Look quite attractive if there, of course , when the civil war ends, the country will unite and eventually it will be possible to conduct some kind of activity, but the chinese are trying to create a position there in advance. We forgot about this topic of the death of russian peacekeepers during the karabakh operation, and this is a very important topic, russia has always reacted very nervously to such things, now even an official statement has not been made, yes, and that is why i think that this precisely in the context of the agreements that took place, that is, the russians really need it, they really need it, and they do not want to quarrel, and they will swallow the cases and simply pretend that Nothing Happened , that is, it looks like this. By the way, i wanted to ask what the meetings that were held in the presidency of zelensky hmm what happened in todays meeting with the head of the sudanese general and spoke absolutely frankly that they talked about wagner, it was said officially by the commander of the armed forces well, well, with the command of the armed forces will have to this is essentially the military leadership of sudan, so, well, this is me, what i am talking about. In principle, this is what happened after cnnl reported that there was a Ukrainian Special operation to eliminate the wagnerites in sudan. Ukraine can really carry out such special operations outside the borders of its country and to fight against russia in africa no, well, if we are talking about military intelligence , then it is in accordance with its statutory obligations and everything else. It can operate abroad, so we know how ukrainian intelligence was quite effective in afghans why it cannot operate in sudan, well, it is quite possible and it is an interesting new experience in general, which, to be honest, did not happen a long, long time ago, that is, it can and never happened, that is, ukraine did not conduct any combat operations in africa, if this is true, then we can say that we began, well, to advance on the fifth for the russians in those countries is also wagners and it fell into the small, it is also interesting why it fell, well, that is, there are a lot of such interesting coincidences of details that indicate that yes, we are starting to work a little in africa as a counterbalance. And we can say that the Ukrainian Armed forces they have a bigger one opportunities than, say, the french well, i even have opportunities not military, but political , that is, they can afford what the french cannot afford, say , in africa. According to the russians, wherever, however, the president gave us permission so that everything is in order, and the meeting with the Prime Minister of israel and jehovah there ended with nothing concrete in general , this is a big mystery. According to the zrolyatians, they end up with big riddles in a hurry. Well, in principle, we did our parts, if we had done our part. That is , we led the hasidim to prayer. They stopped not letting ukrainians into bengurion, well, its quite possible that its very difficult to talk here, you can of course use the goldemeier formula here, but i m not the one, but its uh, in this situation i dont know how to talk with the bible provided and here is being in zelenskyis place i wouldnt give up from here that is, about what when everything has already been said and repeated many times and there is a position of israel that so far it is clear that it does not change somehow in general they will comment i dont know and zelensky is on tenyak all these quiet talks walks no comments no comments wine yes yes well maybe in fact there were no comments even in the media, as it often happens there, the Israeli Press reports something, we did not see anything , although there when it comes to contacts there with saudi arabia or with someone else, with someone there, a million assumptions at least two words were said no, you know, there is usually such a thing here when they say that it is so mysterious that the things that were discussed are not even possible to do it yet , well, to report it is just a situation, but they say that nesterny can be a mediator if there is a peaceful process. Do you believe in this . No, i dont believe it because well, first of all, we have already clearly stated that we will not have intermediaries , at least as of now, we have too many intermediaries who want to be thank you, mr. Igor igor semelo, director of the center for middle eastern studies, we will break for literally a few minutes, dont switch, blink well, cycles, everything as you want, click and now you control the game. Watch and you are in a tv show, what you need. Google , turn on hundreds of channels in thousands of movies and sports. I have discounts on floor from 10 in pharmacies. Portnikov and we will discuss the main events of this week Vitaly Portnikov and top experts about the most striking events of the last seven days, our guest will be generator troops , the former National Security adviser of the president of the united states, donald trump , herbert, a master artist, all current topics h three questions authoritative comments and forecasts in the project informational marathon with Vitaly Portnikov every sunday at 20 10 on espresso hello this is freedom morning informational project radio svoboda top guests every day this is the shipping district of kherson live inclusion we are somewhere in the vicinity of bakhmut we tell the main thing on weekdays at 9 00 vasyl zimas Big Broadcast my name is vasyl zima two hours of air time two hours of your time we will talk about the most important things two hours to learn about the war serhiy zgoretska joins our broadcast military summaries of the day and how does the world live . What is there in the world . Ms. Natalka didenko is ready to tell us about lena or other presenters who have become familiar to many, maybe the weather will give us some optimism, and we will also have volodymyr grishko as an honored guest of the studio today if everything goes well, the events of the day in two hours , vasyls Big Broadcast in winter, a project for intelligent and caring people, in the evening on espresso, dear friends, lets go back to avatar. Our viewers are still debating about poland, who is guilty of what and who is not guilty, how to talk to poles, how not to talk to poles, uh, well, of