Please be advised that the ringing and use of all cell phones, pagers and similar sound producing Electronic Devices are prohibited at this meeting. Please be advised that the chair may order the removal from the meeting room of my person responsible for the ringing or use of a cell phone, pager or other similar sound producing Electronic Devices. Please be advised that a member of the public has up to three minutes to make pertinent Public Comment on each agenda item unless the Port Commission adopts a shorter period on any time. Item 8, Public Comment on items not listed in the agenda. Is there any Public Comment . Seeing none. Item 9, executive directors report. Good afternoon, president brandon, rise president adams, commissioner woo ho. I am elaine forbes, and i am the ports executive director. First i would like to congratulate the hit toric pier 70 and the historic pier 70 and the orton project. On march 7th at 8 30, they will receive an award honoring their outstanding contribution and other outstanding winners. Id like to explain why they won this award. The award rationale is despite challenges, historic constraints, environmental and structural challenges, a complex capital stack, tax credits, these buildings were historically renovated and successfully leased, and they have served as a catalyst for the reextremity of the larger site. These revenues have been put back into rehabilitation for the port of San Francisco. These proud structures inaccessible to the public since their original construction can now be viewed, experienced, and appreciated by future generations. So congratulations to Orton Development, eddie orton, to plant construction, to the port team led by phil williamson, and i believe we have a representative from Orton Development here. Yes, hello. I think this is mr. Mora, would you like to say a word to the Port Commission . Youre not obliged to, sir. Come to the microphone, please. Hello, everyone. My name is everardo maora, andi thank you for this opportunity to stand before you and also for the opportunity to bring these buildings back to the community. Restoring them was a very meaningful, difficult project for us, and were happy to be on the final stretch with them. We also look forward to coming back within about two months once we finalize the project to give you an update on where the project stands overall, and we look forward to future opportunities on the waterfront. And just, you know, just want to really, really give a big thank you to the port staff at all levels, the port engineering department, the Environmental Review department, historic department, they all had an incredibly important part of our success, so thank you very much. Thank you so much. Congratulations, and thank y you. Thank you. Were extremely proud of this project. Id also like to update you on the status of mission rock. Since the Port Commission approved the transaction documents and accepted ceqa findings just at our last Commission Hearing on january 30th, the project team has been extremely busy. Last monday, on the 5th of february , the board of supervisors land use and Transportation Committee recommended the project to the full board of supervisors. They acknowledged the projects many public benefits. On tuesday, the next day, the 6th of february , the sfmta board approved the project Development Agreement and interagency cooperation agreement, complimenting the team on its careful approach to right sizing the future parking structure. The following day, the 7th, our team, led by rebecca benecini, and for the giants, fran wells, appeared before the budget over Sight Committee to explain the plans structure, and they approved the plan to the full board of supervisors. Yesterday, they received a positive recommendation on the projects financing mechanisms, which is vitally important to the projects success, and the project was forwarded to the full board with a recommendation today, cu culminating from 11 years of thoughtful presence and efforts, and thanks to a purposeful and thoughtful discretion of the board commission, the project is before the board of supervisors to hear the final approval. At the second the boreds second hearing, the project will occur on final read on the 23rd of february , and then, mayor farrell will have ten days to sign the transaction documents. The team is currently working with state Land Commission to explain the structure in a Firm Compliance with state legislation, leading to an april request for state Lands Commission approval. In may, my team anticipates approval of a major approval from bcbc for the projects permanent open space plan, and in october, we anticipate initial site work to commence, so were very busy and pleased with the progress weve made just since your last hearing. This room is going to get an audiovisual upgrade. After dealing with equipment that was put in in the late 80s, i believe, its time for an improvement. The upgrade will occur from february 26th through march 30th. The modernization will improve the quality and consistency of sound and the video experience in this space. It will also improve what the viewers see on channel 26, and the recording quality of the meeting for the public. Well also now have high speed wifi in the room, which will be a nice upgrade. During the upgrade project, were going to be relocating to pier 1 for our Port Commission hearing, and that means for the meeting on february 21st, march 13th, and march 27th, we will be in the bay side rooms at pier 1. We look forward to reconvening the Commission Meeting with full services here in april, and id like to thank all for skillfully overseeing the project, and that concludes my report. Thank you. Thank you. 9d . Oh, im sorry, any Public Comment on the executive directors report. No . 