the detectives say they were determined to keep an open mind. I think i told michael, lets not get tunnel vision on this just because hes got a girlfriend, you know. Lets make sure we look outside and not just key on that as a possible motive or reason for the shooting. So the detectives went back to work, examining every piece of evidence they had. Turns out that Church Surveillance tape would take their investigation in a whole new direction. Coming up. It clearly showed nancy arriving at the church. As shes pulling into the parking lot, theres a silver vehicle thats following in behind her. Had someone been stalking nancy . Oh, yeah. It was clear from that video she was followed. We know that shes not just a random target. It appears theres Something Else going on here. When dateline continues. W . Next time try bounce wrinkle guard dryer sheets. The worlds first mega sheet with 3x more wrinkle relaxers. Look at the difference of these two shirts. The wrinkle guard shirt has less wrinkles and static, and more softness and freshnes a to tame wrinkles on the go use bounce 3in1 rapid touch up spray bounce out wrinkles with bounce wrinkle guard dryer sheets and touch up spray both, with a money back guarantee. Heres to the duers. To all the people who realize they can du more with less asthma thanks to dupixent, the addon treatment for specific types of moderatetosevere asthma. Dupixent isnt for sudden breathing problems. It can improve lung function for better breathing in as little as 2 weeks and help prevent severe asthma attacks. Its not a steroid but can help reduce or eliminate oral steroids. Dupixent can cause serious allergic reactions including anaphylaxis. Get help right away if you have rash, shortness of breath, chest pain, tingling or numbness in your limbs. Tell your doctor if you have a parasitic infection and dont change or stop your asthma treatments, including steroids, without talking to your doctor. Are you ready to du more with less asthma . Talk to your asthma specialist about dupixent. If your financial situation has changed, we may be able to help. If your financial situation has changed, thisgarnier createscream its thenew serum creameam the power of a serum, the moisture of a cream, and the protection of an spf 30 3 products in 1 bottle, 1 step choose vitamin c or hyaluronic acid formulas that are clean and vegan for glowing, healthierlooking skin in just 1 step new garnier green labs serum cream by garnier, naturally stnarrow it to all thes ikarate moms. In desperate need of brown sugar. Meaning, you. Youre the one we made mywalgreens for. With pickup in as little as 30 minutes. Hiya get 30minute pickup at walgreens. Com detectives wall and turner were following all leads in their investigation into nancy howards shooting, evaluating and reevaluating every new scrap and tidbit that came their way. Take nancys purse and its contents. After the shooting, they had had her cell phone tracked and quickly discovered her purse in a nearby dumpster. There was still 11. 10 inside the purse. The cell phone, the keys. It appeared as if all of the contents of the purse were still there. But what really caught their attention was the fact that her drivers license seemed to have been removed and cast aside. That was the only item that was taken from the purse. It was at that point in time that i became suspicious. If the shooter didnt want nancys money and credit cards, then maybe hed planned to kill her. Why was the drivers license found separate from the wallet . I believe i think you would agree they pulled out the drivers license out of the bill fold to make sure they got nancy howard and confirmed it with the drivers license. Working on a hunch that nancy had been marked for death, the detectives decided to take a closer look at the video from the security cameras at her church. The video clearly showed nancy arriving at the church. As shes pulling into the parking lot, theres a silver vehicle thats following in behind her. She drives around to the south side of the church and parks. That silver vehicle parks a few parking spots away from her. Could you make out the license plate . Could you make out the people in the vehicle . The video was wasnt clear enough for us to see the license plate. You could tell from the video that there was two occupants, a driver and a passenger in the front seat. Shortly after nancy enters the church, the silver car drives away. But returns just before the Church Service ends. Then a big moment in the case. The church cameras catch a glimpse of a possible suspect. The driver exits the vehicle, enters the church to use the rest room. He was wearing a hat. It was brought down partially covering his face. The driver comes back out and gets in the silver vehicle. And as nancy leaves the Church Service and gets in her car, she backs out, leaves the parking lot and that vehicle follows her out of the parking lot. Is this Crystal Clear to you now that nancy was a target . Oh, yeah. Oh, yeah. Yeah t was clear from that video she was followed and that they came back to the church to wait on her to leave. It was an exciting moment because weve got a lead now. We know shes not just a random target. It appears there is Something Else going on here. Something else indeed. In fact, a fellow cop told them about a routine traffic stop a month before that suddenly seemed quite significant. A white honda accord. It was in the Early Morning hours that Carrollton Police officers stopped a car about a mile from the howard home. How long have you been in carrollton tonight . Returning from my uncles house for two, three, four hours. Okay. The reason i ask because i saw you guys earlier and i see you again. Now we were going in circles and circles. There were two men in the car. They were 100 miles from their homes in east texas. Please step out of the car. I want to check. The driver was a 19yearold named dustin hirams. According to the police, hirams appeared to be high on something, possibly meth. Initially he told police he came to carrollton to get money from his uncle. He said he was looking for his stepfather. He said his stepfather was in jail and he was really looking for someone else. Tell me who youre visiting here. You said uncle john, okay. We always called him john. That was it. So john, a friend of the family . Yes, basically. John . Thats a name youll hear later in this story. But at the time it meant nothing to the officers. Uncle john. The whole thing might have