Transcripts For CNNW CNN Republican Presidential Debate 20151219

Welcome to the cnn facebook Republican Debate here in the venetian, las vegas. We have a very enthusiastic audience. Im wolf blitzer, your moderator tonight. This debate is airing on cnn networks here in the United States and around the world and on the Salem Radio Network. The nine leading candidates. They are here. Lets welcome them right now. Senator rand paul of kentucky. New jersey governor, chris christie. Former florida governor, jeb bush. Senator ted cruz of texas. Businessman and real estate developer, donald trump. Retired neurosurgeon, dr. Ben carson. Senator marco rubio of florida. Former hewlettpackard ceo carly fiorina. And ohio governor, john kasich. Ladies and gentlemen, welcome these republican candidates for president of the United States. This is the final Republican Debate before the Election Year begins. And were taking a moment for the photographs of the candidates together on this stage. Now, everyone, please rise for the National Anthem sung by ala brown. O say, can you see by the dawns early light what so proudly we hailed at the twilights last gleaming . Whose broad stripes and bright stars through the perilous fight oer the ramparts we watched were so gallantly streaming . And the rockets red glare the bombs bursting in air gave proof through the night that our flag was still there oh, say, does that starspangled banner yet wave oer the land of the free and the home of the brave . [ cheers and applause ] i know everyone is eager to get started. So, candidates, please take your places while i explain the ground rules for tonight. As moderator, ill guide the discussion and ill be joined in the questioning by Salem Radio Network talk show host hugh hewitt and cnn political dana bash. We ask nationwide to share their questions for the candidates. We teamed up with facebook to send a Campaign Camper across the country over the past several weeks. Thousands of people stepped inside and recorded stepped inside and recorded their questions. Millions more weighed in on facebook. Candidates, i will try to make sure each of you get your fair share of questions. Youll have 1 15 to answer and 30 seconds for followups and rebuttals. Ill give you time to respond if youre singled out for criticism. Our viewers should know we have timing lights that are visible to the candidates to warn them when their time is up. And as the candidates requested, a bell will sound like this. We know you are all eager to jump in and debate these important issues. So, please, wait until youre called on. These nine republicans are positioned on stage based on their ranking in the recent polls, so, lets begin right now. Id like to invite each candidate to introduce himself or herself to our audience. Youll have one minute. First to you, senator paul. The question is, how do we keep america safe . The question is, what does he mean by that . Like they do in north korea . Like they do in china . Rubio says we should collect all americans records all of the time. The constitution says otherwise. I think theyre both wrong. I think we defeat terrorism by showing them that we do not fear them. I think if we ban certain religions, if we sensor the internet, i think that at that point the terrorists will have won. Regime change hasnt won. Toppling secular dictators in the middle east has only led to chaos and the rise of radical islam. I think if we want to defeat terrorism, i think if we truly are sincere about defeating terrorism, we need to quit arming the allies of isis. If we want to defeat terrorism, the boots on the ground. The boots on the ground need to be arab boots on the ground. As commander in chief i will do whatever it takes to defend america. But in defending america, we cannot lose what america stands for. Today is the bill of rights anniversary. I hope we will remember that and cherish that in the fight on terrorism. Thank you, senator. Governor kasich. Thank you, wolf. Just last weekend a friend asked one of my daughters, do you like politics . And my daughter said, no, i dont. And the reason i dont like it is because theres too much fighting. Too much yelling. Its so loud i dont like it. I turned to my friend and i said, you know. Shes really on to something. When we think about our country and the big issues, wolf, that we face in this country. Creating jobs, making sure people can keep their jobs. The need for rising wages. Whether our children when they graduate from college can find a job. Protecting the homeland. Destroying isis. Rebuilding defense. These are all the things that we need to focus on but well never get there if were divided. Well never get there if republicans and democrats just fight with one another. Frankly, we are republicans and they are democrats. But before all of that, were americans. And i believe we need to unify in so many ways to rebuild our country to strengthen our country to rebuild our defense and for america to secure its place in the world for us. For our children. And for the next generation. Thank you. Governor christie. Thank you, wolf. America has been betrayed. Weve been betrayed by the leadership that barack obama and Hillary Clinton have provided to this country over the last number of years. Think about just whats happened today. The Second Largest School District in america in los angeles closed based on a threat. Think about the effect that that is going to have on those children. When they go back to School Tomorrow wondering, filled with anxiety about whether theyre really going to be safe. Think about the mothers who will take those children tomorrow morning to the bus stop. Wondering whether their children will arrive back on that bus safe and sound. Think about the fathers of los angeles who tomorrow will head off to work and wonder about the safety of their wives and their children. What is barack obama and Hillary Clinton done to this country that the most basic responsibility of an administration is to protect the safety and security of the American People. I will tell you this. Im a former federal prosecutor. I fought terrorists and won. When we get back in the white house, we will fight terrorists and win, again. And america will be safe. Ms. Fiorina. Like all of you. Im angry. Im angry at whats happening to our nation. As citizens, its time to take our country back. Insults wont take it back. Political rhetoric that promises a lot and delivers little wont take it back. All of our problems can be solved. All of our wounds can be healed by a tested leader who is willing to fight for the character of our nation. I have been tested. I have beaten breast cancer. I have buried a child. I started as a secretary. I fought my way to the top of Corporate America while being called every bword in the book. I fought my way into this election. And on to this debate stage while all the political insiders and the pundits told me it couldnt be done. Ive been told no all my life. And all my life ive refused to accept no as an answer. Citizens, it is time to take our country back from the Political Class. From the media. From the liberal elites. It can be done. It must be done. Join me and we will get it done. Governor bush. Our freedom is under attack. Our economy is under water. The leading democrat is under investigation. And america is under the gun to lead the free world to protect our civilized way of life. Serious times requires strong leadership. Thats what is at stake right now. Regarding National Security. We need to rebuild our military, to destroy isis before it destroys us. Regarding economic security, we need to take power and money away from washington, d. C. , and empower American Families so that they can rise up, again. Look, america still is an exceptional country. We love to lead. And we love to win. And we do it when we take on any challenge and when we take on, we support our friends. As president , i will keep you in our country safe, secure and free. Thank you. Senator rubio. Thank you, wolf. Its really amazing to be back in las vegas. I spent six years here as a child growing up. Not far from where we stand tonight i sat on the porch and listened to my grandfather. One thing my grandfather instilled in me is i was really blessed because i was a sit wherein of the greatest country of all mankind. But people who wanted america to be more like the rest of the world. In 2008, one of them was elected president of this country and the result has been a disaster. Today you have millions of americans that feel left out and out of place in their own country. Struggling to live paycheck to paycheck and called bigots because they hold on to traditional values. Around the world, americas influence has declined while this president has destroyed our military, our allies no longer trust us and our adversaries no longer respect us. Thats why this election is so important. Thats why im running for president and thats why im going to ask you for your vote tonight. If you elect me president , we will have a president that believes america is the greatest country in the world and we will have a president that acts like it. Senator cruz. Thank you, wolf. America is at war. Our enemy is not violent extremism. It is not some unnamed force. It is radical islamic terrorist. We have a president who is unwilling to other its name. The men and women on this stage, every one of us, is better prepared to keep this nation safe than is barack obama or Hillary Clinton. We need a president who understands the first obligation of the commander in chief is to keep america safe. If i am elected president , we will hunt down and kill the terrorists. We will utterly destroy isis. We will stop the terrorist attacks before they occur because we will not be prisoners to Political Correctness. Rather we will speak the truth. Border security is National Security and we will not be admitting jihadists as refugees. We will keep america safe. Dr. Carson. Thank you, wolf. Please join me for a moment of silence and remembrance of the San Bernardino victims. Thank you. You know, our country since its inception has been at war. Every 15 or 20 years. But the war that we are fighting now against radical islamist jihadists is one we must win. As a neurosurgeon i had to face life and death situation. I had to come up with the right diagnosis and right plan and execute that plan frequently with other colleagues. Right now, the United States of america is the patient. And the patient is in Critical Condition and will not be cured by Political Correctness and will not be cured by timidity. And i am asking the congress, which represents the people, to declare a war on isis. So that we can begin the process of excising that cancer and bring peace and prosperity back to america. Mr. Trump. Thank you. I began this journey six months ago. My total focus was on building up our military, building up our strength. Building up our borders. Making sure that china, japan, mexico both at the border and in trade no longer takes advantage of our country. Certainly would never have made that horrible, disgusting, absolutely incompetent deal with iran where they get 150 billion. Theyre a terrorist nation. But i began it talking about other things. And those things are things that im very good at and maybe thats why im center stage. People saw it. People liked it. People respected it. A month ago things changed. Radical islamic terrorism came into effect even more so than it has been in the past. People like what i say. People respect what i say. And weve opened up a very big discussion that needed to be opened up. Thank you very much. Thank you. Since you last debated, americans have witnessed terror attacks in paris and San Bernardino. The fbi director says the country now faces the greatest Terror Threat since 9 11. You all have different approaches to keeping the country safe. And that will be the focus of tonights debate. Mr. Trump, as you mentioned in your Opening Statement, part of your strategy is to focus in on americas borders. To keep the country safe, you say you want to temporarily ban nonamerican muslims from coming to the United States. Ban refugees fleeing isis from coming here. Deport 11 Million People and wall off americas southern border. Is the best way to make America Great again to isolate it from much of the rest of the world . We are not talking about isolation. Were talking about security. Were not talking about religion. Were talking about security. Our country is out of control. People are pouring across the southern border. I will build a wall. It will be a great wall. People will not come in unless they come in legally. Drugs will not come through that wall. As far as other people into migration where theyre going, tens of thousands of people having cell phones with isis flags on them. I dont think so, wolf. Theyre not coming to this country. And if im president and if obama has brought some to this country, they are leaving. Theyre going. Theyre gone. Governor bush. You called mr. Trump unhinged when he proposed banning nonamerican muslims from the United States. Why is that unhinged . Well, first of all, we need to destroy isis in the caliphate. That should be our objective. The refugee issue will be solved if we destroy isis there. We need to embed our forces, our troops inside the iraqi military. We need to arm directly the kurds and all of that has to be done in concert with the arab nations. If were going to ban all muslims, how are we going to get them to be part of a coalition to destroy isis . The kurds are our strongest allies. Theyre muslim. Look, this is not a serious proposal. In fact, it will push the muslim world, the arab world away from us at a time when we need to reengage with them to be able to create a strategy to destroy isis. So, donald, you know, is great at the one liners. But hes a chaos candidate. And hed be a chaos president. He would not be the commander in chief we need to keep our country safe. Mr. Trump. Jeb doesnt really believe im unhinged. He