Transcripts For MSNBC Morning Joe Weekend 20241007

Joe weekend. It it was another fast moving newsweek. Here are some of the conversations you might have missed. The first line of Jack Smiths 165page filing the Defendant Donaldel Donald trump he is immuned from prosecution for his criminal scheme to overturn the 2020 president ial election because he claims it entailed official conduct. Not so. And he goes onto explain why. The special council making case and piercing the supreme Court Decision and we are looking at Jack Smiths Election interference case. A Judge unsealed the filing in response to the supreme Court Ruling on president ial immunity. Smith argues trump was not acting as President Of The United States when he sought to overturn his 2020 election law. So though his multiple conspiracies began after Election Day in 2020, the defendant laid the groundwork for the crimes well before then. Smith goes onto write that same day in an implicit acknowledgment he had no lawful way to prevail he sidelined the Campaign Staff responsible for mounting his legal challenges telling the defendant the truth that he did not want to hear which is that he had lost the defendant turned to a private attorney who was willing to falsely claim Victory And Spread knowingly false claims of Election Fraud. Smith argues in the brief trump knew the claimses were false following Election Day and throughout the charged conspiracies the defendant his coconspirators and their agents spread lies that there had been fraud in the election that he had actually won. Smith details conversations between Vice President Mike Pence and trump in which pence told trump he had seen no evidence of fraud in the election. Pence, smith writes, gradually and gently tried to convince the defendant to accept the lawful results of the election even if it meant the defendant lost. Smith also highlights trumps speech on January 6th writing defendant repeated the same lies about Election Fraud in arizona, michigan nevada, pennsylvania and wisconsin that were publicly or directly debunked. The defendant used the lies to inflame and motivate large and angry crowd of supporters to march to the capitol and disrupt the certification proceeding. The filing from Smith Details another conversation between Trump And Pence on january 1st. Where the former Vice President explained he didnt believe he had the power under the constitution to decide which votes to accept. Trump then told pence, hundreds of thousands of people are going to hate your guts and people are going to think you are stupid. And beraided pence you are too honest. Smith argues even if the court determines the conversations were official, the government can rebut the presumption of immunity because the use of the evidence poses no risk to Executive Branch prerogatives. The content of the conversations at issue the defendant and pences joint electoral fate and accepting the Election Results have no bearing on function of the Executive Branch. We fight, we fight like hell and if you dont fight like hell you wont have a country anymore. Of course thats Donald Trump on January 6th and this is 165 pages as mika said, its a lot of detail. Its clear a lot of the testimony is coming directly from Mike Pence among other people around Donald Trump. But it seems to me and i will let you walk us through and explain the Core Argument is trump is not acting as president he was acting as a president ial candidate effectively when talking to Mike Pence about the things. I think thats exactly Right, willie. Supreme court said that certain official conduct is off limits. A president , any president , mr. Trump would be immuned from prosecution for official acts. So the governments brief here, styled as a motion for the Judge to make determinations about immunity, but the thrust of the governments brief here, will willie, is that he was acting a candidate not a president but a candidate trying to secure reelection. And so, all those 165 pages have a similar theme. They lay out a series of acts of conversations, between the president and private officials in the most part. Explaining that the president was willfully blind to the facts he lost. That he was urging people to act in fraudulent and dishonest ways, and he is trying to retain office. All of it intended to convince the trial Judge, district Judge'>Court Judge, Judge-chutkan'>Judge Chutkan they are not immuned. Remember, the Supreme Court had the easy job, willie. All they had to do is pronounce a rule. Judge chutkan has to implement the rule and the government is trying to give her a path, a Road Map to implement the rule in a way they means mr. Trump may be prosecuted for all the unofficial acts as a candidate. Interesting. So, chuck, boy, this goes into the relationship with pence in a big way. The different efforts and different states to try to change the outcome. Also, trumps tweets making it very clear by the way that it was him tweeting, but he goes through tweets as a candidate, casting doubt on Election Integrity. Tweets making false claims of Election Fraud and tweets retweets attack those speaking the truth about the election. Tweets exhorting individuals to travel to the Washington Dc save the america. And tweets regarding Pepss Role defendants 2 24 p. M. Tweet on January 6th. And i mean, it is very specific that these tweets were done by trump but my question is, how can you separate his official capacity as to his unofficial capacities not immuned, if he is still theres a transition that is underway. Does that make sense . It does make sense, mika. And its the Right question. Easy for the Supreme Court to proclaim. Its like 9th Grade Algebra Teacher says i have to work harder study better and get grades up. Hard are for me to did it, oozy for her to say. The Supreme Court said that official acts are out of bounds, immuned. Now Judge-chutkan'>Judge Chutkan you figure it out and tell us which which acts you think are prosecutable. So the governments making its case that every thing in the 165page Brief is prosecutable as evidence that maybe introduced at trial and used by a jury if they see fit to convict mr. Trump of the fraud with which he is charged. But to your tint point, some of this stuff, and i have No Doubt mr. Trumps attorneys will argue, that some of this stuff is official conduct. Particularly, Right, conversations that mr. Trump had with his then Vice President. So, i think its this is is a very difficult task for Judge-chutkan'>Judge Chutkan i couldnt get my grades up algebra easy for my teacher to say i should and harder for me to do it. This is the Opening Salvo in a long difficult stretch of pretrial litigation. Well, that was one of my questions was if you thought this was going to be a tough slog to push this through the Judge, but secondly was there anything in here this surprised you . Not real yes. It reads like a Trial Brief or memorandum before a complex trial, sometimes prosecutors and ive done this will file a Trial Brief telling the District Court what to expect from various witnesses so theres no surprises. This is not styled as a Style Brief but as a motion for the Judge to make immunity determinations. But it really lays out much more of the goffed Governments Evidence i dont know its all but probably most of it at least in broad strokes, and so, because and they are doing this because they have to adues a trial thats not immuned and introduce an evidence used to convict mr. Trump. The government superseded the indictment and struck from the original indictment passages they believe are clearly immuned. So the government has arrived at a place where they think they have the Right Stuff And Balance of stuff, stuff thats not immound from prosecution to push the case forward. Does the Judge agree . We shall see. Donald trump was asked about the unceiling of this brief yesterday, the redacted brief in an interview Last Night. Heres what he said. This was a weaponization of the government and thats why it was released 30 days before the election. And its nothing new in there by the way. Nothing new. They rigged the election. I didnt rig the election. They rigged the election. Okay. So jonathan, he said someone else rigged the election. We can sift through that but if you look through 165 pages, some of the detail which again is not terribly surprising based on the reporting we have seen and based on volume produced by the House Committee on January 6th and election of 2020, but there are some moments that stand out as when an aide came up to Donald Trump on January 6th as He Sat Scrolling Twitter and watching Fox News, and said, your Vice President Mike Pences life is in danger the Secret Service rushed him and he is not safe and Donald Trump is alleged to have said, so what. When approached by his daughter ivanka and her husband Jared Kushner he said according to the brief it doesnt matter if you won on loss, you have to fight like hell. What stood tout to you as someone who wrote a book about this day and all the events around it. No surprises in here. But vivid detail and you tick through some. Trumps callousness and uncaring on January 6th when there was violence. Violence to the point put his Vice President s life in danger. We have also in here, an unnamed Campaign Aide from an earlier moment saying make them riot. When there was a disturbance at another campaign office. This was part of the plan to stir unrest, to fight to intimidate, to try to overturn the will of the people. And, you know this comes, John Trump claims this is election incidents appearance. Two rebuttal. First, lets remember 2016, james Comey Letter about about the Fbi Hillary Clinton is a week and this is further out. The reason this is coming out now is because of Donald Trumps legal Teams Delay tactics. The push they have made and the supreme Court Decision about Immuneity Which Jack Smith is trying to circumvent. I dont think this qualifies as October Surprise but its reminder to americans what trump did, what those years were like, and what another Trump Presidency could be like. Do you think its going to matter this election. I think you are Right. We have a lot of October Surprises and we are in day three or day four and there are a ton and most around the