been forgotten except for this. At one point hirams blurted out he was a hit man involved in a plot to kill a carrollton woman. At the time it sounded like another crazy story from a drug adult teenager. Police looked into it anyway, but they couldnt pin it down. Hirams was booked on minor charges and released. Weeks later nancy was shot. Once the incident occurred on august 18th when nancy was shot, it really kind of tied those two things together. Police wondered if dustin hirams and his buddy in the car were tied to the shooting. If nancy could pick either of those men out of a photo lineup, the detectives figured it would be case closed. Are you thinking shes going to be able to i. D. One of these guys immediately . Oh, yeah, we could get the shooter identified, i mean, thats over half the battle right there. So you show her the photos and . She wasnt able to identify anybody from the photo lineups. Was that a letdown . Yeah, but its expected. Are you thinking still she still could be them . She might have gotten it wrong . Yeah. Just because she didnt identify them, that wasnt for us to change direction and go anywhere else. Were still on the trail of those two. But just as they were beginning their hunt for dustin hirams, the investigators got a call. As luck would have it, there was someone over at the county jail who claimed he had the inside story of the shooting. The county investigator called us and stated Billy Johnson, an inmate, wanted to speak with us about the shooting. The detectives were intrigued and set up a meeting at the county jail. Just for the record, billy, you asked to speak with us, is that correct . Yes, sir. His full name was billy earl johnson. His rap sheet showed he was a career criminal with a reputation for being mean and scrappy. A reputation billy didnt mind discussing. I got a reputation of being a bad ass, sir. Everybody claim me to be tough and bad. I dont claim to be tough and bad. Im mean. Im going to hurt you. If you jump on me, im going to hurt you. If billy was mean, he was also calculating. Police would soon learn that whatever tale he had to tell could be theirs for a price. Coming up. It was two of them that done it. Hes providing a lot of information that he should not know. Billy seems to know all about the plot to murder nancy, and it may be a family affair. Certainly a strange cast of characters. Some people might depict them as the hee haw gang. The hee haw gang are about to hit this case like a monster truck when dateline continues. , its time for theraflu hot liquid medicine. Powerful relief so you can restore and recover. Theraflu hot beats cold. Thisgarnier createscream its thenew serum creameam the power of a serum, the moisture of a cream, and the protection of an spf 30 3 products in 1 bottle, 1 step choose vitamin c or hyaluronic acid formulas that are clean and vegan for glowing, healthierlooking skin in just 1 step new garnier green labs serum cream by garnier, naturally we like clockwork. Ht. Do it run your dishwasher with cascade platinum. And save water. Did you know certified dishwashers. Use less than four gallons per cycle, while a running sink uses that, every two minutes. So, do it with cascade. The surprising way to save water. Nancy howard was shot point blank at her home in carrollton, texas. Remarkably, she survived. And a week into the investigation, detectives wall and turner got a lead from an inmate who claimed to know he knew the real story behind the crime. His name was billy earl johnson. The cops knew billy earl was a tough guy from east texas, an area about 90 miles from carrollton, home to those piney woods. Billy was the ring leader of a colorful crew. Many of them petty criminals related to billy by blood or marriage. Theyre certainly a strange cast of characters, but theyre east texas folks. Some people might depict them as the hee haw gang. A gang that was just getting by in a region thats struggling to make it. Theres a lot of drugs, lot of meth amphetamine out there. If someone out there makes money and has extra money, they hand it out to each other. Billy earl was a man on a mission. He wanted to cut a deal and fast. Im 49 years old. I done been to the pen 15 years. I have grand kids, i want to spend the rest of my life with them. I want to be free and i want out this weekend. Billy told the cops he knew things about the shooting they did not, including the identity of the hit team. He played hardball, even as he mixed his metaphors. I got the big ace in the hole and i got the ball in my court on this. If yall want this motor, yall need to work with me because i aint [ bleep ] playing. You need to give it to me [ bleep ] in a basket. If cops didnt want to play billy earl was going to zip it. Im not giving up nothing until i got something solid on my end. Ill die with it. He thought he was in control. Because he was sitting on an important piece of information. Oh, yeah, yeah. And so i told him, i cant go to the d. A. With you just saying this. You have to provide some information. So billy did. He was in jail on drug charges the night nancy was shot. But he told investigators he not only knew who ordered the hit on nancy. He knew how it went down. It was two of them that done it. One driving to pick them up and one that pulled the trigger. Which one drove and which pulled the trigger, i dont know, but i know both of them. Byy toilly told detectives h thought the murder for hire plot began in 2009. I was lying on the couch. How he got my name i dont know. The stranger said his name was john. He told me his name. I dont know you, but i was told you might be the one to do the job for me. The job . Kill nancy howard. He wanted it done so it wouldnt come on him, like a carjacking, purse snatching. John was a man of means, he told the detectives, who drove a lexus and communicated with a disposable drop phone. See that number there . 1764. Thats johns Contact Number if he still got the phone. Thats how you called him . He had it memorized. He provided the whole phone number which was that 1764 number. Billy knew more. He could describe nancys car. She aint had it long. Its brandnew. Its dark blue, a four door. It has like a hatchback. A mehes providing a lot of information that he shouldnt know. Youre buying it. Hes involved in this. I dont think this woman deserved what happened. No, she didnt. She deserves a little bit of justice. And shell get it. I want my back scratched, too. Not from you. I want my back scratched, too. Billy told cops he never intended to go through. Instead he was going to play john and take as much money as possible. And for more than two years thats just what happened. How many conversations have you had with john regarding this . Many. More than ten . Yeah. More than 20 . 