said that very simply because he has failed in this campaign. Its been a total disaster. Nobody cares. And, frankly, im the most solid person up here. I built a tremendous company and all i want to do is make America Great, again. I dont want our country to be taken away from us and thats whats happening. The policies that weve suffered under other president s have been a disaster for our country. We want to make America Great again. And, jeb, in all fairness, he doesnt believe that. Look, he mentioned me. I can talk. This is the problem. Banning all muslims will make it harder for us to do exactly what we need to do. Which is to destroy isis. We need a strategy. We need to get the lawyers of the back of the war fighters. Right now under president obama weve created this standard that is so high that its impossible to be successful in fighting isis. We need to engage with the arab world to make this happen. It is not a serious proposal to say that to the people that youre asking to support, for their support that they cant even come to the country to even engage in a dialogue with us. Thats not a serious proposal. We need a serious leader to deal with this. I believe im that guy. Senator rubio. Im going to go to senator rubio, again, his thoughts. You have said that banning muslims is unconstitutional. But according to a recent abc News Washington post poll a majority of americans support mr. Trumps idea. This president hasnt kept us safe. We had an attack in San Bernardino and we were paying attention to the most important issue we had in this country since 9 11 and all this talk about the proposal that isnt going to happen. We must deal with this threat of radical islamists, especially from isis. The most sophisticated terror group that has threatened the world or the United States of america. Theyre actively recruiting americans. Born and raised in this country, he was a health inspector. Had a newborn child and left all that behind to kill 14 people. We also understand that this is a group that is growing in its governance of territory. Not just iraq and syria. They are now a predominant group in libya. Beginning to pop up in afghanistan and increasingly involved in attacks in yemen and jordan in its sights. This group needs to be confronted and the president has left us unsafe. He spoke the other night to the American People to reassure us. I wish he hadnt spoken at all. He made things worse because what he basically said was were going to keep doing what were doing now and what we are doing now is not working. Hugh hewitt, you have a question. Senator cruz, youve said you disagree with mr. Trumps policy. I dont want to cage match, but republican primary voters deserve to know. With the kind of specificity that you delivered in your Nine Supreme Court arguments how you disagree with mr. Trump. Would you spell that out with us . Well, listen, hugh, everyone understands why donald has suggested what he has. Were looking at a president whos engaged in this double speak. Where he doesnt call radical islamic terrorism by its name. Indeed, he gives a speech after the San Bernardino attack where his approach is to try to go after the Constitutional Rights of law abiding citizens, rather than to keep us safe. Even worse, president obama and Hillary Clinton are proposing bringing tens of thousands of Syrian Refugees to this country when the head of the fbi has told congress they cannot vet those refugees. I understand why donald made that proposal. Introduced in the senate and what my legislation would do is suspend all refugees for three years from countries where isis or al qaeda controls substantial territory. So, youre saying you disagree because hes too broad and you have more narrower focus. Why do you disagree with him . Im reminded of what fdrs grandfather said. He said all horse thieves are democrats. But not all democrats are horse thieves. In this instance, there are millions of peaceful muslims across the world in countries like india where there is not the problems we are seeing in nations that are controlled. Have territory controlled by al qaeda or isis and we should direct at the problem, focus on the problem and defeat radical islamic terrorism. Its not a war on a faith. Its a war on a political ideology that seeks to murder us. Carly fiorina, this is the christmas dinner debate. This will be the debate that americans talk about at christmas. Thus far in the first ten minutes, we havent heard a lot about Ronald Reagans sitting on a hill. But heard a lot of keeping americans safe and everyone else out. Is this what you want the party to stand for . What i think we need to stand for are solutions. I offer myself as a leader to the people of this country because i think theyre looking for solutions. Not lawyers arguing over laws. Or entertainers throwing out sound bites that draw media attention. We need to solve the problem. To solve the problem, we need to do something here at home. And something over there in their caliphate. We need to deny them territory. Here at home we need to do two fundamental things. Number one, we need to recognize that technology has moved on. The patriot act was signed in 2001, roughly. The iphone was invented in 2007. The ipad was invented in 2011. Snapchat and twitter and all the rest of it have been around just for several years. Technology has moved on and the terrorists have moved on with it. Let me tell you a story. Soon after 9 11 i got a phone call from the nsa. They needed help. I gave them help. I stopped a truck load of equipment and i had it turned around. It was escorted by the nsa into headquarters. We need the private sectors help because government is not innovating. Technology is running ahead by leaps and bound. The private sector will help, just as i helped after 9 11. They must be engaged and they must be asked. I will ask them. I know them. Governor christie, americans are clearly more afraid today than at any time since 9 11. As you mentioned in your Opening Statement today in los angeles, 650 School Children didnt go to 650,000 School Children didnt go to school because of an email threat. This, two weeks after an attack killed 14 people in San Bernardino. Is this the new normal . And, if so, what steps would you take as president of the United States to ensure that fear does not paralyze america . Wolf, unfortunately, its the new normal under barack obama and Hillary Clinton. The fact is that if you listen to Hillary Clinton the other day, what she said to the American People was, thats regards to isis. My strategy would be just about the same as the president s. Just about the same as the president s. We have people across this country who are scared to death. Because i could tell you this, as a former federal prosecutor, if a center for the developmentally disabled and San Bernardino, california, is now a target for terrorists, that means everywhere in america is a target for these terrorists. Now, i spent seven years of my life in the immediate aftermath of september 11th doing this work. Working with the patriot act. Working with our Law Enforcement. Working with the Surveillance Community to make sure that we keep america safe. What we need to do, wolf, is restore those tools that have been taken away by the president and others. Restore those tools to the nsa and Law Enforcement community. We need a president what action and we need a president and a cabinet that understands that the first and most important priority as the president of the United States is to protect the safety and security of americans as someone who has done it, i will make sure it gets done, again. Thank you. Governor kasich. One of the killers in San Bernardino was an american who was not on anyones watch list. How are you going to find that radicalized person and stop another such attack . Well, first of all, wolf, i said last february that we needed to have people on the ground, troops on the ground in a coalition similar to what we had in the first gulf war. I remember when the egyptian ambassador to the United States stood in the rose garden and pledged arab commitment to removing Saddam Hussein from kuwait. Before we came out here tonight, i am told that the saudis organized 34 countries who want to join in the battle against terrorism. First and foremost, we need to go and destroy isis and we need to do this with our arab friends and our friends in europe. When i see they have a Climate Conference over in paris, they should have been talking about destroying isis because they are involved in virtually every country, you know, across this world. Now, you destroy isis in a coalition and you get joint intelligence with our european friends and then here at home, there are things called the joint Terrorism Task force. Headed by the fbi and made up of local Law Enforcement, including state police. They need the tools and the tools involve encryption where we cannot hear what theyre even planning. When we see red flags, a mother, a father, a neighbor that says we have a problem we have to give Law Enforcement to listen to stop these terrorist attacks before they occur. Pay me now or pay me a lot more later. This is the direction we need to go. Thank you. Dana bash, you have the next question. How to balance surveillance with privacy and keeping americans safe. Senator cruz, you voted for a bill that president obama signed into law just this past june that made it harder for the government to access americans phone records. In light of the San Bernardino attack, was your vote a mistake . Well, dana, the premise of your question is not accurate. Im very proud to have joined with conservatives in both the senate and the house to reform how we target bad guys. And what the usa freedom act did it did two things. Number one, it ended the federal governments bulk collection of phone metadata of millions of lawabiding citizens. Number two in the second half that is critical. It strengthened the tools of National Security and Law Enforcement to go after terrorists. It gave us greater tools and we are seeing those tools work right now in San Bernardino. In particular, what it did is the Prior Program only covered a relatively narrow slice of phone calls. When you had a terrorist, you could only search a relatively narrow slice of numbers, primarily landlines. The usa freedom act expands that so we have the phones that terrorists are likely to use and the focus of Law Enforcement is on targeting the bad guys. You know, the Obama Administration keeps getting wrong is whenever anything bad happens they focus on lawabiding citizens instead of focusing on the bad guys. We need to focus on radical islamic terrorists and we need to stop them before they carry out acts of terror. Bipartisan support for that. But you voted against it. So, is senator cruz wrong . He is and so are those who voted for it. Some that voted for it because they wanted to keep it alive and they were afraid the whole program would expire. Heres the world we live in. A radical Jihadist Group and radicalize american citizens and its inability to exploit loopholes in our ilLegal Immigration system and capture to hold territory in the middle east and multiple countries. This is not just the most capable, but the most sophisticated Terror Threat we have ever faced. We are now at a time when we need more tools and not less tools. That was a valuable tool that we no longer have at our disposal. Senator cruz . I would note that marco knows what hes saying, they are saying the same thing. They are knowingly false and attacks like barack obama and the reason is simple. What he knows is that the old program covered 20 to 30 of phone numbers to search for terrorists. The new Program Covers nearly 100 . That gives us greater ability to stop acts of terrorism and he knows that is the case. Senator let me be very careful when answering this. I dont think National Television in front of 15 Million People is the place to discuss personal information. There is nothing we are allowed to do under this bill that we could not do before. This bill did, however, take away a valuable tool that allowed the National Security agency and other intelligence agencies to quickly and rapidly access phone records and match them up with other phone records to see who terrorists have been calling. Because i promise you the next time there is an attack on this country, the first thing people are going to want to know is, why didnt we know about it and why didnt we stop it . The answer better not be we didnt have access to information to identify these killers before they attack. Senator paul, i know this is this has been a very big issue for you. You hear many of your colleagues are calling for increased surveillance by Law Enforcement. You call that hogwash. Why is that hogwash . You know, i think marco gets it completely wrong. We are not any safer through the collection of all americans records. In fact, i think were less safe. We get so distracted by all the information, were not spending enough time getting specific information on terrorists. The other thing is, the one thing that might have stopped San Bernardino and might have stopped 9 11, stricter controls on those who came here. Marco has opposed increased security Border Security for those who come to our country. On his gang of eight bill, he would have legalized immigration and he did not and he steadfastly opposed any new Border Security for refugees or students. Last week, i introduced another bill saying we need more security. We need more scrutiny. Once again, marco opposed this. So, marco cant have it both ways. He thinks he wants to be this, oh o, im great and strong on national defense. But hes the weakest of all the candidates on immigration. He is the one for an open border that is leaving us defenseless. If we want to defend the country, we have to defend against those coming in and marco allegiance than he does to conserve policy. Senator rubio. I want to thank rand for another 30 seconds because, number one, what hes pointing to is