Mom and dad will probably live their entire lives on that facility in a pin whether its smaller or a larger size but theyre not themselves hence they are breeding stock they they typically dont come in the house and snuggle on the couch. They have no idea what life is is about because they spend 247 in a cage when you came into one of these puppy malls you would just see one on top of another in these Little Chicken wire crates. You know how cramped it is when youre when youre flying and i was thinking about and i thought it must be like that for the puppy dogs that are in these cages being able to get up and move around and i think thats the 740 sevens comedy 400 people and i thought its just like taking 400 golden traverse or labs or shepherds. And putting them in a scene strapping them in and making them live there for 8 years you will typically smell the facility before you actually walk near the cages and as soon as you can see the cages. I know its going to be a bad situation when you have the above ground wire bottom changes because that sort of tells us that the person is trying to be very efficient. This is a Business People are not for profit for an initial outlay of a couple 100. 00 for a few breeding pairs you can be selling puppies for a 1000. 00 or more apiece if you breed every heat cycle which is not what youre supposed to do but which many millers do you could be making tens of thousands of dollars within a couple of years they were housed in chicken coops one dog groups theres probably more dogs and chicken coops no these are their own chickens. They make money on dogs being born. They rarely see of that. Thats are expensive and expensive the met with cognitive problems as far as selling the dogs. Its not good its really not a good place for going to a. Night that i was on the internet and somehow something came over me and said i want a puppy so i googled these puppies online. Delivery person called me to set up a day and time out what time the dog would be arriving and he said you know i would like cash upon arrival. All i did check and that was fine so he would 1st wanted me to meet him at a rest stop off the new jersey turnpike. I just cut him off right there like that was not im not and that one day i think this is not happening. You know i know some things are right and that was one of them. Im not a nervous person im not scared of many things but i was nervous make children more inside and this guy was delivering a puppy 11 oclock at night in a van that reeked of cigarette smoke i said this is a street my house and i want to have a real address so he said thats fine ill call you on the street his restaurant it oclock east call and said he was running late and he showed up at 11 so it was very fast he called he was out front i ran outside a mystery and he got opened his it was a van he opened his van and there is our crates of dogs puppies in the back and he picked out rufus and he said heres your dog. 2 pieces of paper came with the dog that they looked like i could have printed off the computer but thats i didnt know any better so i just assumed it was fine. I brought the dog and it was late so i just put him play with him for a little bit but he was super tired and he just looked like he wanted to go to sleep so i put his bed in his crate and cry was really weird because when i had puppies before they cried in a crate the 1st time he didnt make a sound that was like the best dog every doesnt make noises perfect baby and i look up to a dog that was basically having seizures going to the bathroom and throwing up but there is going to die. In it that i you know is its only 24 hours but you buy that is a person you just feel super bad for its a baby in you just want to help it. He starts making this horrific sound like hes yelping in pain out of nowhere like just laying down just making this terrible sound off and on he said this isnt normal and then he threw up and had diarrhea and i said im going to take him to our family that. Im thinking that i cant believe that somebody was and this dog here that sec and this is all the money that were going to spend and this is crazy because i had no idea what to expect as they said they could stay there for days to get better and i was just i was worried about the money i was worried about the dog at the same time after spending 2 days at northstar parents being treated for hypoglycemia rufus was able to return home at the initial examination the veterinarian the care for rufus certified he was unfit for purchase rufuss crosscountry journey began in millers berg ohio on a farm owned by most troyer this is how i am after i buy the dog after he is delivered then i start googling most rare then is when i start and then i was like what was wrong with you why wouldnt i really thats how naive i was i thought it was going to be perfect and then then i start googling and i hindsight was like i need to find out where these parents are like i was disgusted less than 2 weeks before nicole purchased rufus on line tours u. S. D. A. License was cancelled currently no u. S. D. A. Or state commercial license is issued for this address ive got like giving up a couple times a day said no ones call me back this is so frustrating but then i kept thinking it wasnt about the money it was the fact that this was a life that no one cared about. They are just like oh take the puppy that was 6 weeks old 5 weeks old away from its mom and to shove it in a van with creeps stirrer and then called a day like no one cared. Of state highway 53. 00 in the middle of ohio this is a puppy mill not unlike the one that rufus was likely born and its where his parents will remain until theyre unable to produce the puppies and profits expected by the owner theres no Natural Light no human contact except for the red pickup that stops by wanted a discount or food in fill water bowls unregulated and under the radar. Was. Often we find that on the east coast that many of the puppies are coming from what we call ground 0 for large scale volume bring puppy mill breeding and thats Holmes County and it is really the heartbeat of where a lot of the puppy mills and a lot of the issues have started in the state of ohio when you consider that they have 43000 population and you have over 500 channels thats a lot of kennels for the number of people in that general area. And Holmes County alone and 200720088 was a 9000000. 