9d, Port Commissioners report. Commissioners, anything to report . Commissioner adams . Vice president adams first of all, i just want to say to our president brandon, it was an honor to attend your 20th anniversary on the San Francisco Port Commission, madam president , and a special howd o shout out to renee, to make that a very, very historical evening. For me, it was historical in the sense that this being black history month, and president brandons contribution to this community, and to see her friends and family. Corrine spoke, jack blair from the giants spoke, mayor brown, and then kims partner in life, mimi, and it was just an honor to be a part of that, so thank you so much for allowing me to be there and playing such a small part. And also, i would just like to say that madam president , when you get done speaking, could we have a moment of silence for madam secretary amy posadas mother who passed away . Thank you. Thank you. I, too, thank elaine and renee and all the port staff that had anything to do with the event last week. It was it was just so magical and memorable and just such an honor, and im just so humbled and thankful to have been able to take this journey with all of you for so long, so yes. In i really want to thank everybody. It was just a great event, and sorry that everybody couldnt attend. And i would like to take a moment of go ahead. No, i was just going to before you spoke, i was just going to say congratulations, not only on the event, but on which, unfortunately, i had a prior commitment, so i came at the tail end, and people were still having a great time and talking about how wonderful it was. But really, just congratulations on 20 years. That is, i think, extraordinary in terms of the amount of dedication and commitment that youve given to the port and the city of San Francisco, so just really want to thank you for your commitment to Public Service and service to the port and really just take a moment to reflect on how significant it is for somebody to give 20 years of service to a Commission Like this. Its no easy feat while carrying on all of your other Community Activities as well, but i guess it just goes to show, if you want something done, ask a busy person. Congratulations on 20 wonderful years, and perhaps 20 more. Thank you. Id just like to add, i think that everything should be said has been said, but just add my own personal congratulations. I remember kim when she came on the commission, she was really helpful to explain because she had the history, she had the knowledge, and she had the culture, and shes very persistent, so i have a tremendous amount of respect for what she has done and contributed for the commission, for her community, and for each one of us, and so its very appropriate that she also gets to celebrate this anniversary as she is president this year, so congratulation again. Thank you. Now, can we have a moment of silence for amys mother. Thank you. Items on consent, 10a, request approval for a member of the Port Commission to travel with port staff to attend the sea trade cruise global conference on march 5th through t8th, 2018 in fort lauderdale, florida. 10b, request approval for the Port Commission to travel to [ inaudible ] 10c, request approval for the port of San Francisco drone policy relating to the ports use of drones on port property pursuant to the city and county of San Franciscos citywide employee drone policy, adopted by the citys committee on information technology. May i have a motion . So moved. Second. Is there any Public Comment on items 11, 12, or 13 . Seeing none, all in favor . Any opposed . Resolutions 1811, 12, and 13 have been approved. Item 11a, informational presentation on the ports fiscal year 2018 through 2019 and 2019 through 2020 biennial operating budget. Good afternoon, im megan wallace, the ports manager, and im here today to present on the proposed fiscal year 201819 and 1920 budget. Today, ill really be focusing primarily on the operating budget, as our capital manager, anonda hirsch, will be presenting on the Capital Budget shortly after me. I also just want to note just putting together any budget is really a team effort, and i particularly want to thank tar anavarro and mayrilyn yates frm the real estate and maritime division. Margaret doyle, shes supported me, and its been an amazing experience, as well. So i guess, you know, just really quicking it o really kicking it off, the mayor office and staff do a rigorous review of the citys economic and fiscal outlooks, and what weve been seeing weve been on a really long growth period for our local economy, and were starting to get warning signs, so we need to be more conservative in our opening outlooks, and that is also being paired with, as youre familiar with the ongoing story of growing personnel in expenses, those two drivers are really putting a real squeeze on the citys general fund, and while we arent a general Fund Department and arent being held to the same requirement of cutting our budget, we are being held to control our personnel growth, given thats one of the key drivers of ongoing growth within our budget. So heading into the ports budget process, we really did try to take a fiscally prudent approach of controlling our expenses. You are going