we are connected at the hip in our colleagues in florida. we hope they will do well. they have a hearing this thursday. their hearing on the merits is this week. we'll be watching closely. >> greta: you mentioned you are familiar with the judge. when the judge was an assistant united states attorney i was an intern for that judge. now, do i understand the united states claims essentially it had the authority to pass this health care mandate because the commerce clause gave them the authority and the general welfare clause they can tax. first to commerce. what did judge hudson say about the commerce clause and the federal government's authority to require this mandate? >> first, he repeated his, what i would call speculative statement back in the first round of the case the motion to dismiss where he said this appears to go beyond any enactment relying on the