00 business. Now when you consider that the average Family Income for a family of 4 is probably less than 30000. 00 in Holmes County thats a considerable amount of on production that is coming out of that particular area in amish country. Rufuss journey to new jersey is similar to the one thousands of puppies travel from Holmes County ohio in the years since rufus arrived at nicoles house and the driver has made multiple journeys to the east coast delivering puppies sold on the internet from puppy mills throughout Holmes County. Theres times where we here where the puppy was actually transported by someone just like john public and they load him into a vehicle and so when the puppies arrive its not unusual to have a vehicle full of puppies and some of those puppies are very sick and some wont make the trip whatsoever they assumed ban puppy mills places they always meant like the mall the puppy store in the mall or the puppy store the inside of st i just never thought that it was like on the internet i really thought when i bought rufus that he was in pennsylvania running through a field happy night didnt think it was a puppy mill dog at all. Pennsylvania farmers began breeding dogs probably about 30 or so years ago there were actually breeders in missouri who came up to pennsylvania specifically because of its large amish and mennonite farming communities here we had one of the worst states for puppy mills i we were called the puppy mill capital of the east and that was primarily because pennsylvanias number one industry is agriculture. And the mennonites are more likely to view these animals as cash crops as Agricultural Products weve heard that over and over again and i believe that to be true. Not all amish families or not all minimally families breed dogs but the large majority the overwhelming majority of the people that we deal with the breeders are from illinois it was something that farm families could do between when you harvest in the fall and when you plant the spring. As commercial kennels cropped up across pennsylvania in the late 1960 s. The welfare of the dogs trapped in puppy mills was not viewed as a priority of the Pennsylvania Department of agriculture inspections were few and far between the regulations were ill defined and the program was clearly underfunded so the regulators were completely tied by the laws and just the the van ness of all of them so what we really needed was in forcible measurable standards you would see inspection reports time and time again where a warden is morning operator to do something. And this didnt go on for like one or 2 inspections in a years time youre talking about years and years of warnings for many of the same offenses there was so much opposition from within the industry itself that the regulations were just going nowhere. And it became very apparent that we had to do a legislative fix. What politicians do. They put themselves on the line they did accept the reject. So when you want to be president. Or somehow want to. Have to go right to be close thats what the 43. 00 of them or cant be that. Interested always in the waters in the. First sitting. Up until recently politics were about policy preferences and ways to implement them that is not the case today your political views are now what define you as a person and there is a moral dimension bias against those who are not politically correct is the last acceptable form of discrimination this is the end of politics. My feeling with this world is right now is were so confused and fearful and this is a certain generation thats controlling all the Politics Around the world when that generation. Of children that are brought out of this movie really are less materialistic dont really care about these things dont even more automobiles want to live by the side want to ride a bicycle this movement is global and its going the world is going to house to go this direction and its going to change. Throughout the years efforts to improve the lives of dogs in pennsylvania puppy mills would ultimately die in the legislature at the hands of powerful lawmakers. It was not until a simple billboard was put up in Lancaster County that the general public began to learn of the problem our 1st billboard we did it look like a postcard and we had a family in our car and they were all waving across the top and yellow script just like a postcard and said welcome to cynic like mr county home to hundreds of puppy mills and we received over 3000 phone calls and emails in 2 days and the majority of those phone calls came from people who lived in Lancaster County who were thanked us for finally doing something about what their neighbors were doing i think the issue gained a lot of traction through the media you know more reporting on the issue it became sort of something that was that was out front it was no longer confined to you know what happened behind the party doors after witnessing the overwhelming response to their billboards in pennsylvania mainline Animal Rescue placed a new billboard this time Oprah Winfrey studio in chicago when we were on oprah and the aftermath we watched up here in the kennel i realized that it really didnt matter what the legislators wanted or what they didnt want because people started contacting us and people were horrified horrified by what was happening in Lancaster County or was happening in pennsylvania what was happening in missouri and oklahoma in nebraska and they couldnt believe that animals were being treated this way and they wanted to do something about it. This was 100 percent public effort it was really because people were hearing about the plight of puppy mills on the news on oprah reading about it in their newspapers going home