world. I dont think this does count as one. So far, every time that Donald Trump has had a legal setback, and i think you know what chuck was saying earlier about this is a hard for Jack Smith to define a role as a Candidate Or President given he was both at the same time. How do you discontinuing wish between the two. Every time he had it in the past he used it to raise more money. He on the trump side, they feel this doesnt set them back necessarily. I think its interesting that this sheds light on Jd Vances last few moments when you heard Donald Trump about i didnt rig the election they rigged the election saying the election was stolen because it was a fake outcome according to Donald Trump. That is why Jd Vance was put in that position. Its a tough one to get through. Morning Joe Weekend will be Right back. Weekend will be Right back. Hey, scott. This stuffs perfect for fall, Right . Yep it feeds your lawn now to strengthen roots all winter for a better lawn next spring. How do you know all of this . Says it Right there on the bag. Yes, it does. Download the my Lawn App Today for Lawn Care tips and customized plans. Feed your lawn. Feed it. You didnt start a business just to keep the lights on. Lucky for you, shopify built the just onetapping, ridiculously fastacting, skyhigh sales stacking champion of checkouts. Businesses that want to win, win with shopify. Me and my Friends Life is better with the Credit Gods are on your side. Rewards once available to the few are now accessible to the many. Credit one bank. Get cash back rewards, and live large. [child laughing] [child giggling with delight] ooooh. Ooooh. Ooooh. Ooooh. Come on, you two. Dinner time. Ooooh. Ooooh. Baby. Ooooh. Ooooh. Is it possible to count on my internet like my customers count on me . It is with Comcast Business. Keeping you up and running with our 99. 9 network reliability. And security that helps outsmart threats to your data. Moaire Dida Twoo . Your data, too. Theres even roundthe clock customer support. So you can be there for your customers. With Comcast Business, Reliability Isnt just possible. Its happening. Switch to reliable Comcast Business internet with security and get started for 49. 99 a month. Plus ask how to get up to a 500 prepaid card. Call today when youre Governor Congressman you are trying to solve problem. You want a straight answer on something. The moment that stuck out is i asked the simplest of all questions that every single american should be able to answer. I asked him if Donald Trump lost the 2020 election he refused to answer. Understand in that 88th minute Last Night, with that damming nonanswer, Senator Vance made it clear that he will always make a different choice than Mike Pence made. And as i said then and i will say now, that should be absolutely disqualifying if you asking to be the Vice President of the united states. Who ares the simple reason, the media obsessed with talking about the election of four years ago. I am focused on the election 33 days from now because i want to throw Kamala Harris out of office and get back to Common Sense economic policies. But i also think you can believe that america needs to have secure and free elections, but also talk about the fact that just a couple weeks ago, democrats in the u. S. Congress blocked a piece of legislation that would have ensured illegal aliens dont vote in the elections. If you believe american democracy, if you believe in our constitutional republic, you should be trying to strengthen american Election Integrity and not weaken it. Michael steel your thoughts on this, and i am curious, i really think Tim Walz defind the Election And Choice in that moment during the debate. As much as you can see vance trying to sane wash it. Theres a lot of use of that word lately. But there are there are a swath of voters who are watching Maga Tv whether Fox News, News Max rumble or whatever else they have going on out there, and they are not hearing anything about this or very little. I really feel like the Harris Campaign needs to get into the arena. They need top surrogates going on Fox News and going to the places and trying to talk to people, and he know that might be hard, and perhaps they are not welcomed. But then tell us that. I mean, we need to somehow get the entire conversation out there for all the american people to see, for all the american people to see the facts, and the choice. So, lets say this a couple i was. The first part. You are Right. I looked at debate between vance and walz, as two fighters in a ring going at each other. One fighter vance, for, you know, out of a ten Round Bout for nine rounds, was winning on points. Right. He was the Judges were impressed by the style, the movements, he landed punches. He was winning on points. In the tenth round the guy losing on points landed a Knockout Blow with one question. Which utterly disqualified his opponent for the office that he is seeking. And thats a profound moment and he think that moment will register and has registered with the 40 plus million americans who watched that debate. That part of that what happened of that story, is what the campaign has to get out in front and which they have begun to do. Almost immediately after that debate. With a very important ad that clarifies that. Thats one. Two, with respect to someone whos watching Fox Or News Max or any of the stations, if thats their only source of news, there is nothing else we can say to them at this point. I dont think the Harris Campaign can waste its time on convincing the unconvincible. What i think they need to look at are those voters out there who are sitting on the sidelines saying, i just dont know if i want to vote. And i think thats where the focus has to be. Because those are the getable voters. They are not necessarily going to be persuaded by the knockout punch. Which you have to understand and get to is what is the thing keeping them from getting in the ring with governor walz. And think a lot of that has to do with the economy. And which i was happy long Shoreman Peeling back the Story Line and look at relationship between, you know, mr. Daggard and the president former President Of The United States. And why now and that you talk about October Surprises. Right . The planning around that. When there were people trying to get that resolved before we got to this point. So theres things that touch on the economy of people that they want to use as a reason for not speaking out and speaking on behalf of walz and harris. Then address that for them. Because those are the voters you are going to need in the battleground states. The Fox Viewer is not going to be moved by anything Kamala Harris has to say in the 34th Day of the came left in the campaign. But there are voters out there who are on the sidelines who are making the excuse for not getting in. Help them get over the excuse and give them the reason to get in the race because thats where the richness of the vote lies for them. We will dig into the dock worker strike. It could have a impact as this drags on if it does for several more weeks. Chuck rosenberg to tie up the filing from the special council and look out ahead on where this goes from here you touched on it briefly before, but the Trump Team obviously gets a chance over the next couple weeks to respond to the filing. And then the Special Counsel gets to respond to the response and you are at halloween at that point. In terms of a impact on the election, it doesnt looks like there will be one. But, where will this go from here as Judge-chutkan'>Judge Chutkan considers both sides of the argument of whether Donald Trumps actions were private or if he was acting in the role as president. You are quite Right, willie. Trump team will respond and argue that all of these things are actually official conduct and therefore immuned and the indictment in whole or in part ought to be dismissed. I want to touch on one other Point Wouldnt this constitution election interference. Couple points here that i think are important. Number one, this brief was in the released by the justice department. Or by the president or by the Harris Campaign. It was filed by the special council and it was made public by a sitting federal district Judge'>Court Judge. Number two, whether or not she released this redacted filing she would be at least in theory accused of some political decision making. The decision to keep it sealed by be viewed as political on one side and the decision to unseal it in part might be viewed on the other side as political. Think the Judge-chutkan'>Judge Chutkan simply did what Judges do. Moving her docket along. There is a strong preference in the Federal Courts to make document public because the public ought to be able to see what is happening in their courts. And so she did what Judges do. She made the filing public, again, either way, if you do, if you dont you are accused of Filing Something or Withholding Something and people think you are acting politically. To your other point, willie, this will take a while. You are not going to have an answer by october. There may even by The End of october. And there may even be more appeals as Judge-chutkan'>Judge Chutkan tries to parse what remains of the indictment to determine what is inbounds and what is out of bounds. Coming up, Donald Trump recently said if he is reelected Women Voters wont be thinking about abortion. Because they will be protected. Our next guest is digging into the history of reproductive Health Care especially when it comes to communities of color. That conversation is straight ahead. Color. That conversation is straight ahead. The markets closed. Futures dont sleep in the after hours, bro. Dad, is mommy a Finance Bro . she switched careers to make money for your weddings. Ooh Penny Stocks are blowing up. Sweetie, grab your piggy bank, were going all in. Let me ask you. For your wedding, do you want a gazebo and a river . Uh, i dont. Whats a gazebo . Something that your mother always wanted and never got. Or. You could give these different Investment Options a shot. The Right money moves arent as aggressive as you think. Im keeping the vest. Introducing the second Chance Offer from betmgm. Whatd he say . If you bet on a player to score the first