to see were recommending strategic increase increases. In terms of managing personnel, were asking more along the lines of substitution of existing staff, so we are not seeing growth in our ongoing support, but we are requesting a good number of funding positions, and theyre contingent upon project funds. So we really held to the budget instructions, and i think that overall, were managing trying to repair our budget for a potential downturn moving into the next two fiscal years. I think one great thing about the budget is it really is making policies, putting its putting our money where our mouths are in terms of our strategic objectives, and its really important that we look and make sure that we are investing in the areas that we want to see ourselves grow and improve in, and so when it comes to sustainablity, resiliency, also economic vitality, we are making some key changes within the structure of the department by consolidating real estate and Development Together so that we can have more a strategic approach to those leasing initiatives. We do have a new chief Operations Office to try to coordinate efforts between divisions more effectively, and really, just all of these efforts do improve the Overall Economic vitality along the waterfront and in San Francisco, we believe. But i think really the key focus for the budget, you would tend to lead to, is stability, and weve continued to really stick to our policies of we have a 15 operating reserve requirement to protect us in an economic downturn or other y uncertainties. We do meet or capital policy requirements, and as youll see in this presentation, as well as in the capital presentation, we really are making an effort to invest in our facilities to stablize our revenues into the future. So getting into the details of the budget, first, im going to start with sources, and not to site a bunch of numbers, i think it is important to note that the fiscal budget for 1819 is 192. 6 million, and this is compromised of approximately 160 million of ongoing sources and 32. 8 million from onetime sources, and this is a 46 million increase over yauall, really driven by fund sources and other things that werent in the prior budget. For fiscal year 1920, the budget is 161. 3 million. Thats a 31. 3 million decrease from the proposed 1819 budget, and thats because youll see that our Capital Program tends to be sort of lumpy, that were spending down accumulated finances from Previous Year in the first year of the budget. Were requesting general fund support in the first year of the budget, and so in the second year, you see a drop in those sources. And its important to note the ongoing sources primarily support our operation, so we really look to obtain Funding Sources to keep that going. So these pie charts show total funding over the twoyear proposed budget. As you can see, the largest source really are our operating revenues. Fund balance is the next largest source. Just quickly to note, fund balance supports or Capital Program and its the source for our operating reserve, but for our operating fund, that biggest piece, its mostly compromised of commercial and industrial rents from our 500 someodd leases along the waterfront, parking, and then our various maritime business lines that each contribute about 20 of ourov overall revenue operating revenue. I do want to mention were missing a familiar business name on the maritime line. This does not reflect ship repair. As you know our shipyard is currently closed, and we did not assume any funds in this line for the proposed budget. I yes. Do you mind. I know you didnt assume any on this line. Are you projecting out not seeing any revenue as we have to do some repair on that, as well. Yeah. I havent done a fiveyear outlook review. I think its time will tell . Ill look to our Deputy Director and see if hes like to be informed, but for budget services, we have not assumed anything. That would be an improvement if we get. Clerk s heading into the spring, its not too late to update the budget before we get it done before its approved through the board of supervisors, but for now were taking the conservative approach and not accounting for it. Thank you. So overall, you know, over the twoyear period, were looking for a net increase in revenues of only 2. 2 million. Thats significantly less than in prior years, and i think its important to note that the key drivers of that is actually some revenue lines that are pulling that growth down. Parking is one, as we see development coming in, were actually going to be taking some facilities offline. Some of them are shipping to commercialindustrial rent so that helps the growth on the commercialindustrial rent side, but overall, it does appear to be a reduction, but ship repair, cargo and cruise are all maritime lines, where weve either seen declines in business, such as in ship repair. Cruise, were adjusting our parking assumptions, and we are seeing some dips in passenger volume. Cargo, its important to note that our overall business is doing quite well, but we had to change the structure of how we budgeted for that business, so it appears that our revenues are going significantly down, but our but overall, its really just because we had to shift how were reflecting this revenue line. Our gross revenues continue to be very strong. And for the commercial industrial rents, i do want to note that while were being conservative on things like ship repair, were actually being fairly aggressive lion things like our projected less revenue, and thats really going to call on our staff to push and get these facilities ready for leasing and get them up and running with new tenants. And i think its important that we push ourselves. Were seeing some dips in our you know, some easing in our revenue growth, but i think bottom line, its important for our ongoing stability to knack suknack make sure that were getting these facilities leased. On the uses side, the again, the budget in the first year is 192. 