a bill last week that amendment that he voted for that only ten people voted for. You know why . Because its not focused on terrorists. Someone from taiwan would not have been able to come here as a tourist. This Metadata Program is actually more strict than what a regular Law Enforcement agency has now. If a regular Law Enforcement agency wants your phone records, all they have to do is issue a subpoena. Not able to quickly gather records and look at them to see who these terrorists are calling. And the terrorists that attacked us in San Bernardino was an american i bet we wish we had access to five years of his records to see who he was working with. Governor christie, ill come to you in a minute. Go ahead, senator paul. Can i respond . Go ahead, please. Marco still misunderstands the immigration issue. What i put forward was an amendment from highrisk terrorist countries but would have started it up but wanted to go through global entry which is a program where we do background checks. Every terrorist attack we had since 9 11 has been Legal Immigration. Marco wants to expand that. I want more rules, more scrutiny and to defend the country you have to defend the border. Senator, were going to talk about immigration in a while. But governor christie, just listening to this, listening to this, you heard senator paul, senator cruz talk about how important it is to protect americans privacy, even in a time of grave danger. Whats wrong with that . Listen, i want to talk to the audience at home for a second. If your eyes are glazing over like mine this is what it is like to be on the floor of the United States senate. Endless debates about how many angels on the head of a pin from a person who never had to make a consequential decision. How to pull forward or pull back. Whether you use certain actionable intelligence or whether not to. They debate about this bill and the subcommittee and nobody in america cares about that. What they care about. Are we going to have a president who knows what theyre doing to make these decisions . For the seven years afterwards new jersey was threatened like no other region in this country and what we did is we took actions within the constitution to make sure that Law Enforcement had all the information they needed. We prosecuted two of the biggest terrorism cases in the world and stopped ft. Dix from being attacked from six radicalized muslims from a mosque in new jersey because we work would the Muslim American community to get intelligence. We used the patriot act to get other intelligence. This is the difference between having been a federal prosecutor and actually doing something and just spending your life as 1 of 100 debating it. Lets talk about how we do this and not each bill which these guys like more. People dont care about that. Thank you. Thank you. Dr. Carson. Youre in favor of monitoring mosques and schools where there is antiamerican sentiment. What do you consider antiamerican . Well, first of all, let me just complain a little bit. This is the first time i have spoken and several people have had multiple questions. So, please try to Pay Attention to that. Now, as far as monitoring is concerned, what my point is, we need to make sure that any place. I dont care whether its a mosque, a school, a superintendent, you know, a theater. It doesnt matter. If there are a lot of people getting there, engaging in radicalizing activities, then we need to be suspicious of it. We have to get rid of all this stuff and people are worried about somebodys going to say that im islamaphobic or what have you. This is craziness. We are at war. Thats why i ask congress, go ahead and declare the war. We need to be on a war footing. We need to understand that our nation is in grave danger. You know, what the Muslim Brotherhood said and the Explanatory Memorandum that was discovered during the Holyland Foundation trial is that they will take advantage of our pc attitude to get us. We have to be better than this. We have to be smarter than they are. Dr. Carson, who was right in that little debate we just heard between senator rubio and senator paul . I think you have to ask them about that. I dont want to get in between them. Let them fight. Wolf, these hold on one second. We have a lot more to come and everyone will have their full opportunities. Governor bush, six days after 9 11, your brother visited a mosque and said, islam is peace. The conversation tonight is about banning muslims and surveillance of mosques. Are president bushs words still relevant in Todays Republican Party . They are relevant, if we want to destroy isis. If we want to destroy radical islamic terrorism. We cant disassociate ourselves from peaceloving muslims. If we expect to do this on our own, we will fail. If we do it in unison with people who are also at risk and threatened by Islamic Radical terrorism, well be far more successful. Look, the fbi has the tools necessary to monitor unamerican activities in our country. It goes on. We shouldnt be talking about it. To be honest with you, out in the public. They have those capabilities and we should be sure we give the fbi and nsa and intelligence communities all the resources they need to keep us safe. But the main thing we should be focused on is a strategy to destroy isis. I laid out a plan at the Reagan Library before the tragedy of pairs and before San Bernardino to do just that. It requires leadership. Its not filing an amendment and calling it success. Developing a strategy and funding it and making sure we have a military that is second to none and doing the job and making sure that we destroy isis there. Thats how you keep america safe. Ms. Fiorina, as you pointed out, you were a ceo in Silicon Valley on 9 11. Companies there say they wont help the fbi crack encrypted from isis. Should they be forced to . Listening to this conversation, let me just say, we have a lot of argument about laws, but none of it solves the problem. Lets examine what happened. Why did we miss the tsarnaev brothers . Why did we miss the San Bernardino couple . It wasnt because we had stopped collecting metadata. It was because i think as someone who comes from the technology world, we were using the wrong algorithms. The government is willfully behind the technology curve. But secondly, the bureaucratic processes that have been in place since 9 11 are inadequate, as well. What do we now know that dhs vets people by going into databases of known or suspected terrorists. Isis is recruiting people who are not in those databases. So, of course, were going to miss them. Then we now learn that dhs says, no, we cant check their social media. Every parent in america is checking social media and every employer is, as well. The government cant do it . The bureaucratic procedures are so far behind. Our government has become incompetent, unresponsive, corrupt. That incompetence and lack of accountability is now dangerous. It is why we need a different kind of leadership in the white house that understands how to get bureaucracies competent, again. But my question was, should these Silicon Valley companies be forced to cooperate with the fbi . They do not need to be forced. They need to be asked. To bring the best and brightest. The most recent technology to the table. I was asked as a ceo. I complied happily and they will, as well. But they have not been asked. Thats why it cost billions of dollars to build an obama website that failed. Because the private sector wasnt asked. Mr. Trump. You recently suggested closing that internet up. Those were your words as a way to stop isis from recruiting online. Are you referring to closing down actual portions of the internet . Some say that would put the u. S. In line with china and north korea. Well, look, this is so easy to answer. Isis is recruiting through the internet. Isis is using the internet better than we are using the internet and it was our idea. What i wanted to do is i wanted to get our brilliant people from Silicon Valley and other places and figure out a way that isis cannot do what theyre doing. You talked freedom of speech. You talked freedom of anything you want. I dont want them using our internet to take our young impressionable youth and watching the media talking about how theyre masterminds. These are masterminds. They shouldnt be using the word mastermind. These are thugs and terrible people in isis. Not masterminds. We have to change it from every standpoint. We should be using our brilliant people. Our most brilliant mind to figure a way that isis cannot use the internet. And then on second, we should be able to penetrate the internet and find out exactly where isis is and everything about isis. We can do that if we use our good people. Let me follow up, mr. Trump. So, are you open to closing parts of the internet . I would certainly be open to closing areas where we are at war with somebody. I sure as hell dont want to let people that want to kill us and kill our nation use our internet. Yes, sir. I am. Thank you. Governor kasich, is shutting down any part of the internet a good idea . No. I dont think it is. I want to go back to two other issues. One is the metadata. We know we have to hold this data for a longer period of time. And, you know, in a lot of ways, chris is right. What a president has to do is stake a position. We dont want to err on the side of having less. We want to err on the side of having more. Thats good for our families. In addition to that, wolf, there is a big problem. Its called encryption. And the people in San Bernardino were communicating with people who the fbi had been watching but because their phone was encrypted, because the intelligence officials could not see who they were talking to, it was lost. We have to solve the encryption problem. It is not easy. A president of the United States, again, has to bring people together. Have a position. We need to be able to penetrate these people when they are involved in these plots and these plans and we have to give the local authorities the ability to penetrate than disrupt. Thats what we need to do. Encryption is a major problem and congress has got to deal with this and so does the president to keep us safe. Thank you, governor. The fight against radical islamic terrorists and isis has been called the war of our time. Lets talk about how each of you as commander in chief would fight this war and win it. Senator cruz. You have said you would carpet bomb isis into oblivion testing whether or not sand can glow in the dark. Does that mean leveling the isis capital where there are hundreds and thousands of civilians . What it means is using overwhelming air power to utterly and completely destroy isis. To put things in perspective. In the first persian gulf war we launched roughly 1,100 air attacks a day. We carpet bombed them for 37 days. Saturation bombing after which our troops went in and mopped up what was left of the iraqi army. Right now obama is launching between 15 and 30 air attacks a day. We need to use overwhelming air power and we need to be arming the kurds and we need to be fighting and killing isis where they are. Let me go back to the earlier discussion a minute ago. It is not a lack of confidence that is preventing the Obama Administration from stopping these attacks. It is Political Correctness. We didnt monitor the facebook posting of the female San Bernardino terrorist because the obama dhs thought it would be inappropriate she made a public call to jihad and they didnt target it. The tsarnaev brothers. The elder brother made a public call to jihad and the Obama Administration didnt target it. Assad communicated with a cleric waging jihad against his fellow soldiers. The problem is because of Political Correctness, the Obama Administration, like a lot of folks here, want to search every ones cell phones and emails and not focus on the bad guys and Political Correctness is killing people. Thank you. To be clear, senator cruz, would you carpet bomb raqqa where there are a lot of civilians . Yes or no. You would carpet bomb where isis is. The location of the troops. You use air power directed. But the object isnt to level a city, the object is to kill the isis terrorists. To make it, listen, isis is gaining strength because the perception is that theyre winning. And president obama fuels that perception. That will change when militants across the globe see that when you join isis that you are giving up your life. You are signing your death warrant and we need a president who is focused on defeating every single isis terrorist and protecting the homeland which should be the first priority. Thank you, senator. Senator rubio. You have been critical of senator cruzs strategy. His voting record doesnt match his rhetoric. Why . Well, let me begin by saying we have to understand who isis is. Isis is a radical sunni group. Air strikes are a key component, but they must be defeated on the ground force and that must be made of sunni arabs themselves. Sunni arabs that confront them militarily. We will have to embed additional American Special operators alongside them to help them with training and help them conduct special missions and help improve the air strikes. The air strikes are important. But we need to have an air force capable of it and because of the budget cuts we are facing in this country, we are going to be left with the oldest and the Smallest Air Force we have ever had. We have to reverse those cuts. In addition to the cuts to our navy and in addition to the cuts to our army, as well. Beyond that we must win the information war against isis. Every war we have ever been involved in has had a propaganda of informational aspect to it. Isis is winning the propaganda war and recruiting people, including americans, to join them. We have to show what life is really like in isis territory and we have to show them why isis is not invincible by going out and conducting these attacks and publicizing them to those who they recruit. I ask the question, senator, because you said this. You said