The last five years. Every day and that first tweet hit it on the head, asking about the real danger, and thats one question we dont have an answer to right now. One japanese doctor said the radiation released by fukushima in just five months is like 29 hiroshima atomic bombs. If you are trying to imagine how much that is, it is more than enough to fill Yankee Stadium to the brim. But 43 of children in that area show thyroid abnormalities, the diagnoses, called a2. A2. [ speaking japanese ] while most parents forget about kids forgetting their lunch, in japan, its if they remembered to pack their radiation detectors. [ speaking japanese ] its a standard accessory for a lot of kids near that area. It has been nearly three years since the disaster, and it seems that the bad news continues to mount. Optimistic estimates put cleanup at about 40 years. So what are the continuing impacts of fukushimas radiation, in japan and the world . Shes a fukushima native, where she and her family live. And marco is with saving children from radiation, and she has worked for 42 years to educate the public about the medical hazards of the nuclear age. And radiation expert, dr. Robert gale. He led the soviet assistance, and welcome to all of you. Thank you for having us. So marco, when we hear about fukushima these days, we hear about the plant or the workers, but we dont really hear about whats going on on the ground. Whats the daily life like for people there . And as we mentioned, your family and friends are there, and what are they dealing with every day . Well, it has been very, very difficult, because initially, they wanted to get out of the place, because many people are not aware of the dangers of radiation. But gradually, because of the media, because of the government, everybody is telling fukushima that fukushima is fine, and you can eat fukushima foods. You dont have to go. If you go, you cant get medical expense, or you cant join the medical tests. They have been doing. So most of them kind of like there are three different so if you leave the area, you dont get medical care provided by the government . Thats right. So they have to be there. And there are basically three different kinds of groups. One group, theyre very aware of all of that, the danger of the situation, so they get out of fukushima, or they are very very worried. The other group is very unvigorous. Well, someone says its safe. Other people say no, its not safe. So they are very confused. And more than half of the people think that okay, it could be fine. And i love this place, so were going to stay here, and stick with here no matter what. As a matter of fact, there was a fukushima festival in new york city a couple of weeks ago. And i went to see what it was like, and it was very successful. Performers, and i talked to the organizer, and she told me that well, they got sponsorship from big corporations, and a couple of local newspaper companies, so they had the event. Putting a nice face on it all. What theyre selling is that fukushima is doing fine, and people are trying to restore the place. Im sure that people are trying to restore the place, but obviously, theres a lot of confusion. What kind of information are people in japan, and specifically in fukushima getting . Well, theyre getting very little information. They are lying to them. And the government is lying to them. In fact, the government didnt announce for three months there had been three nuclear melt downs, and they occurred in the first few days. The people fled into the paths of the highest radiation level during the accident because they were not told where the radiation was going. But the government knew, and they didnt want to create a panic. I have addressed two three large meetings of people in tokyo. Many mothers desperate of what to look for in their children. They know that the children are 1020 times more sensitive to radiation than adults, that little girls are twice as sensitive as little boys. Doctors in fukushima have been told by their superiors not to relate symptoms of radiation, saying not to tell the patients that their symptoms could be caused by radiation, which i consider as criminal as a physician. Already 44 children under the age of 18 in fukushima have been diagnosed with, or suspected to have thyroid carcinoma, and Thyroid Cancer very rare in children. One or two per million. And as you mentioned, many have cysts. About 43 have abnormalities on their thyroid ultrasound. It really indicates that these people got a very high dose of radiatioraid, and for me as a p, its the tip of the iceberg. Some think its exaggeration dr. Gale, were going to get new the conversation. You stated that people have less to fear from the radiation itself than the panic that it sets loose. Is this really an exaggeration when you look at all of the numbers . You know, we try to put it in perspective. Of course all of us are being exposed to radiation all the time. And all of us are radio active. Fending on where you live in january, if you live on mount fuji, there are some cities on the slopes of mount fuji, versus tokyo, you get an entirely different dose of radiation. If you lived all of your life in certain areas of japan, just normal areas, versus living awful your life in tokyo, you will receive a much higher dose of radiation than anyone living in the fukushima area. Oh, dr. Gale, i totally disagree. There are certain areas in the world, high mountains in india