touchdown and instead he scores the second . Boom you get your Money Back in cash. Straight cash . Second chance, you heard . What if my guy fumbles, and some other guy scores first . Second chance. What if you need a Second Chance to land on the field . This offer only applies to touchdowns. You alRight . I hurt my spleen get the second Chance Offer from betmgm. The sportsbook born in vegas. Heres to getting better with age. Heres to beating these two every thursday. Help Fuel Today with boost high protein, complete nutrition you need, and the flavor you love. So, heres to now. Now available Boost Max for abortion figures to play a prominent role in the president ial race it will be a major factor at State Level this november. Across the country, Abortion Related Referendums are on the ballots in ten states including five that currently have some type of Abortion Ban already in place. The restrictions on reproductive Health Care in the u. S. Is one of the topics discussed in the new book entitled abortion, our bodies, their lies, and the truths we use to win. And the books best Selling Author Jessica Valente joins us now. Good to have you on the show. What are some of the more dangerous lies that you are taking on in this book . There are so many, think we saw a lot of them actually Last Night with Jd Vance, the biggest one being that republicans care about womens health. And that they are working to protect womens health. Think vance worked really hard Last Night to try to seem compassionate because he knows that republicans are losing so badly on this issue. But americans can see whats happening in front of their faces every day and know Theres Nothing Compassion about Mess Carrying Women turned away from hospitals or cancer patients being denied radiation or little girls being forced into child birth. And so i think that is really the biggest one that they knew that this is what the consequence of their laws would be. And they did it anyway. So, in the book, you argue jessica, republicans are backing away from the Term Ban when it comes discussing abortion you writein part anti abortion Movements Effort to row define ban means they are on defensive. Literally running from their own policies. Some republicans have even begun to adopt pro Choice Rhetoric calling their 12 week Abortion Bans plans to legalize abortion after 12 weeks. They are using the words to trick americans, making them believe that these laws are far less extreme than they are. Americans getting angrier, and angrier at what Abortion Bans are doing to their families and communities republicans are desperate to hide the truth from voters. Lets make it harder for them and we can start by pointing out that their Science And Expertise is anything but. Tim walz made a great point no matter whether you are democrat or republican, you will know somebody like the women on stage who died or had forced been forced to go through physical and mental trauma because of the bans. It seems like the truth is going to be popping up all around them and in their own lives. Abortion is Health Care. Its not Jd Vances version of a Cat Lady who doesnt want to have a baby. Yeah, its not going to be long before every single american has been touched by an Abortion Ban in some way. Whether its because they know someone who has been denied care, or because they cant get a. Smear appointment for three months because the obgyns left the count pi. Theres all these ripple effects as a result of the laws and they dont want to talk about that. They dont want to talk about the real every day tangible consequences they have on american women. Who is there anyway of being able to know how many women have been affected by threes coneian laws and rulings because we hear some of the horrific stories of a woman dying of highly preventable accepts ies Prevent Sepis and can you shed light on the stories you heard. I include those stories in the bock and i think one of the things that is so hard is that we are only hearing a very tiny fraction of the Horror Stories because people are afraid to come forward, especially when it is a Loved One who has died. They know that the Right wing Media Machine is going to attack the person. We have seen that happen with the women who have died and we have heard the stories and so there is this real fear about coming forward. The other thing thats happening is the antiabortion movement is trying really hard to make it hard to track those deaths. Right. And so you have places like texas where they are putting and the abortion extremeists on the maternal Mortality Review Committee to make sure that data that goes out doesnt reflect just how bad these things really are. So, the new book is called, abortion, our bodies, their lies and the truths we use to win. Its on sale now. Author Jessica Valenti thanks very much for coming on the show this morning and congratulations on the book. We appreciate it. Thank you. Next, we will take a closer look at how Third Party candidates can impact the president ial election. Morning Joe Weekend will be Right back. Morning Joe Weekend will be Right back. Know they can save hundreds on Car Insurance by checking allstate first. Whos ready for my famous charred duck . Like you know to check the mascot first before bringing food to a tailgate. So check allstate first for a quote that could save you hundreds. I was stuck. Unresolved depression symptoms were in my way. I needed more from my antidepressant. Vraylar helped give it a lift. Adding vraylar to an antidepressant is clinically proven to help relieve overall depression symptoms better than an antidepressant alone. And in vraylar clinical studies, most saw no substantial impact on weight. Elderly dementia patients have increased risk of death or stroke. Report unusual changes in behavior or suicidal thoughts. Antidepressants can increase these in children and young adults. Report fever, stiff muscles, or confusion, as these may be lifethreatening, or uncontrolled Muscle Movements, which may be permanent. High Blood Sugar, which can lead to coma or death, Weight Gain, and high cholesterol may occur. Movement Dysfunction And Restlessness are common Side Effects. Stomach and sleep issues, dizziness, increased appetite, and fatigue are also common. Side effects may not appear for several weeks. I didnt have to change my treatment. I just gave it a lift. Ask about vraylar and learn how abbvie could help you save. A perfect day for a Family Outing shingles doesnt care. But shingrix protects. Only shingrix is proven over 90 effective. Shingrix is a vaccine used to prevent shingles in adults 50 years and older. Shingrix does not protect everyone and is not for those with severe allergic reactions to its ingredients or to a previous dose. An increased risk of Guillainbarre Syndrome was observed after getting shingrix. Fainting can also happen. The most common Side Effects are pain, redness, and swelling at the Injection Site, muscle pain, tiredness, headache, shivering, fever, and upset stomach. Ask your Doctor Or Pharmacist about shingrix today. How many Voting Members. Compare us. No, no, answer the question. How many Voting Members in the united States House of representatives republican democrat and independent. How many total . How many total are there . Yes. 600 some. Its 435. Plus 100 in the senate Right. 1 i said house and representatives. That was Jill Stein on the Breakfast Club Radio show in New York unable to answer how many members are in the house of representatives. Lets bring in she she is only 150 off. Oh, my God Editor at large at Newsweek Tom rogers. His latest piece is entitled Jill Stin blew it for Hillary Clinton will she do the same for harris . Lets start there. Will she . Well, all the focus went off Third Party candidates when Rfk Jr. Dropped out. But theres real peril for Kamala Harris in terms of what remains. Jill stein was responsible for Hillary Clinton not making it to the white house. Her margins says in michigan was 50,000 votes and trump only won by 10,000 votes there. And the whole Trump Math is that we know trump has a ceiling. Whether its 47 , 48 , so, he needs to have Somebody Siphon off votes from the democratic candidate in order to win by bluality. And Jill Stein being on the ballot is in a position we know it will come down to 1 or 2 margins. Thanks. And to talk about how this is really changed american history especially this century, without ralph nader, taking a Couple Percentage points from al gore in 20,000 and Jill Stein taking a Couple Percentage points in Hillary Clinton in 2016. Democrats would have won the electrical college but won the popular College But Minus two Spoiler Party candidates, no republican would have been elected president since 1992. Absolutely Right, and its not only the Stein Threat but Cornel West is on the ballot in North Carolina Michigan and georgia and theres a double threat there. Theres also a Leb Tearian candidate on all the Swing State ballots on Leb Tearian candidate pulls from Gary Johnson Libertarian in 2016 actually polled more than Jill Stein but we know biden in 2020, was able to actually increase his margin while trumps margin stayed the same as 2016, meaning biden increased margin over trump probably came off the back of not having stein on the ballot in 2020 and getting the chair of Third Party votes. Tom, help me understand, and our viewers to understand, that what is the point of the Third Party candidates . What are they trying to represent and why are they there . I ran in 2004 and decided to run in the primaries. I didnt think i was going to be president. Because of we was Right after 9 11. But, i wanted to be in the debates and bring out issues i felt would not be discussed. What is their point of running. They are not in the debates because they are not running in the pry mareies. So, i mean, what is the point other than they end up messing up someone that may be closer to their politics than the other . Well, think you ask the money question. I dont think there is a point other than to be a spoiler. They make the argument that they represent viewpoints that need to be on the ballot to give voters a choice even though they know they have no Chance Whatsoever of winning or no chance of even