6 million; in the second year, its 161. 3. And this is compromised of operating expenses, the Capital Budget, and our reserve. And you know, really just noting that while we are seeing growth on the operating expense side, we really did continue to make it a priority to make sure that were designating sufficient revenues to capital so that we are having ongoing support for our Capital Improvement program. So over the twoyear windows as these pie charts show, about half of our budget is actually invested in our operating expenses. The Capital Budget is 22 , and then, the Third Largest line is the designation of capital, as i mentioned, so thats really net revenues that were putting away for future Capital Budgets. And within operating expenses, you can see personnel compromised half of that budget, so thats why its so crucial to keep control of our expense line, and then as you can see other expenses are a major expense line. Again, in terms of trends, the real drivers here for growing costs, primarily salaries and inexpenses. We have very high insurance needs. Thats one of the key drivers of this growth. Director forbes has actually asked us to look into this and see if we can control growing costs in insurance in future budget years. But some good news is we do have some other current expenses that were actually able to reduce by the second year of the budget. [ please stand by ]. Instead of adding staff to help us deliver the work we need to get done, were asking for substitutions to meet our staff to rhea line our current needs to be able to deliver our work. We also have reassignments within the budget, and this is in part because were consolidating Development Staff into the real estate division, and were actually redistributing staff from the Operations Division that had been created. Were putting staff back into the original divisions that they had been located in. We are actually asking for some additional positions, but were actually going to offset those by an assumption of salary saving, so for every new position were putting in the budget, were assuming well have to hold a position vacant to offset it. And then, lastly, we are requesting 12 new project funded positions. Actually, ananda will talk about this in capital, but its for a budget management office, also for staff who can deliver our work products. We have a lot of staff needs that were requesting to staff up so we can make sure were getting through projecting, administering the project correctly, and things like that. And then lastly, the capital designation, i just want to highlight that again so were really making sure that were meeting our capital policy requirement. It is a significant portion of our budget, and as you can see here on this slide, since the school year 1415 when weve started to implement this strategy, weve seen Significant Growth in this designation, and even though that program can have its ups and downs, the one time sources have given us extra strong years in budgeting, all in all you can see were building up a sustainable source to make sure were funding our Capital Program. The next step, staff is actually requires to submit the budget to the Mayors Office next wednesday, on february 21st, thats before ill be back before you on february 27th, for formal approval. I do want to note that if you have any changes to the budget after weve submitted to the Mayors Office, well work with mayors staff to reflect those changes. Were just trying to follow city timeline requirements. And then, the mayor will submit the budget to the board in may, well go through, and we need to the city needs to formally approve the budget by july 31st, and in september, ill be back before you with a budget update to let you know what happened in all those months in between. So if you have any questions for me, im happy to answer, otherwise, we have other staff that are ready to help out as needed. Thank you. Is there any Public Comment on the budget . No Public Comment. Commissioner katz . Commissioner katz thank you so much, and as always, really fantastic presentation. It makes it easy when were prepping in advance and here, so i thank you for that. I have a couple questions that you may have answered, but one is i noticed in term its not a huge differential, but what has allowed us to decrease our funds on the South Beach Harbor and marina . Is that sort of getting where we want it to be . Is it sort of stablized and were now in a good operational place so we dont have to put as many funds into it . Well, i think part of what you might be seeing, if im looking at the overview table, is South Beach Harbor actually shows up in two places within the budget. On the uses side, its an operating expense. Theres 3. 7 million; and then in the Capital Budget, theres 1. 