50, 60. Detectives say it wasnt just billy playing the john game. Members of billys crew were at it as well, and the cops already knew one of them. His name is john, okay. We always called him john. That was it. Remember dustin hirams . He was the young man pulled over a month before nancy was shot. He spun a crazy story that night about being a hit man. Tur turns out dustin is billys stepson. Maybe his story hadnt been so crazy after all. Coming up, could the hee haw gang hold the key to this case . He started laying out the whole thing. When dateline continues. Over 10 years. Olays hydration was unbeaten every time. Face anything. Find out more at olay. Com special guest flo challenges the hand models to show off the ease of comparing rates with progressives home quote explorer. International hand model jonjon gets personal. Your wayward pinky is grotesque. Then a high stakes pattycake Battle Royale ends in triumph. You have the upper hands its a race to the lowest rate, and so much more. Only on the upper hands. Its a race to the lowest rate, and so much more. Its just a cold. If you have high blood pressure, a cold is not just a cold. Most cold medicines may raise blood pressure. Choose coricidin hbp. The brand with a heart. For powerful cold relief without raising your blood pressure. Every minute. Understanding how to talk to your doctor about Treatment Options is key. Today, we are redefining how we do things. We find new ways of speaking, so youre never out of touch. Its seeing someones face that comforts us, no matter where. When those around us know us, they can show us just how much they care. The first steps of checking in, the smallest moments can end up being everything. Theres resources that can inform us, and that spark can make a difference. When we use it to improve things, then that change can last within us. When we understand whats possible, we wont settle for less. The best thing we can be is striving to be at our best. Managing Heart Failure starts now with understanding. Call today or go online to understandheartfailure. Com for a free Heart Failure handbook. Call today or go online to understandheartfailure. Com looking to save money this look at allstate. N . Drivers who switched saved, averaged 718 dollars. Saving is easy when youre in good hands. Call a local agent, or 1800allstate for a quote today. Detectives wall and turner headed for east texas immediately after hearing details only an insider could know about the nancy howard shooting. Their informant was billy earl johnson. He was the patriarch of an east texas family. He claimed hed been involved in a plot to kill nancy. Wall and turner wanted to talk to those family members starting with billys stepson dustin hirams. Billy earl didnt seem to think much of him. Hes so stupid. He didnt know how to put antifreeze in a pickup truck. He doesnt know nothing about nothing. Dustin hirams was the young man pulled over in nancys neighborhood a month before she was shot. His name is john, okay. We always called him john, that was it. The detectives found you dustin staying with friends in a trailer. We were able to locate him, get him in custody. And then for the next probably 2 1 2 to three days brian and i spent talking to dustin. Youre a good kid. You got yourself messed up, but youre a good kid. What was that like . The first night he was on meth, crying. He was pretty upset. And so it was dustin scared and strung out who provided the detectives with new details about this man named john. A man who wanted nancy howard killed. Wasnt shy about suggesting how it could be done. He told dustin that he wanted nancy to be robbed while she was staying at the hotel in grapevine and he wanted it done with a baseball bat. John provided a photo of her, details about her schedule, and even suggested nancy be killed while scrapbooking with friends. She didnt do nothing wrong. Who shared with you shes a christian woman . John did. Dustin told the detectives john liked to spread his money around. He started laying out the whole thing regarding his stepdad, Billy Johnson, his mom, meetings with john, large sums of money being transferred. He was talking in the millions. Sounds hard to believe. Yeah. So he lays out, including his grandmother receiving money, billys other children that were involved. Soon dustin says members of the johnson klan were calling john whenever they needed money. When theyre in jail and cant get bonded out, then he decides short stories, he decides, i can do this and starts getting all this money. At one point dustin said john gave him 24,000 to carry out the hit. Money that he promptly spent on meth or gave away. He had 8,000 blow off his car, he told us, in the Church Parking lot. Did you go back and get it . No, are you kidding me . Ill get more. As the investigators dug deeper, they learned nearly a dozen people from east texas knew about the plot to kill nancy. Charlie lauder man was one of them. So, have you heard about the shooting in carrollton . Yeah. Everybody else heard about it, you know who was involved . Yeah. Who was that . Billy earl johnson and mr. John. Mr. John, so you know mr. John . Yeah, i know mr. John. Charlie lauderman was one of the few who was not related by blood or marriage to billy earl johnson. Billy earl is out there. He is one son of a bench. Charlie started out as a body guard for billy tried to get him to shoot nancy howard. You tried to get me [ bleep ] to kill her. You have that recorder on . Youre darn right he tried to get me to kill that woman. He said john transferred money between Bank Accounts and sometimes john met billy and handed over packages of cash at a hamburger joint or a gas station. And john was always pressing them to get the hit done. I mean, he was you think you can get it done now . Whats the chances . You know, where are yall at . Billy to would tell him, were about an hour away. Well call you when we get close. Okay, well, call me when you got confirmation. I want this thing done. And i was like, damn, what did this lady do . As long as john was willing to pay, charlie says billy and his family were willing to talk about killing nancy. And every time the hit didnt happen, john