and brazil, where theres a high background radiation. And studies just have shown that those people have higher than normal incidence of cancer and congenital abnormalities, but were talking about extremely high doses of radiation within fukushima, and from the soil and the ground and the roofs, and from vacuum cleaner dust. When measured in america, its so radioactive, that they are qualified to be buried in a radioactive waste dump in america, so i have to disagree with you as a colleague, very strongly. Dr. Gale, why dont you jump in one more time before we take a break. I want to say that not me, but the world health organization. Which is associated with the aiea. Go ahead, dr. Gale. So we have modeled what would happen if a oneyearold child stayed in the most radioactive area in fukushima, a city called name. Oneyearold, and he remained there for his entire life. This is not happening, because name has been evacuated. But u unfortunately, all of us have a 43 chance of developing cancer in our lifetime. And if that child remained in that heavily contaminated city his entire lifetime, his risk would increase from 43 to 44 . Where on earth do you get that who report . Who, world health organization, has an unholy contract with the Atomic Energy agency, and theyre not allowed to report or investigate any atomic accidents unless they agree. Is that true, dr. Gale . I think its preposterous. Its not preposterous, its the truth. The experts on the committee. Many are pro nuclear. Im not pro or antinuclear. Youre a physician. Im going to hit the pause button here because we have to get to break. As we mentioned, thousands of people have left the exclusion zone, but some stay behind and refuse to leave their homes, and one of them is a farmer who once supplied peat to tokyos finest restaurants. He refuses to slaughter his cattle and hes making his farm a living protest against nuclear power. [ speaking japanese ] and the question from our community, as the farmer just mentioned, if people want to know how relevant it is to them, we want to know how relevant it is around the globe. How much radiation families have been exposed to, and what it means to you and your eating habits as radiation pours into the pacific ocean. [ speaking japanese ] welcome back, and were talking about fukushima, and its fall out nearly three years after the tsunami, and the meltdown. Soon we wont be able to eat fish caught off of the west coast because the radioactive waste is making its way to us in the west. And anybody eating seafood will have the same problems. This is an ecological disaster. 400 tons of radiated water in the ocean, and starfish with drying, and chernobyl is the living proof that the pacific is being poisoned. There are reports that fish like tuna and salmon are being contaminated by fukushima and is that the case . Do people need to be concerned about what theyre eating in. What happens is that 400 tons of radioactive water have poured into the pacific every day since the accident. And the pacific is a huge body of water, but people need to know that the biological food chain reconcentrates the radioactive elements. The algae, and the crustations that eat the algae and more in the big fish and we humans stand at the apex of the food chain, so they concentrate most highly in our bodies, so even though the radiation in the water are not going to be reaching a high, we have to worry about the fish, and the epa and the fda are not testing the fish at this time. They should be routinely tested. And its going to hit the west coast north, oregon and washington state, early next year, and then it will hit california later in the year, but you must not eat any food from japan. A lot of the food is radioactive, and theyre actually selling fukushima rice and the like around the world at the moment. So you have to be very careful about what you eat. Youre the cofounder of the network of saving children from radiation, and one of the reasons that we brought you on the program and the lengths that youre going to to keep kids safe. We found the first case of Thyroid Cancer last august, in 2012, and now its raised to 44 children having Thyroid Cancer, and its increasing. The next Health Management studies will be released on the 12th, next week. And well, the thing im a mother, and mothers are very very confused. They dont rely on the Health Management result. They dont trust the information theyre getting from the government . So they take them to see other doctors, for a Second Opinion. Initially, they couldnt get a Second Opinion and now they can, and they find different results. Today, as a matter of fact, fukushima medical university, who has been conducting Health Monitoring survey, announced, and made an official pop gee that they have been made 390 errors in Health Management as a result. I have a copy of that. That was last september, 2012, so this result is not reliable. Now, ncrp, thats national consult on radiation protection, and the lead of the Health Management survey team, made a keynote speech last march. He is the one who tells fukushima people, mothers, children, are safe. You can go outside and play. And you can eat food. Now, at this conference, in maryland in march, he said, well, this is the lifetime survey for 2 Million People of fukushima people. And the target is pregnant women and children. And its about the low dose radiation effects. Dr. Gale, i want you to jump in here, and talk about