he, referring to senator cruz, voted against the Defense Authorization act every year that it came up and i assume that if he voted against it, he would veto it as president. Thats the bill that funds our troops. That is accurate. Three times he voted against the Defense Authorization act. Which is a bill that funds the troops. It also, by the way, funds the iron dome and other important programs. I have to assume you vote against it in the senate, you would also veto it as president. He has also supported, by the way, a budget that is called a containment budget. It is a budget that would radically reduce the amount of money you spend on our military. You cant carpet bomb isis. If we continue those cuts that were doing now, not to mention additional cuts. Well left with the smallest and oldest air force this country has ever had and that leaves us less safe. Senator cruz. You know, marco has continued these attacks and they know its not true. It is true that i voted against the national Defense Authorization act because when i campaigned in texas i told voters in texas that i would oppose the federal government having the authority to detain u. S. Citizens permanently with no due process. I have repeatedly supported an effort to take that out of that bill and i honored that campaign commitment. But more broadly, you know, the notion marco is suggesting that somehow he also has tossed more than a few insults this direction. Lets be absolutely clear. Isis and radical islamic terrorism will face no more determined foe than i will be. We will utterly destroy them by destroying the bad guys. One of the problems with marcos Foreign Policy is he is far too often supported Hillary Clinton and barack obama undermining governments in the middle east that have helped radical islamic terrorists. We need to focus on killing the bad guys, not getting stuck in middle eastern civil wars that dont keep america safe. Senator rubio. Three points of distinction. The first is, if youre an american citizen and you decide to join up with isis. Were not going to read you your miranda rights. Number two, we do need our defense capabilities. It is a fact that the cuts we are facing today and the cuts that senator cruz would have supported would leave us with an even smaller air force and a smaller navy than the one we are going to be left with. The final point i would make is Hillary Clinton and barack obama strategy is to lead from behind. It sounds like what he is outlining is not to lead at all. We cannot continue to outsource Foreign Policy. We must lead. And the most powerful nation in the world. We need to begin to act like it, again. Much more on this, but i want to move now back to mr. Trump. Look, this legislation . Hold on. Hold on. We have a lot. We have a lot to discuss. I want to move to mr. Trump right now. We have a question on this war against isis and how you would fight and win this war. Heres the question from facebook. Listen to this. Im josh jacob from georgia tech. Recently donald trump mentioned we must kill the family of isis members. Between civilians and combatants. My question is, how would intentionally killing innocent civilians set us apart from isis . Mr. Trump . We have to be much tougher and much stronger than weve been. We have people that know what is going on. You look at the attack in california the other day. Numerous people, including the mother that knew what was going on. They saw a pipe bomb sitting all over the floor. They saw ammunition all over the place. They knew exactly what was going on. When you had the World Trade Center go. People were put into planes that were friends, family, girlfriends and they were put on planes and they knew what was going on. They went home and wanted to watch their boyfriends on television. I would be very, very firm with families. Frankly, that will make people think because they may not care much about their lives. But they do care, believe it or not, about their families lives. Governor bush. This is another example of the lack of seriousness. Look, this is, this is troubling because were at war. Theyve declared war on us and we need to have a serious strategy to destroy isis. But the idea that that is a solution to this is just is just crazy. It makes no sense to suggest this. Look, two months ago donald trump said that isis was not our fight. Just two months ago. He said that Hillary Clinton would be a great negotiator with iran. And he gets his Foreign Policy experience from the shows. That is not a serious kind of candidate. We need someone that thinks this through. That can lead our country to safety and security. Mr. Trump. Look, the problem is we need toughness. Honestly. I think jeb is a very nice person. Hes a very nice person, but we need tough people and we need toughness and we need intelligence and we need tough. Jeb said when they come across the southern border they come as an act of love. You said on september 30th that isis was not a factor. Are you talking or am i talking . You can go back. You interrupted me. Are you going to apologize, jeb. No. Am i allowed to finish . Excuse me, am i allowed to finish . Go ahead, mr. Trump. Governor bush, please. One at a time. Look, look, look. We need a toughness. We need strength. Were not respected, you know, as a nation any more. We dont have that level of respect that we need. And if we dont get it back fast, were just going to go weaker, weaker and just disintegrate. And we cant allow that to happen. We need strength. We dont have it. When jeb comes out and he talks about the border and i saw it and i was witness to it and so was everyone else and i was standing there, they come across as an act of love. Hes saying the same thing right now with radical islam. And we cant have that in our country. It just wont work. We need strength. Governor bush. Donald, youre not going to be able to insult your way to the presidency. Thats not going to happen. And i do have the strength. Leadership, leadership is not, leadership is not about attacking people and discouraging people. Leadership is about creating a serious strategy to deal with the threat of our time. I laid out that strategy before the attacks in paris and before the attacks in San Bernardino. And it is the way forward. We need to increase our military spending. We need to deal with the nofly zone in syria and building a military that is second to none. With jebs attitude, we will never be great again. That i can tell you. We will never be great, again. Hugh hewitt and dana bash. Go ahead with the next question. Dr. Carson, you mentioned in your opening remarks that youre a pediatric neurologist neurosurgeon. People are inspired by your life story, your kindness and evangelical core support. Were talking about ruthless things tonight. Carpet bombing, toughness, war. People wonder, could you do that . Could you order air strikes that would kill innocent children by not the scores, but the hundreds and thousands . Could you wage war as a commander in chief . Interestingly enough, you should see the eyes of some of those children, when i say to them, were going to have to open your head up and take out this tumor. Theyre not happy about it, believe me. They dont like me very much at that point. But later on, they love me. Sometimes you i sound like him. Later on they really realize whats going on and by the same token, you have to be able to look at the big picture. And understand that its actually merciful if you go ahead and finish the job rather than death by 1,000 so you are okay with the deaths of thousands of innocent children and civilian . You got it. That is what war. Can you be as ruthless as churchill was. Ruthless is not necessarily the word i would use but tough, resolute, understanding what the problems are and understanding that the job of the president of the United States is to protect the people of this country and to do what is necessary in order to get it done. Senator paul. You said isis grew stronger because of the hawks in your party. Do you really think that republicans have fueled the rise of isis . I think that by arming the allies of isis the islamic rebels against assad that we made that space bigger for isis to grow. I think those that wanted regime change have made a mistake. When we toppled gadhafi in libya, i think that was a mistake. I think isis grew stronger and we had a failed state and more at risk. I would like to also go back to another question. Which is, is donald trump a serious candidate. The reason i ask this is, if you are going to close the internet, realize america what that entails. That entails getting rid of the first amendment. Okay. No small feat. If you are going to kill the families of terrorists, realize that there is something called the Geneva Convention were going to have to pull out of. It would defy every norm that is america. So, when you ask yourself whoever you are that think youre going to support donald trump. Think, do you believe in the constitution . Are you going to change the constitution . So, they could kill us, but we cant kill them . Thats what youre saying. As far as the internet is concerned. Were not talking about closing the internet. Im talking about parts of syria, parts of iraq. Where isis is. Spotting it. Now, you could close it. What i like even better than that is getting our smartest and getting our best to infiltrate their internet. So, that we know exactly where theyre going. Exactly where theyre going to be. I like that better. But, we have to who would be. I just cant imagine somebody booing. These are people that want to kill us, folks. And youre objecting to us infiltrating their conversations . I dont think so. I dont think so. Senator paul. Senator paul, i want to go back to my initial question which is, you saying that isis grew stronger because of your party and do you think your own party, the people who youre describing are responsible for the rise of isis . I think that if you believe in regime change, youre mistaken. In 2013, we put 600 tons of weapons. Us, saudi arabia and qatar into the war against assad. By pushing assad back we did create a safe space. We had people coming into our Foreign Relations committee and saying we need to arm the allies of al qaeda. Theyre still saying this. It is a crazy notion. This is the biggest debate we should be having tonight is regime change a good idea. Has it been a good idea . There are still people. The majority on the stage. They want to topple assad. And then there will be chaos and i think isis will be in charge. Governor kasich, would you like to respond to senator paul . Yeah, let me just suggest to everybody. And i hear, last february i said we needed to have people on the ground and a coalition with europe and our allies. This is not going to get done just by working with the sunnis. And it is not going to get done if we just embed a few people. We have to go massively like we did in the first gulf war where we destroyed saddams ability to take kuwait. We need to have a coalition that will stand for nothing less than the total destruction of isis and we have to be the leader. We cant wait for anybody else. I served on the Armed Services committee for 18 years and we must lead or the job wont get done, unfortunately, for our country. Thank you, governor. Senator rubio. Lets continue this conversation. This is a critically important issue. I hope at some point youre going to ask me my strategy for defeating isis. We have a lot of time. I want to get senator rubio right now. One of the aspects of your strategy. The only way to defeat isis with Ground Forces made up primarily of arab forces. Those nations have conducted less than 5 of the air strikes and actually none since august. What makes you think they are willing to fight on the ground if theyre not even willing to fight from the air . They most certainly will have to be worked on to provide more than what theyre doing now. One major reason why they are not a broader part of the coalition. They have lost complete trust and confidence in this president. This president cut a deal with our mortal enemy the shia in iran. This is the reason why they no longer trust this president and willing to work alongside them. They have as much invested in this than us or more so. The king of jordan they want to dethrone. They want to go into egypt. Like the way theyve gone into libya. On another point we need to talk about. Assad is one of the reasons why isis exists to begin with. He has been so brutal towards the sunni within syria that he created the space that led for the people of syria them selves to stand up and overthrow him. That led to the chaos to grow more powerful. No alternative groups on the ground to be empowered leaving isis the prime operating space they needed. Stand by. Ms. Fiorina. The former defense secretary bob kate says the chances of getting sunni arab forces on the ground to get the job done. His words, chances very remote. Whats your strategy . Well, first, ill just point out that talking tough is not the same as being strong. To wage war, we need a commander in chief who made tough calls in tough times and stood up to be accountable over and over. Not firstterm senators who never made an executive decision in their life. One of the things i would immediately do in addition to defeating them here at home is bring back the warrior class. Petraeus, mcchrystal, mattis, keane, flynn. Every single one of these generals i know, every one was retired early because they told president obama things that he didnt want to hear. We must have sunni arabs involved in this coalition. We must commit leadership, strength, support and resolve. I will just add that Margaret Thatcher once said if you want something talked about. Ask a man. If you want something done, ask a woman. Thank you. Governor christie, what is your strategy . Wolf, you sit up here and you listen to this stuff and you think that so many of these people have had so much to do in this national debate. They talk like they were bystanders. You know, we