wanted to know why. Billy was the master of outlandish excuses. He had a brain tumor. He had seizures, he had spells. He done too much dope. The neighbors were home. He [ bleep ] as far as he could take it and john would buy it. Hook, line, sinker every time. Mr. Johns big money scheme to kill nancy howard was an economic bonanza for east texas. According to charlie, billy earl couldnt seem to spend that money fast enough. Motorcycles, vehicles for his children, all three of them. A car for his mother. Three or four four wheelers, gocart for the grand kids. He bought me a riding mower, four wheeler, assault weapons. Anything he wanted. And so for more than two years, the murder plot bank rolled by john killed nothing but time. They didnt follow through with it because they wanted more money. They had been called the hee haw gang, but they were very valuable to you, all of these characters. It would have been a tough case if we only had one or two of them as witnesses. But when we had this number of people involved, someone either is telling the truth or someone handed out a script to all these people with all the information because it was all the same information. The east texas crowd was canny enough to document their dealings with the mysterious mr. John. They even had a picture of him in his fancy car. Wait till you see it. Its a stunner. Coming up. Who is this infamous mr. John . Its the biggest twist of all. I was in disbelief. It was so farfetched. When dateline continues. These are real people, not actors, whove got their eczema under control. With less eczema, you can show more skin. So roll up those sleeves. And help heal your skin from within with dupixent. Dupixent is the first treatment of its kind that continuously treats moderatetosevere eczema, or atopic dermatitis, even between flare ups. Dupixent is a biologic, and not a cream or steroid. Many people taking dupixent saw clear or almost clear skin, and, had significantly less itch. Dont use if youre allergic to dupixent. Serious allergic reactions can occur, including anaphylaxis, which is severe. Tell your doctor about new or worsening eye problems, such as eye pain or vision changes, or a parasitic infection. If you take asthma medicines, dont change or stop them without talking to your doctor. So help heal your skin from within, and talk to your eczema specialist about dupixent. If your financial situation has changed, we may be able to help. Hello, im dara brown. Heres whats happening. Congress reached a 900 billion relief package hours before the midnight deadline. It provide 600 in direct payment, Small Business loans and funding for vaccine distribution. The several european nations are banning flights from the u. K. After the discovery of a new coronavirus strain spreading fast in the country. Researchers say the strain is up to 70 more transmissible. Now back to dateline. Throughout the piney woods of east texas, detectives turner and wall heard the same refrain. A man named john was frank howard. Here is a photograph of frank howard sitting in his gray lexus and in the foreground of the picture, Billy Johnson sitting on his motorcycle. He may have been frank to his friends and mr. John to the east texans, but in truth, he was both. His full name was John Franklin howard. John franklin howard. A. K. A. Frank. Frank. Three names for a man who evidently had been living three lives. One with his wife in carrollton. One with his mistress in california. And a third one with the east texas crowd. It was a surprise, based on being a beaver it was a surprise just based on being the Beaver Cleaver family, being involved with the church. It was unusual. Reporter so eight days after nancy was shot, the detectives returned to the scene of the crime. This time they had a warrant. And im sitting there watching tv and working. And the police show up at the door to arrest me. And that was very ive never experienced you know, i have no clue whats going on and whats happening. Reporter they just put you in the car and took you to the station . Yeah. Yeah. Reporter the charge solicitation for murder. Franks children were in shock. Their father may have had an affair, they thought, but hiring hit men . That made no sense. Its a very specific type of evil person that tries to kill their spouse. And my dad is just not that person. You know, having an affair is a human mistake. Trying to murder someone is not human. No human would do that. And im sorry, my dad is a human. Humans make mistakes. It was such a huge leap to what they were accusing him of. And i had never felt like my dad hated the kids enough to do that to our mom, and he never hated my mom, never talked poorly about my mom enough to do that. Reporter even nancy refused to believe that her husband of nearly 30 years could have orchestrated a plot to have her killed. Well, you know, i was totally in shock. This is so far from anything, first of all, that i ever dreamed that i would be involved in. But second of all, i mean it all came at the same time. Im shot. And then i find out my husband has been having a threeyear affair. I was in disbelief. It was so farfetched. Reporter his friends felt the same way. In fact, frank was so well regarded in carrollton that his friends offered to post his 1 million bond. At his bond hearing, witness after witness testified to his character and sterling reputation. Even Denton County prosecutor jamie beck was impressed. People from his church, people from his community, clients, current clients came forward and packed the courtroom for a bond hearing, which is just unheard of. They took the stand. They, you know, just sang his praises on what a good guy he was. Reporter though he quickly bonded out of jail, the investigators were convinced frank howard was behind the attempt on his wifes life. Not only could they prove hed been having an affair and that hed paid hundreds of thousands of dollars to a bunch of makebelieve hit men, they also had a picture of him meeting with one of them. Still, a crucial element for solving this case was missing. Were still knee deep in the middle of this. We dont have the shooter identified. And everyone that we have arrested up until this point, we can only confirm that theyre involved in a solicitation to have nancy killed. Reporter which is not to say that they didnt get some useful hints from the east texans. Dustin hiroms, he gives us the name of michael speck. And michael speck is Billie Johnsons nephew. Reporter the