1 million. Right. So it looks like a decrease on the operating side, and maybe that does actually lead to your point, but there was about 300,000 more that we were able to allocate to the Capital Program, that we were trying to facilitate ground repairs to the harbor. It is selfsustaining, and were just trying to find ways, just as with the port harbor funds, were trying to create a similar structure for South Beach Harbor c. Commissioner katz and then, can you articulate a little bit more the general increase in funds. Actually, anana will go into more detail, but for the Capital Program, for the seawall, and for the Mission Bay Ferry Landing project. And then theres not a significant increase in our operating reserves. Does that keep it as a comfortable level, though. Yeah, its supposed to be 15 of our operating expenses, so weve been controlling those expenses, we havent seen Significant Growth year over year in the reserve requirement. And then going back to on the revenue side, right now, we are getting about 22 revenue from our parking, and im anticipating that change, but as we move forward, it seems its going to be incumbent on this to figure out how we adjust to this decreased revenue for a pretty significant period of time until we start seeing an increase from the projects coming in. Do you have any thoughts on that or what we should be looking to do to kind of adjust for that or just be aware of it . Skbl yeah. I think what we saw with the fiveyear Financial Plan is that a lot of these deal impact the parking increase the commercialindustrial rents. The best way to bridge that gap is to try to get the structure ideals to make sure were constructing rent as construction occurring, not just as we dont have a period of time where were not generating revenue from a site. Commissioner katz okay. Thank you. So i think weve taken that into account in most of the deals that weve been looking at, but are there any that are coming up, and i guess not that you have to address it now, but perhaps when it comes back to us, ask that we take that into account and be reminded, and something that we should be cognizant of as we go forward. Right. Commissioner katz and then really just sort of an openended question, that you would highlight us to be aware of as we go forward over the next couple of years. I think ultimately, the challenge for this budget is the demands on the port is growing. Were such a Diverse Department and we have so many needs that were trying to meet, yet were trying to control our costs. When i first started, i was gung ho, lets get so much money into capital, but yet to deliver our work, but i think we need to continue to conduct those trade offs of conducting operations but needing to deliver on capital, so if we start to see an economic downturn in our revenues due to declines, maybe we need to consider repriority the work were doing, but thatll be a citywide discussion. We have bigger problems are, i guess, if that comes up. Yes. Commissioner katz all right. Well, thank you very much. Appreciate it. Commissioner woo ho . Commissioner woo ho thank you. Obviously, i think youve put together a very detailed, and jennie learned were pretty conservative in terms of when we do budgets. In a separate conversation, id like to compare how weve done in the past versus our budget particularly on both revenue and expenses, but generally we do better. Id like to peel the oni on a little bit more and understand that theres some negative trends and downturn in the market that we think are going to negatively affect us in the negative couple of years. Does the city give you some assumptions so that every department use those same supgs assumptions and you translate those equally or try to in your particular budgets without having each one of you do your own subjective analysis, so thats question number one. I think the answer is yes, the city does give guidance to the Controllers Office in particular. So how do they translate . What do they tell you . Well, i think personnel is the most complicated because when it comes to salaries and fringe benefits. Thats a negative of saying you either keep your salaries either flat or your fte flat, but how do they translate what the impact of the economy is. What trends are they pointing to . Impact on the economy . Theyre not necessarily expenditure well, youre saying the economy is going to slow down. How does that translate to each enterprise departments or even that arent enterprise. Im just trying to understand how the citys budget process work. I understand how they say lets control personal expense. I understand that. Well, its a little trickier than the Controllers Office or the Mayors Office do not give us instructions on how to project our revenues, but we as a department are structured we right lane to look at [ inaudible ] we are very well commissioner woo ho so we try to look at the negative trends, for instance, you just mentioned a couple, but do we assume know that vacancy rates are going up, our rates increased are slowing down. What are some of the assumptions . Oh, i would need to turn to tara navarro. Commissioner woo ho i dont need to know all the specific numbers, but i just want to know what are you considering when you say theres a slow down. Vacancies going up, rents are slower, Less Properties coming up for renewals. I think the proper way we see it in our budget [ inaudible ] in recent years to show that in the fiveyear Financial Plan, for example, our percentage rents were very strong, but now, in the last year, were seeing them ease a bit, and so our commissioner woo ho so were assuming our tenants are not going to do as well on the revenue side. So what are we saying . That theyre not going to be participating in the sales side, but we havent obviously heard specifically from them, but