getting any electrical college votes. But it is very clear in the Jill Stein in 2016, russians through Social Media efforts were promoting her. It is very clear that both Stein And West have benefited when it comes to Signature Collection to get on the ballot in Swing States. That republican connected trump lawyers have been involved in their efforts and republican Money Looks like it is at the heart of getting west on the ballot. So, these are spoiler efforts. And anybody who thinks about voting Third Party whether they are voting because they dont think harris is progressive enough and dont like her position on gaza and think because of fracking she is not green enough, all they are doing is electing Donald Trump President And Anybody who knows a neighbor, a Friend Anybody who says i dont like either candidate, i think i am going to vote Third Party, let them know they are electing Donald Trump if they do that. The piece is on line for Newsweek Editor at large tom rogers, thank you very much for coming on the show this morning. We appreciate it. Coming up, a look at the new Off Broadway Play based on the trial of the first american convicted for the January 6th attack. The mans own son turned him into authorities. And he joins us next. To author and he joins us next. Lose. Protein supports muscle health. Ensure Max Protein has a 30 Gram Blend of high Quality Protein to feed muscles for up to seven hours. So take the challenge. Ensure, nutrition for strength and energy. Rsv can severely affect the lungs and lower airways. But im protected pause with arexvy. Arexvy is a vaccine used to prevent lower Respiratory Disease from rsv in people 60 years and older. Rsv can be serious for those over 60, including those with asthma, diabetes, copd and certain other conditions. But im protected. Arexvy is proven to be over 82 effective in preventing lower Respiratory Disease from rsv and over 94 effective in those with these health conditions. Arexvy does not protect everyone and is not for those with severe allergic reactions to its ingredients. Those with weakened Immune Systems may have a lower response to the vaccine. The most common Side Effects are Injection Site pain, fatigue, muscle pain, headache, and joint pain. Arexvy is Number One in Rsv Vaccine shots. Rsv . Make it arexvy. have you ever considered getting a walkin tub . Well, look no further rsv . Make it arexvy. Safe steps best offer, just got better now, when you purchase your brand new Safe Step walkin tub, youll receive a free Shower Package. Yes, a free Shower Package and if you call today, youll also receive 15 off your entire order. Now you can enjoy the best of both worlds the therapeutic benefits of a warm, soothing bath that can help increase mobility, relieve pain, boost energy, and even improve sleep or, if you prefer, you can take a refreshing shower. Allinone Product Call now to receive a free Shower Package Plus 15 off your brand new Safe Step walkin tub. The tracking down everyone who was there. You know thats Right. You know that videos and cell phones. Government is closing in. Isnt that, you know, bad . I dont care. How can you not care. I didnt break any laws. You smashed through police barricades and overtook the capitol. I didnt break laws. You carried gun on federal ground. Okay we owned own and american citizens own. Paying tacks gives you no Right. Who said i pay taxes. What . I had every constitutional Right to care Yea Weapon and take over congress just because the law is written doesnt mean it is the Right law. We went in there and they scurried away like rats and hid. Thats how you do it. That was a scene from the new Off Broadway Play fatherland, which opened last week. It is based on the trial of Guy Wesley Feffitt The First American convicted for the attacks on January 6th. Prosecutors say he lit the match for the mob at the capitol. The play is told from court Transcripts Case Evidence as well as public statements and it centers on the relationship between the defendant and his son who reported him to the fbi and then later testified against him in court. Joining us now is guy Feffitts Son jackson and Stephen Sachs who conceived and directed. Thanks for being here. Jackson, we will start with you. Lets talk a little bit if you dont mind about the real Life Incident here after January 6th that what compelled you to work again to turn in your father. Well, the tip came from before January 6th. My dad was getting way more radicalized as time went on following trump. And isolating himself more and more and it was terrifying. What are signs you saw. He was watching immediate and and isolated himself to online groups far Right radical and growing more and more violent. Not to just the family, but to the people around him. And it scared me. And then had you saw January 6th how soon after did you realize your father was involved and you had to act further . It was while they were pointing guns at the doors of the house. You saw him there. I he was texting my mom, and face timing her, and it was dilutional. Did you have any hesitation about going further. He is your father but as you say you saw him there with guns and prosecutors said he lit the match of January 6th. Of course. It was the hardest decision i made. And it continues to haunt me to this day. But, you know, i dont regret it, and i still feel for him and my family. So stephen, lets turn to you now. Talk to us, please, if you will, as to how you came across this idea this project how it came to be. Well, i am the Artistic Director of the Fountain Theater in los angeles, and we have long history of creating and developing new work that is political or dramatizes urgent issues of the time. And in november i was hunting for a work of theater that would somehow add our voice to the national election that we were involved in. I was reading all kinds of scripts and hunting for plays. Wasnt finding what i was looking for, and than i remembered the story of this young man who turned his own father into the fbi because of his Dads Role in attack on the u. S. Capitol. So i goggled it, and when i discovered that the entire Court Transcripts were available online for public access, because it was a federal case, and then when i clicked on the transcript, and i read the testimony jacksons testimony, and the Cross Examination between the two attorneys, interrogating this young man in Federal Court who had just turned his father in to the fbi, i was riveted by it. And then i realized, i have now found my play. So lets Take A Look at one of the more dramatic moments from the play, a fight between the father and son. Everybody who was there on the 6th should be locked up for the rest of their lives everyone. Are you recording this . What . Are you recording this . No. I am not recording. You better not be. Dont betray me. Oh. Dont ruin the family. Oh. Do not put the family in jeopardy. I am not the one putting the family in jeopardy. If you cross a line here i will do my duty and i will have no other choice choose a side. Choose a side or die. I put you in this world, and i can take you out. Dont turn your back on me. I am not turning my back. You turn your back on me is a traitor is that whats happening if if you turn your back on meow are a Traitor And Traitor gets shots. Extraordinary drama there, a Family Story but as you started to allude to so much bigger the one the nation is processing day in and day out and there are January 6th cases brought to trial every week. And its the forefront of another election. Absolutely. And what to me makes this Theater Work stand out is that it is verbatim. Its verbatim theater. Its. The play that i wrote. Every word of this play comes from Court Transcripts, public statements, and case evidence. So every word is the truth coming from the people who spoke it. And it really does dramatized a large political story that this nation is still grappling with. But at the heart of it, fatherland is a father and sons story. It is a story of a young man who somehow must summon the Moral Courage to stand up and speak out against his own father. To me, it has the echo of greek tragedy. It is shakespearean in a way, and yet, deeply american. Moral courage is Right. And jackson, your father was convicted. He is currently serving a seven year seven plus year sentence. What is it like for you to see moments from your life, the most difficult moments of your life, being played out on stage like that . So, i initially saw it about a week ago, and i they wanted me to read the scripts, and i said no. I wanted to be out arely surprised not only because i was nervous about the expectations of such a sensitive topic that has affected thousands of people, people like in this very room that have been affect by radicalized people, in these isolated dangerous environments. So, walking into the theater, i was utterly terrified. But walking out, i had finally cried because through the entire experience, it was nearly impossible for me to cry. Just because its one thing after another trying to be a better man, but walking that theater and it being verbatim i didnt know really was until i left the theater. It broke me. And dont go away, we have a second hour of morning Joe Weekend on this sunday morning, Right after the break. Ay morni Right after the break. Safelite . Were always working on a project. While loading up our suv, one extra push and. Crack so, we scheduled at safelite. Com. We were able to track our technician and knew exactly when hed arrive. We can keep working synth Music Woman Safelite came to us. Tech hi, im kendrick. Woman with a replacement we could trust. Thats service the way we want it. Vo schedule free Mobile Service now at safelite. Com. Singers safelite repair, safelite replace. Shopping for Health Insurance is my favorite thing to do. Just kidding. Its not. Thats why i tell everyone about healthmarkets. And how simple they make it. They search through plans and help find the Right fit for your needs and budget. You can do it online, on the phone or in person. With a licensed insurance agent. And its not pushy. My agent took her time to help find me the Right plan. At the price i wanted. I wish everything was this easy. Not kidding. Check out healthmarkets. Com today. Hey, welcome