investigators zeroed in on that name, michael speck. A search of jail recordings of billie earl johnsons phone calls soon revealed a surprise. Not only did they hear billie earl talking about somebody named michael, they also heard another familiar voice. It was the voice of frank howard. I can get out of here, which will take about a month to get out of here, but i need some money. Well, thats part of my problem. I mean, what happened to michael . I gave him a bunch of money. How much you give him . I dont even know anymore its been so long. Did you give him 20 . Uh, at least. Its clear from those phone conversations at the jail that franks directly involved in orchestrating this. Michaels got everything i had left. He said he could take care of everything. Reporter even though the police were sure michael speck was one of the men in that silver car, they had no idea who the other man was. Then a few months later, a call out of the blue seemed to provide the break theyd been looking for. The caller sounded credible because she knew details that only the shooter and nancy would know. For instance, in a flustered moment nancy had handed her bag of food to the shooter. My ears perked up, and i felt like she had some pretty good information about who was responsible for shooting nancy. Reporter the caller led them eventually to someone who they believed was the shooter. His name was also michael, Michael Lorance. He and speck had been prison cellmates. This is like six degrees of separation. It is. Reporter everyone in this case. All the puzzle pieces were starting to come together for us. Reporter the police thought they could finally put both michaels in that silver car on the night nancy was shot. It would now be up to a jury to decide whether frank howard had paid them to kill his wife. Coming up the case begins. And the witnesses sure are colorful. But are they credible . Very questionable characters. Absolutely. How do you get the jury to believe what theyre saying . When dateline continues. Youd never wash your dishes in this. Your dishwasher looks clean but, when grease and limescale build up, its not as hygienic as you think. Use finish dishwasher cleaner its dualaction formula tackles grease and limescale. Finish. Clean dishwasher. Clean dishes. Unstopables inwash scent booster. Downy unstopables. How are you doing . In the months after nancy howard was shot in the face and left for dead she tried to move on. She divorced frank and found comfort in the sheltering embrace of her faith and family. Isnt that pretty . She even enjoyed happy moments when the shooting was almost forgotten. Like the day her youngest daughter got married and frank walked brianna down the aisle. It was very special that he was able to do that. And for me there was, you know, never a doubt in my mind that my dad would be walking me down the aisle. And we actually had a very good time. It was a very joyful time. I can remember walking with him and then saying, hmm, well, we ended up doing this together after all, didnt we . Reporter hard to imagine . Not really if you remember that frank and nancy always put family first. For a long time nancy refused to believe the worst about frank. As the months passed, she had a change of heart, though she kept hoping she was wrong. I believe he had relationships with the kind of people who would do Something Like this. But i am going to let the jury make the decision on whether he called the shot. Reporter so youre not ready to say he ordered im not ready to say that. Reporter the hit . Denton county prosecutor jamie beck was ready to say that and a lot more. I try not to get too personally involved, so to speak. But i just i did not like him. I did not like the good versus evil aspect to him and the manipulation that i felt. Reporter in early august 2014, frank howard went on trial for attempted capital murder. Prosecutors started with nancys 911 call. Lord jesus help me. Oh, my god. Help me. Oh, jesus, help me. Reporter it was an emotional opening punch, one that left frank visibly shaken, as did nancys testimony about her injuries and overwhelming feelings of betrayal. I was married to a man named frank howard. For the majority of our marriage, i was married to frank howard. But when john walked in the door, he started taking over. Frank was a man who was loving and kind. He had integrity. John . John was about himself. Reporter prosecutors laid out their theory. John, aka frank howard, had hired a hit man to kill his wife, but for more than two years hed ended up throwing money at one potential killer after another to get the job done. This group of characters, some people have even called them the heehaw gang. Yes. Reporter very questionable characters. Absolutely. Reporter with long rap sheets. How do you get the jury to believe what theyre saying . When youre going to go out and hire a hit man, youre not going to hire a good person off the street. Youre going to hire a criminal. Youre going to hire somebody with a seedy past and thats willing to do that job. Reporter if orange is the new black, this was a fashionable crowd. On the stand the witnesses from east texas corroborated each others stories. They testified theyd received money from a man named john to kill his wife. They had communicated with john by calling his drop phone. And each of them said that john and frank were one and the same. Charlie louderman says john didnt seem happy to see his east texas friends again. He didnt want to see me there. He didnt like that. He was twirling on his pen, pop, pop, like a principal going to give me some licks. Reporter charlie told the jury about seeing vast sums of money change hands. Sometimes itd be 5,000, sometimes itd be 80,000. I counted 83,000 on my bedroom floor. Reporter investigators were able to follow the money on franks computers. They found Wire Transfer receipts that added up to more than threequarters of a million dollars. Assistant prosecutor rick daniel. It sounds hard to believe that frank, the accountant, the meticulous numbers guy, is just throwing around money. And not only throwing around money, but theyre documenting it. Theyre Wire Transfers. Its hard to believe. Right. At first it was all cash. And i think he just kind of got tired of having to go and meet, and once he started with the Wire Transfer, i think he probably realized that, you know, its done. Might as well keep doing it now. And i think he just kept trying to get a solution to his problem by