were just projecting on their behalf. Thats right, yeah. And i would just say that were projecting theyre not going to do as well as theyve done in prior years, so were not saying that theyre not going to be growing, its just that commissioner woo ho their rate of growth is slower. Yeah. And tyrone, you can add more to that. In terms of what the city provides us, the, we convene an economic summit for all the city staff in that year. In that forum, its a halfday session, they bring in experts from tourism, hotel, office, and all the sectors of the economy to discuss what kinds of trends theyre seeing, and that really does help the finance staff align what were seeing at the Department Level with the larger city trend, so that is one form that we get revenue projection advice, but in terms of this budget here, tyrone, you can add more in the real estate portfolio. The maritime portfolio is very stable, because we actually know how many cruise ships are coming in, and cargo, as megan said, weve redone how we put the revenue and expense. The cargo volume is actually on the rise. So theres a range from projection to very, very dill tailed information that causes us to know almost to the dollar what we will receive. So the real estate side i can understand what you mentioned. With the maritime side, were struggling with whats going to happen with ship building, and whether we can get a tenant, and on the cruise ship side, it seems like the special events are lower. Were not seeing as much cruise ship volume come in because it is booked in advance. Im just wondering what other besides this budget, should we be doing a Strategic Review of what our Maritime View should be in these longer terms of business. I think we have something to address that is not just budgetary for the next two years, but something strategically that is important. I think youve got youve got the south beach marina, youve got the cruising, the special events, youve got the ship building, and missing one. Harbor services. Harbor services. Weve always known that its a hodgepodge of things, but i think we should be rethinking our maritime strategies. Its supposed to be a priority of this port, and we want to make sure that were not just swimming upstream. It is absolutely a priority, and ive already been speaking to our chief operating officer about the cruise strategy and how the port can grow in cruise. We know well be receiving bigger ships, but where are our berths to welcome bigger ships, and i think it would be something great to put on the calendar so you can hear some of our bigger thinking on how to grow in the cruise business and also to stablize the business that we have. We know cruise is cyclical, and when there is a recession, definitely, cruise declines, but we want to stablize a certain volume of trips to San Francisco, so we can ensure a profit to our cruise investment in pier 27, so i think it would be excellent to come back and talk specifically about cruise strategy, its something staff is working on. Im sorry, and the other one was cargo, because we had these conversations with pascha and dmw. If theres offsets, we should understand where that all fits into this. I guess im used to, in the corporate world, you do your budget, but you have risks and opportunities, and you show what the sensitivity and analysis of what could hurt you, because some circumstances are beyond your control, as you mentioned, the market conditions, but others are opportunities that you dont want to book because youre not sure, but you want to know that youre on top of them. It would be nice to know what the opportunities are besides just the submitting in the formal budget. I understand thats a requirement we have to do, and were always conservative. Were never going to stretch too far. Thats my experience in looking at these budgets for five years, because every time we look at the actuals, we do better; and even on the expense side, thats the other thing where i said at some point, not in this meeting, we have a Historical Perspective of the trend line that were seeing over the last five years so were seeing the trends of the organization and how it plays out, and not what we think is going to happen. We only hear what is going to happen, not what is actually happening. I think on the personal expense, i know you mentioned, you know, the project management office, and i can understand the need for that. I think in the past weve also talked a lot about and i dont know whether this is a factor in this years budget, Employee Benefits keep going up for the city of San Francisco. Is that an issue for us in terms of the Employee Benefit ratio and, you know, is that also whats causing personal expenses to go up a lot . Its very much whats driving. Does the health care cost, pension cost, etcetera, thats another factor there, so its more than just adding head count . Thats correct. So by maintaining our head count, even with our existing head count, were seeing expenses grow because or pensions need to be you know were trying the citywide goal on funding pensions needs to be you know, needs to be met. Even the unfunded pension liability has been incompetent creased and at some point, you need to do something about it. And Health Care Costs is something were all familiar with, so these things are being incorporated into our existing employee expenses, and so in that regard, citywide, everybody is being asked to try to solve many of these well, the Mayors Office look at the whole picture and figure out what to do, because