>> the judge had left elmore's fate up to other judges to decide. >> i became literally became hysterical. completely sobbing, running, i threw it at john blume. and he was, what the hell is the matter with you? >> john blume had assigned elmore's case to diana as an intern. >> i was stunned. i had really expected that he would grant relief because they had presented a compelling case of mr. elmore's innocence. >> diana was discovering that proving mr. elmore's innocence was not enough. to get a new trial, elmore's team would have to prove that elmore's constitutional rights had been violated. >> a person can be innocent but as long as they get a fair trial, that's all they're entitled to. well, that begs the question. is it a fair trial if somebody has lied? >> diana's team immediately appealed the judge's decision to