course, even during the week, even on facebook, if you look at p. I honestly saw vitaly for the first time criticism that portnikov is playing into zelenskyis hand, they are always betting when they dont like the position yesterday, yesterday, poroshenko, today, zelenskyi, the day before yesterday , it doesnt matter because it matters, you understand, it matters, ukrainians cant even understand no , Public Opinion, facts, because we had Public Opinion that nanarusia will never be able to attack us, remember, well, as a result, people who believed so in the number there are 73 . They woke up from missile strikes, but now 73 of kazakhs there believe that russia will not attack them the day will come when they will wake up from reality, this can also happen in their lives , so to be honest, what worries me is what people there think about themselves, i think, and what worries me is the factology, but we have to deal with a simple thing, we want to be part of the European Union, its not easy the way to become part of the European Union we signed the Association Agreement our polish friends as well as our slovak friends all other friends were ardent supporters of this agreement the Association Agreement it provides for customs duties and quotas on ukrainian Agricultural Products, we made these decisions precisely because we want to become members of the European Union in the future , to become part of the common market, that no one will set any customs quotas for me, and we agreed that this agreement is a transitional period during which our neighbors will agree with certain standards of future life will prepare for ukrainian mesh products on the market, and that is why we sell more to the poorest countries of the world, mostly to the global south and not to europe, say where we could successfully compete with poland or with portugal, conditional because we are also a very serious agricultural country, unfortunately because there is nothing good in the economy here , neither for poland nor for us, it is better for you to be a hightech country but this is how the economy turned out, it is what it is yes, and these quotas have been activated, which means that this is not the case. It could happen in 10 or 15 years , in 30 years we became members of the European Union and it was somehow harmonized, but then the war began, the war began when Ukraine Russia began absolutely erer harshly to destroy our economy, our neighbors lobbied for the decision to remove from us all the restrictions on the supply of products that were foreseen in the Association Agreement this was the initiative of warsaw, prague, budapest, they all convinced the European Commission to do this in order to save our economy and that is why we now exist in the economic sense in the regime of a member state of the European Union, while most of our economy has already been destroyed almost completely, and i think that agriculture can also expect that in the following for years the same fate because we see that russia has closed ukrainian ports even if we make some alternative corridor it is not a very large volume even if we cover the whole of poland with our grain and destroy polish agriculture, it is not at all those oo about the volume well, im joking, ill never do that because its clear that poland will protect its market well, in any case, it doesnt solve anything, but one way or another, its a shelling of certain money that goes to our budget. And by the way, i want to remind dear viewers that the armed forces they have money from our budget, everything, everything. All the money that the Ukrainian Military receives is money from the state budget of ukraine. Our sponsors, allies, who give us money, do not give a penny to the armed forces of ukraine. Ugh, they give to social welfare. The ukrainians survived, and all that gives to the army is what we earn , we will not earn anything, we will have no money, and for the army, we will simply lose this war and simply be part of the Russian Federation, then the Russian Federation will sell our grain and i wont ask poland, i wont sell it on the polish market, if it makes it easier for the poles, oh, and we know that every cut of money in the ukrainian state budget is someone s death, oh, the death of your relative, oh, the death of your brother, oh, the death of your man, you just need to know for sure that something was not bought, something was not completed, some Military Hospital was not, er , created. People have lived to see that donatan entered the territory in which there will not be well, its so simple, so simple, but thats the way it is. Its just so that we understand what the taxes of the ukrainian agrosect are, because we like to talk about baryg, about diffundists, about the agro corporation, and in poland, Small Farmers who pay ukrainians pennies for strawberries are wonderful people, we know about their strength, i told you, i dont argue , they are strong electorate so you have to protect them, not our agroholding, but unfortunately , taxes to the ukrainian budget go from these Agricultural Holdings, even if you forget about farmers, and from polish strawberry farmers, taxes go to the polish budget , thats such a nuisance. Well, not much, because they pay little there, and ukrainians working in poland will tell you that they keep their salary, so to speak, without any taxes , just like zlotys e as they say in the black box , well, thats right. It wont be me at all, this problem is not mine, its Prime Minister marovetskyis problem, what does he have with fiscal policy , let him decide it and tell the voters, not me, but in any case here they started to define to sell all our products that we still have, it would have been metallurgy, remember, there is nothing , you have started to sell your grain, that is , it went in transit to poland to other countries , but some of it was bought. When they say it is some kind of smuggling, it cannot be smuggling because we are allowed , at the request of poland itself, to have a regime similar to that of any country that is a member of the European Union, and here the Election Campaign began and the confederation of independent poland began to speak. And what is this and polish opportunities they were afraid that this confederation would take away his votes, and god forbid they would lose power or join a