the results that margo is speaking on, the National Error rates on these things. Let me just say that i spent two years in the soviet union, dealing with the chernobyl accident, and i spent the last two years living in japan, dealing with the fukushima accident. The fukushima accident is tragic for a variety of reasons. The cleanup costs, 100 billion. There have been 135,000 people displaced, from a social point of view, from an economic point of view, from an environmental point of view, its tragic, and its very sad. But you know, theres a huge confusion here over what the medical consequences are going to be. Now, according to dr. Caldecott, theres a huge conspiracy of the National Academy of science, the world health organization, and theres not a single credible scientist, knowledgeable about radiation biology, who is expecting any longterm, direct radiation consequences of the fukushima accident. Now, its very unlikely that everyone is involved in a conspiracy, and all of us are wrong. Im only talking about people who are in the who, iae and the new york doctors did a sterling job of publishing the reports of 5,000 papers written in russian, and condensed into a report of whats happening in russia, and what that study showed, and its an extremely important medical study. It should be read by all of our colleagues. 2 Million People have died already as a result of chernobyl. And if you ex strap late that to fukushima, its very very serious, and they have discredited their own report because of pressure from pro nuclear people within the new york academy of science. We have to go to break. Well pick it up in 2 minutes. Were talking about fukushima, and three years after it happened and the impact on japan and the implications for the rest of the world. And margo, you had a question for dr. Gale. After extensive study of fukushima, you said theres only going to be a 0. 22 chance of risk in the japanese population in the future, and at the same time, you said you made an incorrect prediction about the number of chernobyl victims. I guess i dont know what all of the firefighters that were injured at chernobyl are patients of mine. I treated them, and i just returned from moscow two nights ago. I brought my family to kiev about two weeks after the accident, and in just the notion that [ talking at the same time ] 2 . The notion that 1 Million People died from chernobyl is just so incredulous. Im there every month or two, and i am treating these are my patients, and so im treating them. And i dont know where anyone could possibly think that 1 Million People. We have lost very sadly 31 people. Only 31, thats not right. Have you read the new york academy of sciences report of all of the pages in russian that were translated into english by very eminent russian scientists and physicians and biologists. Have you read that . As you know, the new york academy of science has put on its website a notation that these are papers that were not reviewed and they have discredited it. They were reviewed by the russians and not by well paid western society. We can talk about papers all night and its incredibly interesting, but i want to get back to what do People Living in fukushima and around the globe, and i want to know from both of you, what do people need to know today about the dangers of fukushima . As i said, the people are not going to be allowed to go in any area that poses a substantial risk, and im up there all the time. We are overall cautious in allowing people to go there. But we should always be careful about radiation, but just remember that if you get a ct scan, if you insist that your child get a ct scan in the emergency room because he has a seizure. Hes going to get a dose of radiation thats 100 or 1,000 times greater than anyone got from fukushima thats not one of the workers. Youre right about ct scans, very high doses, and we use them too discriminately. But were talking about external radiation exposures, and youre not talking about food and emitters that are concentrated in various organs of the body, in endocrine glands, and the cardiac muscle and i could go on and on. The radiation in the food. Dr. Caldecott, the world needs to come together and start making big zigs about fukushima. Its not japans decision. And i want to give you an example. Most dangerous situation. Today, actually, there were going to start to remove those but they stopped it by a Nuclear Authority chairperson. Because he knows, and everyone is aware that that is more dangerous than contaminated water even. So think about the situation that children have to live there, people have to live there. And they were told that its safe to live there, its all going, and i really want to tell the children of fukushima, get out. Its not for humans to live. And they have future, and if we dont stop this, we failed chernobyl, and many places, and its going to happen to other places and to your child and our future children. Thank you to all of our guests. Good evening everyone. Welcome to Al Jazeera America im joie che John Siegenthaler w york. Iran nuclear talks. The secretary of state says no deal. Battered by the storm. People in parts of the philippines are trying to add up the damage to win o one of the t powerful typhoons on record. You cant show you are hurt, you cant show you are in pain. That is what i mean by the culture of the n. F. L. What is taoue what we have to change. The mentality that led to the leagues bullying