throwing more money at it. Reporter the east texans who gladly took that money were not charged because they were either doing time or facing prosecution for other crimes. Still jamie beck and her team wanted to link frank to the men who they believe actually shot nancy, the men in the silver car. First they tried to establish that frank had paid the alleged driver. They played a snippet of the jailhouse call recorded a few weeks before the shooting. And so i basically, you know, gave michael every i said, im all in with you, buddy because i dont know what else to do. I was all in with him. Reporter even more incriminating, prosecutors said phone records proved frank was communicating with the alleged driver the day of the shooting. As for the alleged shooter, the other michael, the prosecution called a witness who testified he confessed to her the night nancy was shot. Jamie beck summed up that testimony. He does a fullout confession. Ive murdered someone. I shot a woman in the forehead in her garage, took her food and her purse, and then we dumped everything on the way back. Reporter both michaels pleaded not guilty. Their day in court would come later. As for motive, the prosecutors told the court that was as old as time. Frank had another woman. And this was no casual fling. They presented evidence of franks devotion, the flowers, letters and cards he sent to Suzanne Leontieff when he wasnt with her. Police also discovered frank had spent enormous sums of money on his mistress. I think the figure that he had given suzanne was 1. 9 million. Ultimately we discovered that they had purchased a home together in california. They had purchased a condo in lake tahoe together. He had given her 500,000 in cash. And so its my understanding she was certainly living a life with a lot of money from frank. Reporter the pictures police found of suzanne on franks cell phone show a happy couple. But suzanne had grown tired of being the other woman. She began putting pressure on frank to get a divorce. The police found a letter from frank, dated december 2011, eight months before the shooting, pleading for patience. Reporter one of the lines was all i know to do is to get things done and hope youre still around. What do you think he meant by, to get things done . I think he meant following through with killing nancy. In this text suzanne wrote, im so sick of being alone. You need to file by this friday or move on. Ive waited long enough. Prosecutors said that affair was franks motive. So all eyes were on suzanne when she took the stand. She believed he was in a loveless marriage, that he was basically separated from his wife, that living under the same roof for convenience sake. But in separate bedrooms. How important was the mistresss testimony, suzanne . You know, i dont think suzanne had any kind of knowledge of any of this. I dont think she knew that there was a murder for hire plot. I dont think she knew about any association with criminals. I think suzanne fully believed, just like everybody else around frank, they take him at his word and they believe him. Reporter prosecutors told the jury that for a family man like frank, divorce was not an option. But, they argued, murder was. I mean, it didnt have to happen. A divorce was the solution. Reporter frank was with suzanne in california on the day nancy was shot. Even so, he still found time to send an email to his wife. Prosecutor jamie beck read it to the jury in her closing argument. I know you have a busy day today. Because he knows her schedule. Hes provided it to the two michaels. So i will try to call you sometime today. I love you and cant wait to get home to you. Thats sick. That is sick. He wanted to get home to her casket. Thats what he wanted to come home to. Reporter on august 18th, 2014, two years to the day after nancy was shot, the prosecution rested. Now it was the defenses turn to convince the jury that all those east texans were lying and that frank never paid anyone to kill his wife. Coming up the defense comes out swinging. And in its corner, two devoted daughters. I wanted to be there for my dad. Hes not this man that youre talking about. When dateline continues. Waltz around in those foot knives, watch your blue light lanterns, blast those eardrum bangers look at this one hes trying to pick up the mail hah silly. Oh. Silly humans. Who do you think you are . Pain will bring you to your senses. You cannot keep this up pain says you cant. Advil says you can. Did you know that 70 of the on your clothes are invisible . Under u. V. Light, you see the invisible dirt trapped deep down. Try new tide pods hygienic clean heavy duty. For a deep clean, just toss in a pac. Formulated with 10 concentrated cleaning actives, that clean deep down into the fabric to remove invisible dirt. See the difference, after being washed with tide hygienic clean. For a deep clean, try tide hygienic clean with a 100 money back guarantee if its got to be clean, its got to be tide. That came from me. Really. My first idea was in one quarter of an hour, your savings will tower. Over you. Figuratively speaking. But thats not catchy, is it . Thats not going to swim about in your brain. So i thought, what about. 15 minutes. 15 percent. Serendipity. 15 minutes could save you 15 or more on car insurance. Frank howard was a confident man. Or at least he claimed to be when he spoke to us a few months before his trial began. Did you have anything to do with your wife being shot that day in your garage . No. No, i did not. I absolutely did not. Reporter nevertheless, Defense Attorneys jerry cobb and Ricky Perritt knew they had their work cut out for them when they rose to Frank Howards defense. The state put on a large, large amount of evidence. They showed a lot of money being transferred. They showed the affair. They showed sympathetic pictures of the poor lady shot in the head when shes at the hospital. Reporter powerful images to be sure. But the prosecutions case, they argued, simply didnt make sense. It was really incredible to hear the allegations that a man would have spent the kind of money that they said was spent in order to have someone shot. And particularly in light of the fact that when you saw all the people that were saying he paid them, look at the kind of people they were. Reporter so the first line of defense was dont trust anybody who wears prison garb to court. I just believe that when the jurors look at the case and they see how these people are liars, theyre criminals, theyre drug users, that they wont lend any credibility to it, and if they dont believe those people, they cant convict him for attempted capital murder. You got all these people who supposedly got hundreds of thousands of dollars to kill somebody, and theyre not even being prosecuted. I mean, it makes no sense. Reporter not only that but, the defense argued, some of their stories were just too fantastic to be believed. Take one from charlie louderman. He testified that some of Frank Howards cash had come from the middle east in body bags. It was money that literally reeked of death. Some of it had hair with blood stuck to it. Some of it had burn marks on it. And i said, what in the hell is that awful damn smell . And billie looked at me and said, you know thats how were getting that money in here, is on dead bodies coming from kuwait in the caskets. Reporter the defense called that claim outrageous. Just crazy things, crazy. 