coalition with this confederation , all politics would go to hell. To the negotiating table, and i remember that president zelensky went to poland, talked about it with president dudu and the Prime Minister of moravia, the results of these negotiations were not so great for us, we agreed that there would be restrictions until september 15, until september 15 there will be restrictions. But after this time, poland and other countries must prepare for this possible volume of ukrainian grain, and after that the restrictions will be canceled and we will live as they wanted. When they proposed to cancel the restrictions, it was not us, it was what they wanted. In september , the president of the Russian Federation , Vladimir Vladimirovich putin, speaks with his pompous face and says that russia is withdrawing from the black Sea Grain Initiative, which, in my opinion, should have been done by the polish voltaire mr. Marovetsk, he should have picked up the phone, nothing would have happened to him, and called the Prime Minister of ukraine and said, you know , russia is withdrawing from the black Sea Grain Initiative, and this means that additional volumes of grain that we did not agree on may enter our market we fear this all the more if it happens before the elections, we will lose power, lets sell consultations, lets continue these restrictions together, we will go to the European Commission with a request to continue these restrictions there until november 15, so that three months there for two or there we will agree with you from the European Commission the volumes with which you can sell more lets solve this issue what does Prime Minister marovetsky say he does not behave like a Prime Minister as a rally politician he goes to a rally and says poland demands an extension of the restrictions. And if the restrictions are not extended according to the European Commission, we will conduct them unilaterally. Call , but they did not call. What is there to prevent him . He is interested in winning the elections. Mr. Kachynskyi mr. Moravetskyi mr. Er duda and indirectly he is also the president of this party. She is simply throwing everything under the influence of these elections, including the interests of ukraine. I really want to have breakfast, what does this Election Company look like . The minister of defense takes a map showing the operation that nato considered possible before buchi every year that russia attacks the borders of nato and it is a wellknown story that russia attacks the country nato countries are retreating there to well where where where to warsaw where to riga where to vilnius they are retreating and holding the defense until the main parts of nato pull up and counterattack russia this was the strategy before buche i. E. When they saw what happened in buche the nato Member States said no we wont retreat anywhere because uh well, its clear why we will keep defenses on the borders, no matter what its worth, to prevent them from letting them into our territory because they are barbarians , they will just kill civilians and we cant allow that well here is the minister of defense p is crying, showing this map and saying, do you understand here, he wanted to give half of poland to russia . Well, this is even more brutal than the history of grain , what is the goal . It just didnt work out, but the Prime Minister of poland spoke well, he announced it later, it means the polish government. By the way, what slovaks are flying in hungarians about this, uh, we also have to remember that the slovak government is doing this out of its preelection interests, the hungarian government is it is done as always. It is clear that why is viktor robert doing this . It is necessary to explain. I think once again they are making this decision. What is ukraine doing . Ukraine is submitting to the arbitration of the world trade organization. Unilateral restriction is adopted by the union this is a violation of the legal norms of etrade, we apply by and large not so much even to poland, slovakia and hungary as to the European Union because these decisions violate the decision of the European Union and thus the European Commission must decide what to do or to sue us, but this is a losing process because it itself canceled the restrictions, but it is for or to accept our lawsuit, to agree with it , that is, to be on our side, but then take all this money from poland, slovakia and hungary, poland, slovakia and hungary understand very well that they will lose this story, they will lose this arbitration in court , the European Union itself will lose because you removed any representative of the World Organization restrictions and then banned access to their products, why and how could this happen, because we need to understand again poland, slovakia and hungary are not independent economic organisms, but we are because we are not members of the European Union, we can prohibit the delivery of polish products to us. It will be nothing, even the world trade organization, we have the right, today we have one restriction, tomorrow we will have another peace, as valery rightly said, he is not anyones ally, but they delegated their powers to the European Commission when joined the European Union, they have no right, because if they want , they must first leave the European Union, and then they can completely close their market from any products to ours, which is in german completely, but while they are in the European Union, they must fulfill these obligations more that they themselves initiated them, they themselves proposed until september 15 to do such a thing themselves. It was their proposal, they canceled it themselves and it looks very funny. To be honest, because thats why. By the way, we already agreed and slovakia, because slovakia understands that if it goes further , it can simply lose more money than the slovak farmers will earn, well, that is, it is a compromise decision. I think that we also spend from it , but that is how it should be between the union and its neighbors, we will lose something and they spend something but as a result, slovakia will not pay as much fine money as it paid as a result of losing the process. And we will be able to supply our task to the slovak market at some point. I hope that there will be the same agreement with poland or after, they do not know