and looking in the faces of these little pooches that are sharing their you know tables and beds for most of us and saying oh my gosh what if that had been my dog and it became very very personal to a huge number of people who started picking up the phones and calling their legislators through this whole struggle and it was a struggle and it was hard it was very very difficult i never lost sight of the fact that people have the power to change things and. When the legislature realized that they did not want to go home in an election cycle and face the constituency wondering why didnt you do something about this the bill got legs and this was a 2 year long is like 2 to 3 year long legislative battle in pennsylvania many of the dogs that the law was was pushed through many of the law the dogs that we wanted to protect are now dead so im hoping that its that the dogs the future dogs the dogs that are in these places in the future are helped by what weve done but most of the dogs the majority of the dogs that we wanted to help are gone now and they never got the relief that they deserve or that the law afforded. Only Union Boilermaker out of pittsburgh. Despite every free town life i have is basically in their own working and im working a 10 hour shift im working on saving dogs. Everybody has their own little parts and i think that was that was my call and you know go into the mills and thats what i want them to dogs so i know there are a lot of jobs are covered in your and theyre covering and theyve got fleas what id like to do is take them and hold a mint pad on to say theyre a bit touched a they ok so i mean i dont mind they got no room because i want to separate dead were different you know youre leaving that life and i want their you know the rehab to start as soon as we take the dogs. And its sad because you cant save all said it hurts i mean theres plenty of nights you stay up at night and you can sleep with a lot of rescues or you know deal with the puppy mill dogs know that i mean honestly you know its costly running through your mind to buy the dog you left behind like the one you know i went to the guys bringing the dogs out in there are so many dogs inside the puppy mill that when the dog started barking when he went in to get the dogs the side of the barn was actually shaking. Theres no force was good they suppose he this year and last year and kind of both pennsylvania and ohio made the laws better but they are they they passed the walls but no ones in force and. A lot of people think when you say rescue dogs from puppy mills i think we went in took the born down take the dogs but thats thats not good because the because mills are legal i think a lot of people dont understand that you know these puppy mills are legal theyre allowed to explain to him how you know we wait for the amish to contact you know then we set up a day when we can go get the dogs and then we know will load up the. Ours you know them will drive you know made on their property get the dogs. I mean. I dont know about. They said all that all that all they want is love to get into a. Room for an honor i mean. In my name is eugene deep ask well you know im the pennsylvania auditor general. We make sure all money is spent legally ineffectively but we also audit state programs so its not just a question whether the financial side of it is the you know the the account ledgers are matching up but also what is the effectiveness of the program so we get to go in and say ok the money might have been spent legally but was it spent effectively it was a program run effectively while inspections and prosecutions dramatically increased after the pennsylvania dog law came into force within a few years noticeable concerns began to emerge i started to receive reports confidentially from within department reaching out to me dog wardens administrators people who had worked for the department and had left veterinarian. Who were concerned that the new head of the office of dog law had no idea what she was doing so reviewing inspection reports and in 2011. Indicates that there were virtually no citations issued just like any other law its only as good as the enforcement of it and early on in in the law there were some concerns that it wasnt being enforced properly so and the audit of the dog or program began. In a scathing report under general di pascali found the dog law program from its introduction in 2008 through 2012 showed an intentional lack of enforcement of the states dog law and the commercial kennel canine health regulations. Enforcing the law in the can mean the partner agriculture said this during the audit the thing board enforcing it because they knew the kennels werent complying is say that again they were enforcing it because they knew the kennels werent complying but the goal of that was to get people not to do it the goal of the dog law was not to find champs it was to get kennels do improve the conditions in their facilities for for the animals thats the goal of the program and we were getting the troops ready to really make a huge deal out of the lack of enforcement of this berry popular law and all of a sudden there was a 180 of the department and they hired a director of enforcement who was one of the best dog wardens that weve ever seen but here is the the big big issue and its not just this its anything we do the People Matter who are running the programs and right now i think the Administration Made significant strides into who is running the program but the people that are actually running the program sometimes you know that there are a faceless bureaucrats to the general public and i understand that but the actual individual whos in charge matters and its important governors where they began. Mark radical republicans they not just put people in because of the considerations but also the qualifications of the individual but i do think that that is the case now that you are top notch professional there and that i think is a big reason why youre starting to see a turnaround in approach. While progress has been