back to a second hour of morning Joe Weekend. This sunday morning. Another wild week is officially in the books and we want to show you some of the big conversations that you might have missed. Take a look. Hi, i am Bruce Springsteen. Friends, fans and The Press asked me who i am supporting in this most important of elections. I am with full knowledge my opinions no more or less important than those of any of my fellow citizens heres my answer. I am supporting Kamala Harris for president and Tim Walz for Vice President. And opposing Donald Trump and Jd Vance. Heres why. We are shortly Coming Upon one of the most consequential elections in our nations history. Perhaps not since the Civil War has this great country felt as politically spiritually and emotionally divided as it does that at this moment. It doesnt have to be this way. The common values, the shared stories that make us a great and United Nation, are waiting to be rediscovered and retold once again. Now that will take time, hard work and intelligence, faith and women and men with the national good guiding their hearts. You know, jane, theres so many things that were done Right there stylistically. But the words he talks about how we are more divide than any time than since the civil wan and says it doesnt have to be this way. Common values and shared stories that makes us great and United Nations are the United Nation are waiting to be rediscovered and retold once again. And then he says of Donald Trump, he doesnt understand the meaning of this country. Its history and what makes america great. And at The End, i love how he says to the fans and anybody else watching, hey, listen, just one guys opinion. I know people think differently. But this is the most freshest thing i have my vote and thats why i am telling you its so important. Not only to vote for Kamala Harris, but to beat Donald Trump. What are your thoughts . Well, look, he really does have a way with words, doesnt he . He has for a while. I just saw bruce and the E Street Band perform here in a washington my friend and they were in terrific form. And it was such a cross section. It is it is a display of Americaa Up Americana of those who speak through the music and lyrics that are just piercing. He is just he is amazing. And i thought that was great endorsement. It really was. It was pure Bruce Springsteen and i hope people watch it. You know, donny with mika off the show i can say you Advertising And Branding legend. She would tell me to be quiet and stop making your bed bigger. Lets roll this and while donny talks so we can look at the visuals of it. Talk us through that donny, why does that the second it hits the screen why does that appeal to americans so much . Appeals from two reasons. Number one Bruce Springsteen but number two, that is a seat that pretty much anybody in the country can relate to sitting in. Thats a diner, thats in an every we all know the diner. And hes wearing the Flannel Shirt and something about springsteen that transcend every other celebrity. That Flannel Shirt talking about consistency it works because it consistent with who he knows he is. The whole thing is authentic. And the whole thing is i have been outspoken not very but said many times it a way from celebrities democrats. They put you in the eliteist. Bruce is in different place than everybody else. He is not red or blue, he is american. He is red, white and blue. And theres a Trust Factor and theres an hon of the there i and honest there and you say it best it is authentic. You know theres a challenge in there. Which is, this is what i have been writing about in my songs for 50 years. And it is i almost his way of saying you say you love my songs, you say you love my lyrics. You say like you are a super fan of mine. Okay, well, what you have been singing to, the songs that youve been singing to are exactly what i am talking about now over the two and a half minutes. Well, i am glad you brought that up because first i wish my father was here who also was a lifelong Advertising Executive creative director. No way. I started out there. You guys could have quite conversation. He fired you. I was about to say. Told you stop wearing the baby gap. He went onto own his own company and he has a long history in the business. But i love watching Campaign Spots with him because he has such a similar take. And i think what he would say, too, is the other reason it works is that it respects the audience. It is not talking down to the viewer. It is saying, youre one of me, youre one of us, i am here at this table with you. Sit at my table. And i am going to treat you like an adult. And then it says please, do the Right thing. You can its up to you, but heres why i believe so strongly in this. Come sit with me. And it is powerful. Its also really important because this is a moment where the campaign desperately needs more male surrogates and more trusted male surrogates to get the message out. And i think thats why walz has gotten so under Donald Trumps skin because he is a man that can be strong without diminishing others and without controlling others. And so, the more examples we see of that, and legends like Bruce Springsteen are directly in that tradition, the better. Not just for Kamala Harris, but for the country. I mean, ultimately, this is about between Liz Cheney and Bruce Springsteen saying this is america. Those guys over there who want to take away your Rights, destroy the country for themselves and their pals, thats not america. Yeah. This is us. You also bring up a great point where the Harris Campaign is Right now. And we knew this was going to be the case beforehand. I think we talked about it when you substitute Joe Biden for Kamala Harris, you are going to substitute a candidate who overperforms among for democrats and among older white guys, in Wisconsin Michigan and pennsylvania but underforms among people of color and younger voters. Thats been switched since Kamala Harris is come on board. And now, it is the older white guys in Wisconsin Michigan and pennsylvania that the Harris Campaign needs to pick up. Along with hispanics. She needs to gain and this is a message to those guys again in a diner, as donny said, everyone of the guys and All Of Us understand, yeah, its an important message of those voters. More morning Joe Weekend after a quick break. Weekend after a quick break. Its time to feed the dogs Real Food in the Right amount. A healthy weight can help dogs live a longer and happier life. The Farmers Dog makes Weight Management easy with fresh food preportioned for your dogs needs. Its an idea whose time has come. Dexcom g7 is one of the easiest ways to take better control of your diabetes. This small wearable replaces fingersticks, lowers a1c, and its covered by medicare. Not managing your diabetes really affects your health for the future. The older you get, the more complications youre gonna see. I knew i couldnt ignore my diabetes anymore because it was causing my eyesight to go bad. For my patients, getting on Dexcom G7 is the biggest Eye Opener Theyve ever had. I couldnt believe how easy it was. This small wearable sends my Glucose Numbers Right to my phone or my receiver. With just a glance i can see if im going high, low, or steady. So, i can make quick decisions in the moment. Now, im a superstar. My a1c is 5. 7. My a1c has never been lower. No other Cgm System is more affordable for medicare patients than Dexcom G7. Dont wait call now, and talk to a real person. History teaches us again and again that democracy can fall they paul to Pop Lift and strong men. Strong men who Bow Guile the fellow citizens with Conspiracy Theories and false emergencies. As my friend the late Charles Crowdhammer taught us, lesson of history is the task of maintaining strong and sturdy the structures of our constitutional order is unending. It is the continuing and seasless work of every generation. And that responsibility now falls on All Of Us in this election. We have a shared commitment, a shared commitment as americans to ensuring future generations live in a nation where power is transferred peacefully. Where our leaders are men and women of good faith, and where or public servants set aside partisan battles to do whats Right for this country. So today, i ask all of you here and every one listening across the great country, to join us. I ask you to meet this moment. I ask you to stand in truth, to reject the depraved cruelty of Donald Trump. And i ask you instead to help us elect Kamala Harris for president. Its remarkable. Absolutely remarkable. I ask you to meet this moment. It is so funny, you will have, i am sure, people on twitter and others saying she is a rhino no she is not she had 95 aca rating. Acu rating. Conservative rating when she was in the house as was i which means we were so conservative usually we would make people uncomfortable at Dinner Parties if they werent all republicans. This is not the mushy middle. Dic Cheney Form are republican Vice President not the murray middle. You Cant Call Dick cheney a rhino either. Vice president Mike Pence, also, a Vice President not voting for Donald Trump. Alberto gonzales, a man loathed by many on the left. Thats what the people share. They were loathed at one point by people on the left by democrats, for being too conservative. They say Donald Trump not fit to be President Of The United States. Donald trumps own secretarys of defense say Donald Trump not fit to be President Of The United States. Donald trumps own secretary of states, saying Donald Trump not fit to be President Of The United States. Donald trumps own national security advisers, multiple national security advisers, saying Donald Trump not fit to be President Of The United States. Hundreds of republican administration officials in bush 43ss Administration And Bush 41s Administration in ronald reagans administration, kim its aelmen, all of them, saying Donald Trump is not fit to be President Of The United States. We dont need John Meachum to ask if it ever happened before in modern american politic. It simply has not. Again, i dont know how anybody could see what happened yesterday and see whats been happening over the past several weeks with one republican after another republican after