talk about our military being degraded over time and, yet, weve had folks on the stage that have been a part of congress who have participated in sequester. Who participated in the degrading of this military over time. And thats why i think people get so frustrated with washington, d. C. , now. Thats why theyre so angry with the electorate so angry with everybody who is involved in government washington, d. C. Because if you listen to the folks up here, you would think that theyre not even there. They had nothing to do with this. This is the difference between being a governor and being in the legislature. Because when something doesnt work in new jersey, they look at me. Say why didnt you get done. Why didnt you do it . You have to be responsible and accountable. When isis, lets be clear so get it done . The president needs to be a force that is trusted in the world. And on this i agree with marco. You know, this president s not trusted. If youre the king of jordan or in the royal family in saudi arabia and hes made this deal with iran to give them money to wage a war and try to extend their empire in the middle east, why would you want to do it now . But when i stand across from king hussain of jordan you have a friend who will stabbed with you to fight this fight. Dr. Carson, what is your strategy . I have been talking about this for over a year. We have to destroy their caliphate. That gives them legitimacy to go ahead with the global jihad. We have to take their energy because they are isis is the richest terrorist organization there is, take their oil and shut down their mechanisms by which they can disperse money. And they are able to pay them, and that makes a difference. As far as the command centers are concerned in raqqah and mosul, cut those off the same kind of thing we did with sinjar, working with the embedded forces with the kurds, shut off the supply routes and follow with our air force to take them over. Those are things that work. But also, you know, this whole concept of boots on the ground, you know weve got a phobia of boots on the ground. If our military experts want boots on the ground there should be boots on the ground. And there will be boots on the ground and they will be their boots and theyll be over here if we dont stand our ground. Stand by, were only just beginning. Which candidates on this stage tonight want to move u. S. Foreign policy in a dramatically new direction . Well be right back. Withof my moderate to severe rheumatoid arthritis. Ordinary objects often seemed. Intimidating. Doing something simple. Meant enduring a lot of pain. If ra is changing your view of everyday things orencia may help. Orencia works differently by targeting a source of ra early in the inflammation process. For many, orencia provides longterm relief of ra symptoms. Its helped new ra patients and those not helped enough by other treatments. Do not take orencia with another biologic medicine for ra due to an increased risk of serious infection. Serious side effects can occur including fatal infections. Cases of lymphoma and lung cancer have been reported. Tell your doctor if youre prone to or have any infection like an open sore, the flu, or a history of copd, a chronic lung disease. Orencia may worsen your copd. If youre not getting the relief you need. Ask your doctor about orencia. Orencia. See your ra in a different way. But the more you learn aboutnd your coverage,t. The more gaps you might find. Like how you thought you were covered for all this. When youre really only covered for this. Hot dog . Or how you may think youre covered for this. But not for this. Whoa no, no, oh , oh . Or this. Or this. Or that. Talk to farmers and see what gaps could be hiding in your coverage. My heaven we are farmers bum pa dum. Bum bum bum bum welcome back to the cnn facebook republican president ial debate at the venetian, las vegas. The war against isis will pose many challenges for the next commanderinchief. The last two president s pursued a policy that promoted toppling dictators to support democratic. Senator cruz you said that the world would be safer if Saddam Hussein was in iraq and Hosni Mubarak ruled egypt. Would you preserve dictatorships rather than promoting democracy in the middle east. If i believe an America First Foreign Policy that president obama and Hillary Clinton and more than a new republicans have gotten distracted from the central focus of keeping this country safe. So lets go back to the beginning of the Obama Administration when Hillary Clinton and president obama let nato in toppling the government in libya. A number of republicans supported them, the result of there were these moderate rebels that would take over. The result is that libya is now a terrorist war zone run by jihadists. Move to egypt. Once again the Obama Administration toppled mubarak who had been a reliable ally of the United States and israel and in its place morsi and the Muslim Brotherhood came in, a terrorist organization. And we need to learn from history, these same leaders, obama, clinton and far too many republicans want to topple assad. Assad is a bad man. Gaddafi is a bad man. But they were assisting us at least gaddafi and mubarak in fighting terrorists. And if we topple assad, isis will take over syria and it will worsen National Security interests. And the approach inset of a democracy promoter we ought to hunt down the enemies and kill isis rather than creating opportunities for isis to control new countries. Senator rubio, isis is clearly growing in turkey. Senator cruz says you havent learned your lesson do. You have any regrets for supporting president obamas intervention in libya . The revolt against gaddafi was started by the libyan people. And i argued we needed to get involved because he was going to go one way or the other and the longer the civilian war takes, the more militias would be formed. As far as moe mar gaddafi, he is the man who killed the americans over lockerbie, scotland and killed marines. And you know why he cooperated on the Nuclear Program . Because we got rid of Saddam Hussein. We will is to work with less than ideal governments. The government in saudi arabia is not a democracy but we have to work with them. The government in jordan is not perfect but we have to work with them. But assad, who get ieds into iraq if they go, i will not shed a tear. Senator cruz . Its more than not shedding a tear its actively getting involved to topple a government and we keep hearing from president obama and Hillary Clinton and Washington Republicans that they are searching for myth call moderate rebels. Its like a purple unicorn. They dont exist. They end up being jihadists. And Prime Minister netanyahu has said at the same time, Prime Minister netanyahu doesnt want to see syria governed by isis and we need to focus on american interests nod everybody stand by for a moment. Governor kasich go ahead. Assad with aligned with iran and russia. We want to prevent iran being able to extend a shia crescent across the middle east. There are moderates in syria who we should be supporting. I dont support a civil war or want to be policeman of the world but we cant back off of this. And the saudis have agreed to put together a coalition inside syria to stabilize that country. He must go. Would be a blow to iran and russia. Mr. Trump, are americans safer with dictators running the world in the middle east . In my opinion go ahead, mr. Trump. We have spent 4 trillion trying to topple various people that frankly if they were there and if we could have spent that 4 trillion in the United States to fix our roads, our bridges and all of the other problems, our airports and all the other problems we have we would have been a lot better off i can tell you that right now. We have done a tremendous disservice not only to the middle east but to humanity, the people that have been killed, the people that have been wiped away and for what . Its not like we had victory. Its a mess. The middle east is totally destabilized, a total and complete mess. I wish we had the 4 trillion or 5 trillion. I wish it were spent right here in the United States on schools, hospitals, roads, airports and Everything Else that are all falling apart. That is exactly what president obama said. Go ahead. Thats exactly what president obama has said im amazed to hear that from a republican president ial candidate. But lets start with who got it wrong, who really got it wrong. Hillary clinton has gotten every Foreign Policy challenge wrong. The reset button with Vladimir Putin. She called Bashar Al Assad a positive reformer and opened an embassy and later said over and over and over, Bashar Al Assad must go although she was not prepared to do anything about it. Hillary clinton was all for toppling moe mar gaddafi and didnt listen to her own people on the ground. And she lied about the terrorist attack in benghazi. There is nothing to respond to. People feel differently. Benghazi was a disaster because of libya everything fell into place. It could not have been worse. What do we have now . We have spent 3 trillion and probably much more. Thousands and thousands of lives, we have nothing. Wounded warriors all over the place, who i love, we have nothing for it. Ben said, correctly, this is not a knock. This is one of the finest men. But i have been talking about oil for three years. Ive been saying take the oil. Take the oil. I didnt just say bomb it, take it and use it and distribute it so the Wounded Warriors and people. I have been saying this now for many years. Now all of a sudden everyone saying take the oil. I have been saying it for years. Dr. Carson, is the middle east better off with dictators . No one is ever better off with dictators. But there comes a time when youre on an airplane, they always say, in case of an emergency, oxygen masks will drop down put yours on first and administrator help to your neighbor. We need oxygen right now and need to think about the needs of the American People before we go and try to solve everybody elses problems. The fact of the matter is, the middle east has been in turmoil for thousands of years. For us to think that were going to go in there and fix that with a couple of little bombs and a few declarations is relatively foolish. Governor bush . I think we are governor bush, here is the question, you said getting rid of Saddam Hussein was a pretty good deal. In light of what is happened in iraq do you still feel that way . I do. And the Lesson Learned is we have to have a strategy to get in and a strategy to get out which means you create a stable situation. President obama does not believe americans leadership in the world is a force for good. He does not believe that our strength is a place where security can take place. He leads from behind. He creates an environment that now were creating the most unstable situation weve had since the world war ii era. The focus ought to be that Hillary Clinton wants to double down on a failed Foreign Policy. We need to be united to beat that. Well be in a place far less secure than it is today. Senator paul, was getting rid of Saddam Hussein a good deal . These are the fundamental questions of our time. Whether or not regime change is a good idea or a bad idea. I dont think because it was a bad idea it means that hussein was necessarily a good idea. There is variations of evil on both sides of the war. What we have to decide is whether or not regime change is a good idea. Its what the neoconservatives have wanted and what the vast majority of those on the stage want. They want regime change in syria, they wanted it in iraq and libya. It has not worked. You get chaos and you have seen repeatedly there the rise of radical islam. So we get this profession of they want to do something about terrorism and yet theyre the problem because they allow terrorism to arise out of that chaos. Wolf hold on. Hold on. Hold on. Hold on. Whether we should topple dictatorships is asking the wrong question. We should be defeating wait your turn. We have two hours. Well have plenty of time. The focus should be on defeating our enemies senator, please. Senator, youll have plenty of opportunities. Iran has declared war on us. But we shouldnt be toppling regimes that are fighting radical islamic terrorists that are helping these are the rules all of you agreed to. Hugh go ahead with your question. Mr. Trump, we are talking about the most important thing. You are okay with mr. Al assad staying in power but you are in favor of winning. If he stays in power, iran is winning, hezbollah is winning. They are winning everywhere. If they are winning how can we be winning . I think al assad is a bad guy. A lot of people killed. We are backing people we have no idea who they are. The rebels, we have no idea. A lot of people think that they are isis. We have to do one thing at a time. We cant be fighting isis and fighting al assad, al assad is fighting isis, russia is fighting isis and iran is fighting isis. We have to do one thing at a time. Lindsey graham said i have been here for ten years. But he will be there another 50. He wont be able to solve the problem. We have to get rid of isis first. Then we start thinking about it. But we cant fight al assad and when you fight al assad you are fighting russia and a lot of different groups. Governor christie, is he right . Because if we step back, iran goes nuclear. Is donald trump right . I think we have to focus on what the priorities are. And what ive always said that the president has set up an awful situation through his deal with iran. Because what his deal with iran has done is empower them and enrich them. And thats the way isis has been created and formed here. Isis is created and formed because of the abuse that al assad and his iranian sponsors have rained down on the sunnis in syria. When we empower iran thats why this president and when Hillary Clinton says her theory against isis will be just about the same as the president. Then get ready for more unrest and more murder and more violence