its not something you as a department can figure out about pension and Health Care Costs. There has to be a plan citywide to figure out how to reduce growth. What you presented is all very, very reasonable and understandable, but we have to put it in the bigger landscape of where were headed. Since were concerned about having enough money for the Capital Budget, and now youre saying youre a little concerned about the operating budget, yet for the first time weve hit over 100 million in revenue. A few years ago, it wasnt that big of an issue when elaine was the ceo, but now its an issue. I hope we keep looking for nuggets. I do want to add that the commercial and industrial rents, you have a very strong optimistic place holder for future leases that we dont yet have. Theres about 5 million of revenue that were assuming there for facilities that have not yet been filled, so those are opportunities that that create a net revenue in our budget, so its designated to capital. If they dont come through, it means less money to capital, but we want to be optimistic to set those goals and have targets for ourselves. So i know the Orton Development has some timelines, not been as fast as we would like, but as i recall way bockmanny years, when we presented, it should start to generate revenue. Where is that in this budget . Is orton a contributor at all . Its not a contributor yet. Okay. And if this timeline was i mean, two years weve been at it for how many years now. Were going to get an update in march from Orton Development, as our guest today said, and i know their revenue projections are stronger than what weve seen in the past. Okay. [ inaudible ] thats something that we should be keeping our eye on. Yes. Okay. Okay. I rest. Commissioner adams . Vice president adams well, i really appreciate the interaction between the commissioners. I have a different point of view on this first of all, i think your prevention, very calm, and i like people that speak that dont say uh, uh, uh. Clearly, you know what youre talking about. Clearly, the port is going through some changes, and i think we seem to be adjusting with that. You can kind of see whats happening with the stock market, and what comes up is definitely going to come down. I like some things you can be conservative, other things, you can be a little bit more out there. And i just wanted to say to commissioner woo ho, this is just my humble opinion. Corporation, they answer to their shareholders. Port, our shareholders are the public, so its a totally different concept, and i just wanted to throw it out, thats how i see things. And then, the maritime aspect, clearly pasha hasnt grown as fast, but i think theres a plan in place, and i think a week ago, two weeksing, president brandon and director forbes, we met to discuss that. I think it takes time for us to get to where we really need to go, and i think its continuing to grow. I know i will be going with the port staff, metro will be there, and i know local ten, we will be down in florida here at the sea trade conference, meeting with the ceos of the cruise ship companies, trying to promote San Francisco as the number one destination on the west coast, so we have to continue to do that, and thats a thing that i think is a work in progress. I think we keep working on it. I think pasha, theyre still out, trying to get customers. I think we got good news with hanson and others, so i think its going to take a little time, and i think we have to be kind of patient. I think we have to have a very, very really, like, coming to jesus meeting about the shipyard. The way we know the shipyard as it was in the past is going to be different, lets just face that. When we sent out the last rfp, we had one bidder put in, okay . We know that. There may be a change the way we do things around here. That is okay, but weve got to figure out what will work. But you know what . We regrouped. The port staff, they thought about it, they put their heads together, and theyll try again. I dont know what its going to look like. I agree with you, commissioner woo ho, but weve got to find something that works. The ship repair is to competitive with all the other places that are doing it that are in the same business, and its if you really think about it, portland took 60, 70 of our work. So what did we do and i dont believe in living in the past. I believe sometime you cut your losses, you look to the future, and we find out what may have to go there. It may be ship repair, it may be something else, but i think we can get some revenue. I think this is a good plan, laying it out there. I think we got some work to do, but i truly believe that a port runs so different than a corporation, and as i say, the shareholders of the port is the public, and none of these commissioners up here, we dont get shares like a corporation do, so its totally run totally different, and this is what i do every day, dealing with all the west coast ports for the last 40 years of my life, so i clearly understand how that runs, but i do understand commissioner woo hos concern. I think well continue talking about maritime, i think well keep going at it, but also, i think theres a lot of facets to this. I think this is a good report. I think as we move along on it, and we make some adjustments, i think one of the hardest things that i see is seem to be getting staff hired. Bureaucracy is tough. I mean, i cant even imagine that, and the commissioners, we come to a Commission Meeting maybe twice a month, but were not down in the