80,000 or 100,000 in cash coming back in the body cavities of dead soldiers from iraq . I mean, this man had crazy things. Reporter the Defense Attorneys not only challenged the credibility of billie earl and his crew, they told the jurors the real reason frank howard was in contact with the east texas crowd boiled down to one word blackmail. You take a guy whos been a Straight Arrow all of his life, has a great reputation in his hometown, im sure it would bother him if the people at church knew he had an affair, knew he had a girlfriend, knew he went to las vegas, things like that. I think all those things would go into a reason for them to blackmail him and him to pay them money. Reporter franks daughter ashley agrees. You see all this money going out to all of these really shady people. You never really see any return. Theres no action. So my belief is that he was being blackmailed. For the affair . I cant say what. My dad was a really generous person. Maybe somewhere in there, you know, it was hey, give a guy a second chance, help me out. And then it just snowballed into either threatening his family or telling about the affair. I mean, i dont know. So i think it probably started as a generous, you know, give grace to somebody, help another human, and became something way out of his control. Reporter according to the defense, frank stopped paying members of the johnson clan weeks before the shooting. And that, franks attorneys suggested, could be the reason nancy was shot. Do you think that this was payback to frank because the money train had stopped . I believe it was something to get the money going again. I believe they were sending him a message, you know, youre not going to quit paying us. Very well could be that, and also, you know, they may not have really intended to kill nancy. You know, the guys standing right there, he shoots her in the head. Shes still conscious. If hes going to kill her, why didnt he shoot her again . Reporter frank did not take the stand in his own defense. But all three of the howard children did. Was it hard to take the stand in the trial knowing what was at stake . It definitely was because, you know, i wanted to be there for my dad. And i wanted to do things and say things that gave a different perspective to hes not this man that youre talking about. Hes imperfect, absolutely. But hes a good person. Reporter you could have been his best weapon, his own children standing behind him. When we say that we support our dad, its not a blind support. Its a well thought out support. And its a reasoned support. And weve been able to separate the feelings about the affair from the feelings about his involvement in this criminal scheme. Reporter in closing, the Defense Attorneys urged jurors to ask themselves one question. Did the prosecutors theory of why and how frank howard plotted his wifes murder make any sense . Where in the world has any evidence been told to you that divorce is unacceptable to mr. Howard . Hes already had a divorce. Hes been married once. Look at the evidence and ask yourself if thats what that means. And i do not believe as reasonable people you can convict someone on the testimony of the kind of people they brought in here that their house of cards has to be built on, and it starts with Billie Johnson and it ends with Billie Johnson. Because i do not believe thats the kind of evidence in this country that we want to use to convict someone of a crime, to deprive them of their liberty if theyre convicted. Reporter the jury now held Frank Howards fate in its hands. Coming up the man of rock solid character or this cast of characters . Who would the jury believe . When dateline continues. When you switch to xfinity mobile, youre choosing to get connected to the most Reliable Network nationwide, now with 5g included. Discover how to save up to 400 a year with shared data starting at 15 a month, or get the lowest price for one line of unlimited. Come into your local xfinity store to make the most of your mobile experience. You can shop the latest phones, bring your own device, or trade in for extra savings. Stop in or book an appointment to shop safely with peace of mind at your local xfinity store. Theyd once called themselves the Beaver Cleaver family. Close, wholesome and picture perfect. If nothing else, John Franklin howards attempted capital murder trial proved that image was as dated as a blackandwhite rerun. Nancy sat on the prosecution side of the courtroom surrounded by her friends and family. And franks supporters sat across the aisle behind the defense table. As for the children, when they were in the courtroom they almost always sat on their dads side of the aisle. For me i was just very, you know, focused on the goal, focused on what were here for. And it was my dad all the way. Reporter the tension and stress caused by the howard childrens devotion to their father was at times etched on nancys face. Im trying to trying to understand. You have to understand they had continual contact with their father for the past two years. And they, too, wanted to believe that their father was the same man. Reporter after ten days of testimony and a mountain of evidence, jurors might have been expected to be out for a while. Has the jury reached a verdict in this case . Reporter but they werent. Yes, we have, your honor. And is that a unanimous verdict of each and every one of the twelve jurors in this case . Yes, it is. Please hand that to the bailiff. Reporter it had taken just 90 minutes of deliberation for the jury to reach a