in the middle east. We need to focus our attention on iran. If you miss iran you are not going to get isis. The two are connected because one causes the other. Senator paul, let me ask you heard governor kasich say al assad must go. Do you agree . I think its a mistake. Regime change in syria i have been saying this for several years now. In 2013 i said you are giving arms to radical jihadists . Thats crazy. But the great irony is youll be back fighting against your own weapons. Had assad been bombed two years ago, isis would have been in charge of all of syria now. We need a realistic Foreign Policy instead of a utopian one. They are not going to love us. The Foreign Policy, you have to know how to pick and choose. Theres no way if saddam had not had weapons of mass destruction i would have gone. I dont believe that the u. S. Should be involved directly in civil wars. I opposed the u. S. Involvement in lebanon. There is a difference between iraq, where you have sunni, shia and kurds put together after the First World War by the western powers. It doesnt work. It needs to break up into three parts. And finally in regard to syria, understand that al assad is an ally of iran. And it is time we punched the russians in the nose. We need to stand up against them. Not just there but also in Eastern Europe where they threaten some of our most precious allies. My name is ashley, ms. Fiorina you said you would not communicate with Vladimir Putin because you would be communicating from a position of weakness. Do you believe its feasible to not communicate with another world leader and do you think thats also a sign of weakness . U. S. And russian war planes are flying over syria right now. Is this a good time for the United States not to talk to putin . I didnt say i would cut off all communication with putin. As president of the united i said the president , now is not the time to talk with him. There is a time and a place for everything. There is a time and a place for talk and a time and a place for action. I know Vladimir Putin. He respects strength. He lied to our president s face. He didnt bother to tell him about war planes and troops going into syria. We need to speak to him from a position of strength. So as commander in chief, i will not speak to him until weve set up the nofly zone, until weve gathered our allies and begun to deny isis territory and ive called the Supreme Leader of iran and said new deal. We the United States of america are going to cut off the money flow, which we can do, and i will not speak to him personally until weve rebuilt the sixth fleet, rebuilt the Missile Defense in poland and conducted a few military exercises in the battic states. And let us remember one other thing. Hillary clinton and barack obama are responsible for the growth of isis because they withdrew from iraq in 2011 against the advice of every single general. Its not these people up here. Its Hillary Clinton. Thank you. Governor christie. If the u. S. Impose a new fly zone over syria and a russian plane encroached it, would you be prepared to shoot down the russian plane and risk war . I would do it. A no fly zone means a no fly zone. Thats what it means. See, maybe because im from new jersey i have a plain language hangup. I wouldnt not talk to him. I would talk to Vladimir Putin a lot. I would say listen, mr. President , theres no a no fly zone in syria. You fly in, it applies to you, and we would shoot down the planes of russian pilots if they were stupid enough to think this president was the same feckless weakling that the president we have in the oval office is right now. Senator paul. I want you to respond to what we just heard from governor kris ty. If there was a no fly zone you say that could lead to world war iii. I think if you have r in favor of world war iii, you have your candidate. Heres the thing. What we want in a leader is someone with judgment, not someone who is to reckless as to stand on the stage and say yes, im going to shoot down russian planes. Russia flies in that air space. It may not be something were in love with the fact theyre there, they were invited by iraq and syria to fly in that air space, and so if we announce a no fly zone, Hillary Clinton is for it. Its a recipe for disaster. Its a recipe for world war iii. We need to confront russia from a position of strength. But we dont need to confront them from a point of recklessness that would lead to war. This type of judgment, its having that kind of judgment. Who you would appoint and how youre going to conduct affairs thats important. I mean, i think when we think about the judgment of someone who might want world war iii, we might think about someone who might shut down a bridge because they want to get a democrat, they dont like their friends. I think we need to be careful about that. Governor christie. Reckless is calling asaad a reformer. Reckless is inviting russia into syria to team with iran. That is reckless, and the reckless people are the folks in the white house right now, barack obama, and Hillary Clinton are the reckless people. If you think a no fly zone is a reckless policy, youre welcome to your opinion. Hows it working . We have 250,000 people murdered and slaughters, millions running for their lives. Its not working. Governor bush, you stid trump said trump is not qualified because hes not qualified to deal with putin. Why are you . I would seek out the best advice that exists. I wont get any information from the shows. I dont know if thats saturday morning or sunday morning. I dont know which one. I will seek out the best advice, and i will create a strategy and i will persuade the American People what the role of america should be. Ive laid out a policy of rebuilding our military. All of the talk that were seeing here, most of which i agree on, requires a much stronger military. We now have a lack of readiness that is quite scary. We have planes that harry truman inaugurated. The navy has been gutted. The readiness of the marines is way down. If were serious about americas leadership in the world, we need to make sure we have the back of the armed forces. The radio is here listening to us today. I hope they know if im president , ill lead this country in a way that will create greater security and greater safety. Mr. Trump. I think its very sad that cnn leads jeb bush, governor bush, down a road by starting off virtually all of the questions, mr. Trump this. I think its very sad. And frankly, i think its very sad. And frankly, i watch the first debate, and the first long number of questions were mr. Trump said this. Mr. Trump. These poor guys, although i must tell you, santorum, huckabee, good nice. They were nice and i respect them, but i thought it was very unfair that virtually the entire early portion of the debate was trump this, trump that in order to get ratings i guess. Mr. Trump, i was on cnn last night i think its unprofessional. I watched you last night. Its not cnn. Its not cnn. Its america is watching you. Fine. I was mentioned so i can bring up something, i think. The simple fact is if you think this is tough and youre not being treated fairly, imagine what it will be like dealing with putin, or dealing with the islamic terrorism that exists. This is a tough business to run for president. Youre a tough guy, jeb, i know. And we need to have a leader youre never doing to be president of the United States by insulting your way to the presidency. Im at 42 and youre at 3. So far im doing better. Youre moving over further and further. Pretty soon youll be off the edge. This doesnt do a thing to solve the problem. It sounds more and more what my daughter said that i said in the beginning. All the fighting and arguing is not advancing us. It will not solve the problem. Its not the way well strengthen our country. Well strengthen our country when we come together. You have rand paul, cruz, marco, a lot of people on this stage that have studied these issues. You know what a leader does . They have the sound program, has a good policy, and then brings people together to solve problems. Guess what . Both in congress and in balances the budget and in ohio fixing the economy, and we talk about the fence, the first thing wed better get going is strengthening our economy, because if we dont have a strong economy, we cant pay for all of this, and the world wants us to be able to function from strength. Believe it or not, get our economy going, get these people together in a room. We can fix this, ladies and gentlemen. We dont have to fight all the time. It can be done, and we will be great when we join together. Thank you. Dr. Carson, commander in chief question. Youre on a lot of boards and have travelled the world. Does that prepare you to command troops from japan and afghanistan and to iraq to be in charge of the men and women watching tonight . Well, theres a false narrative that only the Political Class has the wisdom and the ability to be commander in chief. But if you go back and you study the design of our country, it was really designed for the citizen statesman, and we need to be talking about where does your experience come from . And ive had a lot of experience building things. Organizing things. You know, a National Scholarship program. One of the things that youll notice if you look through my life is that i dont do a lot of talking. I do a lot of doing. And really, it says more about a person than how much they talk. And some people say youre weak because youre not loud and youre not boisterous, and youre not rude. But the fact of the matter is, look and see what ive done. And that speaks volumes about strength. Thank you, dr. Carson. Weve been talking tonight about programs and policies proposals that you have to keep americans safe. And its a big discussion on the campaign trail. Also about Border Security and immigration. So lets talk about immigration. Senator rubio. You coauthored a bill with democrats two years ago that allowed a path to citizenship for undocumented immigrants. Do you still support that path to citizenships which means giving them the right to vote. Its not an issue i read about in a paper. Ive lived around it. All of my neighbors are immigrants. My family is immigrants. I see the good, the bad, and the ugly. Heres what we learned in 2013. The American People dont trust the federal government to enforce the immigration laws and well not be able to do anything on immigration until we prove to the American People that ilLegal Immigration is under control. We can do that. It takes at least 20,000 more Additional Border agents and completing the 700 miles of fencing and a mandatory e verify system and a tracking system to prevent visa overstays. After that, the second thing is reforming and modernizing the Legal Immigration system. After that, i think the American People are going to be very reasonable with what do you do with someone whos been in this country ten years and hasnt violated their laws. Theyll have to undergo a background check, pay a fine, pay taxes, and theyll get a work permit. Thats it for ten years. But you cant even get to the third step until youve done the two things. That was the lesson in 2013. Theres no trust the federal government will enforce the law. Senator, you havent answered the question. You just described a long path, but does that path end at citizenship . I answered that question. I am personally open. After ten years in that probation status with a work permit, i am open the to a howing people to apply for a green card. That might not be a majority position in any party. But thats down the road. You cant begin it until you prove to people, not just pass a law, youre going to have to prove to people that its working. That was the lesson of 2013. After a migratory crisis that youre seeing start up again now and after all the executive orders, we need to prove to people that ilLegal Immigration is under control. Senator cruz. Rubio has said his immigration system isnt different than yours is that true . There was a time for choosing where there was a battle over amnesty. Some chose to stand with barack obama and support a massive amnesty plan. Others chose to stand with steve king and the American People and secure the border. This issue is directly connected to what weve been talking about because the front line with isis isnt just in iraq and syria. Its also in Kennedy Airport and the rio grand. Border security is National Security. And one of the most troubling aspects of the Rubio Schumer gang of eight bill was that it gave president obama blanket authority to admit refugees, including Syrian Refugees without mandating any background checks. Weve seen what happened in San Bernardino. When youre letting people in when the fbi cant vet them, it puts american citizens at risk. If im elected president , we will secure the border. We will triple the Border Patrol and build a wall that works, and ill get donald trump to pay for it. Ill build it. Thank you. Senator rubio. Please. In 2013, we had never faced a crisis like the syrian refugee crisis now. As far as his record, irm puzzled by his attack. Ted, you support legalizing people in this country illegally. He supported a 500 increase in the visas, the guest workers allowed into this country, and doubling the number of green cards. Whats important for us to understand is theres a way forward that we can bring our country together. And i will do it. It will begin by bringing ilLegal Immigration under control and proving it to the American People. Senator cruz. Look,i understand that marco wants to raise confusion. It is not accurate what he said i supported legalization. I led the fight against his legalization and amnesty bill, and there was one commentator what said for marco to suggest our record is the same is like suggesting the fireman and the arsonist have the same record because theyre both at the scene of the fire. He was granting not to secure the border. I was fighting to secure the boarder, and this also goes to trust. On campaign trails, candidates all the time, make promises marco said he learned into the American People didnt trust the federal government. He. Ted does he support legalizing people in this country illegally. Ladies and gentlemen, this is why the American People are fed up. Can you answer that question. Does ted cruz rule out ever legalizing people in this country now . I have never supported legalization. Do you rule it out. I dont intend to support legalization. And let me tell you how you do this this is why the nation is fed up with the political. Weve wait your turn, well get you to. You havent gotten to me. This is why theyre fed up with the Political Class. What you do is enforce the law. Ive layed out a detailed immigration plan on my website. Tedcruz. Org. Its 11 pages. Existing federal law, and in particular, the question of what to do with people who are here now, you enforce the law. That means you stop the Obama Administrations policy of releasing criminal illegal aliens. Do you know how many illegal aliens bill clinton deported . 