nor republican that they used to pledge their loyalty to saying dont vote for this guy he is not fit to be commander in chief. I think the question is, you know, this election is going to be decided by a handful of states by a small number of voters in those states. And its moments like this that could make that difference. Had you go to wisconsin, when you go to michigan and pennsylvania, in North Carolina, where i was just on assignment, and you have republicans, not just men, men especially, but also women, republicans who say, you know, if Liz Cheney can stand with Kamala Harris, on a stage, maybe i can vote for her. Or maybe i can stay home and not vote for Donald Trump. This is powerful. I also think its important because it does something Liz Cheney is doing something that has not been done which is to say, you know what, i am going to stand with this black woman and i am going to wrap my arm around her and say she is a patriot. I am a patriot, she is a patriot, we are all patriots. This is the coalition of patriots thats not about party. Right. Thats about democracy. And what ever Donald Trump is doing over there, is not about you or us. Its not about america or democracy. Its about him. Yep. And, thats a pretty powerful message. Think we will find out on the trail how it is resinating. I think theres going to be more surrogates need. More answer,. More. It has to be the beginning is my take away not The End. You know, what Liz Cheney did was courageous and its courageous because it cost her her political career. So for people who think somehow she is enjoying that moment on the stage and cruising to political benefit, she is now a woman without a party. I will say i, too, like all the other people, i am a man without a party. And if you all will just forgive me for a moment of indulgence personal point of personal preference or whatever. Privilege. Privilege. Its been a while since i was on the house floor. So, we talked about it last week, but i went to the 30th Anniversary Signing of the contract with america. Where we talked about and they said you are going to that with those republicans . My answer is i love those republicans. I said because those republicans what we said around in the back we were not talking about the crazy cultural war issues. We were constantly asking how do we balance the budget. Why do we do to balance a budget and what leverage do we have not over democrats our own leaders. How do we push our own leaders, how do we push or appreciators to push the tough choices and time and time again we lost, we lost, we lost, we lost and would win one. And then would go back. And would shut down the government. We would vote down a rule that would shut down congress. And i was saying Newt Gingrich spoke at it and he said a couple things that were interesting. One he said you know how he did it, we worked and it was hard. And it was hard. Thats the reason why we are the only congress along with bill clinton, balance the budget four years in a row. That has not happened in 100 years. And it was also a team effort. Another thing Newt Gingrich said was anybody is close to Donald Trump, you may want to tell him how we did it. He goes you notice the word we, we did it. And Thats Something that is missing Right now. And so, i am not thrilled about the fact that my party has turned into what it turned into. Liz cheney is not thrilled that her partys turned we always have crazy people there. We did crazy things. Democrats have crazy people in their party. Democrats have crazy things. But our North Star was balancing the budget, being responsible with taxpayers money, and protecting the country and trying to stay out of peoples business. And theres not a party that does that anymore. So, no, that was not easy for Liz Cheney to do. Coming up on morning Joe Weekend, new polling from a number of critical Swing States find a tight race for the white house. We will discuss the shift towards Kamala Harris on two issues that had been among the strongest for her opponent, Donald Trump. Strongest for her opponent, Donald Trump. Hey, scott. This stuffs perfect for fall, Right . Yep it feeds your lawn now to strengthen roots all winter for a better lawn next spring. How do you know all of this . Says it Right there on the bag. Yes, it does. Download the my Lawn App Today for Lawn Care tips and customized plans. Feed your lawn. Feed it. looking good, guys thanks vacations are better with the Credit Gods are on your side. Im Coming Up rewards once available to the few are now accessible to the many. Earn points for travel with credit one bank, and live large. If youre living with hiv, imagine being good to go without Daily Hiv pills. Good to go unscripted. Good to go on a whim. With cabenuva, theres no pausing for Daily Hiv pills. For adults who are undetectable, cabenuva is the only complete, longacting Hiv Treatment you can get every other month. Its two injections from a healthcare provider. Just 6 times a year. Dont receive cabenuva if youre allergic to its ingredients, or if youre taking certain medicines, which may interact with cabenuva. Serious Side Effects include allergic reactions, postinjection reactions, liver problems, and depression. If you have a rash and other allergic reaction symptoms, stop cabenuva and get medical help Right away. Tell your doctor if you have Liver Or Kidney problems, Mental Health Concerns and if you are pregnant, breastfeeding, or considering pregnancy. Some of the most common Side Effects include injectionsite reactions, fever, and tiredness. With cabenuva, youre good to go. Ask your doctor about switching. Stuck at the dmv, and i think im late on my Car Insurance. Good thing The General gives you a break with flexible payment options. Lets get you a break while you wait. What is this place . This is our dmvip. Vending Machine Charcuterie . For a great low rate, go with The General. There is is now polling from the Cook Political Report finding Kamala Harris leading or tied with Donald Trump in all but one battle ground state. All within the margin of error. And theres been some notable Movement On some key issues. Joining us now with more on that Publicker And Editor in chief of cook political Report Amy walters. So what are the key issues you see Movement On . Yeah, when we saw just in the headLine Numbers top Line Numbers not much change between august and september. Really just barely on the margin. But on the issues of immigration, and specifically the issue of inflation, Donald Trumps lead has either narrowed or in the case of inflation completely collapsed. So trump had a six Point Lead who would do a better issue controlling Cost And Inflation back in august. And today, the two candidates are even on that measure. And on immigration, it is still trumps strongest issue but it was an issue he had a double Digit Lead on in august and its now down to a single Digit Lead. The good news for trump is that for people who are still undecided in the race or who say maybe i will vote Third Party, they do see him by a pretty significant margin as being stronger on issues surrounding the economy. What is holding them back in many cases for voting for Donald Trump and it goes back to the conversation on your first panel, is Donald Trumps personal behavior. And so, this is The Pressure that Cross Pressure for the decided thedecided voters wanting to support his policies but not trump. Person. This Race Couldnt be much closer. The Polling Renext that. Zero in on one state that is listed as tied and that may come as a surprise to some because North Carolina, in the last few weeks, democrats felt like they had a chance to build a bit of a lead because of the Scandal And Snarling of the republican gubernatorial candidate mark robinson. And robinsons numbers have fallen in polling. But at least here, looks like he is not dragging done trump at all. Thats good point and thats Right. The democratic Candidate Part of the reason he built a big lead is hes winning over about 20 of trump voters. So there are plenty of voters in North Carolina now who are happy to split their ticket. They say i am sticking with Donald Trump but i am not voting for the republican for governor. I am going to vote for the democrat. And i think that is something that in a state like North Carolina, its going to be really important. But we are also seeing interesting this play out in other states, this interesting gap in state like arizona, where the democratic candidate for the senate building a bigger lead over Kari Lake Who ran for governor there in the last election. And even as the race for president there incredibly close. So, we may see more Split Ticket Voting in this election than we are used to seeing certainly used to seeing in the last couple of cycles. Wouldnt that mean both in arizona and in North Carolina that the efforts of turnout getting your solid base communities districts to turn out at a higher level than expected could decide both states in terms of whether president ial vote goes, because the operations on the ground we dont see a lot from trump in either state and we do see some evidence of that with president ial candidate harris. Yeah. Wouldnt a Ground Operation have major impact. Yeah, i think in a race this close, we will look back and point to 100 little things that made the difference between one candidate winning or losing, and it is true if you go back to 2020, a lot of the frustration among democrats that year was that they werent able to do the on the ground organizing, and the door to dore campaigning because of covid. And they are doing that now. The Trump Campaign has outsourced a lot of their Field Operations to third parties. Which means you dont have as much control over that. You dont know exactly whats happening and who they are targeting. The one thing we do know, though, at least from the last two elections, president ial elections, 2016 and 2020, is that trump voters tend to turn out whether they get their door knocked or not. And in many cases, its not pecked up in polling either. And so, trump has been successful in turning out his base even if the campaign itself has not been as efficient as the democrats have. All Right. Publisher and editor in chief of the Cook Political