decision. We the jury find the defendant, john howard, guilty of the offense of attempted capital murder as alleged in the indictment. Reporter when you heard that word, guilty, whats going through your mind . Just complete heartbreak. But yet it was also peace because it was finally over. Reporter in a separate hearing frank howard was sentenced to life in prison. My gut reaction is, well, now we have to appeal. Reporter so you didnt even let the guilty process . No, i mean, for me, i mean, that was the plan. Not guilty, we move on. Guilty, we appeal. Theres no lets all cry and hold hands and be sad because dad is in jail for no. Were going to appeal. Reporter its probably easier to cope that way, i would think. Yeah, at first theres kind of shock. Mmhmm. And then its like, youre just angry. Youre angry that they didnt be as you know, you dont feel like they got the truth. You may be seated, sir. Reporter in the end, Frank Howards appeals were denied. But even then this case was far from over. Remember the michaels, the two men prosecutors say actually carried out the attack on nancy . In 2015 billie earls nephew michael speck turned on his former cellmate Michael Lorance. In return for a reduced sentence speck testified at lorances trial that Michael Lorance had been the trigger man. Lorance was convicted of aggravated assault with a Deadly Weapon and sentenced to 60 years. He appealed and in 2017 a texas court overturned his conviction on the grounds that evidence introduced relating to the overall murder for hire scheme was misleading and unfairly prejudicial. Lorance was retried, and this time a jury found him not guilty. But lorance isnt off the hook yet. The District Attorney has decided to prosecute him for conspiracy to commit murder in the nancy howard case. He has pleaded not guilty. As for the money frank howard used to finance the murder plot and support his lavish lifestyle . Turns out it was stolen from that wealthy contractor that frank once worked for. Some people might have a hard time wrapping their head around the fact that he was so haphazardly giving money out. Yes. Just freely giving it out. Just freely giving it out. The only way i can explain that is when you dont earn the money, when its not from your hard work and efforts, it has no value. As a matter of fact, for the two years i called it his monopoly money. The money didnt have meaning to him other than how he could use it to manipulate people. Reporter in late 2015 an Arbitration Panel determined that frank howard had embezzled more than 6 million from his former boss between 2009 and 2012. Frank was ordered to repay that money with interest. You went into this hoping there was a chance that maybe he didnt call the shots. Right, i did. I tried to keep my heart open. Reporter so you have no doubt in your mind now absolutely. Reporter that frank called the shots on your attempted murder . Absolutely. John called the shots. Reporter almost like an alter ego . Yep. It is. I want to say john howard, you messed up, buddy. Reporter perhaps nobody knew john better than the east texas crowd. Charlie louderman in full finger wagging mode says john howard got what he deserved. Youre smart and you hired an idiot to do your dirty work. Reporter charlie says he regrets he ever got involved with Billie Johnson and hes remorseful about what happened to nancy. I carried a lot of guilt over her injury with her eye because she just looked like a really happy lady in the pictures to me. And to johns children, im sorry, but your dad did it. You know. Theres no getting around it. Reporter but even after hearing the evidence, john and nancys daughters still believed their father was innocent. There are going to be people watching this saying you two girls are delusional. Your dad was found guilty of trying to have your mom killed and here you are supporting your dad. I get that. But i would say those people that think that were delusional have not shared our experiences, they havent sat down and they havent gone to jail, sat behind that glass, picked up that phone and talked to the same man that theyve been talking to for the last 28 years. And you can say all day long, oh, that poor girl, you know. She just wants to support her dad. Lets be very clear. I think that Justice Needs to be served. I dont think it has been. And i think its unfortunate that now were all going to say weve gotten justice for my mom and that man is a terrible human being and the truth is theres no justice for my mom and now theres no justice for my dad. Reporter though the sisters conceded in 2014 that the familys bonds had been strained by this case, they insisted those bonds had not been broken entirely. Do you hope that as time goes on, things can be healed with your mother . Oh, absolutely. Its a very raw time. A big life event happened. A big change happened. So were all having to process what we feel and then come back together and really sort it out. Reporter the future for the Howard Family . We were a Strong Family then. Were going to be a Strong Family in the future. And those two are not going to look the same, but thats okay. Were going to figure it out. Reporter its unclear how Frank Howards daughters feel about their father and mother now. Neither of them responded to datelines requests for comment. For her part, nancy says she has forgiven and moved on with her life. Shes gone back to work at a law firm as an Administrative Assistant and now goes by her maiden name, nancy shore. In the spring of 2017 nancy told her story in a book titled the shooting of nancy howard a journey back to shore. Deep in my heart, my heart is broken because i would have loved to have continued being the Beaver Cleaver family. I would have loved to continue being married to frank because i loved that man with all my heart. And that man loved me at some point, but it was obviously a change in who he was and is. This sunday, a shot in the arm. I feel like healing is coming. Americans begin receiving Pfizers Covid vaccine. Its safe. Its s okay. And we need to do it. A little bit of a sore arm, a little aching muscle, but no fever, headache, or anything unusual. And omodernas vaccine is o the way. This is the most significant accomplishment in medicine over the past, you know, 100 years. But the pandemic iskn raging with more than 300,000 americans now 3 dead. I have to be the one that says, im sorry, you cant come to seey, your loved one. Ill talk to the former and likely future surgeon