12,000,000. Bush, 10 million. We can enforce the laws. If we secure the border, that solves the problem. As president , i will solve this problem and secure the border. Mr. Trump, you like to say you restarted this conversation. I think i did. Who do you side with . I have a hardlined position. We have a country or we dont. People who have come into our country have to go and come back through a legal process. I want a strong border. I do want a wall. They have to work. You just have to speak to the folks in israel. Walls work if theyre properly constructed. I know how to build, but i feel a very strong bind and really, im bound to this country. We either have a border or we dont. People can come into the country. We welcome people to come in, but they have to come in legally. Thank you. Governor bush, listening to this, do you think this is the tone, this immigration debate, that republicans need to take to win back hispanics into your party, especially states like where we are in nevada with a large hispanic community. It isnt, but its important to talk about. And i think people have good ideas on this. Clearly we need to secure the border. Coming here legally needs to be easier than coming here illegally. If you dont have that, you dont have the rule of law. There are problems because of ease of bringing heroin in. We have to secure the border. Its a skeers juns undertaking. We need more fencing and we need to use technology and more border control, and we need to have better cooperation with local Law Enforcement. There are 800,000 cops on the beat. They ought to be trained to be the eyes and ears for Law Enforcement for the threat against terror as well as for immigration. This is a serious challenge, and if we can get it right, well start winning votes again. The real problem isnt anybody on the stage. The real problem is barack obama has had six years to advocate a position to fix this, and hes done nothing. The congress has funded programs of building more fencing and doing all this, and he doesnt done it. He wants to maintain it as a wedge issue, and so does Hillary Clinton. Republicans need to fix it. Thank you. Dr. Carson, you recently visited a refugee camp in jordan and said the people there didnt want to come to the United States. Do you think these camps are a longterm solution to the problem of Syrian Refugees . Well, it was very interesting having an opportunity to talk to the syrians themselves, and i asked them, what do you want . What is your supreme desire . Their supreme desire was to be settled back in their own country. I said what can americans and other countries do. They said support the efforts of those who are trying to provide safety for us. Including the jordanians. They had a brand new hospital unstaffed because there wasnt enough money to do it. Heres whats really neat. If you go into a province in North Eastern syria, thats an area thats as big as lebanon, its controlled by the kurds, the christians and the moderate sunnis, and there are airstrips and hotels. You could settle a lot of people there. All we would have to do is be willing to provide them with some weaponry, some defensive weaponry. We seem to be afraid to give the kurds weaponry. We like to send it through bag dad, and then they only get a tejt of it. If we support them, we dont need to set this audiotape as we either take a bunch of refugees who will be infiltrated with terrorists, i guarantee you. For them not to be would be terrorist malpractice, and we need to choose the right choice, not false choices. Senator paul, you oppose letting refugees from syria into the United States. The u. S. Has accepted 2,000 Syrian Refugees, including livering here in laug right now. Would you spend them back . What would you do with these people . We need to set the record straight. I think marco misspoke about the bill. In the gang of eight bill, there was no provisions for safety for refugees. At the time the bill came up, two iraqi refugees came to my hometown. Their fingerprints were on a bomb from iraq. They were in the database, but we didnt pick them up. We put them in Government Housing, got them on food stamps. We didnt have adequate security. On the bill, there was a conservative consensus for an amendment i put forward called trust but verify that strengthened Border Security on refugee, students and those coming here and marco sided and was, i guess more sympathetic to Chuck Schumer and the president than conservative principles. This goes to national defense. He has to explain why he hasnt stepped up to support Border Security. As hes just admitted, the reason why the refugees were allowed in is because they messed up in using the database. It didnt work well. As far as the refugees, its not that american doesnt want to accept refugees. Its that we may not be able to do. We have to be 100 right on it. If we allow thousands of refugees into the United States and all of them are good people, but one person is an isis killer, one person i dont think wrong, we have a serious problem. Theres not one person who can guarantee well be 100 right. Senator paul, you didnt answer the question about the 2,000 Syrian Refugees who are already here in the United States. Will you send them back or let them stay . My bill would be only for refugees going forward. I havent taken a position on sending anyone home, but i have taken the position that we have a lot of problems in our country, and one of the things we do, charity is about giving your own money. Thats not giving someone elses money. To put everyone on Government Housing and bring them in from around the world i think is a big mistake. Ive given to my church. My church has helped people from bosnia. Thats a good thing. We shouldnt have a program that says were going to take care of the worlds refugees. Nobody in the middle east is doing anything. Saudi arabia, qatar, kuwait. All the gulf nations are going nothing. We have another question from facebook. Lets listen. I am carla. I am from the university of texas at austin. My question is directed to all the candidates. If the bible clearly states that we need to embrace these in need and not fear, how can we justify not accepting refugees. You say there should be a pause in allowing new refugees to come into the United States, including orphans under the age of five. What do you say to carla . I say the first job of the president of the United States is to protect your safety and your security, and the security and safety of your family. And this debate stops with me in the discussions with the fbi director. Now, listen, im a former federal prosecutor. When jim comey gets up and says we cannot effectively vet people, thats the end of the conversation. We have to put americas security first. The American People, we need to open our ears. We need to open our ears. The American People are not whispering. Theyre screaming. Its so dysfunctional and ineffective. Its so ineffectual that the American People say we dont trust them to do anything anymore. Im not going to let Syrian Refugees in this country, and it was widows and orphans, and we now know from watching the San Bernardino, that women can commit heinous acts against humanity just the same as men. I dont back away from that position for a minute. When the fbi director says he can vet the people, then well consider it and not a moment before because your safety and security is important to me. Governor kasich. You know, obviously as president of the United States, we have to keep the people safe. Its the first and foremost. As governor of ohio, i have an obligation to keep the people in ohio safe. Weve been effective with the joint Terrorism Task force, being able to make busts. We just made one against a person who was favorable to isis living in akron. Let me tell you whats interesting about the administration. We had central certain miners placed in ohio and we never knew a thing about it. We didnt know where they were, and we know now some of them, theres a case going on where some of them may have been human trafficked. When the Administration Says we have a great vetting process, the proof is in the pudding. They sent these miners to us. Our schools were disrupted. Now they tell me we ought to be able to admit these Syrian Refugees. People have accused me of having too big of a heart. Thats okay. But i also have to keep the people of my state safe. Theres much more coming up. We are only just beginning. Coming up, what other global hot spots await the next president of the United States. To treat the fluis fdad in people two weeks of age and older whose flu symptoms started within the last two days. Before taking tamiflu, tell your doctor if youre pregnant, nursing, have Serious Health conditions, or take other medicines. If you develop an allergic reaction, a severe rash, or signs of unusual behavior, stop taking tamiflu and call your doctor immediately. Children and adolescents in particular may be at an increased risk of seizures, confusion, or abnormal behavior. The most common side effects are mild to moderate nausea and vomiting. Antiflu . Go antiviral with tamiflu. The next thing i know itsedic morning. With tempurflex youve got the spring and bounce of a traditional mattress and it also adjusts to my body. My cloud feels. Its like somebodys hugging you. How can a bed do that . vo theres a tempurpedic for everyone. Welcome back to the cnn facebook republican president ial debate. Were here at the venetian las vegas. We have been focusing on the middle east but lets turn to world threats you will potentially face as commanderinchief. Candidates here have called the north Korean Leader unstable. He now says he has a hydrogen bomb. What would you do about kim jongun . He is a dangerous man. And republican and democrat administrations have been ineffective dealing with him. We need china as part of the strategy. China is a rising adversary. We have to push back on china. They, too, recognize one thing, strength and their own economic interest. I know that in order to get china to cooperate with us we must first retaliate against their cyberattacks so they know were serious. We have to push back on their desire to control the trade route through the south china sea. We cannot let them control the disputed islands and we must work with the ages, the south koreans, the japanese and the philippines to contain china and we must ask for their help and support with north korean. China is concerned about kim jongun as we are. Dr. Carson . What would you do about kim jongun . I do believe he is unstable and china has more influence with him than we do. But we also recognize that north korea is in severe financial straits and they have decided to use their resources to build their military than to feed their people and take care of the humanitarian responsibilities that we have. We can capitalize on. That we can use that to keep putin contained. He is a onehorse show, energy. And we have an abundance of energy but we have archaic energy exportation rules. We need to get rid of those and make europe dependent on us for energy, put him back in his little box where he belongs. And we need to do a lot of other things with the resources that we have. So that economic power works just as well as military power, perhaps better. The military needs to be upgraded. You look at the ohio glass submarines, the minuteman 3 missiles, the b52 bombers, you know, if we dont get the military right nothing else matters. Dana and hugh you have questions. If you said if china launches a cyberattack on the u. S. They will see cyberwarfare like they have never seen before. What would that look like . We have one of the great advantages of america being the open society that we are. We are not hiding things from the American People but china is conducting business in a way that hides things from their people. If they want to attack all the personnel records in the federal government which they have done and they have my Social Security number and fingerprints as well as other folks on this stage. They need to be fought back on. And we need to go with the things they are most sensitive and embarrassing to them that they are hiding and get that information and put it out in public and let the Chinese People digest how corrupt the government is and how they are enriching oligarchs all throughout china. And this president has seen personnel records of people who have sacrificed for the american and for the federal government stolen by the chinese and done nothing in return. This is why i said at the beginning that this administration, barack obama and Hillary Clinton have betrayed the American People. It has led to putin in the middle east and Eastern Europe and significant problems in the middle east as well. Governor bush, what you just heard from governor christie, are you concerned that could escalate with china and they could retaliate and as the nsa has said, attack the u. S. And maybe its power grid which is chinese have the