Report, Amy Walter thank you very much for coming on this morning. Thanks for having mow. We will turn to madison, wisconsin, the chair of the democratic party there. Ben great to have you on the show. Lets get latest, especially with Liz Cheney teaming up with Vice President Kamala Harris today. How is that going to play out . We are so excited in wisconsin because the Vice President and Liz Cheney is going to ripon, wisconsin the place of the republican party when it was the antislavery Party Calling for change and more justis. At this point the republican party is drifted from the best spirit and Liz Chen hello, has been telling people they need to defeat trump to put the country over Party And Today Shoal Campaign i think for the first time with Vice President harris in wisconsin, the state that tipped both last two president ial elections. Its exactly those undecided voters that Amy Walters talked about who are conflicted, and this is a moment when they can choose Patriotism And Love of country and make a choice for harris knowing that the water is safe, there are or republicans doing the same thing democrats independent and this is the time to make a statement about our constitution. Still ahead, a republican appointed Judge in Fulton County strikes down georgias six week Abortion Ban. We will Take A Look at that new ruling and its political implications. Thats straight ahead on morning Joe Weekend. s Straighn Morning Joe Weekend. Heres to getting better with age. Heres to beating these two every thursday. Help Fuel Today with boost high protein, complete nutrition you need, and the flavor you love. So, heres to now. Now available Boost Max have you always had trouble losing weight so, heres to now. And keeping it off . Same. Discover the power of wegovy®. With wegovy®, i lost 35 pounds. And some lost over 46 pounds. And im keeping the weight off. Wegovy® helps you lose weight and keep it off. Im reducing my risk. Wegovy® is the only fdaapproved Weightmanagement Medicine thats proven to reduce risk of major cardiovascular events in adults with known Heart Disease and with either obesity or overweight. Wegovy® shouldnt be used with Semaglutide Or Glp1 medicines. Dont take wegovy® if you or your family had medullary thyroid cancer, multiple endocrine Neoplasia Syndrome Type 2, or if allergic to it. Stop wegovy® and get medical help Right away if you get a Lump Or Swelling in your neck, severe stomach pain, or an allergic reaction. Serious Side Effects may happen, including Pancreatitis And Gallbladder problems. Wegovy® may cause low Blood Sugar in people with diabetes, especially if you take medicines to treat diabetes. Tell your provider about Vision Problems or changes, or if you feel your Heart Racing while at rest. Depression or thoughts of suicide may occur. Call your provider Right away if you have any mental changes. Common Side Effects like nausea, vomiting, and diarrhea may lead to dehydration, which may cause kidney problems. With wegovy®, im losing weight, im keeping it off. And im lowering my cv risk. Thats the power of we. Check your Cost And Coverage before talking to your Health Care professional about wegovy®. Judge in Fulton County, georgia struck down the strict six woke abortion and allows the procedure to resume and make it legal up to 22 weeks. The superior Judge'>Court Judge explained in the ruling that liberty in georgia includes the power for a woman to control her own body. He added the power is not unlimited stating, when a fetus growing inside a woman reaches viability, when society is assume Care And Responsibility for that separate life, then and only then may society intervene. Joining us now from litigateor and legal correspondent lisa ruben. Good morning. Great to see you. People have been watching this case very closely to see where it would land. What was the decision ultimately by the Judge here . Decision by the Judge is prohibition on abortion beyond that six Week Mark what fetal heartbeat is detected is no longer good law. And he says thats rooted in georgias only constitution that theres a recognition of Right to Liberty And Liberty includes a liberty of privacy, and that georgias own law recognizes that liberty of privacy is broader than federal constitutional Right. And on that basis, he said as you just noted, although the state has a compelling interest in promoting feetal life, we are your balancing that against a Womans Liberty of privacy to control her own body, the States Interest is not so compelling as to overcome the womans Right to control her body until fetus is viable outside of the body. This is the debate we heard a lot since dobbs the heartbeat six weeks versus viability at 22 weeks or whenever you set the standard. So, as of now, Women In Georgia Up To 22 weeks because of the Ruling Yesterday can get an abortion. But i assume this will be appealed again perhaps all the way up to the Supreme Court. Yeah, i think there are people who will be afraid to perform abortion in the intervening time period because this is not just a ban on abortion but its a criminal prohibition on abortion and as Judge-mcburny'>Judge Mcburny the Fulton County superior Judge'>Court Judge notes the woman could be prosecuted and he recognize all throughout his decision. This is i want to be clear with you and viewers, this is almost a radical decision in the recognition of the Right of women to control their body and more importantly, to prevent against a sort of involuntary forced labor. Theres a recognition that women are not as he says collectively owned community property. That they cannot be forced to carry a fetus before viability anymore than you or i could be forced to give up a kidney. Thats a fairly radical conception of the Right to abortion. And made a lot of women i know think Oh My God this is The End of judicial Gaslighting Someone sees us. At The End of the idea of women being collective property and considered radical is extraordinary. Lisa, so do we think this ruling can serve as a templet for other states with restrictive bans in place. I think it depends on what the States Law is constitutionally. Because each state is interpreting its own constitution. Some of the other states that have recognized a fundamental Right to abortion in their States Constitution dont do so from a Liberty Perspective but for example on equal protection. Here the Judge is saying georgia has a long history of recognizing a broad Right to privacy and he roots it there. On the other hand there are pieces of the opinion that could be very helpful for other Judges to latch onto in particular, he really disavows Textualism And Originalism the constitutional interpretive methods of day and the problem for look for original public meaning is that it necessarily excludes half the population. Women who had limited Rights, in the 18 i am sorry 1860s when proinvestigations were put in place and black women who had no Rights at all. And thats explicit in the opinion. So, lisa, women in georgia have a reprieve for the moment and women in other states were there to be similar lawsuits has similar reprieves until the reprieves themselves are challenged by higher courts. Presumably, the only way that this gets completely resolved and there is a standard that is allows women to have access to abortion up to 22 weeks of viability is for some decision to be made by Congress Or Reversal of the Supreme Court. I think thats true. Although, theoretically the final word is georgia Supreme Court interpreting its own constitution. What makes this decision really important is that again, if folks like former President Trump are saying abortion is left up to states, this is a state Judge'>Court Judge interpreting his own constitution. Yes, it will likely be appealed all the way up to georgia Supreme Court, but, the text here that matters is georgias constitution not the federal constitution. And while congress could make abortion legal, all across the nation for georgias women Right now, what really matters is their constitution. Still ahead here, its been 24 years since Malcolm Gladwell released the Seminole Book tipping on the which became a New York times best seller. Now, he is revisiting the work that propelled him to literary stardom. He will join us next on morning Joe Weekend. Next on morning Joe Weekend. This one is for you. Have you ever considered getting a walkin tub . Well, look no further Safe Steps best offer, just got better now, when you purchase your brand new Safe Step walkin tub, youll receive a free Shower Package. Yes, a free Shower Package and if you call today, youll also receive 15 off your entire order. Now you can enjoy the best of both worlds the therapeutic benefits of a warm, soothing bath that can help increase mobility, relieve pain, boost energy, and even improve sleep or, if you prefer, you can take a refreshing shower. Allinone Product Call now to receive a free Shower Package Plus 15 off your brand new Safe Step walkin tub. Heres to getting better with age. Heres to beating these two every thursday. Help Fuel Today with boost high protein, complete nutrition you need, and the flavor you love. So, heres to now. Now available Boost Max we really dont want people to think of Feeding Food like ours is spoiling their dogs. Good, Real Food is simple. It looks like food, it smells like food, its what dogs are supposed to be eating. Protect against rsv. With arexvy. Arexvy is a vaccine used to prevent lower Respiratory Disease from rsv in people 60 years and older. Arexvy does not protect everyone and is not for those with severe allergic reactions to its ingredients. Those with weakened Immune Systems may have a lower response to the vaccine. The most common Side Effects are Injection Site pain, fatigue, muscle pain, headache, and joint pain. Arexvy is Number One in Rsv Vaccine shots. Rsv . Make it arexvy. Welcome back. Nearly 25 years ago journalist Malcolm Gladwell writing for the New Yorker published the first book which had the title the Tipping Point. How little things make a big difference which explores the Theory Ideas spread like viruses. And it was the first of his seven New York times best sellers. Now gladwell is revisiting the themes of that debut work, with hi News Book which has the Title