until elections will be enough for them, common sense will not be enough. But it should be such an agreement that would allow poland to fulfill its obligations to the European Union. And we were allowed to sell grain, but once in the tragic situation of polish farmers. Restrictions were introduced until september 15. If poland prepared for this, they received billions of subsidies from the European Union, that is, polish farmers earned a lot for all these stories in order to prepare for the ukrainian Agricultural Products, and they were also told that they will continue to pay imenda. In principle, you can do otherwise , you can not give them money, this is also a way to stop giving them money to polish farmers, slovak farmers, hungarian farmers, bulgarian farmers, who have now blocked the roads to bulgaria. And money should be given to our farmers because the bulgarian the Prime Minister absolutely honestly told them that you owe all your goodness to european subsidies and not to your own, not only your hard work because you lost the competition a long time ago and the fact that europe gives you money is what saved you in general as farmers as actors in poland well, therefore, if the European Commission makes certain decisions, then you should follow the run simply because you obliged them. I say that there is another result, money to take away from them, they themselves rush to their fertile land and from me very fertile , that is why there are subsidies and give it to us and give it to us. It is also an option that you can divide these subsidies between polish ukrainian farmers, not only the restrictions have been removed, transfer them to the regime to the European Union and to give our Agricultural Holdings and our farmers the money that the polish farmer receives, it can be transferred, and it is possible to offer the money of the polish farmers in any preelection rally , it is offered to the farmers. At the session of the Un General Assembly, who offended the poles so much, i wont say now whether the president should have spoken is it from the rostrum of the Un General Assembly or not, but the poles were actually offended not because he spoke from the rostrum of the Un General Assembly and what he said to the Un General Assembly was not because he mentioned them, but because he compared their positions with the position of russia, and it was very rude from their point of view, but if you dont want to be compared to moscow, dont we need to behave like Russian Politicians well, because, well , the president of the Russian Federation appears again and says that russia is withdrawing from the black Sea Grain Initiative russia begins to shell the infrastructure of odessa russia is shelling the infrastructure of rainy ismail and others of our donetsk ports to destroy ukrainian agriculture. This is the result of his decision practically. At the same moment , the Prime Minister of poland appears, may god give him health, our great ally who helped us a lot, even rome. Thank you for everything he did for us together with the president of poland, together with mr. Kachynskyi, thank you very much. This is the moment when he says that poland imposes restrictions on ukrainian Agricultural Products , the real result of these restrictions is also the collapse of ukrainian agriculture, that is, i i am not going to compare poland with russia in a nightmare, russia is an aggressive terrorist state, poland is a democratic european state, putin is a dictator and a criminal , kaczynski, duda and moravetski are democratically elected politicians, electoral politicians who protect the interests of their own people, and putin does not protect the interests of even his own people , you cant even compare this. How to compare sweet and wet ugh, i dont even have such an opinion kaczynski was solidarity and putin was kgb compare if you tell me that i am comparing kaczynski and cousin its simple blasphemy i simply respect even the life path or path of Yaroslav Kaczynski risked himself for the sake of freedom from a free poland i say this absolutely seriously but the results are the same the results of the decisions are the same that dictators from a terrorist state and people i respect from a democratic country close to ukraine why cant you tell them that they have the same result, lets let them like it. If we have the same results with putin, maybe something is wrong, then it could have been done somehow face to face and not in front of everyone but they they make public statements about grain, they were publicly said, maybe it should have been done face to face , macho, what moravian, who, you know, who was the first to start in such a situation. For everyone to call, as the ministers of agriculture call now when the smell of roasting is coming, maybe it should have been done and after that to speak at a rally and say that we have protected the interests of polands agriculture, we agreed with the ukrainians that they will not supply grain to our market now, we have reached a compromise, restrictions, how the commissions for poland will act there is still unknown. Jumps how long there are 2 months, it does not matter what ukrainian will go with me, it will not interfere with this, we need a lot of things, listen, no i need to write speeches from matyosomretska, he has beautiful professional spishits, now what do we have, on the one hand, we have, uh, this russianukrainian russianukrainianpolish conflict is very unpleasant, and the second is that you have a Bad Reputation we write not after this statement by moravetsky, but after moravetskys statement that poland stops supplying weapons to ukraine, and again, i do not see any criminality in this statement , the Prime Minister said absolutely logical things, we handed over our old weapons to the ukrainians, and now we have received and are purchasing new ones weapons in order to arm our army because we gave away our weapons and this weapon with which it was voiced arming our army we are not going to give it to anyone, that is, he voiced it for the internal audience but he did not think about the fact that it sounds like it was like this will be perceived so all the publications of the world everyone has seen this situation and it means how it looks in essence poland stops supplying weapons to ukraine and it is not supplying now because it