capability to do . I agree with chris. Hillary clintons using a private server for where classified information goes by. This is a serious administration . The president receives an inspector generals report that the office of Personnel Management could be hacked into, 23 million files have are in the hands of the chinese, allegedly, including by the way, members of the press it turns out last week. So now you can have a feel for what it is like to see this type of attack. This is something we have to have the best defensive capabilities and coordinate our efforts with the private sector and offensively we need to have capabilities second to none. We need to create a situation where they know that there will be adverse impacts if they continue to do what theyre doing. They will respect a United States that is serious about protecting our infrastructure. If we dont do it we will continue to see what is happening. The russians and rogue actors, including isis, this is a serious part of the 21st century security challenge that we face. Mr. Trump dr. Carson just referenced the single most important job of the president , the command and care and control of the military forces. The triad, the missiles and submarines are aging out. Its an executive order. What is your priority . I think we need someone we can trust who is total responsibility who knows what he or she is doing that is so powerful and so important. And one of the things that im frankly most proud of is that in 2003, 2004, i was against going into iraq because you are going to destabilize the middle east. I called it very strongly and it was very important. But we have to be extremely vigilant and careful when it comes to nuclear. Nuclear changes the whole ball game. I would have said get out of syria. If we didnt have the power of weaponry today, the power is so massive that we cant just leave areas that 50 years ago we wouldnt care, it was hand to hand combat. The biggest problem this world has today is not president obama with Global Warming which is inconceivable, this is what hes saying. The biggest problem we have today is Nuclear Proliferation having some maniac, having some madman go out and get a nuclear weapon. In my opinion, that is the single biggest problem that our country faces right now. Of the three legs of the triad do you have a its important. Maybe a lot of people have not heard that terminology, its the ability of the United States to conduct Nuclear Attacks using airplanes, from the ground and from our nuclear subs. All three are critical. It gives us the ability at deterrence. Some are more critical than others. The ohio class submarine needs to be modernized. The b52 as someone pointed out is an outdated model that was flown by the grandparents of the people flying it now. And we need an upgrade on the silolaunched missiles. Some of you have questioned whether your opponents have the right temperament to be in control of the nuclear codes. Dana you have a question on this. Mr. Trump, you said this weekend that senator cruz is not qualified to be president because he does not have the right temperament and acted like a maniac. But last month you said you were open to naming senator cruz as your running mate. I did. I have gotten to know him over the last three or four days, he has a wonderful temperament. Hes just fine. Dont worry about it. Senator cruz. You have not been willing to attack mr. Trump in public. But you you better not attack. But you questioned his judgment in having control of marks nuclear arsenal. Why are you willing to say things in private and not in public. I said that the judgment that every voter is making of every one of us up here is who has the experience, who has the vision, who has the judgment to be commanderinchief. That is a standard im held to. And in the course of this discussion about our Foreign Policy threats it illustrates the need for clarity of focus. My daughters, caroline and katherine came tonight. They are 7 and 5. You think about the los angeles schools cancelling their schools today. And every parent is wondering how do we keep our kids safe . We need a commanderinchief that did what reagan did. He set out a strategy to defeat communism. One of the things weve seen here is how easy it is for president obama and Hillary Clinton to be distracted from islamic terrorism. We need a president who stands up and says we will defeat isis and says the greatest national a lot of people have seen a lot of people have seen these comments you made in private. What you are saying is that you do believe that mr. Trump has the judgment to be commanderinchief . That is a judgment for every voter to make. But all nine of the people here would make an infinitely better commanderinchief than barack obama or Hillary Clinton. Thank you, senator. And there is a real danger, dana when people get distracted. Thank you im answering the question. There is a danger when people are distracted by peripheral questions and military conflict. We need to focus on defeating jihadism, isis and iran have declared war on america and we need a commanderinchief who will do everything necessary to keep our children safe and i will do everything we are a month and a half away from the first real test who will be the republican president ial nominee. Hugh . My listeners are worried that Hillary Clinton is going to win because you will run as an independent. Will you assure the people that you will run as a republican . I really am. Dr. Carson . Can i just finish . Please. Ive gained Great Respect for the republican leadership. Ive gained Great Respect for many in different forms for the people on the day. I have Great Respect for the people i have met in this process. But i will tell you, i am totally committed to the republican party. I feel very honored to be the front runner. And i think ill do very well if im chosen if im so fortunate to be chosen. Polls have come out recently that say i will beat hillary. Dr. Carson, mr. Trump just committed to stay the distance regardless of the result. How about you . The statement that i would leave the party was contingent upon whether in fact the party acts like they have in the past with a lot of subterfuge. And i have been assured that the Washington Post writer had it all wrong and they will not be engaging in anything to thwart the will of the people. Thats why i got into this race as a member of we the people to bring back honesty to the process. When we come back, everyone will have an opportunity to explain why this particular candidate, each of you on the stage, believes he or she should be the republican president ial nominee. While youre watching this, im hacking your company. Grabbing your data. Stealing your customers secrets. Theres an army of us. Relentlessly unpicking your patchwork of security. Think youll spot us . You havent so far. The next wave of the internet requires the next wave of security. Were ready. Are you . Usic thunder clatter by wild cub most weekends only last a couple of days. Some last a lifetime. Hampton. We go together. Always get the lowest price, only when you book direct at hampton. Com withof my moderate to severe rheumatoid arthritis. Ordinary objects often seemed. Intimidating. Doing something simple. Meant enduring a lot of pain. If ra is changing your view of everyday things orencia may help. Orencia works differently by targeting a source of ra early in the inflammation process. For many, orencia provides longterm relief of ra symptoms. Its helped new ra patients and those not helped enough by other treatments. Do not take orencia with another biologic medicine for ra due to an increased risk of serious infection. Serious side effects can occur including fatal infections. Cases of lymphoma and lung cancer have been reported. Tell your doctor if youre prone to or have any infection like an open sore, the flu, or a history of copd, a chronic lung disease. Orencia may worsen your copd. If youre not getting the relief you need. Ask your doctor about orencia. Orencia. See your ra in a different way. Its time for closing statements. Senator paul . The greatest threat to National Security is our debt. We borrow a Million Dollars a minute and whose fault is it in you have those on the right who say we wont spend anything on the military and the same on the left who say the same for domestic welfare. But there is an unholy alliance and we we spend more money on everything. We are not stronger if we go further into debt. We are not projecting power from bankruptcy court. There is no greater threat than our debt and im willing to hold a the line on all spending. I hope you will consider me in the election. Thank you very much. Governor kasich . No republican has ever been elected president of the United States without winning ohio. Let me give you a tip on how to win ohio, its reform, its hope, its growth, its opportunity, and its security. The people of ohio are the people of america. The people of america are reflected in ohio. Our message has to be big. And bold, and positive and connect, not just with peoples heads but also connect with their hearts. If we do it, we will beat Hillary Clinton and we will run the white house and we will fix america. Governor christie . I was named chief federal prosecutor of new jersey and on september 11st 2001, i lost touch with my relatives and praying they were alive. They were sent home. Many of our friends and others in our neighborhood lost their lives that day. Terrorism, radical Jihadist Terrorism is not theoretical to me. Its real. For seven years i spent my life protecting our country against another one of those attacks. You wont worry when im president whether it can be done. I have already done it. If you give me the chance and give me your vote i will protect america from the wars brought to our doorstep. Miss fiorina . I, too, remember september 11th. I remember immediately putting into place security procedures all throughout our country that did business in 170 countries where we thought corporate interests would be attacked next. To take our country back, to keep our nation safe, we have to begin by beating Hillary Clinton. We need to unify our party. We need to be better than our government which 75 of the American People now think is corrupt and incompetent. We need to be better than our politics. We have 80 of the people who think we have a professional Political Class. We need to unify our party. We need a conservative in the white house and we need to beat Hillary Clinton to take our country back and keep our nation safe. I can. I am. And together, if you join me, we will take our country back. Governor bush . Ask yourself, which candidate will keep you and our country safer, stronger, and freer . Hillary clinton has aligned herself with barack obama on isis, iran, and the economy. Its an alliance doomed to fail. My plans will fortify our national and economic security. And my record as governor will give you a sense i dont make false promises. I deliver real results. For america to be safe and sound i ask for your support. Thank you all very much. Senator rubio . As we near the end of the year we enter one of the most important elections in a generation. What is at stake is not just who is in charge but our identity as a people and a nation. For over 200 years this is a unique place where anyone from anywhere can achieve anything. And millions of americans feel like they are being left behind insecure in their future and unsafe in the face of terrorism. This is about electing a president so that the American Dream can expand and reach more people and change more lives than ever before and rebuild our military so we can remain the strongest nation on earth. I ask for your vote. If you do this, we will rebuild this country and usher in the greatest era in the history of this great land. Senator cruz . Judgment. Strength. Clarity and trust. Barack obama has said he doesnt believe in American Leadership or america winning, he is wrong. America can win again and we will win again. Ronald reagan reignited the american economy, rebuilt the military and i will do the same. Unleashing Small Businesses and rebuilding the military. Our strategy is simple. We win, they lose. Weve done it before. And we can do it again. Dr. Carson . I have been fortunate enough to travel to 58 different countries. And i thank god every day i was born in this country, the most exceptional country that the world has ever known. And i want to make sure that we preserve that exceptionalism for the nextgeneration. My mother told me if i work hard and i believed in the american principles and i believed in god anything is possible. I believe that is true. Thats why im not anxious to give away american principles for the sake of Political Correctness. Our country doesnt win anymore. We dont win on trade. We dont win on the military. We cant defeat isis. Were not taking care of our great people, the veterans, were not taking care of them. We have to change our whole way, our Health Care System is a disaster. Its going to implode in 2017. It doesnt work. Nothing works in our country. If im elected president we will win again. We will win a lot and were going to have a great, great country, greater than ever before. Thank you. Thanks to all the republican president ial candidates. That does it for this republican president ial debate. On behalf of everyone at cnn and the venetian, las vegas. We want to wish everyone a very merry christmas, happy holidays especially to the soldiers, sailors, airmen and marine protecting us around the world. Modern turkey was founded in 1923 on the principles of secular, democratic statehood after centuries of empire. It has been the most turbulent year in a decade of turkeys political history. Turkey has set a new course. One that many hoped would carry it into the european union. Theres clearly a significant portion of the turkish population thats not happy with the policies of the democratically elected government. But things have changed. They are changing