made the challenges of regulating and inspecting license to marshal breeders and finding unlicensed breeders in pennsylvania continues in the heart of Lancaster County millwood kennel aka millwood puppies provides a prime example of the bureaucratic shell game played by some large scale breeders. David and iommi stalls foods have been breeding dogs on their property in Lancaster County since the early 1990 s. Having obtained both the pennsylvania license and a u. S. D. A. Commercial breeders license from 2003 onwards pennsylvania inspection reports clearly indicate dogs were suffering in a facility that was not meeting even minimal welfare standards after a further string of her round us inspection reports in 2008 david voluntarily relinquished both his pennsylvania and u. S. D. A. License but the dogs remained at the same puppy mill though the name was changed to millwood puppies and ownership passed to davids son matthew stills foose matthew quickly obtained a u. S. D. A. Commercial breeders license at the same address. Immediately the violations continued under the new license when millwood puppies was inspected in october 2009 the violations were so severe that the commonwealth of pennsylvania brought multiple charges against matthew for violations under the dog law. Before pennsylvania district judge isaac stalls foose all charges against matthew were summarily withdrawn and all cases closed in 2010. At no time with the dogs removed from the facility by either state or federal authorities. Around this time matthew found a new very lucrative avenue to sell his puppies the internet since 2010 its estimated that matthew has sold over 3000. 00 puppies online ranging from 3022800 dollars each in 2013 alone millwood puppy sold 472 dogs more than a dog a day during this period matthew maintained a pennsylvania kennel license but in january 2014 he applied for a new u. S. D. A. Commercial breeders license for millwood puppies l l c this was the 3rd u. S. D. A. Commercial breeders license and the 2nd pennsylvania license issued for this one address in the past 8 years i think one of the most remarkable things that we actually were able to illustrate on the oprah show that one of the dogs that we picked up from know what chemicals. It was either know what kind of timer millward puppies was a yellow of a male you know a lab and ill never forget hes a really beautiful dog but he had never been off water for it its a beautiful beautiful yellow and the amish breeder if you stop astride the dog government we put take the dog up and put a dog in a bit and we put the dog down on the solid floor and in the lobby he started to walk like he had never been here ever going to south or again he started walking up the wall he tried to walk up the wall of our lobby because he had never been solid before and its just amazing to me that they would expect an animal to live in his or her entire life a wire flooring and they wouldnt do it themselves. Matthews large scale puppy breeding business was not his only interaction with the u. S. D. A. During the same time period he was receiving farm subsidies from the u. S. D. A. The total 56624. 00 in commodity subsidies associated with. His dairy farm Lancaster County pennsylvania has a total population of a little over 536000 residents from 1995 to 2012 farmers in the county have received 100 28000000. 00 in taxpayer funded farm subsidies from the u. S. D. A. An extensive investigation for this film found numerous examples of u. S. D. A. License commercial breeders receiving multiple violations from the Animal Health of vision on one hand and large taxpayer funded farm subsidies on the other while the programs are viewed as distinct and separate by the u. S. D. A. The fact remains that license commercial breeders with multiple dog welfare violations continue to receive taxpayer funded farm subsidies in Lancaster County and many other rural areas throughout the United States these commercial breeders are exploiting a federal agency by receiving a taxpayer funded handout while simultaneously receiving major violations for failing the dogs in their care. In this community there are people who believe that its ok to sell crack its really hard there are no jobs and you see the kids that ask and as a pair. I can come up with an argument theres a lot of conflict in the game between the cost of the conflict i would say overall is around money and most of that money is made. Close one on each others. Each other this could be just the state of california alone makes 6000000000. 00 a year of prison couplets just to get some point in your life where. You dont care and cares about your so you dont care about anything. Ok in the special something we can thank you susan for the men of the. Book to. The but also. You talked a whole doping in russia i think was over for get it. Through your complete but im sure we have the last real summer as a model so that is. Russian outlets eligibility for the International Competition says that stake this includes events like the Tokyo Olympics and the fifa world cup in qatar if i am in the early as last. Year when you come in you know just as it was 4 years ago in moscow antidoping plavix at the center of the scandal so who tampered with the duping samples database and one does greegor you have to do with it i knew. It was dr paul mean you could. Use the push on the wish. To expose me on the sometimes a little bit so the pull of. Germany expels to Russian Embassy staffers in berlin saying that there is quote sufficient evidence to link russia or chechnya to the murder of a Georgian National moscow denies any state involvement. As nato celebrations come to an end for its 70th birthday in the u. K. Member states in the alliance a struggle to find common ground. And donald trump labels the new House Intelligence Committee report on his impeachment a joke but u. S. Democrats believe the document may be enough to pin the president. Coming on his hero next hour with a full update on todays top stories crosstalk is by the way in just a minute stay with us