Revenge of the Tipping Point over stories super spreaders and rise of social engineering. And Malcolm Gladwell joins us. Thanks for being here. What made you decide to revisit this subject, and the Tipping Point itself was largely an optimistic look. Yeah. At the world. This one not so much. Yes, its darker. I was i was we live in darker times i wrote the first at The End of the 1990s. Crime was falling, Berlin Wall had gone away, and i was in my mid30s the world seemed like a happy place. This time around i was originally just going to do a light revise on 25th anniversary. And i realized i had so much more to say. My perspective on many of the issues changed. And i was not full of the same kind of sunny optimism i was when i first wrote the book. You know, malcolm, i dont mean to say you are a guy who is in love with epidemics. But, i mean, theres a lot of Epidemic Stuff in the book. Lets Leave Covid aside, and go to opioids. Yeah. Do you think that the american people are more susceptible being swallowed by an epidemic like opioid than other cultures. Opioid crisis begin and end the book with an account of the Opioid Crisis. The last chapter is summation of the arguments is my kind of revised history of what happened. And i open with a very simple graph, and shows Opioid Overdoses in all the major western countries. And what you see is united states is up here, and scottland is close to us, and go down a whole canada and than theres a whole series of countries, france, italy, portugal, with the basically had no Opioid Crisis at all. So, for us to think about this one of the big themes of the book is epidemics have ideas and Behavior Observed Boundaries in way that viral epidemics do not. And we need to be asking the question, your question, looking at the countries that didnt have an Opioid Crisis and why why. Its not because its not because they are richer and we are not richer than them. Its not because of they dont have lower rates of unemployment than us. No, in every way, we are probably a more successful economy than they are. Its somehow they have avoided Da Taft catastrophe this country has gone through. What is the answer. Purdue pharma, the company that produced oxycontin was able to exploit some holes in our way that we regulate pain killers. In particular, they were able to target a small number of doctors. They realize a couple of,000 dollars were all they needed to carry their epidemic forward, and they ruthlessly pursued, persuaded, exploited whatever manipulated the doctors. And that same dynamic is not in other countries in the west. The Covid Epidemic And Opioid Ep dem being i see why it makes you feel darker but is there something more than that, something you know, we spend the whole time on the program thinking theres so much going on in the world thats not particularly sunny but is there something structurally in the world or in your relationship with the world that made you less optimistic . Maybe its because i am just older. I have kids now. I worry once you have kids you worry about things you didnt worry about before. I have a chapter in the book on called Popular Grove its not the real name but a perfect upper middle Class Suburb that had this ongoing crisis in their School System over the last ten years or so. Affluence, essentially, but the extraordinary expectations that placed on kids. And thats a kind of new kind of problem thats quite specific to america. And thats occurring in most unlikely of places. If you visit the Poplar Grove this is a last place you would think was being engulfed by this kind of i dont want to give away whats happening there. So thats a kind of realizing that sometimes we have problems because we have been successful in other areas, Thats Something that is new to my understanding. And it was central to the book. Next up here, Nbc News national and political Correspondent And Academy Award Filmmaker join us to discuss documentary separated detailing the Trump Administration Family Separation Policy at the southern border. The important conversation is straight ahead here on Morning Joe. Straight ahead here on morg joe. I know about 20 of you, and youre rich as hell. Were going to give you tax cuts. Im not rich as hell. Im the one that really needs the break, not the people that are already rich and have the money. The 1 dont serve anybody but themselves. So for them to get a tax break, no, thats not cool. Kamala harris is going to make billionaires pay their fair share, and shes going to cut taxes for working people like me. Im buddy, and im not rich as hell, and im voting for Kamala Harris. Ff pac is responsible for the content of this ad. The Darkness Of Bipolar Depression made me feel like life was moving on without me. Then i found a chance to let in the lyte. discover caplyta. Unlike some medicines that only treat bipolar i, caplyta is proven to deliver significant Symptom Relief from both bipolar i ii depression. And in clinical trials, Movement Disorders and Weight Gain were not common. Caplyta can cause serious Side Effects. Call your doctor about sudden mood changes, behaviors, or suicidal thoughts Right away. Antidepressants may increase these risks in young adults. Elderly dementia patients have increased risk of death or stroke. Caplyta is not approved for dementiarelated psychosis. Report fever, confusion, or stiff muscles, which may be life threatening, or uncontrolled Muscle Movements which may be permanent. Common Side Effects include sleepiness, dizziness, nausea, and dry mouth. These arent all the Side Effects. In the darkness of bipolar i ii depression, caplyta can help you let in the lyte. Ask your doctor about caplyta. Find savings and support at caplyta. Com. The government thought that showing the world separations through the eyes of people like me, they would scare the out of people attempting to come from coming. Is that the Right strategy. If you are part of a family and break the law you are incarcerated. I never seen anything like that. There are 1500 kids in there. A federal Judge says the government needs to reunite young immigrant children with their parents. We had 14 days to reunify all of the children under 5. There Assessment Form of The System doesnt have much information. Whats your moms name mom. Every mom, their name is mom. Do i call it Child Abuse or torture . Separation was the purpose. Prosecution was the tool. Its not over. Five years later, we are still trying to reunite up to 1,000 children. Theres nothing to stop them. This is a new era. Troubles me profoundly that it could happen again. That was look at powerful new documentary from Nbc News studios titled separated. Based on New York times best Selling Book of the same title from Nbc News national and political correspondent, Jacob Soberoff and fill being maker erol morris. It describes the impact of the Family Separation Policy by the Trump Administration at the southern border. And they join us now. Jacob serves as Executive Producer on the project and jacob, we can add the title of Movie Star to your introduction. So this is a story obviously you have been covering for a long time. Viewers of the network will feel like they know it. Tell us why the film is so important. Dont take my word for it. Look at what George W Bush appointed Judge in the southern district of New York who stopped the policy said about it. He said it was one of the most shameful chap of chapters in the history of the country. Not my words republican appointed Judge. 500 kids were separated from their parents for no other reason than to harm them and hurt them and scare people from coming to the united states. Its a part of a pattern of Immigration Policy in the united states that is bipartisan that revolves around deterrence and scaring people from coming here by hurting them and most profondly obviously with the famous example of the trump Family Separation Policy. And theres questions about why it happened and how it could have happen and how the nation let it happen and erol and i decide to do when he has done a spectacularly beautiful film that only he can make. You just mentioned that it was part of a Pattern Deterrence and it happened for two decades now. What is the alternative to that . The alternative is a system as the biden administration had laid out when mayorkas came in as Homeland Security Secretary humane and fair. I am not an Immigration Policy expert. I am a journalist who witnessed this myself and what i can tell you is what happened in the summer of 2018 was not that. Hi, its molly, you are. Hi. You are known as such a legend, what drew you to this story . I had read the book, book is an important book. Policies are nightmare like. And i felt that it was important to do something. Call great are attention to what had been going on during the Trump Administration. I felt quite impassioned about it, and i was given the extraordinary opportunity to make this movie with jacob and for that i am truly grateful. So, in her upcoming memoir former first Lady Melania Trump made her husband, then President Trump drop the hard Lien Child Separation immigration policies. The guardian got their hands on the book and reported former first lady told her husband this has to stop. Emphasizing trauma it caused the families. And seeing him swiftly comply. Can we fact check that did we see the Trump Administration change the policy on a dime whether or not the former first lady. He said why he topped he didnt like the sights and sounds of the children separated on television. But as i reported in the book, and you will see in the film, he wanted it reinstate it and has not said whether or not he would reinstate it. And thats why there are you know thats why the fill s so important what errol has done to answer questions what the future holds as much as in the past. Including what the biden administration has promised but has not done which is have the whole sale radical departure based on deterrence and cruelty. Thats all the time for this weekend. Thanks for spending part of it with us. Tune in tomorrow for new week of Morning Joe as we inch closer to one of the most consequential president ial elections of our lifetimes. Until then, enjoy the rest of your sunday. Til then, enjoy th your sunday