trenches every day like the port staff and the executive director, so i think theres some great work. Im speaking just how i see it, and keep on doing what youre doing and take all the commissioners feedback, what they think, and keep moving forward, but i appreciate the report. Thank you. Yeah, i have to Say Something in response. Okay. Thats fine, but commissioner katz has to speak first. Commissioner katz i forgot one issue. You sort of touched on it with commissioner woo hos questions, but id just like to ask executive director forbes to put something on our future calendar to further address whats happening with some of the dip in revenue from the cruise ships, and if we could take a look at how we might increase that revenue. Im not sure if its necessarinecessary tied to Economic Issues or we can subsequently increase more calls to the port but i think we need to definitely take a look at it. Commissioner woo ho i think commissioner adams took my remarks in the wrong context. I have no problems with this budget, and i think you should be submitting this with a lot of quality work. I think from my perspective as a commissioner, i do take, and i do understand our shareholders is the public, and our job as a commissioner is to obviously do the best job for the shareholder and the city, so the things that i say are not meant to be critical of the port staff or the port. Theyre meant to be constructive, to say here are some things we should be looking at, and i think sometimes we are not mired in the daytoday. We helicopter in twice a month, which has its advantages and disadvantages. My comments are not to put you on the defense at all. If anything, its to make the port go on the offense, on the opportunities. I want i think elaine understanding that, but i have to go on the record and say thats how my comments i feel very strongly about my responsibility to the public, and i am not looking through the typical shareholder response. Thats one of the things ive learned as being a commissioner on a Public Service board is how you do have to take your community and your constituents which are so diverse and different into consideration, and all the things we do for the community which is very different in a corporate environment, so i appreciate that, and ive learned a lot about it over time. So i want to say that just for the record, because it was not criticism. I do think your budget is fine, but i do think theres opportunities to look at it, and i think we would be remiss not to take a look at those opportunities and to figure out what we could be doing Going Forward and to understand them better. Commissioner woo ho, i didnt take it in that tone. What i was saying was understanding the port you use the word corporation sometimes, and what i was just saying is a port runs so different than a corporation, and i understand your expertise in that, and i dont come from the corporate world, so i was just making a reference that the public is our shareholders and our community, and the commission here, were shareholders. We dont get paid, and we have a responsibility to make sure all this is upheld, so i appreciate your comments. Were aligned, so its okay. Yea. President Boston Marathon don was happy. Democracy in action. Megan, thank you so much for this report. I think its phenomenal that we have a record with a budget of 192,000. I think all of us should be extremely happy of this accomplishment. I do have to say that the way its presented, and i think that in the past, ive always beencau been accustomed to seeing a details report. Hopefully we can get that prior to the next time you bring the budget to us. But the way its laid out, it does look like we have issues with maritime, and that, you know, across the board, were losing money. And it is should be a point of consideration, and i do think that we do need to come even though i know all the work thats being put into it, and whats being done, and i know we cant we dont know know in advance what our port calls are going to be, but still, we need a strategy. We need a maritime strategy, and we have to look at all those revenues and at all our departments to see which ones were subsidizing and where we need to focus our efforts. Also, it was hard to understand 67 position changes without the details, so im really looking what each of the positions are. You know what the salaries are. We have a new what do you call it . Real Estate Development and planning and environment division. To understand how it all works together. We will work on what documents to prepare for next time. The city shifted to a new financial system. It is harder than in prior years to produce this detail. We will look at what we produced in last year and get more detail. I will say the position changes are all taking that Operations Division that executive director moyer created before she left and i chose not to execute. Creating the chief operating position merging planning with the environment and you will see how that looks and we can produce an Organization Chart as well to explain. Many of these changes have been in place since you appointed me executive director, but the budget is catching up to what i implemented some time ago. The changes within every division . There are cleanup changes within every division. We will show you what those are. Some of them are clarifications of positions individuals have sat on for some time based on the hr recommended classification and more technical matters. We will get the details. Any other question on